admin-valentin/agent-skill-creator
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

chore: Remove non-essential files — lean working set

Browse source 
Remove 110+ files not referenced by SKILL.md or the core tools:
- .clarity/ (internal planning docs)
- docs/ (14 auxiliary docs)
- integrations/ (optional AgentDB code — reference doc stays)
- scenarios/ (67 test scenario files)
- article-to-prototype/ (old generated example)
- 9 unreferenced references/ files (activation, detection, testing)
- Old export artifacts and migration guide
- .ruff_cache/ added to .gitignore

What remains: SKILL.md, README, 5 scripts, 14 reference docs
(all referenced by SKILL.md), templates, stock-analyzer example,
and the shared registry. Everything the skill needs to work.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
francylisboacharuto 2026-02-27 02:42:11 -03:00
parent 833e7d35d0
commit 77e27eb34f
132 changed files with 13 additions and 25350 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

92
.clarity/context.md
View file

@ -1,92 +0,0 @@
# Clarity Context: agent-skill-creator v4.0 Modernization
> Generated by `/clarity` on 2026-02-26
> Sources: Local codebase, agentskills.io/specification, ecosystem research (Feb 2026)
## Sources Analyzed
| Source | Type | Key Extraction |
|--------|------|----------------|
| `/Users/francylisboacharuto/agent-skill-creator/` | Local codebase | Full architecture, all files, git history |
| `agentskills.io/specification` | Web (official spec) | SKILL.md format, frontmatter rules, validation |
| GitHub ecosystem research | Web search | 26+ platform adoption, marketplaces, competitors |
| GitHub Issue #5 | Issue | Non-standard marketplace.json breaking installs |
| Anthropic blog + docs | Web | Agent Skills open standard (Dec 2025) |
| GitHub Copilot docs | Web | SKILL.md adoption, `.github/skills/` paths |
| Cursor docs | Web | `.cursor/rules/*.mdc` format, SKILL.md support |
| Windsurf docs | Web | `.windsurfrules` format, SKILL.md support |
| Cline docs | Web | `.clinerules/` format, SKILL.md support |
## System Understanding
### Current Architecture (v3.2, October 2025)
**Purpose:** A meta-skill for Claude Code that autonomously creates complete Agent Skills from user workflow descriptions through a 5-phase pipeline (Discovery → Design → Architecture → Detection → Implementation).
**Tech stack:** Python 3.x, pure Markdown/JSON config, no package manager (standalone scripts)
**Key files:**
- `SKILL.md` (4,116 lines) — The meta-skill definition. 8x the recommended 500-line max.
- `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` (124 lines) — Non-standard plugin manifest with custom fields (`activation`, `capabilities`, `templates`, `usage`, `test_queries`) that break Claude Code installation.
- `scripts/export_utils.py` (767 lines) — Cross-platform export to Desktop/Web/API .zip packages.
- `integrations/` (2,849 lines) — AgentDB learning system (optional, graceful degradation).
- `references/` (520 KB, 22 files) — Phase guides, activation patterns, cross-platform docs.
- `docs/` (184 KB, 13 files) — Architecture, naming, changelog, user guides.
- `article-to-prototype-cskill/` (244 KB) — Example generated skill.
**Distribution model:**
- Claude Code: Plugin marketplace install (`/plugin marketplace add ./`)
- Claude Desktop/Web: Manual .zip upload via export system
- Claude API: Programmatic .zip upload (8MB limit)
### Critical Problems
1. **Non-standard marketplace.json (Issue #5):** Custom fields cause installation failures. Claude Code rejects unknown schema fields.
2. **SKILL.md is 4,116 lines:** The official spec recommends <500 lines with progressive disclosure. Current file consumes excessive context window.
3. **Only targets Anthropic platforms:** No support for GitHub Copilot (CLI or VS Code), Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, OpenAI Codex CLI, or Gemini CLI.
4. **`-cskill` naming convention is non-standard:** No other tool in the ecosystem uses this suffix. It adds friction and violates ecosystem norms.
5. **Generated skills also use non-standard marketplace.json:** The skills this tool creates inherit the same non-standard format, causing downstream installation issues for all users.
6. **No validation against official spec:** The ecosystem now has `skills-ref validate` but this tool doesn't use it.
7. **Cross-platform guide only covers 4 Anthropic platforms:** Missing the 22+ other platforms that adopted the SKILL.md standard since Dec 2025.
## Inferred Intent
The user wants to modernize agent-skill-creator to:
1. **Align with the Agent Skills Open Standard** (agentskills.io/specification) — fix all spec violations
2. **Generate cross-platform skills** that work on Claude Code, GitHub Copilot CLI, VS Code Copilot, Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, Codex CLI, Gemini CLI, and any future SKILL.md adopter
3. **Fix the marketplace.json bug** — Issue #5 is the most reported problem
4. **Make skills easy to install** across all platforms with clear, platform-specific instructions
5. **Make skills easy to update and maintain** with proper versioning and validation
6. **Keep the core value proposition** — converting workflow descriptions into production-ready skills autonomously
## Key Constraints
- **Must follow Agent Skills Open Standard** (the spec at agentskills.io/specification)
- **SKILL.md frontmatter rules:** `name` ≤64 chars, lowercase+hyphens, no start/end hyphen, no consecutive hyphens; `description` ≤1024 chars
- **Progressive disclosure:** ~100 tokens metadata at startup, <5,000 tokens for full SKILL.md body, resources loaded on demand
- **SKILL.md body recommended <500 lines** — detailed content goes to `references/`, `scripts/`, `assets/`
- **Directory name must match `name` field** in frontmatter
- **Python 3.14 preferred** (user's environment), `uv` as package manager
- **No new heavy dependencies** — user prefers stdlib + lightweight packages
- **Backwards compatibility:** Existing users of the skill should be able to update without breaking their workflows
## Assumptions
- [ASSUMPTION] The user wants to keep the 5-phase pipeline as the core creation methodology (it's the key differentiator vs competitors)
- [ASSUMPTION] AgentDB integration can remain optional — it's a nice-to-have, not blocking cross-platform work
- [ASSUMPTION] The `-cskill` suffix should be fully removed, not just made optional, since no platform ecosystem uses it
- [ASSUMPTION] The `marketplace.json` file should be eliminated for generated skills — the standard requires only SKILL.md
- [ASSUMPTION] Export system should be expanded to generate platform-specific installation configs (`.cursor/rules/`, `.github/skills/`, etc.) in addition to .zip packages
- [ASSUMPTION] The tool should add `skills-ref validate` as a post-creation validation step
- [ASSUMPTION] Skills generated should work on ALL platforms that adopted the open standard without any platform-specific modifications to SKILL.md itself
- [ASSUMPTION] The existing `article-to-prototype-cskill/` example should be updated to the new standard as a reference
- [ASSUMPTION] Security scanning (no hardcoded keys, no shell injection) should be added to the validation pipeline given the ecosystem's security concerns (Snyk ToxicSkills report)
## Ambiguities
1. **Should marketplace.json be kept for Claude Code plugin suites?** Claude Code's plugin system uses marketplace.json for multi-skill plugins. The standard doesn't define this. Best guess: Keep marketplace.json ONLY for complex multi-skill suites that need Claude Code plugin distribution, but strip it to only official fields. For simple skills, eliminate it entirely.
2. **How deep should Cursor/Windsurf native format support go?** These tools have their own formats (`.mdc`, `.windsurfrules`) alongside SKILL.md support. Best guess: Generate SKILL.md as the primary output (works everywhere), with optional export to native formats as a convenience feature.
3. **Should the tool generate platform-specific installation scripts?** E.g., a `install.sh` that detects the platform and copies to the right location. Best guess: Yes, a simple install script that detects `.claude/skills/`, `.github/skills/`, `.cursor/rules/`, etc.

318
.clarity/handoff.md
View file

@ -1,318 +0,0 @@
# Implementation Handoff: agent-skill-creator v4.0 — Cross-Platform Modernization
> Generated by `/clarity` on 2026-02-26
> Spec: `.clarity/spec.md`
## IMPORTANT RULES FOR THE IMPLEMENTING AGENT
1. **Read `.clarity/spec.md` thoroughly** before writing any code.
2. **Do NOT read the `scenarios/` directory.** Those are holdout tests for independent evaluation.
3. Follow the implementation order below. Do not skip ahead.
4. Ask clarifying questions if any requirement is ambiguous — do not guess.
---
## Tech Stack
| Layer | Technology | Notes |
|-------|-----------|-------|
| Language | Python 3.14 | User's environment, use `uv run` for execution |
| Shell scripts | Bash (POSIX-compatible) | For install.sh, must work on macOS/Linux/WSL |
| Config | YAML frontmatter + JSON | Standard formats only |
| Package manager | uv | For Python deps; no new heavy deps needed |
| Linter | ruff | User's preferred linter |
| VCS | git | All changes tracked |
---
## Implementation Order
Complete each step fully before moving to the next. There are 8 steps organized into 3 phases: restructure the meta-skill itself, update the skill generation pipeline, and add cross-platform tooling.
### Step 1: Restructure the Meta-Skill's Own SKILL.md
The current `SKILL.md` is 4,116 lines. It must be restructured into a <500-line SKILL.md with content split into reference files.
- [ ] Read the current `SKILL.md` in full and identify sections that can be moved to `references/`
- [ ] Create a new SKILL.md (<500 lines) with only:
- Spec-compliant frontmatter (`name`, `description` ≤1024 chars, `license`, `metadata` with `author` and `version`, `compatibility`)
- "When to Use This Skill" section (activation triggers)
- "Overview" section (5-phase pipeline summary)
- "Core Workflow" (concise step-by-step)
- "Architecture Decision" (simple vs suite — brief, reference to `references/architecture-guide.md`)
- "Output Format" (what the generated skill directory looks like)
- Cross-references to `references/` for all detailed content
- [ ] Move detailed content into reference files:
- `references/pipeline-phases.md` — Detailed Phase 1-5 instructions (the bulk of the current SKILL.md)
- `references/architecture-guide.md` — Simple vs Suite decision logic, directory structures
- `references/templates-guide.md` — Template-based creation (financial, climate, e-commerce)
- `references/interactive-mode.md` — Interactive wizard documentation
- `references/multi-agent-guide.md` — Batch/suite creation docs
- `references/agentdb-integration.md` — AgentDB learning system docs
- [ ] Keep existing reference files that are still relevant (phase1-discovery.md through phase4-detection.md, activation guides)
- [ ] Delete or merge redundant reference files
- [ ] Verify the new SKILL.md is <500 lines and <5,000 tokens for the body
**Critical**: The `name` field must be `agent-skill-creator` (matches directory name). The `description` must be ≤1024 characters and include all activation keywords.
### Step 2: Fix marketplace.json (Issue #5)
The current `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` has non-standard fields that break Claude Code installation.
- [ ] Read the current `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json`
- [ ] Strip ALL non-standard fields. Keep ONLY:
```json
{
"name": "agent-skill-creator",
"plugins": [
{
"name": "agent-skill-creator-plugin",
"description": "<EXACT copy of SKILL.md frontmatter description>",
"source": "./",
"skills": ["./"]
}
]
}
```
- [ ] Remove these non-standard fields: `owner`, `metadata`, `compatibility`, `templates`, `capabilities`, `activation`, `usage`, `test_queries`
- [ ] Validate the JSON is syntactically correct
- [ ] Verify `plugins[0].description` exactly matches the `description` in SKILL.md frontmatter
### Step 3: Update Phase 5 (Implementation) to Generate Standard-Compliant Skills
This is the most impactful change. The pipeline's output must change.
- [ ] Update `references/phase5-implementation.md` (or the new `references/pipeline-phases.md`):
- **Remove** the mandate to create `marketplace.json` first for simple skills
- **Change** the implementation order to: SKILL.md first (primary file), then scripts, references, assets, install.sh, README.md
- **Add** validation step at the end
- **Add** security scan step at the end
- [ ] Update the generated SKILL.md template:
- Frontmatter must include: `name`, `description` (≤1024 chars), `license` (default: MIT), `metadata` (author, version)
- Optional: `compatibility`, `allowed-tools`
- Body must be <500 lines with references for detail
- [ ] Update the generated directory structure template:
```
{skill-name}/ # No -cskill suffix
├── SKILL.md # <500 lines, spec-compliant
├── scripts/ # Functional Python code
├── references/ # Detailed documentation
├── assets/ # Templates, schemas, data
├── install.sh # Cross-platform installer
└── README.md # Multi-platform install instructions
```
- [ ] Remove ALL mentions of `-cskill` suffix from the generation pipeline
- [ ] Remove ALL mentions of mandatory `marketplace.json` for simple skills
- [ ] For complex suites: marketplace.json is OPTIONAL and must contain ONLY official fields
### Step 4: Remove -cskill Naming Convention
- [ ] Update `docs/NAMING_CONVENTIONS.md` — replace -cskill convention with standard kebab-case naming:
- Names must be 1-64 characters
- Lowercase letters, numbers, and hyphens only
- Must not start or end with hyphen
- Must not contain consecutive hyphens
- Must match parent directory name
- [ ] Update `references/phase3-architecture.md` — remove -cskill from all examples and templates
- [ ] Update `README.md` — remove all -cskill references
- [ ] Rename `article-to-prototype-cskill/` → `article-to-prototype/`
- Update its SKILL.md frontmatter `name` field to `article-to-prototype`
- Update its `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` if present
- Update its README.md
- [ ] Search entire codebase for remaining `-cskill` references and update them
- [ ] Update all example directory names in documentation
### Step 5: Create the Cross-Platform Install Script
Create `scripts/install-template.sh` — a template that gets customized and included in every generated skill as `install.sh`.
- [ ] Write `scripts/install-template.sh`:
```bash
#!/usr/bin/env bash
# Cross-platform installer for Agent Skills
# Detects the user's AI coding tool and installs to the correct location
set -euo pipefail
SKILL_NAME="{{SKILL_NAME}}" # Replaced during generation
SCRIPT_DIR="$(cd "$(dirname "$0")" && pwd)"
# Parse arguments
PLATFORM=""
PROJECT_LEVEL=false
CUSTOM_PATH=""
DRY_RUN=false
while [[ $# -gt 0 ]]; do
case $1 in
--platform) PLATFORM="$2"; shift 2 ;;
--project) PROJECT_LEVEL=true; shift ;;
--path) CUSTOM_PATH="$2"; shift 2 ;;
--dry-run) DRY_RUN=true; shift ;;
-h|--help) show_help; exit 0 ;;
*) echo "Unknown option: $1"; exit 1 ;;
esac
done
# Platform detection logic
# Install to detected or specified location
# Validate SKILL.md before installing
# Report success with next-steps instructions
```
- [ ] Implement platform detection:
- Check for `~/.claude/` → Claude Code
- Check for `~/.copilot/` or `.github/` → GitHub Copilot
- Check for `~/.cursor/` or `.cursor/` → Cursor
- Check for `~/.windsurf/` → Windsurf
- Check for `~/.cline/` or `.clinerules/` → Cline
- Check for `~/.codex/` → OpenAI Codex CLI
- Check for `~/.gemini/` → Gemini CLI
- Fallback: prompt user or use `--platform` flag
- [ ] Implement `--project` flag for project-level installation (`.claude/skills/`, `.github/skills/`, etc.)
- [ ] Implement `--dry-run` flag (show what would happen without doing it)
- [ ] Implement SKILL.md validation before copying
- [ ] Print success message with platform-specific activation instructions
- [ ] Handle errors: permission denied, directory doesn't exist, invalid SKILL.md
### Step 6: Create Validation and Security Scanning Scripts
- [ ] Create `scripts/validate.py`:
- Validate frontmatter: `name` (1-64 chars, lowercase+hyphens, no start/end hyphen, no consecutive hyphens)
- Validate frontmatter: `description` (1-1024 chars, non-empty)
- Validate: directory name matches `name` field
- Validate: SKILL.md exists and starts with `---` frontmatter
- Validate: SKILL.md body <500 lines (warning, not error)
- Validate: optional fields have correct types if present
- Validate: referenced files in SKILL.md body exist
- Return structured result: `{"valid": bool, "errors": [], "warnings": []}`
- [ ] Create `scripts/security_scan.py`:
- Scan for hardcoded API keys (regex patterns for common key formats: `sk-`, `AKIA`, `ghp_`, `glpat-`, etc.)
- Scan for `.env` files included in skill directory
- Scan for `credentials.json`, `secrets.json`, `api_keys.json`
- Scan for `eval()`, `exec()`, `subprocess.call(shell=True)` in Python scripts
- Scan for `os.system()` with string concatenation (shell injection)
- Scan for `__import__` dynamic imports
- Return structured result: `{"clean": bool, "issues": []}`
- [ ] Integrate both into the generation pipeline (Phase 5 runs them after file creation)
### Step 7: Update the Export System
- [ ] Update `scripts/export_utils.py`:
- Keep existing Desktop/Web and API export functionality (backwards compatible)
- Add validation step before export (call `validate.py`)
- Add security scan before export (call `security_scan.py`)
- Remove `-cskill` from any hardcoded name handling
- Update the generated installation guide to include instructions for ALL platforms (Claude Code, Copilot, Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, Codex CLI, Gemini CLI)
- Add optional `--platform` parameter for platform-specific export
- [ ] Update `references/cross-platform-guide.md`:
- Expand from 4 Anthropic platforms to all 8+ platforms
- Add installation paths for each platform
- Add the Agent Skills Open Standard as the unifying reference
- Remove references to marketplace.json as a universal requirement
- [ ] Update `references/export-guide.md` (if it exists) with new platform targets
### Step 8: Update Documentation and README
- [ ] Update `README.md`:
- Update version to 4.0
- Add "Cross-Platform Compatible" badge/note at top
- List all supported platforms (Claude Code, Copilot CLI, VS Code Copilot, Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, Codex CLI, Gemini CLI)
- Remove all `-cskill` references
- Update installation instructions for all platforms
- Add "Agent Skills Open Standard" compliance note
- Update architecture diagrams (no -cskill, no mandatory marketplace.json)
- Add "Migration from v3.x" section pointing to MIGRATION.md
- [ ] Create `MIGRATION.md`:
- How to update from v3.x to v4.0
- Breaking changes: -cskill suffix removed, marketplace.json simplified
- How to migrate existing generated skills (rename dirs, update frontmatter, fix marketplace.json)
- Automated migration: mention that the tool can help migrate with "Migrate this skill to the new standard"
- [ ] Update `docs/CHANGELOG.md`:
- Add v4.0 entry with all changes
- Note breaking changes
- Note new features (cross-platform, validation, security scan, install.sh)
- [ ] Update `docs/CLAUDE_SKILLS_ARCHITECTURE.md`:
- Reference the Agent Skills Open Standard
- Update directory structures (no -cskill)
- Add cross-platform compatibility information
---
## Tests to Write
Write tests for these behaviors (derived from the spec, not from holdout scenarios):
| Test | Covers | Type |
|------|--------|------|
| Validate SKILL.md frontmatter with valid name/description passes | FR-001 | Unit |
| Validate SKILL.md frontmatter with name >64 chars fails | FR-001 | Unit |
| Validate SKILL.md frontmatter with empty description fails | FR-001 | Unit |
| Validate name matches directory name | FR-002 | Unit |
| Validate SKILL.md body >500 lines produces warning | FR-003 | Unit |
| Generated skill has no marketplace.json (simple skill) | FR-005 | Integration |
| Generated skill name has no -cskill suffix | FR-007 | Integration |
| Security scan detects hardcoded API key | FR-013 | Unit |
| Security scan detects .env file in skill | FR-013 | Unit |
| Security scan detects shell injection pattern | FR-014 | Unit |
| install.sh detects Claude Code platform | FR-015, FR-016 | Integration |
| install.sh detects Copilot platform | FR-015, FR-016 | Integration |
| install.sh --dry-run produces no side effects | FR-015 | Unit |
| install.sh --platform cursor installs to .cursor/rules/ | FR-017 | Integration |
| Generated README has multi-platform install section | FR-018 | Integration |
| Export system still generates Desktop .zip | FR-019 | Integration |
| Export system still generates API .zip <8MB | FR-019 | Integration |
| Meta-skill SKILL.md is <500 lines | FR-004, FR-021 | Unit |
| Generated skill works on SKILL.md standard without modification | FR-028, NFR-001 | Integration |
---
## Definition of Done
All of the following must be true:
- [ ] The meta-skill's own SKILL.md is <500 lines with spec-compliant frontmatter
- [ ] `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` contains ONLY official fields
- [ ] No `-cskill` suffix appears anywhere in the codebase (code, docs, examples)
- [ ] `article-to-prototype-cskill/` renamed to `article-to-prototype/` with updated frontmatter
- [ ] Generated skills produce spec-compliant SKILL.md (passes validation)
- [ ] Generated skills include `install.sh` for cross-platform installation
- [ ] Generated README.md includes install instructions for 5+ platforms
- [ ] `scripts/validate.py` checks all spec rules and returns structured results
- [ ] `scripts/security_scan.py` catches hardcoded keys and injection patterns
- [ ] Export system updated with validation, security scan, and multi-platform install guide
- [ ] `references/cross-platform-guide.md` covers 8+ platforms
- [ ] `MIGRATION.md` created with v3.x → v4.0 migration guide
- [ ] `README.md` updated for v4.0 with all platform support
- [ ] No hardcoded secrets or credentials in any file
- [ ] All Python files pass `ruff check`
- [ ] `install.sh` template works on macOS and Linux
---
## Explicit Exclusions
Do NOT implement these (they are out of scope):
- Building a skill marketplace or registry
- Converting `.cursorrules` or `.windsurfrules` into SKILL.md
- MCP server integration
- GUI or web interface
- Rewriting AgentDB integration
- Supporting platforms that haven't adopted SKILL.md standard
- Publishing automation to SkillsMP/SkillHub (just make skills compatible)
---
## Reference Files
- Specification: `.clarity/spec.md`
- Project context: `.clarity/context.md`
- Agent Skills Open Standard: https://agentskills.io/specification
- Current codebase: All files in the repository root

65
.clarity/plan.md
View file

@ -1,65 +0,0 @@
# Implementation Plan: agent-skill-creator v4.0 — Cross-Platform Modernization
> Generated by `/clarity` on 2026-02-26
> Full spec: `.clarity/spec.md`
> Handoff: `.clarity/handoff.md`
> Holdout scenarios: `scenarios/` (59 scenarios covering all 28 FRs + 7 NFRs)
---
## Summary
Modernize agent-skill-creator from a Claude-only meta-skill (v3.2) to a cross-platform skill factory (v4.0) that generates skills compliant with the **Agent Skills Open Standard** (agentskills.io). Skills will work on Claude Code, GitHub Copilot CLI, VS Code Copilot, Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, OpenAI Codex CLI, Gemini CLI, and any future SKILL.md adopter — without modification.
## What Changes
| Area | Before (v3.2) | After (v4.0) |
|------|---------------|--------------|
| SKILL.md | 4,116 lines (monolith) | <500 lines + references/ |
| marketplace.json | Non-standard fields (Issue #5) | Official fields only, optional |
| Naming | `-cskill` suffix mandatory | Standard kebab-case, no suffix |
| Platforms | 4 (Claude Code/Desktop/Web/API) | 8+ (all SKILL.md adopters) |
| Validation | None | Spec compliance + security scan |
| Install UX | Manual per-platform | `install.sh` auto-detects platform |
| Phase 5 output | marketplace.json first | SKILL.md first (primary file) |
## What Stays the Same
- 5-phase pipeline (Discovery → Design → Architecture → Detection → Implementation)
- AgentDB integration (optional, graceful degradation)
- Simple skill vs Complex suite architecture support
- Desktop/Web .zip export and API .zip export
- All activation trigger phrases
## Implementation Steps (8 steps, ~3 phases)
### Phase A: Fix the Meta-Skill Itself
**Step 1** — Restructure SKILL.md: 4,116 → <500 lines with progressive disclosure to `references/`
**Step 2** — Fix marketplace.json: Strip non-standard fields (fixes Issue #5)
### Phase B: Update the Skill Generation Pipeline
**Step 3** — Update Phase 5: SKILL.md-first (not marketplace.json), spec-compliant output, validation + security scan
**Step 4** — Remove `-cskill` naming convention everywhere (code, docs, examples, rename `article-to-prototype-cskill/`)
### Phase C: Add Cross-Platform Tooling
**Step 5** — Create `install.sh` template: Auto-detects Claude Code, Copilot, Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, Codex, Gemini
**Step 6** — Create `validate.py` + `security_scan.py`: Spec validation + OWASP-lite security checks
**Step 7** — Update export system: Multi-platform install guide, validation before export
**Step 8** — Update all documentation: README v4.0, MIGRATION.md, CHANGELOG, cross-platform guide
## Key Deliverables
1. `.clarity/spec.md` — Full specification (28 FRs, 7 NFRs, data model, API contracts)
2. `.clarity/handoff.md` — Self-contained implementation prompt for any AI coding agent
3. `scenarios/SC-001..SC-059` — 59 holdout test scenarios for independent evaluation
4. `.clarity/context.md` — Research context and ecosystem analysis
## Open Questions (4)
1. Should the tool offer direct publishing to SkillsMP/SkillHub?
2. Should `install.sh` support `--uninstall`?
3. Should validation check that referenced files exist?
4. Should Cursor export generate `.mdc` or rely on native SKILL.md support?

394
.clarity/spec.md
View file

@ -1,394 +0,0 @@
# Specification: agent-skill-creator v4.0 — Cross-Platform Modernization
> Generated by `/clarity` on 2026-02-26
> Status: DRAFT
## 1. System Overview
**One-liner**: A meta-skill that autonomously creates cross-platform Agent Skills from workflow descriptions, compliant with the Agent Skills Open Standard.
**Primary user**: Developers and professionals who want to convert repetitive workflows into reusable AI agent skills that work across Claude Code, GitHub Copilot, Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, and 20+ other platforms.
**Project type**: Brownfield delta
### 1.1 Goals
- G1: Full compliance with the Agent Skills Open Standard (agentskills.io/specification)
- G2: Skills generated by this tool work on ALL platforms that support the SKILL.md standard without modification
- G3: Fix all known bugs (Issue #5: non-standard marketplace.json)
- G4: Restructure the meta-skill itself to follow the standard (<500 lines SKILL.md, progressive disclosure)
- G5: Provide cross-platform installation support (auto-detect platform, install to correct location)
- G6: Add validation pipeline using the official spec rules
- G7: Add security scanning to generated skills (no hardcoded secrets, no injection vectors)
- G8: Make generated skills easy to publish to marketplaces (SkillsMP, SkillHub, skills.sh)
### 1.2 Non-Goals (Explicit Exclusions)
- NG1: Building a skill marketplace or registry (use existing ones)
- NG2: Converting existing `.cursorrules` or `.windsurfrules` files into SKILL.md (out of scope)
- NG3: MCP server integration (MCP is a tool protocol, not a skill format — orthogonal concern)
- NG4: GUI or web interface for skill creation (this remains a CLI/agent skill)
- NG5: Rewriting the AgentDB integration system (it works, keep it optional)
- NG6: Supporting platforms that have NOT adopted the SKILL.md standard (e.g., Aider's CONVENTIONS.md)
---
## 1A. Current State
### Existing Architecture
The project is a meta-skill (a skill that creates other skills) structured as:
```
agent-skill-creator/
├── SKILL.md # 4,116 lines (8x recommended max)
├── .claude-plugin/marketplace.json # Non-standard fields (Issue #5)
├── scripts/export_utils.py # Desktop/Web/API export
├── integrations/ # AgentDB learning (optional)
├── references/ # 22 reference files (520 KB)
├── docs/ # 13 doc files (184 KB)
├── article-to-prototype-cskill/ # Example generated skill
└── exports/ # Export output directory
```
### Relevant Files / Modules
| File/Module | Purpose | Will Change? |
|-------------|---------|--------------|
| `SKILL.md` | Meta-skill definition (4,116 lines) | Yes — restructure to <500 lines |
| `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` | Plugin manifest (non-standard) | Yes — fix or remove |
| `scripts/export_utils.py` | Cross-platform export | Yes — add new platform targets |
| `references/phase5-implementation.md` | Implementation guide for generated skills | Yes — remove marketplace.json mandate |
| `references/cross-platform-guide.md` | Platform compatibility matrix | Yes — expand to 26+ platforms |
| `docs/NAMING_CONVENTIONS.md` | `-cskill` suffix rules | Yes — remove -cskill convention |
| `README.md` | Project documentation | Yes — update for v4.0 |
| `article-to-prototype-cskill/` | Example skill | Yes — rename, update to standard |
| `integrations/` | AgentDB system | No |
| `references/phase1-discovery.md` | Phase 1 guide | Minor updates |
| `references/phase2-design.md` | Phase 2 guide | Minor updates |
| `references/phase3-architecture.md` | Phase 3 guide | Yes — remove -cskill, update structure |
| `references/phase4-detection.md` | Phase 4 guide | Minor updates |
| `references/activation-*.md` | Activation pattern guides | No |
---
## 1B. Delta Specification
### What Changes
1. **SKILL.md restructured**: 4,116 → <500 lines. Detailed content moved to `references/`.
2. **marketplace.json fixed**: Strip to official fields only, or remove for simple skill mode.
3. **-cskill suffix eliminated**: All naming conventions, templates, docs, and examples updated.
4. **Cross-platform skill generation**: Generated skills include an `install.sh` script and platform-specific instructions.
5. **Validation pipeline added**: Every generated skill validated against the official spec.
6. **Security scanning added**: Check for hardcoded secrets, shell injection, suspicious patterns.
7. **New platform targets**: Generated installation guides cover Claude Code, Copilot, Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, Codex CLI, Gemini CLI.
8. **Export system expanded**: Beyond .zip packages, add direct-install-to-platform support.
### What Must NOT Change
- The 5-phase pipeline (Discovery → Design → Architecture → Detection → Implementation) — this is the core differentiator
- AgentDB integration — works fine, keep optional
- The ability to create both simple skills and complex skill suites
- Support for Claude Desktop/Web .zip export and Claude API export
### Migration Requirements
- Existing users who installed via `/plugin marketplace add ./` must be able to update via `git pull` and have the tool work
- The example skill (`article-to-prototype-cskill/`) must be renamed and updated as a reference migration
- A `MIGRATION.md` guide for users of v3.x
---
## 2. Functional Requirements
| ID | Requirement | Priority | Notes |
|----|-------------|----------|-------|
| FR-001 | Generated SKILL.md files MUST have valid frontmatter per the Agent Skills spec (name ≤64 chars lowercase+hyphens, description ≤1024 chars, both required) | MUST | Core spec compliance |
| FR-002 | Generated SKILL.md `name` field MUST match the parent directory name | MUST | Spec rule |
| FR-003 | Generated SKILL.md body MUST be <500 lines, with detailed content in `references/` | MUST | Progressive disclosure |
| FR-004 | The meta-skill's own SKILL.md MUST be <500 lines | MUST | Practice what you preach |
| FR-005 | Generated skills MUST NOT include `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` for simple skills | MUST | Fixes Issue #5 |
| FR-006 | Generated skills for complex suites MAY include a marketplace.json with ONLY official Claude Code fields | SHOULD | Multi-skill plugin support |
| FR-007 | The `-cskill` naming suffix MUST be removed from all generated skill names | MUST | Standard compliance |
| FR-008 | Generated skills MUST include `license` field in frontmatter | SHOULD | Marketplace discoverability |
| FR-009 | Generated skills MUST include `metadata` field with `author` and `version` | SHOULD | Marketplace discoverability |
| FR-010 | Generated skills SHOULD include `compatibility` field when platform-specific features are used | SHOULD | Spec recommendation |
| FR-011 | A validation function MUST check every generated skill against the official spec rules | MUST | Quality gate |
| FR-012 | Validation MUST check: name format, description length, frontmatter structure, directory name match | MUST | Spec rules |
| FR-013 | A security scan MUST check generated skills for hardcoded API keys, secrets, and .env files | MUST | Ecosystem security |
| FR-014 | A security scan SHOULD check for shell injection patterns in generated scripts | SHOULD | OWASP compliance |
| FR-015 | Generated skills MUST include an `install.sh` script that auto-detects the platform and installs to the correct location | MUST | Cross-platform UX |
| FR-016 | The install script MUST support: `~/.claude/skills/`, `~/.github/skills/`, `.claude/skills/` (project), `.github/skills/` (project) | MUST | Primary platforms |
| FR-017 | The install script SHOULD support: `.cursor/rules/`, `.codex/skills/`, custom paths via `--path` flag | SHOULD | Extended platforms |
| FR-018 | Generated skills MUST include a README.md with installation instructions for at least 5 platforms | MUST | Cross-platform documentation |
| FR-019 | The export system MUST continue to support Desktop/Web .zip and API .zip variants | MUST | Backwards compatibility |
| FR-020 | The export system SHOULD add a `--platform` flag to generate platform-specific output (e.g., `--platform cursor` generates `.mdc` file) | COULD | Nice-to-have |
| FR-021 | The meta-skill MUST restructure its own content: <500 line SKILL.md with references in `references/` | MUST | Self-compliance |
| FR-022 | Phase 3 (Architecture) MUST generate standard-compliant directory structures (no -cskill suffix) | MUST | Pipeline update |
| FR-023 | Phase 5 (Implementation) MUST create SKILL.md as the first and primary file (not marketplace.json) | MUST | Standard alignment |
| FR-024 | Phase 5 MUST run validation after generating all files | MUST | Quality gate |
| FR-025 | Phase 5 SHOULD run security scan after generating all files | SHOULD | Security |
| FR-026 | Generated README.md MUST include a "Cross-Platform Installation" section with copy-paste commands for each platform | MUST | UX |
| FR-027 | The meta-skill MUST preserve the 5-phase pipeline as the core creation methodology | MUST | Core differentiator |
| FR-028 | Generated skills MUST work on any platform that supports the SKILL.md standard without modification | MUST | Portability |
### 2.1 Core Workflow
**Skill Creation Pipeline (Updated):**
1. User describes a workflow to automate (e.g., "Create a skill for processing daily CSV files")
2. **Phase 1: Discovery** — Research APIs, tools, data sources (unchanged)
3. **Phase 2: Design** — Define use cases, analyses, methodologies (unchanged)
4. **Phase 3: Architecture** — Structure the skill directory using the Agent Skills standard:
```
skill-name/ # No -cskill suffix
├── SKILL.md # <500 lines, spec-compliant frontmatter
├── scripts/ # Executable code
├── references/ # Detailed docs (loaded on demand)
├── assets/ # Templates, schemas, data files
├── install.sh # Cross-platform installer
└── README.md # With multi-platform install instructions
```
5. **Phase 4: Detection** — Generate description with domain keywords for agent discovery (unchanged conceptually, but description now ≤1024 chars)
6. **Phase 5: Implementation** — Create all files in this order:
a. Create directory structure
b. Write SKILL.md with spec-compliant frontmatter (PRIMARY FILE)
c. Write scripts (functional Python code)
d. Write references (detailed documentation)
e. Write assets (templates, configs)
f. Generate install.sh (cross-platform installer)
g. Write README.md (with multi-platform install instructions)
h. Run validation against official spec
i. Run security scan
j. Report results to user
### 2.2 Secondary Flows
**Flow: Cross-Platform Export**
1. User asks to export a skill for a specific platform
2. System generates the appropriate output:
- Claude Code: Standard directory (copy to `~/.claude/skills/` or `.claude/skills/`)
- GitHub Copilot: Standard directory (copy to `.github/skills/`)
- Cursor: Generate `.mdc` rule file from SKILL.md content (optional)
- Desktop/Web: .zip package
- API: Optimized .zip (<8MB)
3. System generates platform-specific installation guide
**Flow: Validate Existing Skill**
1. User asks to validate an existing skill directory
2. System runs spec validation (frontmatter, naming, structure)
3. System runs security scan
4. System reports pass/fail with specific issues and fix suggestions
**Flow: Migrate Legacy Skill**
1. User has a skill with `-cskill` suffix or non-standard marketplace.json
2. System renames directory, updates frontmatter, removes/fixes marketplace.json
3. System validates the migrated skill
### 2.3 Edge Cases & Error Handling
| Condition | Expected Behavior |
|-----------|-------------------|
| Skill name exceeds 64 chars | Truncate intelligently, warn user, suggest alternative |
| Description exceeds 1024 chars | Summarize, move detail to SKILL.md body, warn user |
| Name contains uppercase or special chars | Auto-convert to lowercase kebab-case |
| Name starts/ends with hyphen | Auto-strip, warn user |
| Name has consecutive hyphens | Collapse to single hyphen, warn user |
| Directory name doesn't match `name` field | Rename directory to match, warn user |
| Generated script contains hardcoded API key | Fail security scan, replace with env var reference, warn user |
| SKILL.md body exceeds 500 lines | Move excess to `references/`, add cross-references |
| User requests -cskill suffix | Inform user it's deprecated, generate without suffix |
| Platform directory doesn't exist (e.g., no `.claude/`) | Create it, or inform user to create manually |
| install.sh target platform not detected | Fall back to interactive prompt asking user which platform |
| Complex skill suite needs marketplace.json | Generate with ONLY official fields (name, plugins[].name, plugins[].description, plugins[].source, plugins[].skills) |
---
## 3. Non-Functional Requirements
| ID | Requirement | Target | Notes |
|----|-------------|--------|-------|
| NFR-001 | Generated skills must be valid on all SKILL.md-standard platforms | 100% compliance | Zero platform-specific hacks |
| NFR-002 | Meta-skill SKILL.md context consumption | <5,000 tokens for body | Progressive disclosure |
| NFR-003 | Validation must cover all spec rules | 100% of agentskills.io rules | Use skills-ref as reference |
| NFR-004 | Security scan must catch OWASP top patterns | Hardcoded secrets, injection | Not a full SAST tool |
| NFR-005 | install.sh must work on macOS, Linux, and WSL | 3 OS families | bash-compatible |
| NFR-006 | Generated skills must not require any tool-specific configuration to activate | Zero-config activation | SKILL.md description is the only activation mechanism |
| NFR-007 | Backwards compatibility with v3.x workflows | Users can `git pull` and use immediately | No breaking changes to user-facing invocation |
---
## 4. Data Model
### 4.1 Entities
**SkillManifest** (the generated SKILL.md frontmatter):
```yaml
name: string # 1-64 chars, lowercase+hyphens, required
description: string # 1-1024 chars, required
license: string # optional
compatibility: string # 1-500 chars, optional
metadata: # optional
author: string
version: string
allowed-tools: string # space-delimited, experimental, optional
```
**SkillDirectory** (the generated output):
```
{name}/
├── SKILL.md # Required. <500 lines.
├── scripts/ # Optional. Self-contained executable code.
├── references/ # Optional. On-demand documentation.
├── assets/ # Optional. Templates, schemas, data.
├── install.sh # New. Cross-platform installer.
└── README.md # Required. Multi-platform install instructions.
```
**PlatformTarget** (where skills can be installed):
```
claude-code: ~/.claude/skills/{name}/ or .claude/skills/{name}/
copilot: .github/skills/{name}/ or ~/.copilot/skills/{name}/
cursor: .cursor/rules/{name}/ (or .mdc export)
windsurf: .windsurf/skills/{name}/
cline: .clinerules/{name}/
codex: .codex/skills/{name}/
gemini: .gemini/skills/{name}/
generic: user-specified --path
```
### 4.2 Data Flow
```
User workflow description
↓
Phase 1: Discovery (API research)
↓
Phase 2: Design (use case analysis)
↓
Phase 3: Architecture (directory structure, spec-compliant)
↓
Phase 4: Detection (description + keywords, ≤1024 chars)
↓
Phase 5: Implementation
├── Generate SKILL.md (spec-compliant, <500 lines)
├── Generate scripts/ (functional Python)
├── Generate references/ (detailed docs)
├── Generate assets/ (templates, configs)
├── Generate install.sh (cross-platform)
├── Generate README.md (multi-platform instructions)
├── Run spec validation → pass/fail
└── Run security scan → pass/fail
↓
Output: Complete, validated, cross-platform skill directory
```
---
## 5. API / Interface Contracts
### 5.1 Activation Interface (User → Meta-Skill)
**Trigger phrases** (unchanged):
- "Create a skill for [objective]"
- "Automate this workflow: [description]"
- "Every day I [repetitive task], automate this"
- "Create an agent for [objective]"
**New trigger phrases:**
- "Create a cross-platform skill for [objective]"
- "Validate this skill: [path]"
- "Export this skill for [platform]"
- "Migrate this skill to the new standard"
### 5.2 install.sh Interface
```bash
# Auto-detect platform and install to user-level skills
./install.sh
# Install to specific platform
./install.sh --platform claude-code
./install.sh --platform copilot
./install.sh --platform cursor
# Install to project-level (current directory)
./install.sh --project
# Install to custom path
./install.sh --path /custom/path/
# Dry run (show what would happen)
./install.sh --dry-run
```
**Exit codes:**
- 0: Success
- 1: Validation failed (SKILL.md invalid)
- 2: Platform not detected
- 3: Permission denied (can't write to target)
### 5.3 Validation Interface
```python
# In scripts/validate.py
def validate_skill(skill_path: str) -> ValidationResult:
"""
Validate a skill directory against the Agent Skills Open Standard.
Returns:
ValidationResult with:
- valid: bool
- errors: list[str] # spec violations (must fix)
- warnings: list[str] # recommendations (should fix)
- security: list[str] # security issues found
"""
```
### 5.4 Export Interface (Updated)
```python
# In scripts/export_utils.py (updated)
def export_skill(
skill_path: str,
variants: list[str] = ['desktop', 'api'],
platform: str = None, # NEW: 'cursor', 'copilot', etc.
version_override: str = None,
output_dir: str = None
) -> dict:
```
---
## 6. Technical Constraints
- **Stack**: Python 3.14, uv package manager, bash for install.sh
- **Dependencies**: stdlib only for core (pathlib, json, re, zipfile, subprocess). No new external packages required.
- **Compatibility**: macOS (primary), Linux, WSL. install.sh must be POSIX-compatible bash.
- **Spec compliance**: Must pass `skills-ref validate` (if available) or equivalent internal validation
- **Size**: Generated SKILL.md <500 lines. Meta-skill SKILL.md <500 lines. API packages <8MB.
- **No breaking changes**: Users who `git pull` must not have their existing workflow broken.
---
## 7. Assumptions
- [ASSUMPTION] The Agent Skills Open Standard at agentskills.io/specification is the authoritative source of truth for the SKILL.md format
- [ASSUMPTION] All 26+ platforms that adopted the standard read SKILL.md identically — there are no platform-specific parsing differences in the frontmatter
- [ASSUMPTION] GitHub Copilot reads skills from `.github/skills/` in addition to `.claude/skills/` (confirmed by GitHub docs Dec 2025)
- [ASSUMPTION] Cursor supports SKILL.md natively alongside its `.mdc` rules (confirmed by Cursor docs)
- [ASSUMPTION] Users prefer a single `install.sh` over platform-specific install scripts
- [ASSUMPTION] The `-cskill` suffix removal is non-controversial — no user has expressed attachment to it
- [ASSUMPTION] The `article-to-prototype-cskill/` example can be renamed to `article-to-prototype/` without breaking existing users (it's an example, not an installed dependency)
- [ASSUMPTION] marketplace.json can be eliminated for simple skills without losing functionality — Claude Code can discover skills via SKILL.md alone when placed in `~/.claude/skills/` or `.claude/skills/`
- [ASSUMPTION] Security scanning only needs to catch obvious patterns (hardcoded keys, .env files, `eval()` calls, shell injection) — it's a first-pass filter, not a comprehensive SAST tool
---
## 8. Open Questions
- [ ] Q1: Should the tool offer to publish generated skills to SkillsMP or SkillHub directly? (Would require API integration with those platforms)
- [ ] Q2: Should `install.sh` also handle uninstallation (`./install.sh --uninstall`)?
- [ ] Q3: Should the validation system also check that referenced files in SKILL.md body actually exist in the skill directory?
- [ ] Q4: For Cursor users, should the export generate a `.mdc` file that wraps the SKILL.md content in Cursor's format, or just rely on Cursor's native SKILL.md support?

11
.claude-plugin/marketplace.json
View file

@ -1,11 +0,0 @@
{
"name": "agent-skill-creator",
"plugins": [
{
"name": "agent-skill-creator-plugin",
"description": "Create cross-platform agent skills from workflow descriptions. Activates when users ask to create an agent, automate a repetitive workflow, create a custom skill, or need advanced agent creation. Triggers on phrases like create agent for, automate workflow, create skill for, every day I have to, daily I need to, turn process into agent, need to automate, create a cross-platform skill, validate this skill, export this skill, migrate this skill. Supports single skills, multi-agent suites, transcript processing, template-based creation, interactive configuration, cross-platform export, and spec validation.",
"source": "./",
"skills": ["./"]
}
]
}

3
.gitignore vendored
View file

@ -19,6 +19,9 @@ build/
.DS_Store
Thumbs.db
# Linter cache
.ruff_cache/
# Logs
*.log

148
MIGRATION.md
View file

@ -1,148 +0,0 @@
# Migration Guide: v3.x to v4.0
## Overview
Agent-skill-creator v4.0 brings full compliance with the **Agent Skills Open Standard**, cross-platform support for 8+ platforms, and several breaking changes from v3.x.
## Breaking Changes
### 1. `-cskill` Suffix Removed
**Before (v3.x):**
```
pdf-text-extractor-cskill/
financial-analysis-suite-cskill/
```
**After (v4.0):**
```
pdf-text-extractor/
financial-analysis-suite/
```
**Migration:**
```bash
# Rename directory
mv my-skill-cskill my-skill
# Update SKILL.md frontmatter
# Change: name: my-skill-cskill
# To: name: my-skill
# Update marketplace.json (if present)
# Change: "name": "my-skill-cskill"
# To: "name": "my-skill"
```
### 2. marketplace.json Simplified
Non-standard fields have been removed. Simple skills no longer need marketplace.json at all.
**Before (v3.x):**
```json
{
"name": "my-skill-cskill",
"owner": { ... },
"metadata": { ... },
"plugins": [{ ... }],
"compatibility": { ... },
"templates": { ... },
"capabilities": { ... },
"activation": { ... },
"usage": { ... },
"test_queries": [...]
}
```
**After (v4.0):**
```json
{
"name": "my-skill",
"plugins": [{
"name": "my-skill-plugin",
"description": "...",
"source": "./",
"skills": ["./"]
}]
}
```
**Migration:**
- For simple skills: Delete `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` entirely
- For complex suites: Strip to only `name` and `plugins` fields
### 3. SKILL.md Frontmatter Updated
**Before (v3.x):** Only `name` and `description` required.
**After (v4.0):** Additional recommended fields:
```yaml
---
name: my-skill
description: >-
Description here (<=1024 chars)
license: MIT
metadata:
author: Your Name
version: 1.0.0
---
```
### 4. SKILL.md Body Size Limit
Generated SKILL.md files must now be **under 500 lines**. Move detailed content to `references/` files.
### 5. install.sh Added
Generated skills now include an `install.sh` cross-platform installer script.
## How to Migrate Existing Skills
### Automated Migration
Ask the agent-skill-creator to migrate:
```
"Migrate this skill to the new standard"
"Update my-skill to v4 format"
```
### Manual Migration Steps
1. **Rename directory** (remove `-cskill` suffix)
2. **Update SKILL.md frontmatter**:
- Remove `-cskill` from `name` field
- Add `license`, `metadata` fields
- Ensure `description` is <=1024 characters
3. **Simplify marketplace.json** (or delete for simple skills)
4. **Add install.sh** (copy from `scripts/install-template.sh` and customize)
5. **Update README.md** with multi-platform install instructions
6. **Validate**: Run `python3 scripts/validate.py ./my-skill/`
7. **Security scan**: Run `python3 scripts/security_scan.py ./my-skill/`
## Updating the Meta-Skill
If you have agent-skill-creator installed:
```bash
cd agent-skill-creator
git pull
```
The meta-skill will work immediately. No reinstallation required. The same trigger phrases and workflows still work.
## What Didn't Change
- The 5-phase pipeline (Discovery, Design, Architecture, Detection, Implementation)
- AgentDB integration (still optional)
- Support for both simple skills and complex suites
- Desktop/Web .zip export and Claude API export
- All activation trigger phrases
## New Features in v4.0
- **Cross-platform support**: Skills work on Claude Code, Copilot, Cursor, Windsurf, Cline, Codex CLI, Gemini CLI
- **install.sh**: Auto-detect platform and install to the correct location
- **Spec validation**: `scripts/validate.py` checks compliance with the Agent Skills Open Standard
- **Security scanning**: `scripts/security_scan.py` detects hardcoded keys and injection patterns
- **Lean SKILL.md**: Under 500 lines with progressive disclosure via references/

56
README.md
View file

@ -672,28 +672,6 @@ Each phase is documented in `references/phase{1..5}-*.md`.
---
## Migration from v3.x
Key changes in v4.0:
- `-cskill` suffix removed from skill names (use standard kebab-case)
- SKILL.md body limited to 500 lines (move detail to `references/`)
- `install.sh` cross-platform installer added
- Spec validation and security scanning tools added
- `marketplace.json` simplified (optional for simple skills)
Quick migration:
```bash
mv my-skill-cskill/ my-skill/
# Update SKILL.md name field to remove -cskill suffix
python3 scripts/validate.py ./my-skill/
```
For the complete migration guide, see [MIGRATION.md](MIGRATION.md).
---
## Troubleshooting
**Skill not activating**: Ensure SKILL.md `description` field contains the trigger phrases you expect. The description is the primary activation mechanism.
@ -714,46 +692,35 @@ For the complete migration guide, see [MIGRATION.md](MIGRATION.md).
```
agent-skill-creator/
SKILL.md # Meta-skill definition
SKILL.md # Meta-skill definition (the product)
README.md # This file
MIGRATION.md # v3.x to v4.0 migration guide
scripts/
validate.py # Spec compliance validator
security_scan.py # Security scanner
export_utils.py # Cross-platform export tool
skill_registry.py # Git-based shared skill registry
skill_registry.py # Shared skill registry CLI
install-template.sh # Template for generated install.sh
references/
pipeline-phases.md # Full 5-phase pipeline docs
pipeline-phases.md # Full 5-phase pipeline instructions
architecture-guide.md # Simple skill vs. complex suite
cross-platform-guide.md # Platform-specific details
export-guide.md # Export system documentation
quality-standards.md # Quality and code standards
templates-guide.md # Template system guide
interactive-mode.md # Interactive wizard docs
multi-agent-guide.md # Suite creation docs
agentdb-integration.md # Optional learning system
phase1-discovery.md # Phase 1 deep dive
phase2-design.md # Phase 2 deep dive
phase3-architecture.md # Phase 3 deep dive
phase4-detection.md # Phase 4 deep dive
phase5-implementation.md # Phase 5 deep dive
phase6-testing.md # Testing guide
quality-standards.md # Quality standards reference
templates-guide.md # Template system guide
templates/ # Skill templates
tools/ # Validation and scanning tools
examples/ # Example configurations
registry/ # Shared skill catalog (git-tracked)
examples/stock-analyzer/ # Example skill
registry/ # Shared skill catalog (git-tracked)
registry.json # Skill manifest
skills/ # Published skill directories
integrations/
agentdb_bridge.py # AgentDB integration bridge
fallback_system.py # Graceful degradation system
learning_feedback.py # Learning loop integration
validation_system.py # Integration validation
article-to-prototype/ # Example generated skill
exports/ # Export output directory
docs/
CHANGELOG.md # Version history
NAMING_CONVENTIONS.md # Naming rules reference
PIPELINE_ARCHITECTURE.md # Pipeline internals
DECISION_LOGIC.md # Architecture decision logic
```
---
@ -778,10 +745,7 @@ MIT License.
## Links
- [Agent Skills Open Standard](https://github.com/anthropics/agent-skills-spec)
- [Migration Guide (v3.x to v4.0)](MIGRATION.md)
- [Changelog](docs/CHANGELOG.md)
- [Architecture Guide](references/architecture-guide.md)
- [Pipeline Phases Reference](references/pipeline-phases.md)
- [Cross-Platform Guide](references/cross-platform-guide.md)
- [Export Guide](references/export-guide.md)
- [Activation Best Practices](references/ACTIVATION_BEST_PRACTICES.md)

11
article-to-prototype/.claude-plugin/marketplace.json
View file

@ -1,11 +0,0 @@
{
"name": "article-to-prototype",
"plugins": [
{
"name": "article-to-prototype-plugin",
"description": "Autonomously extracts technical content from articles (PDF, web, markdown, notebooks) and generates functional prototypes and proof-of-concept implementations in the appropriate programming language. Activates with phrases like extract from article, implement from paper, create prototype from, article to code, paper to prototype, parse pdf and implement, build from documentation.",
"source": "./",
"skills": ["./"]
}
]
}

401
article-to-prototype/DECISIONS.md
View file

@ -1,401 +0,0 @@
# Architectural Decisions
This document records the key architectural and design decisions made during the development of the Article-to-Prototype Skill.
---
## Decision 1: Simple Skill Architecture
**Context:** Need to choose between Simple Skill and Complex Skill Suite architecture.
**Decision:** Implemented as a Simple Skill with single focused objective.
**Rationale:**
- The skill has one clear purpose: article → prototype conversion
- Estimated ~1,800 lines of code fits Simple Skill criteria (<2,000 lines)
- All components work toward a single unified goal
- No need for multiple independent sub-skills
- Easier to maintain and understand
**Alternatives Considered:**
- **Skill Suite:** Would have separated extraction, analysis, and generation into independent skills
- **Rejected because:** Overhead of managing multiple skills, user would need to invoke separately, components are tightly coupled
---
## Decision 2: Multi-Format Extraction Strategy
**Context:** Users have articles in various formats (PDF, web, notebooks, markdown).
**Decision:** Implement specialized extractors for each format with a common interface.
**Rationale:**
- Each format has unique characteristics requiring specialized parsing
- Common `ExtractedContent` data structure allows downstream components to be format-agnostic
- Modular design enables easy addition of new formats
- Each extractor can use best-of-breed libraries (pdfplumber for PDF, trafilatura for web)
**Implementation:**
```python
# Common interface (duck typing)
class Extractor:
def extract(self, source: str) -> ExtractedContent
```
**Alternatives Considered:**
- **Single Universal Extractor:** Would have limited effectiveness for specialized formats
- **Format Conversion Pipeline:** Would have converted everything to intermediate format; rejected due to information loss
---
## Decision 3: Language Selection Logic
**Context:** Need to automatically choose the best programming language for generated prototype.
**Decision:** Implemented priority-based selection with 4 levels.
**Selection Priority:**
1. Explicit user hint (highest priority)
2. Detected from code blocks in article
3. Domain-based best practices
4. Dependency-based inference
5. Default to Python (fallback)
**Rationale:**
- Respects user preference when given
- Leverages article's existing code examples
- Uses domain knowledge (ML → Python, Systems → Rust)
- Python is most versatile default
**Alternatives Considered:**
- **User Always Chooses:** Rejected because removes automation benefit
- **Fixed Language:** Rejected because limits usefulness
- **ML Model for Selection:** Rejected due to complexity and training requirements
---
## Decision 4: Prototype Generation Approach
**Context:** Generated code must be production-quality without placeholders.
**Decision:** Template-based generation with dynamic content insertion.
**Quality Requirements:**
- No TODO comments or placeholders
- Full error handling
- Type safety (hints/annotations)
- Comprehensive documentation
- Working test suite
**Rationale:**
- Templates ensure consistent structure
- Dynamic insertion allows customization
- Quality gates prevent incomplete output
- Users can immediately run and extend generated code
**Alternatives Considered:**
- **LLM-Based Generation:** Considered but requires API access and may produce inconsistent results
- **Code Snippets Only:** Rejected because users need complete, runnable projects
- **Interactive Wizard:** Rejected to maintain fully autonomous operation
---
## Decision 5: Modular Pipeline Architecture
**Context:** System has multiple distinct processing stages.
**Decision:** Implemented pipeline with independent, composable stages.
**Pipeline Stages:**
```
Input → Extraction → Analysis → Selection → Generation → Output
```
**Rationale:**
- Each stage has single responsibility
- Stages can be tested independently
- Easy to add new extractors, analyzers, or generators
- Clear data flow and error boundaries
- Supports caching at each stage
**Alternatives Considered:**
- **Monolithic Processor:** Rejected due to complexity and testing difficulty
- **Event-Driven Architecture:** Overengineered for current requirements
---
## Decision 6: Content Analysis Strategy
**Context:** Need to understand article content to make generation decisions.
**Decision:** Rule-based analysis with pattern matching and keyword scoring.
**Components:**
- Algorithm detection (regex patterns + structural analysis)
- Architecture recognition (keyword matching + context extraction)
- Domain classification (TF-IDF-like scoring)
- Dependency extraction (import statement parsing)
**Rationale:**
- Rule-based approach is deterministic and explainable
- No training data required
- Fast execution (<10 seconds)
- Easy to extend with new patterns
- Transparent to users
**Alternatives Considered:**
- **NLP/ML Models:** Rejected due to complexity, latency, and dependency overhead
- **LLM-Based Analysis:** Considered but requires API access and adds latency
- **Manual User Input:** Rejected to maintain full automation
---
## Decision 7: Dependency Management
**Context:** Generated projects need dependency manifests (requirements.txt, package.json, etc.).
**Decision:** Extract dependencies from analysis and supplement with domain defaults.
**Strategy:**
1. Extract from article imports/mentions
2. Add domain-specific defaults (ML → numpy, pandas)
3. Include only essential dependencies
4. Version pinning where detected
**Rationale:**
- Ensures generated code has required dependencies
- Domain defaults cover common cases
- Minimizes dependency bloat
- Users can easily modify manifest
**Alternatives Considered:**
- **All Possible Dependencies:** Rejected due to bloat and installation time
- **No Dependencies:** Rejected because code wouldn't run
- **Minimal Set Only:** Current approach balances completeness and minimalism
---
## Decision 8: Error Handling Strategy
**Context:** Many failure modes: network errors, corrupt PDFs, unsupported formats, etc.
**Decision:** Graceful degradation with informative error messages.
**Approach:**
- Try best strategy first, fall back to alternatives
- Partial extraction better than complete failure
- Detailed error messages with actionable suggestions
- Logging at multiple levels (INFO, DEBUG, ERROR)
**Example:**
```python
# Try pdfplumber, fallback to PyPDF2
if HAS_PDFPLUMBER:
try:
return self._extract_with_pdfplumber(pdf_path)
except Exception as e:
logger.warning(f"pdfplumber failed: {e}, trying PyPDF2")
return self._extract_with_pypdf2(pdf_path)
```
**Rationale:**
- Maximizes success rate
- Provides useful feedback for failures
- Users can troubleshoot problems
- System degrades gracefully
---
## Decision 9: Testing Strategy
**Context:** Generated prototypes should include test scaffolding.
**Decision:** Generate basic test suite with placeholder tests and example integration test.
**Included Tests:**
- Integration test (main execution)
- Placeholder tests with instructive comments
- Test structure following language conventions
**Rationale:**
- Demonstrates testing approach
- Users can run tests immediately
- Encourages test-driven development
- Provides starting point for expansion
**What's NOT Included:**
- Complete test coverage (would be too opinionated)
- Mock data (users' data varies)
- Performance benchmarks (premature optimization)
---
## Decision 10: Caching Strategy
**Context:** Re-processing same article is wasteful.
**Decision:** Implemented multi-level cache with TTL.
**Cache Levels:**
1. Memory cache (current session)
2. Disk cache (24-hour TTL)
3. AgentDB (persistent learning)
**Rationale:**
- Improves performance for repeated operations
- Reduces API calls (web extraction)
- Enables offline re-processing
- 24-hour TTL balances freshness and performance
**Alternatives Considered:**
- **No Caching:** Rejected due to performance impact
- **Permanent Cache:** Rejected due to stale content risk
- **User-Controlled TTL:** Deferred to future version
---
## Decision 11: Documentation Generation
**Context:** Generated prototypes need user documentation.
**Decision:** Auto-generate comprehensive README with source attribution.
**README Includes:**
- Project overview
- Installation instructions (language-specific)
- Usage examples
- Source attribution with link
- License (MIT default)
**Rationale:**
- Users need context for generated code
- Installation steps vary by language
- Source attribution maintains traceability
- Complete documentation improves usability
**Alternatives Considered:**
- **Minimal README:** Rejected due to poor user experience
- **Separate Documentation:** Rejected; README is convention
---
## Decision 12: Language Support Priority
**Context:** Cannot support all programming languages initially.
**Decision:** Prioritize 5 languages with option to extend.
**Supported Languages:**
1. **Python** - ML, data science, general purpose
2. **JavaScript/TypeScript** - Web development
3. **Rust** - Systems programming
4. **Go** - Microservices, CLIs
5. **Julia** - Scientific computing
**Selection Rationale:**
- Cover major development domains
- Large user bases
- Mature ecosystems
- Distinct use cases
**Future Additions:**
- Java (enterprise)
- C++ (performance)
- Swift (iOS)
- Kotlin (Android)
---
## Decision 13: AgentDB Integration
**Context:** Skill should improve with usage (learning).
**Decision:** Design for AgentDB integration, implement gracefully without it.
**Integration Points:**
- Store successful patterns
- Query for similar past articles
- Learn optimal language mappings
- Validate decisions with historical data
**Rationale:**
- Progressive improvement over time
- Benefits from Agent-Skill-Creator ecosystem
- Works perfectly without AgentDB (fallback)
- Future-proofed for learning capabilities
**Implementation Note:**
Current v1.0 includes AgentDB interfaces but doesn't require AgentDB to function.
---
## Decision 14: Project Structure Conventions
**Context:** Generated projects should follow community standards.
**Decision:** Follow language-specific conventions strictly.
**Examples:**
- **Python:** `src/` for code, `tests/` for tests, PEP 8 style
- **JavaScript:** `index.js` entry point, `node_modules/` ignored
- **Rust:** `src/main.rs`, `Cargo.toml`, edition 2021
- **Go:** `main.go` in root, `go.mod` for dependencies
**Rationale:**
- Users expect familiar structures
- Tools work better with conventions
- Reduces cognitive load
- Enables immediate IDE integration
---
## Future Considerations
### Potential Enhancements
1. **Interactive Mode:** Ask user questions during generation
2. **Batch Processing:** Process multiple articles in parallel
3. **Incremental Updates:** Update existing prototypes with new articles
4. **Custom Templates:** User-defined generation templates
5. **More Languages:** Java, C++, Swift, Kotlin support
6. **Diagram Extraction:** Parse and implement architecture diagrams
7. **Video Transcripts:** Extract from video tutorials
8. **API Client Generation:** Auto-generate API clients from docs
### Performance Improvements
1. **Parallel Extraction:** Process long PDFs in parallel
2. **Streaming Analysis:** Analyze content as it's extracted
3. **Pre-compiled Patterns:** Cache regex compilation
4. **Incremental Generation:** Generate files in parallel
---
## Lessons Learned
### What Worked Well
- **Modular Architecture:** Easy to test and extend
- **Format-Specific Extractors:** Better quality than universal approach
- **Rule-Based Analysis:** Fast and deterministic
- **Template Generation:** Consistent, high-quality output
### What Could Be Improved
- **Algorithm Detection:** Still misses complex pseudocode
- **Dependency Resolution:** Could be more intelligent
- **Test Generation:** Too generic, needs domain-specific tests
- **Error Messages:** Could provide more specific troubleshooting
### What We'd Do Differently
- **Earlier Testing:** More test articles during development
- **Language Plugins:** More extensible language support architecture
- **Streaming Output:** Progress updates during long operations
- **Configuration System:** More user-configurable options
---
**Document Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-23
**Author:** Agent-Skill-Creator v2.1

391
article-to-prototype/README.md
View file

@ -1,391 +0,0 @@
# Article-to-Prototype Skill
**Version:** 1.0.0
**Type:** Claude Skill
**Architecture:** Simple Skill
Autonomously extracts technical content from articles (PDF, web, markdown, notebooks) and generates functional prototypes/POCs in the appropriate programming language.
---
## Overview
The Article-to-Prototype Skill bridges the gap between technical documentation and working code. It automates the time-consuming process of translating algorithms, architectures, and methodologies from written content into executable prototypes.
### Key Features
- **Multi-Format Extraction**: PDF, web pages, Jupyter notebooks, markdown
- **Intelligent Analysis**: Detects algorithms, architectures, dependencies, and domain
- **Language Selection**: Automatically chooses optimal programming language
- **Multi-Language Generation**: Python, JavaScript/TypeScript, Rust, Go, Julia
- **Production Quality**: Complete projects with tests, dependencies, and documentation
- **Source Attribution**: Maintains links to original articles
---
## Installation
### Prerequisites
- Python 3.8 or higher
- Claude Code CLI
### Install Dependencies
```bash
cd article-to-prototype
pip install -r requirements.txt
```
### Required Python Packages
```
PyPDF2>=3.0.0
pdfplumber>=0.10.0
requests>=2.31.0
beautifulsoup4>=4.12.0
trafilatura>=1.6.0
nbformat>=5.9.0
mistune>=3.0.0
```
---
## Usage
### In Claude Code
The skill activates automatically when you use phrases like:
```
"Extract algorithm from paper.pdf and implement in Python"
"Create prototype from https://example.com/tutorial"
"Implement the code described in notebook.ipynb"
"Parse this article and build a working version"
```
### Command Line
```bash
# Basic usage
python scripts/main.py path/to/article.pdf
# Specify output directory
python scripts/main.py article.pdf -o ./my-prototype
# Specify target language
python scripts/main.py article.pdf -l rust
# Verbose output
python scripts/main.py article.pdf -v
```
---
## Examples
### Example 1: PDF Algorithm Paper
**Input:**
```bash
python scripts/main.py papers/dijkstra.pdf
```
**Output:**
```
article-to-prototype/output/
├── src/
│ ├── main.py # Dijkstra implementation
│ └── graph.py # Graph data structure
├── tests/
│ └── test_main.py # Unit tests
├── requirements.txt
├── README.md
└── .gitignore
```
### Example 2: Web Tutorial
**Input:**
```bash
python scripts/main.py https://realpython.com/python-REST-api -l python
```
**Output:**
```
output/
├── src/
│ ├── main.py # REST API server
│ └── routes.py # API endpoints
├── requirements.txt # flask, requests
├── README.md
└── .gitignore
```
### Example 3: Jupyter Notebook
**Input:**
```bash
python scripts/main.py ml-tutorial.ipynb
```
**Output:**
```
output/
├── src/
│ ├── model.py # ML model
│ ├── preprocessing.py # Data preprocessing
│ └── training.py # Training loop
├── requirements.txt # numpy, pandas, sklearn
├── tests/
└── README.md
```
---
## Supported Formats
### PDF Documents
- Academic papers
- Technical reports
- Books and chapters
- Presentations
### Web Content
- Blog posts
- Documentation sites
- Tutorials
- GitHub READMEs
### Jupyter Notebooks
- Code and markdown cells
- Cell outputs
- Metadata and dependencies
### Markdown Files
- Standard markdown
- YAML front matter
- Code fences
- GFM (GitHub Flavored Markdown)
---
## Supported Languages
| Language | Use Cases | Generated Files |
|----------|-----------|-----------------|
| **Python** | ML, data science, scripting | main.py, requirements.txt, tests |
| **JavaScript** | Web apps, Node.js | index.js, package.json |
| **TypeScript** | Type-safe web apps | index.ts, tsconfig.json, package.json |
| **Rust** | Systems, performance | main.rs, Cargo.toml |
| **Go** | Microservices, CLIs | main.go, go.mod |
| **Julia** | Scientific computing | main.jl, Project.toml |
---
## How It Works
### Pipeline Overview
```
Input → Extraction → Analysis → Language Selection → Generation → Output
```
### 1. Extraction Phase
- Detects input format (PDF, URL, notebook, markdown)
- Applies specialized extractor
- Preserves structure, code blocks, and metadata
### 2. Analysis Phase
- **Algorithm Detection**: Identifies algorithms, pseudocode, and procedures
- **Architecture Recognition**: Finds design patterns and system architectures
- **Domain Classification**: Categorizes content (ML, web dev, systems, etc.)
- **Dependency Extraction**: Discovers required libraries and tools
### 3. Language Selection
Selection priority:
1. Explicit user hint (`-l python`)
2. Detected from code blocks
3. Domain best practices (ML → Python, Web → TypeScript)
4. Dependency analysis
5. Default to Python
### 4. Generation Phase
Creates complete project:
- Main implementation with algorithms
- Dependency manifest
- Test suite structure
- Comprehensive README
- .gitignore
---
## Configuration
### Environment Variables
```bash
# Optional: Custom cache directory
export ARTICLE_PROTOTYPE_CACHE_DIR=~/.article-to-prototype
# Optional: Default output language
export ARTICLE_PROTOTYPE_DEFAULT_LANG=python
```
### Custom Prompts
Edit `assets/prompts/analysis_prompt.txt` to customize analysis behavior.
---
## Quality Standards
Every generated prototype includes:
- ✅ **No Placeholders**: Fully implemented functions
- ✅ **Type Safety**: Type hints, annotations, or strong typing
- ✅ **Error Handling**: Try/catch, Result types, error returns
- ✅ **Logging**: Structured logging throughout
- ✅ **Documentation**: Docstrings and README
- ✅ **Tests**: Basic test suite structure
- ✅ **Source Attribution**: Links to original article
---
## Troubleshooting
### PDF Extraction Issues
**Problem:** "No text extracted from PDF"
**Solutions:**
- PDF may be scanned (image-based) - try OCR preprocessing
- Try alternative URL if article is available online
- Check if PDF is corrupted
### Web Extraction Issues
**Problem:** "Failed to fetch URL"
**Solutions:**
- Check internet connection
- Verify URL is accessible
- Some sites may block automated access
- Try downloading HTML and processing locally
### Dependency Issues
**Problem:** "Import error for pdfplumber"
**Solution:**
```bash
pip install --upgrade -r requirements.txt
```
---
## Performance
### Typical Processing Times
| Operation | Duration |
|-----------|----------|
| PDF extraction (20 pages) | 3-5 seconds |
| Web page extraction | 2-4 seconds |
| Content analysis | 5-10 seconds |
| Code generation (Python) | 10-15 seconds |
| **Total (end-to-end)** | **30-45 seconds** |
### Optimization Tips
- Use local files instead of URLs when possible
- Cache is enabled by default (24-hour TTL)
- Run with `-v` flag to see detailed progress
---
## Advanced Usage
### Batch Processing
```python
from scripts.main import ArticleToPrototype
orchestrator = ArticleToPrototype()
articles = [
"paper1.pdf",
"paper2.pdf",
"https://example.com/tutorial"
]
for article in articles:
result = orchestrator.process(
source=article,
output_dir=f"./output_{i}"
)
print(f"Generated: {result['output_dir']}")
```
### Custom Analysis
```python
from scripts.analyzers.content_analyzer import ContentAnalyzer
from scripts.extractors.pdf_extractor import PDFExtractor
# Extract
extractor = PDFExtractor()
content = extractor.extract("article.pdf")
# Custom analysis
analyzer = ContentAnalyzer()
analysis = analyzer.analyze(content)
# Access results
print(f"Domain: {analysis.domain}")
print(f"Algorithms: {len(analysis.algorithms)}")
for algo in analysis.algorithms:
print(f" - {algo.name}: {algo.description}")
```
---
## Contributing
This skill is part of the Agent-Skill-Creator ecosystem. To contribute:
1. Test the skill with various article types
2. Report issues with specific examples
3. Suggest new features or languages
4. Submit extraction pattern improvements
---
## License
MIT License - See LICENSE file for details
---
## Acknowledgments
- Created by Agent-Skill-Creator v2.1
- Extraction libraries: PyPDF2, pdfplumber, trafilatura, BeautifulSoup
- Follows Agent-Skill-Creator quality standards
---
## Version History
### v1.0.0 (2025-10-23)
- Initial release
- Multi-format extraction (PDF, web, notebooks, markdown)
- Multi-language generation (Python, JS/TS, Rust, Go, Julia)
- Intelligent analysis and language selection
- Production-quality code generation
---
**Generated by:** Agent-Skill-Creator v2.1
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-23
**Documentation:** See SKILL.md for comprehensive details

2067
article-to-prototype/SKILL.md
View file

File diff suppressed because it is too large Load diff

46
article-to-prototype/assets/examples/sample_input.md
View file

@ -1,46 +0,0 @@
# Quick Sort Algorithm
## Overview
Quick Sort is an efficient, divide-and-conquer sorting algorithm. It works by selecting a 'pivot' element and partitioning the array around it.
## Algorithm
The Quick Sort algorithm follows these steps:
1. Choose a pivot element from the array
2. Partition the array so that:
- Elements less than pivot are on the left
- Elements greater than pivot are on the right
3. Recursively apply the same process to sub-arrays
## Complexity
- **Time Complexity**: O(n log n) average case, O(n²) worst case
- **Space Complexity**: O(log n) for recursion stack
## Implementation Outline
```python
def quick_sort(arr):
if len(arr) <= 1:
return arr
pivot = arr[len(arr) // 2]
left = [x for x in arr if x < pivot]
middle = [x for x in arr if x == pivot]
right = [x for x in arr if x > pivot]
return quick_sort(left) + middle + quick_sort(right)
```
## Usage
Quick Sort is widely used for:
- General-purpose sorting
- In-place sorting when memory is limited
- Systems where average-case performance matters
## References
Hoare, C. A. R. (1962). "Quicksort". The Computer Journal.

31
article-to-prototype/assets/prompts/analysis_prompt.txt
View file

@ -1,31 +0,0 @@
Analyze the following technical content and identify:
1. **Algorithms**: Any described algorithms, procedures, or methods
- Name and description
- Steps or pseudocode
- Complexity if mentioned
2. **Architectures**: System or software architecture patterns
- Pattern name (microservices, MVC, etc.)
- Components and their relationships
- Design decisions
3. **Dependencies**: Required libraries, frameworks, or tools
- Library names
- Versions if specified
- Purpose or usage
4. **Domain**: Primary technical domain
- Machine learning
- Web development
- Systems programming
- Data science
- Scientific computing
- Other
5. **Technical Concepts**: Key concepts explained
- Definitions
- Relationships
- Implementation notes
Provide structured analysis with confidence scores.

80
article-to-prototype/references/analysis-methodology.md
View file

@ -1,80 +0,0 @@
# Analysis Methodology Reference
## Content Analysis Pipeline
1. **Text Combination**: Aggregate all text from sections, headings, and code context
2. **Tokenization**: Split into sentences and words
3. **Pattern Matching**: Apply regex patterns for algorithms, architectures
4. **Domain Classification**: Score content against domain vocabularies
5. **Complexity Assessment**: Evaluate based on length, technical terms, structure
## Domain Classification
### Methodology
- **Keyword Frequency**: Count occurrences of domain-specific terms
- **TF-IDF Scoring**: Weight terms by importance
- **Threshold**: Minimum 3 keyword matches for confident classification
- **Default**: "general_programming" if no strong match
### Domain Vocabularies
Each domain has 10-15 characteristic keywords that indicate its presence.
## Algorithm Detection
### Multi-Strategy Approach
1. **Explicit Detection**
- Look for "Algorithm X:" patterns
- Find numbered procedural steps
- Extract complexity notation (O(...))
2. **Pseudocode Recognition**
- Detect keywords: BEGIN, END, FOR, WHILE, IF
- Identify indented structure
- Check for procedural language
3. **Code Analysis**
- Count control flow structures (loops, conditionals)
- Identify function definitions
- Look for mathematical operations
## Architecture Detection
### Pattern Matching
- Maintain database of known patterns
- Search for pattern names in text
- Extract surrounding context
### Relationship Extraction
- Identify verbs connecting components: "uses", "calls", "extends"
- Map component interactions
- Build dependency graph
## Complexity Assessment
### Scoring Factors
- **Content Length**: >10,000 chars = +2, >5,000 = +1
- **Section Count**: >10 sections = +2, >5 = +1
- **Code Blocks**: >5 blocks = +2, >2 = +1
- **Technical Terms**: +1 for each of: algorithm, optimization, architecture, distributed, concurrent
### Classification
- Score >= 6: Complex
- Score >= 3: Moderate
- Score < 3: Simple
## Confidence Calculation
### Base Confidence
Start at 0.5 (50%)
### Adjustments
- +0.2 if algorithms detected
- +0.1 if architectures detected
- +0.2 if domain classified (not general)
- Cap at 1.0 (100%)
### Interpretation
- > 0.7: High confidence
- 0.5-0.7: Medium confidence
- < 0.5: Low confidence

117
article-to-prototype/references/extraction-patterns.md
View file

@ -1,117 +0,0 @@
# Extraction Patterns Reference
This document describes extraction patterns for different content formats.
## PDF Extraction Patterns
### Academic Papers
- **Title**: Usually in first 20 lines, larger font
- **Abstract**: Labeled section, typically after title
- **Sections**: Numbered or titled (Introduction, Methods, Results, Conclusion)
- **Algorithms**: Indented, numbered steps, or "Algorithm X:" headers
- **Code**: Monospace font, background shading
- **References**: Last section, bibliographic format
### Technical Reports
- Similar to academic papers but may include:
- Executive summary at start
- Appendices with detailed data
- Diagrams and flowcharts (text descriptions)
## Web Content Patterns
### Blog Posts
- **Main Content**: Usually in `<article>` or `<main>` tags
- **Code Blocks**: `<pre><code>` tags with language classes
- **Headings**: `<h1>` through `<h6>` for structure
- **Metadata**: `<meta>` tags and Open Graph properties
### Documentation Sites
- **Navigation**: Sidebar or header navigation (filter out)
- **Content Area**: Main documentation content
- **Code Examples**: Syntax-highlighted blocks
- **API Specs**: Structured format with endpoints
## Jupyter Notebook Patterns
### Cell Types
- **Markdown Cells**: Explanatory text, headings, images
- **Code Cells**: Executable Python (or other language) code
- **Raw Cells**: Unformatted text (rare)
### Content Organization
- Title usually in first markdown cell (# heading)
- Imports typically in first code cell
- Alternating explanations (markdown) and code
- Outputs follow code cells
## Markdown Patterns
### YAML Front Matter
```yaml
---
title: Document Title
author: Author Name
date: 2025-01-01
---
```
### Structure
- **Headings**: # through ###### for hierarchy
- **Code Fences**: ```language notation
- **Lists**: Numbered (1. 2. 3.) or bulleted (- * +)
- **Links**: [text](url) format
- **Inline Code**: `backticks`
## Algorithm Detection Patterns
### Explicit Algorithms
```
Algorithm 1: Quick Sort
1. Choose pivot element
2. Partition array
3. Recursively sort partitions
```
### Pseudocode
```
PROCEDURE Dijkstra(Graph, source):
FOR each vertex v in Graph:
distance[v] := infinity
previous[v] := undefined
distance[source] := 0
...
```
### Inline Descriptions
"The algorithm works by first sorting the input array,
then performing a binary search..."
## Architecture Detection Patterns
### Explicit Mentions
- "The system uses a microservices architecture..."
- "We implement the MVC pattern..."
- "This follows an event-driven approach..."
### Component Descriptions
- "The frontend communicates with the backend via REST API"
- "Services are orchestrated using Kubernetes"
- "Data flows through an ETL pipeline"
## Dependency Detection Patterns
### Import Statements
- Python: `import numpy`, `from pandas import DataFrame`
- JavaScript: `const express = require('express')`
- Java: `import java.util.List;`
### Installation Commands
- `pip install tensorflow`
- `npm install react`
- `cargo add tokio`
### Inline Mentions
- "This implementation uses TensorFlow for training"
- "Built with React and Express"
- "Requires Python 3.8+"

170
article-to-prototype/references/generation-rules.md
View file

@ -1,170 +0,0 @@
# Generation Rules Reference
## Code Generation Principles
### 1. Completeness
- No TODO comments
- No placeholder functions
- All imports present
- Full error handling
### 2. Quality Standards
- Type hints/annotations where supported
- Docstrings/documentation comments
- Logging at appropriate levels
- Clean variable names
### 3. Structure
- Follow language conventions
- Standard directory layout
- Separation of concerns
- Testable architecture
## Language-Specific Rules
### Python
- **File**: `src/main.py`
- **Dependencies**: `requirements.txt`
- **Tests**: `tests/test_main.py`
- **Style**: PEP 8 compliant
- **Type Hints**: Required for functions
- **Docstrings**: Google or NumPy style
### JavaScript/TypeScript
- **File**: `index.js` or `index.ts`
- **Dependencies**: `package.json`
- **Style**: Standard or ESLint
- **Modules**: ES6 or CommonJS
- **Exports**: Named and default exports
### Rust
- **File**: `src/main.rs`
- **Dependencies**: `Cargo.toml`
- **Tests**: Inline with `#[cfg(test)]`
- **Documentation**: `///` comments
- **Error Handling**: Result types
### Go
- **File**: `main.go`
- **Package**: `package main`
- **Error Handling**: Explicit error returns
- **Tests**: `_test.go` files
## Project Structure Rules
### Minimum Files
1. Main implementation file
2. Dependency manifest
3. README.md
4. .gitignore
### Recommended Files
5. Test suite
6. Configuration examples
7. License file
8. Documentation
## README Generation Rules
### Required Sections
1. **Title**: Project name
2. **Overview**: Brief description with source attribution
3. **Installation**: Platform-specific instructions
4. **Usage**: Basic examples
5. **Source Attribution**: Link to original article
### Optional Sections
- Implementation Details
- Testing Instructions
- API Documentation
- Troubleshooting
## Dependency Management
### Strategies
1. Extract from analysis dependencies
2. Add based on domain (ML → numpy, pandas)
3. Include only necessary deps
4. Pin versions where possible
### Defaults by Domain
- **ML**: numpy, pandas, scikit-learn
- **Web**: requests, flask/express
- **Data**: pandas, matplotlib
## Error Handling Strategy
### Python
```python
try:
operation()
except SpecificError as e:
logger.error(f"Operation failed: {e}")
raise
```
### TypeScript
```typescript
try {
operation();
} catch (error) {
console.error('Operation failed:', error);
throw error;
}
```
### Rust
```rust
fn operation() -> Result<T, Error> {
// Use ? operator for propagation
let result = risky_call()?;
Ok(result)
}
```
## Testing Generation Rules
### Test Structure
- At least one integration test (main execution)
- Placeholder tests for expansion
- Example assertions
- Clear test names
### Python Example
```python
def test_main_execution():
"""Test that main runs without errors"""
try:
main()
assert True
except Exception as e:
pytest.fail(f"Execution failed: {e}")
```
## Documentation Rules
### Inline Comments
- Explain non-obvious logic
- Avoid stating the obvious
- Link to source article concepts
- Include complexity notes
### Function Documentation
- Purpose/description
- Parameters with types
- Return value
- Exceptions raised
- Examples (optional)
## Source Attribution Rules
### Required Information
- Original article title
- Article URL or path
- Extraction date
- Generator tool version
### Placement
- File headers
- README overview
- Main function docstring

19
article-to-prototype/requirements.txt
View file

@ -1,19 +0,0 @@
# Article-to-Prototype Skill Dependencies
# PDF Processing
PyPDF2>=3.0.0
pdfplumber>=0.10.0
# Web Content Extraction
requests>=2.31.0
beautifulsoup4>=4.12.0
trafilatura>=1.6.0
# Jupyter Notebook Support
nbformat>=5.9.0
# Markdown Processing
mistune>=3.0.0
# Optional: If using Claude API for enhanced analysis
# anthropic>=0.18.0

8
article-to-prototype/scripts/__init__.py
View file

@ -1,8 +0,0 @@
"""
Article-to-Prototype Skill
Extracts technical content from articles and generates functional prototypes.
"""
__version__ = "1.0.0"
__author__ = "Agent-Skill-Creator"

21
article-to-prototype/scripts/analyzers/__init__.py
View file

@ -1,21 +0,0 @@
"""
Analyzers Module
Provides analysis components for content understanding:
- Content analyzer for technical concepts
- Code detector for algorithms and pseudocode
"""
from .content_analyzer import ContentAnalyzer, AnalysisResult, Algorithm, Architecture, Dependency
from .code_detector import CodeDetector, CodeFragment, PseudocodeBlock
__all__ = [
'ContentAnalyzer',
'AnalysisResult',
'Algorithm',
'Architecture',
'Dependency',
'CodeDetector',
'CodeFragment',
'PseudocodeBlock',
]

124
article-to-prototype/scripts/analyzers/code_detector.py
View file

@ -1,124 +0,0 @@
"""
Code Detector
Detects and analyzes code fragments, pseudocode, and language hints.
"""
import logging
import re
from typing import List, Optional
from dataclasses import dataclass
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@dataclass
class CodeFragment:
"""Represents a detected code fragment"""
content: str
language: Optional[str]
fragment_type: str # 'code', 'pseudocode', 'snippet'
line_number: int
@dataclass
class PseudocodeBlock:
"""Represents a pseudocode block"""
content: str
algorithm_name: str
steps: List[str]
class CodeDetector:
"""Detects code and pseudocode in content"""
PSEUDOCODE_INDICATORS = [
'algorithm', 'procedure', 'begin', 'end', 'step', 'input:', 'output:'
]
LANGUAGE_INDICATORS = {
'python': ['def ', 'import ', 'print(', 'self.', '__init__'],
'javascript': ['function', 'const ', 'let ', '=>', 'console.'],
'java': ['public class', 'void ', 'System.out'],
'c++': ['#include', 'cout', 'std::'],
'rust': ['fn ', 'let mut', 'impl '],
'go': ['func ', 'package ', ':='],
}
def detect_code_fragments(self, content: Any) -> List[CodeFragment]:
"""Detect all code and pseudocode fragments"""
fragments = []
# Code blocks from extractors
for i, code_block in enumerate(content.code_blocks):
fragment_type = 'pseudocode' if self._is_pseudocode(code_block.code) else 'code'
fragments.append(CodeFragment(
content=code_block.code,
language=code_block.language,
fragment_type=fragment_type,
line_number=code_block.line_number or i
))
logger.info(f"Detected {len(fragments)} code fragments")
return fragments
def detect_language_hints(self, content: Any) -> List[str]:
"""Detect mentioned programming languages"""
hints = set()
text_lower = content.raw_text.lower()
# Explicit mentions
for lang in self.LANGUAGE_INDICATORS.keys():
if lang in text_lower or f'{lang} ' in text_lower:
hints.add(lang)
# From code block annotations
for code_block in content.code_blocks:
if code_block.language:
hints.add(code_block.language)
logger.debug(f"Detected language hints: {hints}")
return list(hints)
def extract_pseudocode(self, text: str) -> List[PseudocodeBlock]:
"""Extract and structure pseudocode blocks"""
blocks = []
# Simple pseudocode detection
lines = text.split('\n')
in_pseudocode = False
current_block = []
algo_name = ''
for line in lines:
line_lower = line.lower()
# Check for algorithm start
if any(ind in line_lower for ind in ['algorithm', 'procedure']):
in_pseudocode = True
algo_name = line.strip()
current_block = []
elif in_pseudocode:
if line.strip() and not line.strip().startswith(('#', '//')):
current_block.append(line)
# Check for end
if 'end' in line_lower or (line.strip() == '' and len(current_block) > 3):
if current_block:
blocks.append(PseudocodeBlock(
content='\n'.join(current_block),
algorithm_name=algo_name,
steps=current_block
))
in_pseudocode = False
current_block = []
return blocks
def _is_pseudocode(self, code: str) -> bool:
"""Check if code looks like pseudocode"""
code_lower = code.lower()
count = sum(1 for ind in self.PSEUDOCODE_INDICATORS if ind in code_lower)
return count >= 2

412
article-to-prototype/scripts/analyzers/content_analyzer.py
View file

@ -1,412 +0,0 @@
"""
Content Analyzer
Analyzes extracted content to identify technical concepts, algorithms,
architectures, and domain classification.
"""
import logging
import re
from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Any
from dataclasses import dataclass, field
from collections import Counter
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@dataclass
class Algorithm:
"""Represents a detected algorithm"""
name: str
description: str
steps: List[str]
complexity: Optional[str] = None
pseudocode: Optional[str] = None
@dataclass
class Architecture:
"""Represents a detected architecture pattern"""
name: str
description: str
components: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)
relationships: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)
@dataclass
class Dependency:
"""Represents a dependency or required library"""
name: str
version: Optional[str] = None
purpose: str = ''
@dataclass
class AnalysisResult:
"""Result of content analysis"""
algorithms: List[Algorithm]
architectures: List[Architecture]
dependencies: List[Dependency]
domain: str
complexity: str # "simple", "moderate", "complex"
confidence: float # 0.0 to 1.0
metadata: Dict[str, Any] = field(default_factory=dict)
class ContentAnalyzer:
"""Analyzes extracted content for technical concepts"""
# Domain indicators with keywords
DOMAIN_INDICATORS = {
"machine_learning": [
"neural network", "training", "model", "dataset", "accuracy",
"loss function", "tensorflow", "pytorch", "keras", "scikit-learn",
"classifier", "regression", "supervised", "unsupervised", "deep learning"
],
"web_development": [
"http", "rest", "api", "frontend", "backend", "server", "client",
"route", "endpoint", "express", "react", "vue", "angular", "django",
"flask", "authentication", "middleware"
],
"systems_programming": [
"concurrency", "thread", "process", "memory", "performance",
"optimization", "low-level", "kernel", "system call", "scheduling",
"mutex", "semaphore", "deadlock", "race condition"
],
"data_science": [
"pandas", "numpy", "analysis", "visualization", "statistics",
"dataframe", "matplotlib", "seaborn", "jupyter", "correlation",
"distribution", "hypothesis"
],
"scientific_computing": [
"numerical", "simulation", "computation", "algorithm", "matrix",
"equation", "optimization", "julia", "fortran", "solver",
"differential", "integration"
],
"devops": [
"docker", "kubernetes", "ci/cd", "deployment", "infrastructure",
"container", "orchestration", "pipeline", "jenkins", "terraform",
"monitoring", "logging"
]
}
# Algorithm keywords
ALGORITHM_KEYWORDS = [
"algorithm", "procedure", "method", "technique", "approach",
"sort", "search", "traverse", "optimize", "compute", "calculate"
]
# Architecture patterns
ARCHITECTURE_PATTERNS = {
"microservices": ["microservice", "service-oriented", "distributed services"],
"mvc": ["model-view-controller", "mvc", "model view controller"],
"layered": ["layered architecture", "n-tier", "three-tier", "multi-layer"],
"event-driven": ["event-driven", "event bus", "event sourcing", "pub-sub"],
"pipeline": ["pipeline", "data pipeline", "etl", "stream processing"],
"client-server": ["client-server", "client/server", "server-client"],
}
# Library/dependency patterns
LIBRARY_PATTERNS = [
(re.compile(r'\b(?:import|from|require|include)\s+([a-zA-Z_][\w.]*)', re.IGNORECASE), 1),
(re.compile(r'\b(?:using|with)\s+([a-zA-Z_][\w.]*)', re.IGNORECASE), 1),
(re.compile(r'\bpip install\s+([a-zA-Z_][\w-]*)', re.IGNORECASE), 1),
(re.compile(r'\bnpm install\s+([a-zA-Z_][\w-]*)', re.IGNORECASE), 1),
]
def __init__(self):
"""Initialize content analyzer"""
self.algorithm_pattern = re.compile(
r'(?:algorithm|procedure|method)\s+(\d+)?[:\s]+(.+?)(?:\n|$)',
re.IGNORECASE
)
self.complexity_pattern = re.compile(r'O\([^)]+\)', re.IGNORECASE)
def analyze(self, content: Any) -> AnalysisResult:
"""
Analyze extracted content for technical concepts.
Args:
content: ExtractedContent object from extractor
Returns:
AnalysisResult with detected algorithms, architectures, etc.
"""
logger.info("Analyzing content")
# Combine all text for analysis
full_text = self._combine_text(content)
# Detect algorithms
algorithms = self.detect_algorithms(content)
# Detect architectures
architectures = self._detect_architectures(full_text)
# Extract dependencies
dependencies = self._extract_dependencies(content)
# Classify domain
domain = self.classify_domain(full_text)
# Assess complexity
complexity = self._assess_complexity(content)
# Calculate confidence
confidence = self._calculate_confidence(algorithms, architectures, domain)
logger.info(f"Analysis complete: domain={domain}, complexity={complexity}, confidence={confidence:.2f}")
return AnalysisResult(
algorithms=algorithms,
architectures=architectures,
dependencies=dependencies,
domain=domain,
complexity=complexity,
confidence=confidence,
metadata={
'num_algorithms': len(algorithms),
'num_architectures': len(architectures),
'num_dependencies': len(dependencies),
}
)
def _combine_text(self, content: Any) -> str:
"""Combine all text content for analysis"""
parts = [content.raw_text]
# Add section content
for section in content.sections:
parts.append(section.heading)
parts.append(section.content)
# Add code context
for code_block in content.code_blocks:
if code_block.context:
parts.append(code_block.context)
return '\n'.join(parts).lower()
def detect_algorithms(self, content: Any) -> List[Algorithm]:
"""Detect and extract algorithms from content"""
algorithms = []
# Search in raw text
text = content.raw_text
# Method 1: Look for explicit algorithm declarations
for match in self.algorithm_pattern.finditer(text):
algo_num = match.group(1)
algo_desc = match.group(2).strip()
# Extract steps (look for numbered lists after the declaration)
steps = self._extract_algorithm_steps(text, match.end())
# Try to find complexity
complexity = None
complexity_match = self.complexity_pattern.search(text[match.start():match.end() + 500])
if complexity_match:
complexity = complexity_match.group(0)
algorithms.append(Algorithm(
name=f"Algorithm {algo_num}" if algo_num else "Algorithm",
description=algo_desc,
steps=steps,
complexity=complexity
))
# Method 2: Look in code blocks for algorithmic code
for code_block in content.code_blocks:
if self._is_algorithmic_code(code_block.code):
algorithms.append(Algorithm(
name=code_block.context[:50] if code_block.context else "Detected Algorithm",
description=code_block.context or "Algorithm from code",
steps=[],
pseudocode=code_block.code
))
logger.debug(f"Detected {len(algorithms)} algorithms")
return algorithms
def _extract_algorithm_steps(self, text: str, start_pos: int) -> List[str]:
"""Extract numbered steps following an algorithm declaration"""
steps = []
lines = text[start_pos:start_pos + 1000].split('\n')
step_pattern = re.compile(r'^\s*(?:\d+[\.\)]\s+|[-*]\s+)(.+)$')
for line in lines:
match = step_pattern.match(line)
if match:
steps.append(match.group(1).strip())
elif steps and line.strip() == '':
# Empty line might indicate end of steps
break
elif steps:
# Non-step line after steps started, might be end
if not line.strip():
continue
if line[0].isalpha() and not line.strip().startswith('-'):
break
return steps[:20] # Max 20 steps
def _is_algorithmic_code(self, code: str) -> bool:
"""Check if code looks like an algorithm implementation"""
code_lower = code.lower()
# Look for algorithmic patterns
patterns = [
'def ', 'function ', 'procedure',
'for ', 'while ', 'loop',
'if ', 'else', 'switch', 'case',
'return', 'yield'
]
count = sum(1 for pattern in patterns if pattern in code_lower)
return count >= 3 # At least 3 algorithmic keywords
def _detect_architectures(self, text: str) -> List[Architecture]:
"""Detect architecture patterns"""
architectures = []
for arch_name, keywords in self.ARCHITECTURE_PATTERNS.items():
for keyword in keywords:
if keyword in text:
# Found architecture mention
context = self._extract_context(text, keyword, 200)
architectures.append(Architecture(
name=arch_name.replace('_', ' ').title(),
description=context,
components=[],
relationships=[]
))
break # Don't duplicate
logger.debug(f"Detected {len(architectures)} architectures")
return architectures
def _extract_context(self, text: str, keyword: str, window: int = 200) -> str:
"""Extract context around a keyword"""
pos = text.index(keyword)
start = max(0, pos - window // 2)
end = min(len(text), pos + len(keyword) + window // 2)
return text[start:end].strip()
def _extract_dependencies(self, content: Any) -> List[Dependency]:
"""Extract dependencies from code and text"""
dependencies = {}
# Extract from code blocks
for code_block in content.code_blocks:
for pattern, group_num in self.LIBRARY_PATTERNS:
matches = pattern.findall(code_block.code)
for match in matches:
lib_name = match.split('.')[0].strip()
if lib_name and len(lib_name) > 1:
dependencies[lib_name] = Dependency(
name=lib_name,
version=None,
purpose='Detected from imports'
)
# Extract from notebook metadata if available
if 'dependencies' in content.metadata:
for dep in content.metadata['dependencies']:
if dep not in dependencies:
dependencies[dep] = Dependency(
name=dep,
version=None,
purpose='Detected from notebook'
)
logger.debug(f"Extracted {len(dependencies)} dependencies")
return list(dependencies.values())
def classify_domain(self, text: str) -> str:
"""
Classify content domain based on keywords.
Args:
text: Text content (should be lowercase)
Returns:
Domain name
"""
scores = {domain: 0 for domain in self.DOMAIN_INDICATORS}
# Count keyword occurrences
for domain, keywords in self.DOMAIN_INDICATORS.items():
for keyword in keywords:
if keyword in text:
scores[domain] += 1
# Find highest scoring domain
if max(scores.values()) > 0:
domain = max(scores, key=scores.get)
logger.debug(f"Classified as {domain} (score: {scores[domain]})")
return domain
# Default to general programming
return "general_programming"
def _assess_complexity(self, content: Any) -> str:
"""Assess content complexity"""
# Simple heuristics
score = 0
# More sections = more complex
if len(content.sections) > 10:
score += 2
elif len(content.sections) > 5:
score += 1
# More code blocks = more complex
if len(content.code_blocks) > 5:
score += 2
elif len(content.code_blocks) > 2:
score += 1
# Long content = more complex
if len(content.raw_text) > 10000:
score += 2
elif len(content.raw_text) > 5000:
score += 1
# Technical terms indicate complexity
technical_terms = [
'algorithm', 'optimization', 'complexity', 'architecture',
'distributed', 'concurrent', 'asynchronous'
]
text_lower = content.raw_text.lower()
score += sum(1 for term in technical_terms if term in text_lower)
# Classify
if score >= 6:
return "complex"
elif score >= 3:
return "moderate"
else:
return "simple"
def _calculate_confidence(
self,
algorithms: List[Algorithm],
architectures: List[Architecture],
domain: str
) -> float:
"""Calculate confidence score for analysis"""
confidence = 0.5 # Base confidence
# More detected concepts = higher confidence
if algorithms:
confidence += 0.2
if architectures:
confidence += 0.1
# Non-default domain = higher confidence
if domain != "general_programming":
confidence += 0.2
return min(1.0, confidence)

19
article-to-prototype/scripts/extractors/__init__.py
View file

@ -1,19 +0,0 @@
"""
Extractors Module
Provides extractors for different content formats:
- PDF documents
- Web pages
- Jupyter notebooks
- Markdown files
"""
from .pdf_extractor import PDFExtractor, PDFExtractionError, ExtractedContent, Section, CodeBlock
__all__ = [
'PDFExtractor',
'PDFExtractionError',
'ExtractedContent',
'Section',
'CodeBlock',
]

204
article-to-prototype/scripts/extractors/markdown_extractor.py
View file

@ -1,204 +0,0 @@
"""
Markdown Extractor
Parses markdown files and extracts structure and content.
"""
import logging
import re
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Any
from datetime import datetime
try:
import mistune
HAS_MISTUNE = True
except ImportError:
HAS_MISTUNE = False
from .pdf_extractor import ExtractedContent, Section, CodeBlock
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
class MarkdownExtractionError(Exception):
"""Raised when markdown extraction fails"""
pass
class MarkdownExtractor:
"""Extracts content from markdown files"""
def __init__(self):
"""Initialize markdown extractor"""
self.code_fence_pattern = re.compile(
r'```(\w+)?\n(.*?)\n```',
re.DOTALL
)
self.heading_pattern = re.compile(r'^(#{1,6})\s+(.+)$', re.MULTILINE)
def extract(self, markdown_path: str) -> ExtractedContent:
"""
Extract content from a markdown file.
Args:
markdown_path: Path to the .md file
Returns:
ExtractedContent object with structured content
Raises:
MarkdownExtractionError: If parsing fails
"""
path = Path(markdown_path)
if not path.exists():
raise FileNotFoundError(f"Markdown file not found: {markdown_path}")
logger.info(f"Extracting markdown: {markdown_path}")
try:
with open(markdown_path, 'r', encoding='utf-8') as f:
content = f.read()
except Exception as e:
raise MarkdownExtractionError(f"Failed to read markdown: {e}")
# Extract YAML front matter if present
front_matter, content = self._extract_front_matter(content)
# Extract title
title = self._extract_title(content, front_matter)
# Extract code blocks
code_blocks = self.extract_code_blocks(content)
# Extract sections
sections = self._extract_sections(content)
# Build metadata
metadata = {
'file_name': path.name,
'file_path': str(path),
'num_sections': len(sections),
'num_code_blocks': len(code_blocks),
**front_matter
}
logger.info(f"Extracted {len(sections)} sections and {len(code_blocks)} code blocks")
return ExtractedContent(
title=title,
sections=sections,
code_blocks=code_blocks,
metadata=metadata,
source_url=None,
extraction_date=datetime.now(),
raw_text=content
)
def _extract_front_matter(self, content: str) -> tuple[Dict[str, Any], str]:
"""Extract YAML front matter from markdown"""
front_matter = {}
# Check for YAML front matter (--- ... ---)
if content.startswith('---\n'):
try:
end_index = content.index('\n---\n', 4)
yaml_content = content[4:end_index]
content = content[end_index + 5:]
# Simple YAML parsing (key: value pairs)
for line in yaml_content.split('\n'):
if ':' in line:
key, value = line.split(':', 1)
front_matter[key.strip()] = value.strip()
logger.debug(f"Extracted front matter: {front_matter}")
except ValueError:
# No closing ---, treat as regular content
pass
return front_matter, content
def _extract_title(self, content: str, front_matter: Dict[str, Any]) -> str:
"""Extract title from markdown"""
# Try front matter first
if 'title' in front_matter:
return front_matter['title']
# Look for first # heading
match = self.heading_pattern.search(content)
if match:
return match.group(2).strip()
return "Untitled Document"
def _extract_sections(self, content: str) -> List[Section]:
"""Extract sections based on headings"""
sections = []
# Find all headings
headings = list(self.heading_pattern.finditer(content))
for i, match in enumerate(headings):
heading_level = len(match.group(1))
heading_text = match.group(2).strip()
start_pos = match.end()
# Find content until next heading or end
if i + 1 < len(headings):
end_pos = headings[i + 1].start()
else:
end_pos = len(content)
section_content = content[start_pos:end_pos].strip()
# Remove code blocks from section content for cleaner reading
section_content_clean = self.code_fence_pattern.sub(
'[code block]',
section_content
)
sections.append(Section(
heading=heading_text,
level=heading_level,
content=section_content_clean,
line_number=content[:start_pos].count('\n'),
subsections=[]
))
logger.debug(f"Found {len(sections)} sections")
return sections
def extract_code_blocks(self, content: str) -> List[CodeBlock]:
"""
Extract code blocks from markdown.
Args:
content: Markdown content string
Returns:
List of CodeBlock objects
"""
code_blocks = []
# Find all code fences
for i, match in enumerate(self.code_fence_pattern.finditer(content)):
language = match.group(1) # Language annotation
code = match.group(2).strip()
# Get context (text before code block)
context_start = max(0, match.start() - 200)
context_text = content[context_start:match.start()]
# Get last line as context
context = context_text.split('\n')[-1].strip() if context_text else ''
code_blocks.append(CodeBlock(
language=language,
code=code,
line_number=content[:match.start()].count('\n'),
context=context
))
logger.debug(f"Found {len(code_blocks)} code blocks")
return code_blocks

251
article-to-prototype/scripts/extractors/notebook_extractor.py
View file

@ -1,251 +0,0 @@
"""
Notebook Extractor
Parses Jupyter notebooks and extracts code, markdown, and outputs.
"""
import logging
import json
import re
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Any
from datetime import datetime
try:
import nbformat
HAS_NBFORMAT = True
except ImportError:
HAS_NBFORMAT = False
from .pdf_extractor import ExtractedContent, Section, CodeBlock
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
class NotebookExtractionError(Exception):
"""Raised when notebook extraction fails"""
pass
class NotebookExtractor:
"""Extracts content from Jupyter notebooks"""
def __init__(self):
"""Initialize notebook extractor"""
if not HAS_NBFORMAT:
raise ImportError("nbformat not installed. Install with: pip install nbformat")
def extract(self, notebook_path: str) -> ExtractedContent:
"""
Extract content from a Jupyter notebook.
Args:
notebook_path: Path to the .ipynb file
Returns:
ExtractedContent object with cells and outputs
Raises:
NotebookExtractionError: If parsing fails
"""
path = Path(notebook_path)
if not path.exists():
raise FileNotFoundError(f"Notebook not found: {notebook_path}")
if not path.suffix.lower() == '.ipynb':
raise NotebookExtractionError(f"Not a notebook file: {notebook_path}")
logger.info(f"Extracting notebook: {notebook_path}")
try:
with open(notebook_path, 'r', encoding='utf-8') as f:
nb = nbformat.read(f, as_version=4)
except Exception as e:
raise NotebookExtractionError(f"Failed to read notebook: {e}")
# Extract title from metadata or first markdown cell
title = self._extract_title(nb)
# Extract sections from markdown cells
sections = []
code_blocks = []
raw_text_parts = []
for i, cell in enumerate(nb.cells):
if cell.cell_type == 'markdown':
section = self._process_markdown_cell(cell, i)
if section:
sections.append(section)
raw_text_parts.append(f"## {section.heading}\n{section.content}")
elif cell.cell_type == 'code':
code_block = self._process_code_cell(cell, i)
if code_block:
code_blocks.append(code_block)
raw_text_parts.append(f"```python\n{code_block.code}\n```")
# Extract metadata
metadata = self._extract_metadata(nb, notebook_path)
# Extract dependencies from code cells
dependencies = self.extract_dependencies(notebook_path)
metadata['dependencies'] = dependencies
raw_text = '\n\n'.join(raw_text_parts)
logger.info(f"Extracted {len(sections)} sections and {len(code_blocks)} code blocks")
return ExtractedContent(
title=title,
sections=sections,
code_blocks=code_blocks,
metadata=metadata,
source_url=None,
extraction_date=datetime.now(),
raw_text=raw_text
)
def _extract_title(self, nb: Any) -> str:
"""Extract title from notebook"""
# Try metadata first
if hasattr(nb, 'metadata') and 'title' in nb.metadata:
return nb.metadata['title']
# Look for title in first markdown cell
for cell in nb.cells:
if cell.cell_type == 'markdown':
lines = cell.source.split('\n')
for line in lines:
if line.startswith('#'):
title = line.lstrip('#').strip()
if title:
return title
return "Untitled Notebook"
def _process_markdown_cell(self, cell: Any, cell_num: int) -> Optional[Section]:
"""Process markdown cell into a section"""
content = cell.source.strip()
if not content:
return None
# Check if starts with heading
lines = content.split('\n')
if lines[0].startswith('#'):
heading_line = lines[0]
level = len(heading_line) - len(heading_line.lstrip('#'))
heading = heading_line.lstrip('#').strip()
body = '\n'.join(lines[1:]).strip()
return Section(
heading=heading,
level=level,
content=body,
line_number=cell_num,
subsections=[]
)
# If no heading, create generic section
return Section(
heading=f"Cell {cell_num}",
level=3,
content=content,
line_number=cell_num,
subsections=[]
)
def _process_code_cell(self, cell: Any, cell_num: int) -> Optional[CodeBlock]:
"""Process code cell into a code block"""
code = cell.source.strip()
if not code:
return None
# Extract language from cell metadata
language = 'python' # Default for Jupyter
if hasattr(cell, 'metadata') and 'language' in cell.metadata:
language = cell.metadata['language']
# Get output as context
context = ''
if hasattr(cell, 'outputs') and cell.outputs:
output_texts = []
for output in cell.outputs[:3]: # First 3 outputs
if hasattr(output, 'text'):
output_texts.append(str(output.text)[:100])
elif hasattr(output, 'data') and 'text/plain' in output.data:
output_texts.append(str(output.data['text/plain'])[:100])
if output_texts:
context = ' | '.join(output_texts)
return CodeBlock(
language=language,
code=code,
line_number=cell_num,
context=context
)
def _extract_metadata(self, nb: Any, notebook_path: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Extract notebook metadata"""
metadata = {
'file_name': Path(notebook_path).name,
'file_path': notebook_path,
'num_cells': len(nb.cells) if hasattr(nb, 'cells') else 0,
}
# Extract kernel info
if hasattr(nb, 'metadata'):
if 'kernelspec' in nb.metadata:
kernel = nb.metadata['kernelspec']
metadata['kernel_name'] = kernel.get('name', 'unknown')
metadata['kernel_display_name'] = kernel.get('display_name', 'unknown')
if 'language_info' in nb.metadata:
lang_info = nb.metadata['language_info']
metadata['language'] = lang_info.get('name', 'unknown')
metadata['language_version'] = lang_info.get('version', 'unknown')
return metadata
def extract_code_cells(self, notebook_path: str) -> List[CodeBlock]:
"""Extract only code cells"""
content = self.extract(notebook_path)
return content.code_blocks
def extract_dependencies(self, notebook_path: str) -> List[str]:
"""
Extract imported libraries and dependencies.
Args:
notebook_path: Path to notebook
Returns:
List of dependency names
"""
try:
with open(notebook_path, 'r', encoding='utf-8') as f:
nb = nbformat.read(f, as_version=4)
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to read notebook for dependencies: {e}")
return []
dependencies = set()
import_pattern = re.compile(
r'^\s*(?:from\s+(\S+)\s+)?import\s+(\S+)',
re.MULTILINE
)
for cell in nb.cells:
if cell.cell_type == 'code':
matches = import_pattern.findall(cell.source)
for match in matches:
# match[0] is 'from X', match[1] is 'import Y'
dep = match[0] if match[0] else match[1]
# Get root package name
root_dep = dep.split('.')[0]
dependencies.add(root_dep)
logger.debug(f"Extracted dependencies: {dependencies}")
return sorted(list(dependencies))

478
article-to-prototype/scripts/extractors/pdf_extractor.py
View file

@ -1,478 +0,0 @@
"""
PDF Extractor
Extracts text, structure, and metadata from PDF documents using multiple strategies.
Preserves code blocks, section structure, and handles various PDF formats.
"""
import logging
import re
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Any, Tuple
from dataclasses import dataclass
from datetime import datetime
try:
import pdfplumber
HAS_PDFPLUMBER = True
except ImportError:
HAS_PDFPLUMBER = False
try:
import PyPDF2
HAS_PYPDF2 = True
except ImportError:
HAS_PYPDF2 = False
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
class PDFExtractionError(Exception):
"""Raised when PDF extraction fails"""
pass
@dataclass
class Section:
"""Represents a document section"""
heading: str
level: int
content: str
line_number: int
subsections: List['Section']
@dataclass
class CodeBlock:
"""Represents a code block"""
language: Optional[str]
code: str
line_number: Optional[int]
context: str
@dataclass
class ExtractedContent:
"""Structured extracted content"""
title: str
sections: List[Section]
code_blocks: List[CodeBlock]
metadata: Dict[str, Any]
source_url: Optional[str]
extraction_date: datetime
raw_text: str
class PDFExtractor:
"""Extracts content from PDF files with structure preservation"""
def __init__(self):
"""Initialize PDF extractor"""
if not HAS_PDFPLUMBER and not HAS_PYPDF2:
raise ImportError(
"Neither pdfplumber nor PyPDF2 is installed. "
"Install with: pip install pdfplumber PyPDF2"
)
self.heading_patterns = [
re.compile(r'^(\d+\.)+\s+[A-Z]'), # 1.1 Title
re.compile(r'^[A-Z][A-Z\s]+$'), # ALL CAPS TITLE
re.compile(r'^Abstract\s*$', re.IGNORECASE),
re.compile(r'^Introduction\s*$', re.IGNORECASE),
re.compile(r'^Conclusion\s*$', re.IGNORECASE),
re.compile(r'^References\s*$', re.IGNORECASE),
]
self.code_indicators = [
'algorithm', 'procedure', 'function', 'def ', 'class ',
'import ', 'for(', 'while(', 'if(', '{', '}', ';'
]
def extract(self, pdf_path: str) -> ExtractedContent:
"""
Extract content from a PDF file.
Args:
pdf_path: Path to the PDF file
Returns:
ExtractedContent object with structured data
Raises:
PDFExtractionError: If extraction fails
FileNotFoundError: If PDF file doesn't exist
"""
path = Path(pdf_path)
if not path.exists():
raise FileNotFoundError(f"PDF file not found: {pdf_path}")
if not path.suffix.lower() == '.pdf':
raise PDFExtractionError(f"Not a PDF file: {pdf_path}")
logger.info(f"Extracting content from PDF: {pdf_path}")
# Try pdfplumber first (better layout analysis)
if HAS_PDFPLUMBER:
try:
return self._extract_with_pdfplumber(pdf_path)
except Exception as e:
logger.warning(f"pdfplumber extraction failed: {e}, trying PyPDF2")
if HAS_PYPDF2:
return self._extract_with_pypdf2(pdf_path)
raise
# Fallback to PyPDF2
if HAS_PYPDF2:
return self._extract_with_pypdf2(pdf_path)
raise PDFExtractionError("No PDF library available for extraction")
def _extract_with_pdfplumber(self, pdf_path: str) -> ExtractedContent:
"""Extract using pdfplumber (preferred method)"""
logger.debug("Using pdfplumber for extraction")
text_content = []
metadata = {}
try:
with pdfplumber.open(pdf_path) as pdf:
# Extract metadata
if pdf.metadata:
metadata = {
'title': pdf.metadata.get('Title', ''),
'author': pdf.metadata.get('Author', ''),
'subject': pdf.metadata.get('Subject', ''),
'creator': pdf.metadata.get('Creator', ''),
'producer': pdf.metadata.get('Producer', ''),
'creation_date': pdf.metadata.get('CreationDate', ''),
}
# Extract text from all pages
for page_num, page in enumerate(pdf.pages, 1):
try:
text = page.extract_text()
if text:
text_content.append(f"\n--- Page {page_num} ---\n{text}")
logger.debug(f"Extracted {len(text)} chars from page {page_num}")
except Exception as e:
logger.warning(f"Failed to extract page {page_num}: {e}")
continue
except Exception as e:
raise PDFExtractionError(f"pdfplumber extraction failed: {e}")
if not text_content:
raise PDFExtractionError("No text content extracted from PDF")
raw_text = '\n'.join(text_content)
logger.info(f"Extracted {len(raw_text)} characters from PDF")
# Process extracted text
return self._process_extracted_text(raw_text, metadata, pdf_path)
def _extract_with_pypdf2(self, pdf_path: str) -> ExtractedContent:
"""Extract using PyPDF2 (fallback method)"""
logger.debug("Using PyPDF2 for extraction")
text_content = []
metadata = {}
try:
with open(pdf_path, 'rb') as file:
reader = PyPDF2.PdfReader(file)
# Extract metadata
if reader.metadata:
metadata = {
'title': reader.metadata.get('/Title', ''),
'author': reader.metadata.get('/Author', ''),
'subject': reader.metadata.get('/Subject', ''),
'creator': reader.metadata.get('/Creator', ''),
'producer': reader.metadata.get('/Producer', ''),
}
# Extract text from all pages
for page_num, page in enumerate(reader.pages, 1):
try:
text = page.extract_text()
if text:
text_content.append(f"\n--- Page {page_num} ---\n{text}")
logger.debug(f"Extracted {len(text)} chars from page {page_num}")
except Exception as e:
logger.warning(f"Failed to extract page {page_num}: {e}")
continue
except Exception as e:
raise PDFExtractionError(f"PyPDF2 extraction failed: {e}")
if not text_content:
raise PDFExtractionError("No text content extracted from PDF")
raw_text = '\n'.join(text_content)
logger.info(f"Extracted {len(raw_text)} characters from PDF")
# Process extracted text
return self._process_extracted_text(raw_text, metadata, pdf_path)
def _process_extracted_text(
self,
raw_text: str,
metadata: Dict[str, Any],
pdf_path: str
) -> ExtractedContent:
"""Process raw extracted text into structured content"""
# Extract title
title = self._extract_title(raw_text, metadata)
# Extract sections
sections = self._extract_sections(raw_text)
# Extract code blocks
code_blocks = self._extract_code_blocks(raw_text)
# Build metadata
full_metadata = {
**metadata,
'file_name': Path(pdf_path).name,
'file_path': pdf_path,
'num_sections': len(sections),
'num_code_blocks': len(code_blocks),
}
return ExtractedContent(
title=title,
sections=sections,
code_blocks=code_blocks,
metadata=full_metadata,
source_url=None,
extraction_date=datetime.now(),
raw_text=raw_text
)
def _extract_title(self, text: str, metadata: Dict[str, Any]) -> str:
"""Extract document title"""
# First, try metadata
if metadata.get('title'):
title = metadata['title'].strip()
if title and title.lower() != 'untitled':
logger.debug(f"Using title from metadata: {title}")
return title
# Try to find title in first few lines
lines = text.split('\n')
for i, line in enumerate(lines[:20]): # Check first 20 lines
line = line.strip()
if len(line) > 10 and len(line) < 200:
# Likely a title if it's not too short or too long
if not line.startswith('---'): # Skip page markers
logger.debug(f"Using title from content: {line}")
return line
# Fallback
return "Untitled Document"
def _extract_sections(self, text: str) -> List[Section]:
"""Extract document sections with headings"""
sections = []
lines = text.split('\n')
current_section = None
current_content = []
for i, line in enumerate(lines):
stripped = line.strip()
# Check if line is a heading
is_heading, level = self._is_heading(stripped)
if is_heading:
# Save previous section if exists
if current_section:
current_section.content = '\n'.join(current_content).strip()
sections.append(current_section)
# Start new section
current_section = Section(
heading=stripped,
level=level,
content='',
line_number=i,
subsections=[]
)
current_content = []
elif current_section:
# Add content to current section
current_content.append(line)
# Save last section
if current_section:
current_section.content = '\n'.join(current_content).strip()
sections.append(current_section)
logger.info(f"Extracted {len(sections)} sections")
return sections
def _is_heading(self, line: str) -> Tuple[bool, int]:
"""
Determine if a line is a heading and its level.
Returns:
Tuple of (is_heading, level)
"""
if not line or len(line) < 3:
return False, 0
# Check against heading patterns
for pattern in self.heading_patterns:
if pattern.match(line):
# Determine level based on numbering
if line[0].isdigit():
level = line.split()[0].count('.') + 1
else:
level = 1
return True, level
# Check for short uppercase lines (potential headings)
if line.isupper() and 3 < len(line) < 50 and ' ' in line:
return True, 1
return False, 0
def _extract_code_blocks(self, text: str) -> List[CodeBlock]:
"""Extract code blocks from text"""
code_blocks = []
lines = text.split('\n')
in_code_block = False
current_code = []
code_start_line = 0
context = ''
for i, line in enumerate(lines):
# Check if line looks like code
is_code = self._is_code_line(line)
if is_code and not in_code_block:
# Start of code block
in_code_block = True
code_start_line = i
current_code = [line]
# Capture context (previous line)
if i > 0:
context = lines[i - 1].strip()
elif is_code and in_code_block:
# Continue code block
current_code.append(line)
elif not is_code and in_code_block:
# End of code block
if len(current_code) > 2: # Minimum 3 lines for a code block
code_blocks.append(CodeBlock(
language=self._detect_language('\n'.join(current_code)),
code='\n'.join(current_code),
line_number=code_start_line,
context=context
))
in_code_block = False
current_code = []
context = ''
# Save last code block if exists
if in_code_block and len(current_code) > 2:
code_blocks.append(CodeBlock(
language=self._detect_language('\n'.join(current_code)),
code='\n'.join(current_code),
line_number=code_start_line,
context=context
))
logger.info(f"Extracted {len(code_blocks)} code blocks")
return code_blocks
def _is_code_line(self, line: str) -> bool:
"""Check if a line looks like code"""
stripped = line.strip()
# Empty lines don't indicate code
if not stripped:
return False
# Check for code indicators
for indicator in self.code_indicators:
if indicator in stripped.lower():
return True
# Check for indentation (common in code)
if line.startswith(' ') or line.startswith('\t'):
return True
# Check for common code patterns
if re.search(r'[=\+\-\*\/]{2,}', stripped): # Multiple operators
return True
if re.search(r'[\(\)\{\}\[\];]', stripped): # Brackets and semicolons
return True
if re.search(r'^\s*\d+[\.\)]\s+', stripped): # Numbered steps (algorithm)
return True
return False
def _detect_language(self, code: str) -> Optional[str]:
"""Detect programming language from code"""
code_lower = code.lower()
language_indicators = {
'python': ['def ', 'import ', 'from ', 'print(', '__init__', 'self.'],
'javascript': ['function ', 'const ', 'let ', 'var ', '=>', 'console.'],
'java': ['public class', 'private ', 'void ', 'System.out'],
'c++': ['#include', 'cout', 'std::', 'namespace'],
'c': ['#include', 'printf', 'int main'],
'rust': ['fn ', 'let mut', 'impl ', 'pub '],
'go': ['func ', 'package ', 'import (', ':='],
'pseudocode': ['algorithm', 'procedure', 'begin', 'end', 'step '],
}
scores = {lang: 0 for lang in language_indicators}
for lang, indicators in language_indicators.items():
for indicator in indicators:
if indicator in code_lower:
scores[lang] += 1
# Return language with highest score
max_score = max(scores.values())
if max_score > 0:
detected = max(scores, key=scores.get)
logger.debug(f"Detected language: {detected} (score: {max_score})")
return detected
return None
def extract_metadata(self, pdf_path: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Extract only metadata from PDF.
Args:
pdf_path: Path to PDF file
Returns:
Dictionary of metadata
"""
logger.debug(f"Extracting metadata from: {pdf_path}")
if HAS_PDFPLUMBER:
try:
with pdfplumber.open(pdf_path) as pdf:
if pdf.metadata:
return dict(pdf.metadata)
except Exception as e:
logger.warning(f"pdfplumber metadata extraction failed: {e}")
if HAS_PYPDF2:
try:
with open(pdf_path, 'rb') as file:
reader = PyPDF2.PdfReader(file)
if reader.metadata:
return {k.replace('/', ''): v for k, v in reader.metadata.items()}
except Exception as e:
logger.warning(f"PyPDF2 metadata extraction failed: {e}")
return {}

502
article-to-prototype/scripts/extractors/web_extractor.py
View file

@ -1,502 +0,0 @@
"""
Web Extractor
Fetches and extracts content from web pages and online documentation.
Removes boilerplate, extracts code blocks, and preserves article structure.
"""
import logging
import re
import time
from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Any
from datetime import datetime
from urllib.parse import urlparse, urljoin
from dataclasses import dataclass
try:
import requests
HAS_REQUESTS = True
except ImportError:
HAS_REQUESTS = False
try:
from bs4 import BeautifulSoup
HAS_BS4 = True
except ImportError:
HAS_BS4 = False
try:
import trafilatura
HAS_TRAFILATURA = True
except ImportError:
HAS_TRAFILATURA = False
from .pdf_extractor import ExtractedContent, Section, CodeBlock
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
class WebExtractionError(Exception):
"""Raised when web extraction fails"""
pass
class WebExtractor:
"""Extracts content from web pages with boilerplate removal"""
def __init__(
self,
timeout: int = 30,
max_retries: int = 3,
user_agent: Optional[str] = None
):
"""
Initialize web extractor.
Args:
timeout: Request timeout in seconds
max_retries: Maximum number of retry attempts
user_agent: Custom user agent string
"""
if not HAS_REQUESTS:
raise ImportError("requests library not installed. Install with: pip install requests")
if not HAS_BS4 and not HAS_TRAFILATURA:
raise ImportError(
"Neither BeautifulSoup4 nor trafilatura is installed. "
"Install with: pip install beautifulsoup4 trafilatura"
)
self.timeout = timeout
self.max_retries = max_retries
self.user_agent = user_agent or (
"Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; Article-to-Prototype/1.0)"
)
self.session = requests.Session()
self.session.headers.update({'User-Agent': self.user_agent})
def extract(self, url: str) -> ExtractedContent:
"""
Extract content from a web page.
Args:
url: URL to fetch and extract
Returns:
ExtractedContent object with structured data
Raises:
WebExtractionError: If fetching or parsing fails
"""
logger.info(f"Extracting content from URL: {url}")
# Validate URL
if not self._is_valid_url(url):
raise WebExtractionError(f"Invalid URL: {url}")
# Fetch HTML content
html = self._fetch_html(url)
# Extract content using best available method
if HAS_TRAFILATURA:
try:
return self._extract_with_trafilatura(html, url)
except Exception as e:
logger.warning(f"trafilatura extraction failed: {e}, trying BeautifulSoup")
if HAS_BS4:
return self._extract_with_beautifulsoup(html, url)
raise
if HAS_BS4:
return self._extract_with_beautifulsoup(html, url)
raise WebExtractionError("No web extraction library available")
def _is_valid_url(self, url: str) -> bool:
"""Validate URL format"""
try:
result = urlparse(url)
return all([result.scheme in ['http', 'https'], result.netloc])
except Exception:
return False
def _fetch_html(self, url: str) -> str:
"""
Fetch HTML content with retries.
Args:
url: URL to fetch
Returns:
HTML content as string
Raises:
WebExtractionError: If fetching fails
"""
last_error = None
for attempt in range(1, self.max_retries + 1):
try:
logger.debug(f"Fetching URL (attempt {attempt}/{self.max_retries})")
response = self.session.get(url, timeout=self.timeout)
response.raise_for_status()
# Check content type
content_type = response.headers.get('Content-Type', '').lower()
if 'text/html' not in content_type and 'text/plain' not in content_type:
logger.warning(f"Unexpected content type: {content_type}")
logger.info(f"Successfully fetched {len(response.text)} characters")
return response.text
except requests.exceptions.Timeout as e:
last_error = e
logger.warning(f"Request timeout on attempt {attempt}")
if attempt < self.max_retries:
time.sleep(2 ** attempt) # Exponential backoff
except requests.exceptions.HTTPError as e:
status_code = e.response.status_code
if status_code == 404:
raise WebExtractionError(f"Page not found (404): {url}")
elif status_code == 403:
raise WebExtractionError(f"Access forbidden (403): {url}")
elif status_code >= 500:
last_error = e
logger.warning(f"Server error {status_code} on attempt {attempt}")
if attempt < self.max_retries:
time.sleep(2 ** attempt)
else:
raise WebExtractionError(f"HTTP error {status_code}: {url}")
except requests.exceptions.RequestException as e:
last_error = e
logger.warning(f"Request failed on attempt {attempt}: {e}")
if attempt < self.max_retries:
time.sleep(2 ** attempt)
raise WebExtractionError(f"Failed to fetch URL after {self.max_retries} attempts: {last_error}")
def _extract_with_trafilatura(self, html: str, url: str) -> ExtractedContent:
"""Extract using trafilatura (preferred for main content)"""
logger.debug("Using trafilatura for extraction")
# Extract main content
main_text = trafilatura.extract(
html,
include_comments=False,
include_tables=True,
no_fallback=False,
favor_precision=True
)
if not main_text:
raise WebExtractionError("trafilatura failed to extract content")
# Extract metadata
metadata = trafilatura.extract_metadata(html)
metadata_dict = {}
if metadata:
metadata_dict = {
'title': metadata.title or '',
'author': metadata.author or '',
'date': metadata.date or '',
'description': metadata.description or '',
'sitename': metadata.sitename or '',
'url': url,
}
# Also use BeautifulSoup for code blocks if available
code_blocks = []
if HAS_BS4:
soup = BeautifulSoup(html, 'html.parser')
code_blocks = self._extract_code_blocks_bs4(soup)
# Extract sections from main text
sections = self._parse_text_into_sections(main_text)
# Get title
title = metadata_dict.get('title', 'Untitled Article')
return ExtractedContent(
title=title,
sections=sections,
code_blocks=code_blocks,
metadata=metadata_dict,
source_url=url,
extraction_date=datetime.now(),
raw_text=main_text
)
def _extract_with_beautifulsoup(self, html: str, url: str) -> ExtractedContent:
"""Extract using BeautifulSoup (fallback method)"""
logger.debug("Using BeautifulSoup for extraction")
soup = BeautifulSoup(html, 'html.parser')
# Remove script and style elements
for element in soup(['script', 'style', 'nav', 'header', 'footer', 'aside']):
element.decompose()
# Extract title
title_tag = soup.find('title')
title = title_tag.get_text().strip() if title_tag else 'Untitled Article'
# Try to find main content area
main_content = (
soup.find('main') or
soup.find('article') or
soup.find('div', class_=re.compile(r'content|article|post', re.I)) or
soup.find('body')
)
if not main_content:
raise WebExtractionError("Could not find main content area")
# Extract text
text = main_content.get_text(separator='\n', strip=True)
# Extract metadata from meta tags
metadata = self._extract_metadata_bs4(soup)
metadata['url'] = url
# Extract sections
sections = self._extract_sections_bs4(main_content)
# Extract code blocks
code_blocks = self._extract_code_blocks_bs4(main_content)
return ExtractedContent(
title=title,
sections=sections,
code_blocks=code_blocks,
metadata=metadata,
source_url=url,
extraction_date=datetime.now(),
raw_text=text
)
def _extract_metadata_bs4(self, soup: BeautifulSoup) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Extract metadata from HTML meta tags"""
metadata = {}
# Try Open Graph tags
og_title = soup.find('meta', property='og:title')
if og_title:
metadata['title'] = og_title.get('content', '')
og_description = soup.find('meta', property='og:description')
if og_description:
metadata['description'] = og_description.get('content', '')
og_author = soup.find('meta', property='og:author')
if og_author:
metadata['author'] = og_author.get('content', '')
# Try standard meta tags
if 'description' not in metadata:
description = soup.find('meta', attrs={'name': 'description'})
if description:
metadata['description'] = description.get('content', '')
if 'author' not in metadata:
author = soup.find('meta', attrs={'name': 'author'})
if author:
metadata['author'] = author.get('content', '')
return metadata
def _extract_sections_bs4(self, content: BeautifulSoup) -> List[Section]:
"""Extract sections based on heading tags"""
sections = []
current_section = None
current_content = []
for element in content.find_all(['h1', 'h2', 'h3', 'h4', 'h5', 'h6', 'p', 'pre']):
if element.name.startswith('h'):
# Save previous section
if current_section:
current_section.content = '\n'.join(current_content).strip()
sections.append(current_section)
# Start new section
level = int(element.name[1])
current_section = Section(
heading=element.get_text().strip(),
level=level,
content='',
line_number=0,
subsections=[]
)
current_content = []
elif current_section:
text = element.get_text().strip()
if text:
current_content.append(text)
# Save last section
if current_section:
current_section.content = '\n'.join(current_content).strip()
sections.append(current_section)
logger.info(f"Extracted {len(sections)} sections")
return sections
def _extract_code_blocks_bs4(self, content: BeautifulSoup) -> List[CodeBlock]:
"""Extract code blocks from HTML"""
code_blocks = []
# Find all code blocks (pre, code tags)
for i, code_element in enumerate(content.find_all(['pre', 'code'])):
code_text = code_element.get_text().strip()
if not code_text or len(code_text) < 10:
continue
# Try to detect language from class
language = None
classes = code_element.get('class', [])
for cls in classes:
if cls.startswith('language-'):
language = cls.replace('language-', '')
break
elif cls.startswith('lang-'):
language = cls.replace('lang-', '')
break
# Get context (surrounding text)
context = ''
prev_sibling = code_element.find_previous_sibling(['p', 'h1', 'h2', 'h3', 'h4'])
if prev_sibling:
context = prev_sibling.get_text().strip()[:100]
code_blocks.append(CodeBlock(
language=language,
code=code_text,
line_number=i,
context=context
))
logger.info(f"Extracted {len(code_blocks)} code blocks")
return code_blocks
def _parse_text_into_sections(self, text: str) -> List[Section]:
"""Parse plain text into sections based on structure"""
sections = []
lines = text.split('\n')
heading_pattern = re.compile(r'^#+\s+(.+)$|^([A-Z][A-Za-z\s]+)$')
current_section = None
current_content = []
for i, line in enumerate(lines):
stripped = line.strip()
# Check if line is a heading
match = heading_pattern.match(stripped)
if match and len(stripped) > 3 and len(stripped) < 100:
# Save previous section
if current_section:
current_section.content = '\n'.join(current_content).strip()
sections.append(current_section)
# Start new section
heading = match.group(1) or match.group(2)
level = 1 if stripped.startswith('#') else 2
current_section = Section(
heading=heading,
level=level,
content='',
line_number=i,
subsections=[]
)
current_content = []
elif current_section:
if stripped:
current_content.append(line)
# Save last section
if current_section:
current_section.content = '\n'.join(current_content).strip()
sections.append(current_section)
return sections
def extract_code_blocks(self, url: str) -> List[CodeBlock]:
"""
Extract only code blocks from a web page.
Args:
url: URL to fetch
Returns:
List of CodeBlock objects
"""
logger.info(f"Extracting code blocks from: {url}")
content = self.extract(url)
return content.code_blocks
def crawl_documentation(
self,
base_url: str,
max_pages: int = 10,
follow_pattern: Optional[str] = None
) -> List[ExtractedContent]:
"""
Crawl multi-page documentation.
Args:
base_url: Starting URL
max_pages: Maximum number of pages to crawl
follow_pattern: Regex pattern for URLs to follow (optional)
Returns:
List of ExtractedContent objects
Note: This is a basic implementation. For production use,
consider using a proper crawler like Scrapy.
"""
logger.info(f"Starting documentation crawl from: {base_url}")
logger.warning("Crawling is experimental and may be slow")
visited = set()
to_visit = [base_url]
results = []
pattern = re.compile(follow_pattern) if follow_pattern else None
while to_visit and len(results) < max_pages:
url = to_visit.pop(0)
if url in visited:
continue
visited.add(url)
try:
content = self.extract(url)
results.append(content)
logger.info(f"Crawled {len(results)}/{max_pages}: {url}")
# Find links to follow (basic implementation)
if pattern and HAS_BS4:
html = self._fetch_html(url)
soup = BeautifulSoup(html, 'html.parser')
for link in soup.find_all('a', href=True):
href = link['href']
absolute_url = urljoin(url, href)
if absolute_url not in visited and pattern.match(absolute_url):
to_visit.append(absolute_url)
# Rate limiting
time.sleep(1)
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to crawl {url}: {e}")
continue
logger.info(f"Crawling complete. Extracted {len(results)} pages")
return results

16
article-to-prototype/scripts/generators/__init__.py
View file

@ -1,16 +0,0 @@
"""
Generators Module
Provides code generation components:
- Language selector for choosing optimal language
- Prototype generator for creating complete projects
"""
from .language_selector import LanguageSelector
from .prototype_generator import PrototypeGenerator, GeneratedPrototype
__all__ = [
'LanguageSelector',
'PrototypeGenerator',
'GeneratedPrototype',
]

144
article-to-prototype/scripts/generators/language_selector.py
View file

@ -1,144 +0,0 @@
"""
Language Selector
Selects the optimal programming language for prototype generation.
"""
import logging
from typing import Dict, List, Optional
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
class LanguageSelector:
"""Selects optimal language based on analysis"""
# Domain to language mapping
DOMAIN_LANGUAGE_MAP = {
"machine_learning": "python",
"data_science": "python",
"web_development": "typescript",
"systems_programming": "rust",
"scientific_computing": "julia",
"devops": "python",
"general_programming": "python",
}
# Library to language mapping
LIBRARY_TO_LANGUAGE = {
# Python libraries
"numpy": "python",
"pandas": "python",
"tensorflow": "python",
"pytorch": "python",
"sklearn": "python",
"django": "python",
"flask": "python",
"requests": "python",
# JavaScript libraries
"react": "javascript",
"vue": "javascript",
"express": "javascript",
"node": "javascript",
"axios": "javascript",
# Rust crates
"tokio": "rust",
"actix": "rust",
"serde": "rust",
# Go packages
"gin": "go",
"fiber": "go",
# Java libraries
"spring": "java",
"junit": "java",
}
SUPPORTED_LANGUAGES = [
"python", "javascript", "typescript", "rust", "go", "julia", "java", "cpp"
]
def select_language(
self,
analysis: Any,
hint: Optional[str] = None,
default: str = "python"
) -> str:
"""
Select optimal programming language.
Args:
analysis: AnalysisResult from ContentAnalyzer
hint: Optional explicit language hint from user
default: Default language if can't determine
Returns:
Selected language name
"""
logger.info("Selecting programming language")
# Priority 1: Explicit hint from user
if hint and hint.lower() in self.SUPPORTED_LANGUAGES:
logger.info(f"Using explicit hint: {hint}")
return hint.lower()
# Priority 2: Detect from code blocks
detected = self._detect_from_code(analysis)
if detected:
logger.info(f"Detected from code: {detected}")
return detected
# Priority 3: Domain-based selection
if analysis.domain in self.DOMAIN_LANGUAGE_MAP:
candidate = self.DOMAIN_LANGUAGE_MAP[analysis.domain]
logger.info(f"Selected from domain ({analysis.domain}): {candidate}")
return candidate
# Priority 4: Dependency-based selection
dep_language = self._select_from_dependencies(analysis.dependencies)
if dep_language:
logger.info(f"Selected from dependencies: {dep_language}")
return dep_language
# Default
logger.info(f"Using default language: {default}")
return default
def _detect_from_code(self, analysis: Any) -> Optional[str]:
"""Detect language from existing code blocks"""
# Count language occurrences in code blocks
language_counts: Dict[str, int] = {}
# Check if analysis has code-related data
if hasattr(analysis, 'metadata') and 'language_hints' in analysis.metadata:
for hint in analysis.metadata['language_hints']:
hint_lower = hint.lower()
if hint_lower in self.SUPPORTED_LANGUAGES:
language_counts[hint_lower] = language_counts.get(hint_lower, 0) + 1
# Return most common
if language_counts:
return max(language_counts, key=language_counts.get)
return None
def _select_from_dependencies(self, dependencies: List[Any]) -> Optional[str]:
"""Select language based on dependencies"""
scores: Dict[str, int] = {lang: 0 for lang in self.SUPPORTED_LANGUAGES}
for dep in dependencies:
dep_name = dep.name.lower() if hasattr(dep, 'name') else str(dep).lower()
if dep_name in self.LIBRARY_TO_LANGUAGE:
lang = self.LIBRARY_TO_LANGUAGE[dep_name]
scores[lang] += 1
# Return language with highest score
max_score = max(scores.values())
if max_score > 0:
return max(scores, key=scores.get)
return None
def get_supported_languages(self) -> List[str]:
"""Get list of supported languages"""
return self.SUPPORTED_LANGUAGES.copy()

541
article-to-prototype/scripts/generators/prototype_generator.py
View file

@ -1,541 +0,0 @@
"""
Prototype Generator
Generates complete, production-quality code prototypes in multiple languages.
"""
import logging
import os
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Any
from dataclasses import dataclass
from datetime import datetime
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@dataclass
class GeneratedPrototype:
"""Result of prototype generation"""
output_dir: str
language: str
files_created: List[str]
entry_point: str
metadata: Dict[str, Any]
class PrototypeGenerator:
"""Generates complete prototype projects"""
def __init__(self):
"""Initialize prototype generator"""
pass
def generate(
self,
analysis: Any,
language: str,
output_dir: str,
source_info: Optional[Dict[str, Any]] = None
) -> GeneratedPrototype:
"""
Generate a complete prototype project.
Args:
analysis: AnalysisResult from ContentAnalyzer
language: Selected programming language
output_dir: Directory to write output files
source_info: Optional source article information
Returns:
GeneratedPrototype with file paths and metadata
"""
logger.info(f"Generating {language} prototype in {output_dir}")
# Create output directory
Path(output_dir).mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)
files_created = []
# Generate based on language
if language == "python":
entry_point, files = self._generate_python(analysis, output_dir, source_info)
elif language in ["javascript", "typescript"]:
entry_point, files = self._generate_javascript(analysis, output_dir, source_info, language)
elif language == "rust":
entry_point, files = self._generate_rust(analysis, output_dir, source_info)
elif language == "go":
entry_point, files = self._generate_go(analysis, output_dir, source_info)
else:
# Default to Python
logger.warning(f"Unsupported language {language}, defaulting to Python")
entry_point, files = self._generate_python(analysis, output_dir, source_info)
files_created.extend(files)
# Generate README
readme_path = self._generate_readme(analysis, language, output_dir, source_info)
files_created.append(readme_path)
# Generate gitignore
gitignore_path = self._generate_gitignore(language, output_dir)
files_created.append(gitignore_path)
logger.info(f"Generated {len(files_created)} files")
return GeneratedPrototype(
output_dir=output_dir,
language=language,
files_created=files_created,
entry_point=entry_point,
metadata={
'generated_at': datetime.now().isoformat(),
'domain': analysis.domain,
'complexity': analysis.complexity,
'num_files': len(files_created),
}
)
def _generate_python(
self,
analysis: Any,
output_dir: str,
source_info: Optional[Dict[str, Any]]
) -> tuple[str, List[str]]:
"""Generate Python project"""
files = []
# Create source directory
src_dir = Path(output_dir) / "src"
src_dir.mkdir(exist_ok=True)
# Generate main.py
main_path = src_dir / "main.py"
main_code = self._generate_python_main(analysis, source_info)
main_path.write_text(main_code, encoding='utf-8')
files.append(str(main_path))
# Generate requirements.txt
req_path = Path(output_dir) / "requirements.txt"
requirements = self._generate_python_requirements(analysis)
req_path.write_text(requirements, encoding='utf-8')
files.append(str(req_path))
# Generate test file
test_dir = Path(output_dir) / "tests"
test_dir.mkdir(exist_ok=True)
test_path = test_dir / "test_main.py"
test_code = self._generate_python_tests(analysis)
test_path.write_text(test_code, encoding='utf-8')
files.append(str(test_path))
return str(main_path), files
def _generate_python_main(self, analysis: Any, source_info: Optional[Dict[str, Any]]) -> str:
"""Generate Python main file"""
source_url = source_info.get('source_url', 'Unknown') if source_info else 'Unknown'
source_title = source_info.get('title', 'Untitled') if source_info else 'Untitled'
# Generate imports based on dependencies
imports = ["import logging", "from typing import List, Dict, Any, Optional"]
for dep in analysis.dependencies[:5]: # Limit to first 5
dep_name = dep.name if hasattr(dep, 'name') else str(dep)
imports.append(f"# import {dep_name} # Install: pip install {dep_name}")
imports_str = '\n'.join(imports)
# Generate algorithm implementations
algo_impls = []
for i, algo in enumerate(analysis.algorithms[:3]): # Limit to 3 algorithms
algo_impl = f'''
def algorithm_{i+1}(data: Any) -> Any:
"""
{algo.name}: {algo.description}
Args:
data: Input data
Returns:
Processed result
"""
logger.info("Running {algo.name}")
# Implementation based on: {algo.description}
result = data # Placeholder - implement algorithm logic here
return result
'''
algo_impls.append(algo_impl)
algos_str = '\n'.join(algo_impls)
code = f'''"""
Prototype Implementation
Generated from: {source_title}
Source: {source_url}
Domain: {analysis.domain}
Generated: {datetime.now().strftime("%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S")}
This is a prototype implementation based on the article content.
"""
{imports_str}
# Configure logging
logging.basicConfig(
level=logging.INFO,
format='%(asctime)s - %(name)s - %(levelname)s - %(message)s'
)
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
{algos_str}
def main():
"""Main entry point"""
logger.info("Starting prototype")
# Example usage
sample_data = {{"key": "value"}}
try:
# Run algorithms
{chr(10).join(f" result_{i+1} = algorithm_{i+1}(sample_data)" for i in range(min(3, len(analysis.algorithms))))}
logger.info("Prototype execution completed successfully")
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Error during execution: {{e}}")
raise
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()
'''
return code
def _generate_python_requirements(self, analysis: Any) -> str:
"""Generate requirements.txt"""
deps = ["# Python dependencies"]
# Standard deps
for dep in analysis.dependencies[:10]:
dep_name = dep.name if hasattr(dep, 'name') else str(dep)
deps.append(f"{dep_name}")
# Common deps if not present
if not any('requests' in str(d) for d in analysis.dependencies):
deps.append("# requests>=2.31.0 # Uncomment if needed")
return '\n'.join(deps)
def _generate_python_tests(self, analysis: Any) -> str:
"""Generate Python test file"""
code = '''"""
Tests for prototype implementation
"""
import pytest
from src.main import main
def test_main_execution():
"""Test that main runs without errors"""
try:
main()
assert True
except Exception as e:
pytest.fail(f"Main execution failed: {e}")
def test_placeholder():
"""Placeholder test"""
assert True, "Implement actual tests based on your algorithms"
'''
return code
def _generate_javascript(
self,
analysis: Any,
output_dir: str,
source_info: Optional[Dict[str, Any]],
language: str
) -> tuple[str, List[str]]:
"""Generate JavaScript/TypeScript project"""
files = []
ext = '.ts' if language == 'typescript' else '.js'
# Generate main file
main_path = Path(output_dir) / f"index{ext}"
main_code = self._generate_js_main(analysis, source_info, language)
main_path.write_text(main_code, encoding='utf-8')
files.append(str(main_path))
# Generate package.json
package_path = Path(output_dir) / "package.json"
package_json = self._generate_package_json(analysis)
package_path.write_text(package_json, encoding='utf-8')
files.append(str(package_path))
return str(main_path), files
def _generate_js_main(self, analysis: Any, source_info: Optional[Dict[str, Any]], language: str) -> str:
"""Generate JavaScript/TypeScript main file"""
source_url = source_info.get('source_url', 'Unknown') if source_info else 'Unknown'
if language == 'typescript':
code = f'''/**
* Prototype Implementation
* Generated from: {source_url}
* Domain: {analysis.domain}
*/
// Main implementation
function main(): void {{
console.log('Prototype starting...');
// Implement algorithms here
console.log('Prototype completed');
}}
// Run if main module
if (require.main === module) {{
main();
}}
export {{ main }};
'''
else:
code = f'''/**
* Prototype Implementation
* Generated from: {source_url}
* Domain: {analysis.domain}
*/
// Main implementation
function main() {{
console.log('Prototype starting...');
// Implement algorithms here
console.log('Prototype completed');
}}
// Run if main module
if (require.main === module) {{
main();
}}
module.exports = {{ main }};
'''
return code
def _generate_package_json(self, analysis: Any) -> str:
"""Generate package.json"""
return '''{
"name": "prototype",
"version": "1.0.0",
"description": "Generated prototype",
"main": "index.js",
"scripts": {
"start": "node index.js",
"test": "echo \\"No tests specified\\""
},
"dependencies": {}
}
'''
def _generate_rust(self, analysis: Any, output_dir: str, source_info: Optional[Dict[str, Any]]) -> tuple[str, List[str]]:
"""Generate Rust project"""
files = []
# Create src directory
src_dir = Path(output_dir) / "src"
src_dir.mkdir(exist_ok=True)
# Generate main.rs
main_path = src_dir / "main.rs"
main_code = f'''//! Prototype Implementation
//! Domain: {analysis.domain}
fn main() {{
println!("Prototype starting...");
// Implement algorithms here
println!("Prototype completed");
}}
'''
main_path.write_text(main_code, encoding='utf-8')
files.append(str(main_path))
# Generate Cargo.toml
cargo_path = Path(output_dir) / "Cargo.toml"
cargo_toml = '''[package]
name = "prototype"
version = "0.1.0"
edition = "2021"
[dependencies]
'''
cargo_path.write_text(cargo_toml, encoding='utf-8')
files.append(str(cargo_path))
return str(main_path), files
def _generate_go(self, analysis: Any, output_dir: str, source_info: Optional[Dict[str, Any]]) -> tuple[str, List[str]]:
"""Generate Go project"""
files = []
# Generate main.go
main_path = Path(output_dir) / "main.go"
main_code = f'''// Prototype Implementation
// Domain: {analysis.domain}
package main
import "fmt"
func main() {{
fmt.Println("Prototype starting...")
// Implement algorithms here
fmt.Println("Prototype completed")
}}
'''
main_path.write_text(main_code, encoding='utf-8')
files.append(str(main_path))
return str(main_path), files
def _generate_readme(
self,
analysis: Any,
language: str,
output_dir: str,
source_info: Optional[Dict[str, Any]]
) -> str:
"""Generate README.md"""
source_url = source_info.get('source_url', 'Unknown') if source_info else 'Unknown'
source_title = source_info.get('title', 'Untitled') if source_info else 'Untitled'
install_cmd = {
'python': 'pip install -r requirements.txt',
'javascript': 'npm install',
'typescript': 'npm install',
'rust': 'cargo build',
'go': 'go build',
}.get(language, 'See documentation')
run_cmd = {
'python': 'python src/main.py',
'javascript': 'node index.js',
'typescript': 'npx ts-node index.ts',
'rust': 'cargo run',
'go': 'go run main.go',
}.get(language, 'See documentation')
readme = f'''# Prototype Implementation
> Generated from: [{source_title}]({source_url})
## Overview
This is an automatically generated prototype based on the article content.
- **Domain:** {analysis.domain}
- **Complexity:** {analysis.complexity}
- **Language:** {language}
- **Generated:** {datetime.now().strftime("%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S")}
## Installation
```bash
{install_cmd}
```
## Usage
```bash
{run_cmd}
```
## Structure
This prototype includes:
- Main implementation file
- Dependencies manifest
- Basic test suite (if applicable)
## Detected Algorithms
{chr(10).join(f"- {algo.name}: {algo.description}" for algo in analysis.algorithms[:5])}
## Source Attribution
- Original Article: [{source_title}]({source_url})
- Extraction Date: {datetime.now().strftime("%Y-%m-%d")}
- Generated by: Article-to-Prototype Skill v1.0
## License
MIT License
'''
readme_path = Path(output_dir) / "README.md"
readme_path.write_text(readme, encoding='utf-8')
return str(readme_path)
def _generate_gitignore(self, language: str, output_dir: str) -> str:
"""Generate .gitignore"""
gitignore_templates = {
'python': '''# Python
__pycache__/
*.py[cod]
*$py.class
*.so
.Python
env/
venv/
.venv/
*.egg-info/
dist/
build/
''',
'javascript': '''# Node
node_modules/
npm-debug.log
yarn-error.log
.env
dist/
build/
''',
'typescript': '''# TypeScript/Node
node_modules/
*.js
*.d.ts
npm-debug.log
dist/
build/
''',
'rust': '''# Rust
target/
Cargo.lock
**/*.rs.bk
''',
'go': '''# Go
*.exe
*.exe~
*.dll
*.so
*.dylib
*.test
*.out
go.work
''',
}
content = gitignore_templates.get(language, '# Generated files\n')
gitignore_path = Path(output_dir) / ".gitignore"
gitignore_path.write_text(content, encoding='utf-8')
return str(gitignore_path)

224
article-to-prototype/scripts/main.py
View file

@ -1,224 +0,0 @@
"""
Article-to-Prototype Main Orchestrator
Coordinates the extraction, analysis, and generation pipeline.
"""
import logging
import sys
import argparse
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Optional, Dict, Any
from urllib.parse import urlparse
# Setup path for imports
sys.path.insert(0, str(Path(__file__).parent))
from extractors.pdf_extractor import PDFExtractor, PDFExtractionError
from extractors.web_extractor import WebExtractor, WebExtractionError
from extractors.notebook_extractor import NotebookExtractor, NotebookExtractionError
from extractors.markdown_extractor import MarkdownExtractor, MarkdownExtractionError
from analyzers.content_analyzer import ContentAnalyzer
from analyzers.code_detector import CodeDetector
from generators.language_selector import LanguageSelector
from generators.prototype_generator import PrototypeGenerator
# Configure logging
logging.basicConfig(
level=logging.INFO,
format='%(asctime)s - %(name)s - %(levelname)s - %(message)s'
)
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
class ArticleToPrototype:
"""Main orchestrator for article-to-prototype conversion"""
def __init__(self):
"""Initialize orchestrator"""
self.pdf_extractor = PDFExtractor()
self.web_extractor = WebExtractor()
self.notebook_extractor = NotebookExtractor()
self.markdown_extractor = MarkdownExtractor()
self.content_analyzer = ContentAnalyzer()
self.code_detector = CodeDetector()
self.language_selector = LanguageSelector()
self.prototype_generator = PrototypeGenerator()
def process(
self,
source: str,
output_dir: str,
language_hint: Optional[str] = None
) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Process article and generate prototype.
Args:
source: Path to file or URL
output_dir: Output directory for generated prototype
language_hint: Optional language hint from user
Returns:
Dictionary with generation results
"""
logger.info(f"Processing source: {source}")
try:
# Step 1: Detect format and extract content
logger.info("Step 1: Extracting content...")
content = self._extract_content(source)
# Step 2: Analyze content
logger.info("Step 2: Analyzing content...")
analysis = self.content_analyzer.analyze(content)
code_fragments = self.code_detector.detect_code_fragments(content)
language_hints = self.code_detector.detect_language_hints(content)
# Add to analysis metadata
analysis.metadata['code_fragments'] = len(code_fragments)
analysis.metadata['language_hints'] = language_hints
# Step 3: Select language
logger.info("Step 3: Selecting programming language...")
language = self.language_selector.select_language(
analysis,
hint=language_hint
)
# Step 4: Generate prototype
logger.info(f"Step 4: Generating {language} prototype...")
source_info = {
'title': content.title,
'source_url': content.source_url or source,
'extraction_date': content.extraction_date.isoformat(),
}
result = self.prototype_generator.generate(
analysis,
language,
output_dir,
source_info
)
logger.info(f"✅ Successfully generated prototype in: {output_dir}")
return {
'success': True,
'output_dir': output_dir,
'language': language,
'files_created': result.files_created,
'entry_point': result.entry_point,
'domain': analysis.domain,
'complexity': analysis.complexity,
'num_algorithms': len(analysis.algorithms),
'confidence': analysis.confidence,
}
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"❌ Failed to process article: {e}", exc_info=True)
return {
'success': False,
'error': str(e),
'error_type': type(e).__name__,
}
def _extract_content(self, source: str):
"""Extract content based on source type"""
# Check if URL
if source.startswith('http://') or source.startswith('https://'):
logger.info(f"Detected web URL: {source}")
return self.web_extractor.extract(source)
# Check if file exists
path = Path(source)
if not path.exists():
raise FileNotFoundError(f"Source not found: {source}")
# Detect file type
ext = path.suffix.lower()
if ext == '.pdf':
logger.info("Detected PDF file")
return self.pdf_extractor.extract(str(path))
elif ext == '.ipynb':
logger.info("Detected Jupyter notebook")
return self.notebook_extractor.extract(str(path))
elif ext in ['.md', '.markdown']:
logger.info("Detected Markdown file")
return self.markdown_extractor.extract(str(path))
elif ext == '.txt':
logger.info("Detected text file, treating as markdown")
return self.markdown_extractor.extract(str(path))
else:
raise ValueError(f"Unsupported file type: {ext}")
def main():
"""Command-line interface"""
parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(
description='Extract algorithms from articles and generate prototypes'
)
parser.add_argument(
'source',
help='Path to PDF, URL, notebook, or markdown file'
)
parser.add_argument(
'-o', '--output',
default='./output',
help='Output directory (default: ./output)'
)
parser.add_argument(
'-l', '--language',
help='Target programming language (auto-detected if not specified)'
)
parser.add_argument(
'-v', '--verbose',
action='store_true',
help='Enable verbose logging'
)
parser.add_argument(
'--version',
action='version',
version='Article-to-Prototype v1.0.0'
)
args = parser.parse_args()
# Set logging level
if args.verbose:
logging.getLogger().setLevel(logging.DEBUG)
# Process
orchestrator = ArticleToPrototype()
result = orchestrator.process(
source=args.source,
output_dir=args.output,
language_hint=args.language
)
# Print results
if result['success']:
print(f"\n✅ SUCCESS!")
print(f"Generated {result['language']} prototype")
print(f"Output directory: {result['output_dir']}")
print(f"Entry point: {result['entry_point']}")
print(f"Domain: {result['domain']}")
print(f"Complexity: {result['complexity']}")
print(f"Algorithms detected: {result['num_algorithms']}")
print(f"Files created: {len(result['files_created'])}")
print(f"\nTo run:")
print(f" cd {result['output_dir']}")
print(f" # Follow README.md instructions")
return 0
else:
print(f"\n❌ FAILED: {result['error']}")
return 1
if __name__ == "__main__":
sys.exit(main())

380
docs/AGENTDB_LEARNING_FLOW_EXPLAINED.md
View file

@ -1,380 +0,0 @@
# AgentDB Learning Flow: How Skills Learn and Improve
**Purpose**: Complete explanation of how AgentDB stores, retrieves, and uses creation interactions to improve future skill generation.
---
## 🎯 **The Big Picture: Learning Feedback Loop**
```
User Request Skill Creation
↓
Agent Creator Uses /references + AgentDB Learning
↓
Skill Created & Deployed
↓
Creation Decision Stored in AgentDB
↓
Future Requests Benefit from Past Learning
↓
(Loop continues with each new creation)
```
---
## 📊 **What Exactly Gets Stored in AgentDB?**
### **1. Creation Episodes (Reflexion Store)**
**When**: Every time a skill is created
**Format**: Structured episode data
```python
# From _store_creation_decision():
session_id = f"creation-{datetime.now().strftime('%Y%m%d-%H%M%S')}"
# Data stored:
{
"session_id": "creation-20251024-103406",
"task": "agent_creation_decision",
"reward": "85.0", # Success probability * 100
"success": true, # If creation succeeded
"input": user_input, # "Create financial analysis agent..."
"output": intelligence, # Template choice, improvements, etc.
"latency": creation_time_ms,
"critique": auto_generated_analysis
}
```
**Real Example** (from our tests):
```bash
agentdb reflexion retrieve "agent creation" 5 0.0
# Retrieved episodes show:
#1: Episode 1
# Task: agent_creation_decision
# Reward: 0.00 ← Note: Our test returned 0.00 (no success feedback yet)
# Success: No
# Similarity: 0.785
```
### **2. Causal Relationships (Causal Edges)**
**When**: After each creation decision
**Purpose**: Learn cause→effect patterns
```python
# From _store_creation_decision():
if intelligence.template_choice:
self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "causal", "store",
f"user_input:{user_input[:50]}...", # Cause
f"template_selected:{intelligence.template_choice}", # Effect
"created_successfully" # Outcome
])
# Stored as causal edge:
{
"cause": "user_input:Create financial analysis agent for stocks...",
"effect": "template_selected:financial-analysis-template",
"uplift": 0.25, # Calculated from success rate
"confidence": 0.8,
"sample_size": 1
}
```
### **3. Skills Database (Learned Patterns)**
**When**: When patterns are identified from multiple episodes
**Purpose**: Store reusable skills and patterns
```python
# From _enhance_with_real_agentdb():
skills_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"agentdb", "skill", "search", user_input, "5"
])
# Skills stored as:
{
"name": "financial-analysis-skill",
"description": "Pattern for financial analysis agents",
"code": "learned_code_patterns",
"success_rate": 0.85,
"uses": 12,
"domain": "finance"
}
```
---
## 🔍 **How Data Is Retrieved and Used**
### **Step 1: User Makes Request**
```
"Create financial analysis agent for stock market data"
```
### **Step 2: AgentDB Queries Past Episodes**
```python
# From _enhance_with_real_agentdb():
episodes_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"agentdb", "reflexion", "retrieve", user_input, "3", "0.6"
])
```
**What this query does:**
- Finds similar past creation requests
- Returns top 3 most relevant episodes
- Minimum similarity threshold: 0.6
- Includes success rates and outcomes
**Example Retrieved Data:**
```python
episodes = [
{
"task": "agent_creation_decision",
"success": True,
"reward": 85.0,
"input": "Create stock analysis tool with RSI indicators",
"template_used": "financial-analysis-template"
},
{
"task": "agent_creation_decision",
"success": False,
"reward": 0.0,
"input": "Build financial dashboard",
"template_used": "generic-dashboard-template"
}
]
```
### **Step 3: Calculate Success Patterns**
```python
# From _parse_episodes_from_output():
if episodes:
success_rate = sum(1 for e in episodes if e.get('success', False)) / len(episodes)
intelligence.success_probability = success_rate
# Example calculation:
# Episodes: [success=True, success=False, success=True]
# Success rate: 2/3 = 0.667
```
### **Step 4: Query Causal Effects**
```python
# From _enhance_with_real_agentdb():
causal_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"agentdb", "causal", "query",
f"use_{domain}_template", "", "0.7", "0.1", "5"
])
```
**What this learns:**
- Which templates work best for which domains
- Historical success rates by template
- Causal relationships between inputs and outcomes
### **Step 5: Select Optimal Template**
```python
# From causal effects analysis:
effects = [
{"cause": "finance_domain", "effect": "financial-template", "uplift": 0.25},
{"cause": "finance_domain", "effect": "generic-template", "uplift": 0.10}
]
# Choose best effect:
best_effect = max(effects, key=lambda x: x.get('uplift', 0))
intelligence.template_choice = "financial-analysis-template"
intelligence.mathematical_proof = f"Causal uplift: {best_effect['uplift']:.2%}"
```
---
## 🔄 **Complete Learning Flow Example**
### **First Creation (No Learning Data)**
```
User: "Create financial analysis agent"
↓
AgentDB Query: reflexion retrieve "financial analysis" (0 results)
↓
Template Selection: Uses /references guidelines (static)
↓
Choice: financial-analysis-template
↓
Storage:
- Episode stored with success=unknown
- Causal edge: "financial analysis" → "financial-template"
```
### **Tenth Creation (Rich Learning Data)**
```
User: "Create financial analysis agent for cryptocurrency"
↓
AgentDB Query: reflexion retrieve "financial analysis" (12 results)
↓
Success Analysis:
- financial-template: 80% success (8/10)
- generic-template: 40% success (2/5)
↓
Causal Query: causal query "use_financial_template"
↓
Result: financial-template shows 0.25 uplift for finance domain
↓
Enhanced Decision:
- Template: financial-template (based on 80% success rate)
- Confidence: 0.80 (from historical data)
- Mathematical Proof: "Causal uplift: 25%"
- Learned Improvements: ["Include RSI indicators", "Add volatility analysis"]
```
---
## 📈 **How Improvement Actually Happens**
### **1. Success Rate Learning**
**Pattern**: Template success rates improve over time
```python
# After 5 uses of financial-template:
success_rate = successful_creatures / total_creatures
# Example: 4/5 = 0.8 (80% success rate)
# This influences future template selection:
if success_rate > 0.7:
prefer_this_template = True
```
### **2. Feature Learning**
**Pattern**: Agent learns which features work for which domains
```python
# From successful episodes:
successful_features = extract_common_features([
"RSI indicators", "MACD analysis", "volume analysis"
])
# Added to learned improvements:
intelligence.learned_improvements = [
"Include RSI indicators (82% success rate)",
"Add MACD analysis (75% success rate)",
"Volume analysis recommended (68% success rate)"
]
```
### **3. Domain Specialization**
**Pattern**: Templates become domain-specialized
```python
# Causal learning shows:
causal_edges = [
{"cause": "finance_domain", "effect": "financial-template", "uplift": 0.25},
{"cause": "climate_domain", "effect": "climate-template", "uplift": 0.30},
{"cause": "ecommerce_domain", "effect": "ecommerce-template", "uplift": 0.20}
]
# Future decisions use this pattern:
if "finance" in user_input:
recommended_template = "financial-template" # 25% uplift
```
---
## 🎯 **Key Insights About the Learning Process**
### **1. Learning is Cumulative**
- Every creation adds to the knowledge base
- More episodes = better pattern recognition
- Success rates become more reliable over time
### **2. Learning is Domain-Specific**
- Templates specialize for particular domains
- Cross-domain patterns are identified
- Generic vs specialized recommendations
### **3. Learning is Measurable**
- Success rates are tracked numerically
- Causal effects have confidence scores
- Mathematical proofs provide evidence
### **4. Learning is Adaptive**
- Failed attempts influence future decisions
- Successful patterns are reinforced
- System self-corrects based on outcomes
---
## 🔧 **Technical Implementation Details**
### **Storage Commands Used**
```python
# 1. Store episode (reflexion)
agentdb reflexion store <session_id> <task> <reward> <success> [critique] [input] [output]
# 2. Store causal edge
agentdb causal add-edge <cause> <effect> <uplift> [confidence] [sample-size]
# 3. Store skill pattern
agentdb skill create <name> <description> [code]
# 4. Query episodes
agentdb reflexion retrieve <task> [k] [min-reward] [only-failures] [only-successes]
# 5. Query causal effects
agentdb causal query [cause] [effect] [min-confidence] [min-uplift] [limit]
# 6. Search skills
agentdb skill search <query> [k]
```
### **Data Flow in Code**
```python
def enhance_agent_creation(user_input, domain):
# Step 1: Retrieve relevant past episodes
episodes = query_similar_episodes(user_input)
# Step 2: Analyze success patterns
success_rate = calculate_success_rate(episodes)
# Step 3: Query causal relationships
causal_effects = query_causal_effects(domain)
# Step 4: Search for relevant skills
relevant_skills = search_skills(user_input)
# Step 5: Make enhanced decision
intelligence = AgentDBIntelligence(
template_choice=select_best_template(causal_effects),
success_probability=success_rate,
learned_improvements=extract_improvements(relevant_skills),
mathematical_proof=generate_causal_proof(causal_effects)
)
# Step 6: Store this decision for future learning
store_creation_decision(user_input, intelligence)
return intelligence
```
---
## 🎉 **Summary: From "Magic" to Understandable Process**
**What seemed like magic is actually a systematic learning process:**
1. **Store** every creation decision with context and outcomes
2. **Query** past decisions when new requests arrive
3. **Analyze** patterns of success and failure
4. **Enhance** new decisions with learned insights
5. **Improve** continuously with each interaction
The AgentDB bridge turns Agent Creator from a **static tool** into a **learning system** that gets smarter with every skill created!

350
docs/AGENTDB_VISUAL_GUIDE.md
View file

@ -1,350 +0,0 @@
# AgentDB Learning: Visual Guide
**Purpose**: Visual diagrams and flow charts showing exactly how AgentDB learns and improves skill creation.
---
## 🔄 **The Complete Learning Loop (Visual)**
### **Macro Level: Creation → Learning → Improvement**
```
┌─────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────┐ ┌─────────────────┐
│ User Request │───▶│ Agent Creator │───▶│ Skill Created │
│ │ │ │ │ │
│ "Create agent │ │ Uses: │ │ Functional code │
│ for stocks" │ │ • /references │ │ • Documentation │
└─────────────────┘ │ • AgentDB data │ │ • Tests │
└──────────────────┘ └─────────────────┘
│ │
▼ ▼
┌──────────────────┐ ┌─────────────────┐
│ Store in AgentDB│───▶│ Deploy Skill │
│ │ │ │
│ • Episodes │ • User starts │
│ • Causal edges │ • using skill │
│ • Success data │ • Provides feedback│
└──────────────────┘ └─────────────────┘
│ │
▼ ▼
┌─────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────┐ ┌─────────────────┐
│ Future User │◀───│ AgentDB Query │◀───│ Learning Data │
│ Request │ │ │ │ Accumulated │
│ │ • Similar past │ │ │
│ "Create agent │ • Success rates │ • Better patterns│
│ for crypto" │ • Proven templates │ • Higher success │
└─────────────────┘ └──────────────────┘ └─────────────────┘
```
---
## 📊 **Data Storage Structure (Visual)**
### **What Gets Stored Where in AgentDB**
```
AgentDB Database
├── 📚 Episodes (Reflexion Store)
│ ├── Episode #1
│ │ ├── session_id: "creation-20251024-103406"
│ │ ├── task: "agent_creation_decision"
│ │ ├── input: "Create financial analysis agent..."
│ │ ├── reward: 85.0
│ │ ├── success: true
│ │ └── template_used: "financial-analysis-template"
│ │
│ ├── Episode #2
│ │ ├── session_id: "creation-20251024-103456"
│ │ ├── task: "agent_creation_decision"
│ │ ├── input: "Build climate analysis tool..."
│ │ ├── reward: 0.0
│ │ ├── success: false
│ │ └── template_used: "climate-analysis-template"
│ │
│ └── ... (one episode per creation)
│
├── 🔗 Causal Edges
│ ├── Edge #1
│ │ ├── cause: "finance_domain_request"
│ │ ├── effect: "financial_template_selected"
│ │ ├── uplift: 0.25
│ │ ├── confidence: 0.85
│ │ └── sample_size: 12
│ │
│ ├── Edge #2
│ │ ├── cause: "climate_domain_request"
│ │ ├── effect: "climate_template_selected"
│ │ ├── uplift: 0.30
│ │ ├── confidence: 0.90
│ │ └── sample_size: 8
│ │
│ └── ... (learned cause→effect relationships)
│
└── 🛠️ Skills Database
├── Skill #1
│ ├── name: "financial-pattern-skill"
│ ├── description: "Common patterns for finance agents"
│ ├── success_rate: 0.82
│ ├── uses: 15
│ └── learned_features: ["RSI", "MACD", "volume"]
│
└── ... (extracted patterns from successful episodes)
```
---
## 🔍 **Query Process (Step-by-Step Visual)**
### **When User Requests: "Create financial analysis agent"**
```
Step 1: Input Analysis
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ User Input: "Create financial │
│ analysis agent for stocks" │
│ │
│ → Extract domain: "finance" │
│ → Extract features: "analysis", │
│ "stocks" │
│ → Generate search queries │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
Step 2: AgentDB Queries
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Query 1: Episodes │
│ agentdb reflexion retrieve │
│ "financial analysis" 5 0.6 │
│ │
│ Query 2: Causal Effects │
│ agentdb causal query │
│ "use_finance_template" "" 0.7 │
│ │
│ Query 3: Skills Search │
│ agentdb skill search │
│ "financial analysis" 5 │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
Step 3: Data Analysis
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Episodes Retrieved: │
│ ┌─ Episode A: Success=True │
│ │ Template: financial-template │
│ │ Reward: 85.0 │
│ └─ Episode B: Success=False │
│ Template: generic-template │
│ Reward: 0.0 │
│ │
│ Success Rate: 50% (1/2) │
│ │
│ Causal Effects Found: │
│ ┌─ financial-template: uplift=0.25 │
│ └─ generic-template: uplift=0.10 │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
Step 4: Decision Making
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Decision Factors: │
│ ✓ 25% uplift for financial-template │
│ ✓ 50% historical success rate │
│ ✓ Domain match: "finance" │
│ │
│ Enhanced Decision: │
│ → Template: financial-template │
│ → Confidence: 0.50 │
│ → Proof: "Causal uplift: 25%" │
│ → Features: ["RSI", "MACD"] │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
```
---
## 📈 **Learning Progression (Visual Timeline)**
### **How the System Gets Smarter Over Time**
```
Month 1: Initial Learning
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Creations: 5 │
│ Episodes: 5 │
│ Success Rate: Unknown │
│ Templates: Static from /references │
│ Learning: Basic pattern recording │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
Month 3: Pattern Recognition
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Creations: 25 │
│ Episodes: 25 │
│ Success Rates: Emerging │
│ Templates: Domain-specific patterns │
│ Learning: Success rate calculation │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
Month 6: Intelligent Recommendations
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Creations: 100 │
│ Episodes: 100 │
│ Success Rates: Reliable (>10 samples)│
│ Templates: Optimized per domain │
│ Learning: Causal relationship mapping│
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
Month 12: Expert System
┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Creations: 500+ │
│ Episodes: 500+ │
│ Success Rates: Highly accurate │
│ Templates: Self-optimizing │
│ Learning: Predictive recommendations │
└─────────────────────────────────────┘
```
---
## 🎯 **Real Example: From First to Tenth Creation**
### **Creation #1: No Learning Data**
```
User: "Create financial analysis agent"
Process:
┌─ Query episodes: 0 results
├─ Query causal: 0 results
├─ Query skills: 0 results
└─ Decision: Use /references guidelines
Result:
┌─ Template: financial-analysis (from /references)
├─ Confidence: 0.8 (base rate)
├─ Features: Standard set
└─ Storage: Episode + Causal edge recorded
```
### **Creation #10: Rich Learning Data**
```
User: "Create financial analysis agent for crypto"
Process:
┌─ Query episodes: 8 similar results
│ ├─ Success: 6/8 = 75% success rate
│ └─ Common features: ["RSI", "volume", "volatility"]
│
├─ Query causal: 5 relevant edges
│ ├─ financial-template: uplift=0.25
│ ├─ crypto-specific: uplift=0.15
│ └─ volatility-analysis: uplift=0.10
│
└─ Query skills: 3 relevant skills
├─ crypto-analysis-skill: success_rate=0.82
├─ technical-indicators-skill: success_rate=0.78
└─ market-data-skill: success_rate=0.85
Result:
┌─ Template: financial-analysis-enhanced
├─ Confidence: 0.75 (from historical data)
├─ Features: ["RSI", "MACD", "volatility", "crypto-specific"]
├─ Proof: "Causal uplift: 25% + crypto patterns: 15%"
└─ Storage: New episode + refined causal edges
```
---
## 🔧 **Technical Flow Diagram**
### **Code-Level Data Flow**
```
enhance_agent_creation(user_input, domain)
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Step 1: Query Historical Episodes │
│ episodes = query_similar_episodes(input)│
│ │
│ SQL equivalent: │
│ SELECT * FROM episodes │
│ WHERE similarity(input, task) > 0.6 │
│ ORDER BY similarity DESC │
│ LIMIT 3 │
└─────────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Step 2: Calculate Success Patterns │
│ success_rate = successful/total │
│ │
│ if success_rate > 0.7: │
│ prefer_this_pattern = True │
└─────────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Step 3: Query Causal Relationships │
│ effects = query_causal_effects(domain) │
│ │
│ SQL equivalent: │
│ SELECT * FROM causal_edges │
│ WHERE cause LIKE '%domain%' │
│ AND uplift > 0.1 │
│ ORDER BY uplift DESC │
└─────────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Step 4: Search Learned Skills │
│ skills = search_relevant_skills(input) │
│ │
│ SQL equivalent: │
│ SELECT * FROM skills │
│ WHERE similarity(description, query) > 0.7│
│ AND success_rate > 0.6 │
└─────────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Step 5: Make Enhanced Decision │
│ intelligence = AgentDBIntelligence( │
│ template_choice=best_template, │
│ success_probability=success_rate, │
│ learned_improvements=extract_features(skills),│
│ mathematical_proof=causal_proof │
│ ) │
└─────────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Step 6: Store for Future Learning │
│ store_creation_decision(input, intelligence)│
│ │
│ SQL equivalent: │
│ INSERT INTO episodes VALUES (...) │
│ INSERT INTO causal_edges VALUES (...) │
└─────────────────────────────────────────┘
```
---
## 🎉 **Key Takeaways (Visual Summary)**
```
┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ AgentDB Learning Magic │
│ │
│ 📚 Store Every Decision │
│ 🔍 Find Similar Past Decisions │
│ 📊 Calculate Success Patterns │
│ 🎯 Make Enhanced Recommendations │
│ 🔄 Continuously Improve │
│ │
│ Result: System gets smarter with │
│ every skill created! │
└─────────────────────────────────────────┘
```
**From "nebulous magic" to "understandable process" - AgentDB turns Agent Creator into a learning system that accumulates expertise with every interaction!**

727
docs/CHANGELOG.md
View file

@ -1,727 +0,0 @@
# Changelog
All notable changes to Agent Creator will be documented in this file.
The format is based on [Keep a Changelog](https://keepachangelog.com/en/1.0.0/),
and this project adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/).
## [4.0.0] - February 2026
### MAJOR: Cross-Platform Modernization & Agent Skills Open Standard Compliance
**Full compliance with the Agent Skills Open Standard. Skills now work on 8+ platforms.**
### Breaking Changes
#### `-cskill` Suffix Removed
- All generated skill names now use standard kebab-case (e.g., `stock-analyzer` not `stock-analyzer-cskill`)
- `article-to-prototype-cskill/` renamed to `article-to-prototype/`
- See `MIGRATION.md` for migration guide
#### marketplace.json Simplified (Fixes Issue #5)
- Stripped to ONLY official fields: `name`, `plugins[].name`, `plugins[].description`, `plugins[].source`, `plugins[].skills`
- Removed non-standard fields: `owner`, `metadata`, `compatibility`, `templates`, `capabilities`, `activation`, `usage`, `test_queries`
- Simple skills no longer need marketplace.json at all
#### SKILL.md Restructured
- Meta-skill SKILL.md: 4,116 lines reduced to 272 lines
- Generated SKILL.md must be <500 lines with progressive disclosure via `references/`
### Added
#### Cross-Platform Support (8+ Platforms)
- **Claude Code**: `~/.claude/skills/` or `.claude/skills/`
- **GitHub Copilot**: `.github/skills/`
- **Cursor**: `.cursor/rules/`
- **Windsurf**: `.windsurf/skills/`
- **Cline**: `.clinerules/`
- **OpenAI Codex CLI**: `.codex/skills/`
- **Gemini CLI**: `.gemini/skills/`
#### Cross-Platform Install Script (`scripts/install-template.sh`)
- Auto-detect platform from directory structure
- `--platform` flag for explicit selection
- `--project` flag for project-level install
- `--dry-run` flag for preview
- `--path` flag for custom location
- SKILL.md validation before install
#### Spec Validation (`scripts/validate.py`)
- Validates frontmatter: name (1-64 chars, kebab-case), description (1-1024 chars)
- Checks directory name matches `name` field
- Warns on missing `license`, `metadata` fields
- Warns on SKILL.md body exceeding 500 lines
- Checks referenced files exist
- JSON output with `--json` flag
#### Security Scanning (`scripts/security_scan.py`)
- Detects hardcoded API keys (OpenAI, AWS, GitHub, GitLab, Slack, generic)
- Detects `.env`, `credentials.json`, `secrets.json` files
- Detects dangerous Python patterns: `eval()`, `exec()`, `os.system()`, `shell=True`, `__import__()`
- JSON output with `--json` flag
#### SKILL.md Frontmatter Enhancements
- `license` field (recommended)
- `metadata.author` and `metadata.version` fields (recommended)
- `compatibility` field (optional)
#### Documentation
- `MIGRATION.md`: v3.x to v4.0 migration guide
- `references/pipeline-phases.md`: Consolidated Phase 1-5 instructions
- `references/architecture-guide.md`: Simple vs Suite decision framework
- `references/templates-guide.md`: Template-based creation docs
- `references/interactive-mode.md`: Interactive wizard docs
- `references/multi-agent-guide.md`: Suite creation docs
- `references/agentdb-integration.md`: AgentDB learning system docs
### Enhanced
#### Export System
- Validation and security scan run before export
- Installation guide now covers all 8+ platforms
- Removed -cskill from name handling
#### Cross-Platform Guide
- Expanded from 4 Anthropic platforms to 8+ platforms
- Installation paths for each platform documented
- Agent Skills Open Standard as the unifying reference
#### Phase 5 Pipeline
- SKILL.md created first (not marketplace.json)
- Validation step added after file generation
- Security scan step added after file generation
- No mandatory marketplace.json for simple skills
### Removed
- `-cskill` suffix requirement from naming conventions
- Non-standard marketplace.json fields
- Mandatory marketplace.json for simple skills
---
## [3.2.0] - October 2025
### 🎯 **MAJOR: Cross-Platform Export System**
**Make Claude Code skills work everywhere - Desktop, Web, and API**
### ✅ **Added**
#### 📦 **Cross-Platform Export**
- **Export Utility Module**: Complete Python module (`scripts/export_utils.py`) for packaging skills
- **Desktop/Web Packages**: Optimized .zip packages for Claude Desktop and claude.ai manual upload
- **API Packages**: Size-optimized packages (< 8MB) for programmatic Claude API integration
- **Versioned Exports**: Automatic version detection from git tags or SKILL.md frontmatter
- **Installation Guides**: Auto-generated platform-specific installation instructions
- **Validation System**: Comprehensive pre-export validation (structure, size, security)
- **Opt-In Workflow**: Post-creation export prompt with multiple variants
#### 🗂️ **Export Directory Structure**
- **exports/ Directory**: Organized output location for all export packages
- **Naming Convention**: `{skill-name}-{variant}-v{version}.zip` format
- **gitignore Configuration**: Exclude generated artifacts from version control
- **Export README**: Comprehensive documentation in exports directory
#### 📚 **Documentation**
- **Export Guide**: Complete guide (`references/export-guide.md`) for exporting skills
- **Cross-Platform Guide**: Platform compatibility matrix (`references/cross-platform-guide.md`)
- **SKILL.md Enhancement**: Export capability integrated into agent-creator skill
- **README Updates**: Cross-platform export section in main documentation
### 🚀 **Enhanced**
#### 🎯 **User Experience**
- **Post-Creation Workflow**: Automatic export prompt after successful skill creation
- **Multiple Variants**: Choose Desktop, API, or both packages
- **Version Override**: Manual version specification for releases
- **On-Demand Export**: Export existing skills anytime with natural language commands
- **Clear Feedback**: Detailed status reporting during export process
#### 🔧 **Technical Capabilities**
- **Two Package Types**: Desktop (full, 2-5 MB) and API (optimized, < 8MB)
- **Smart Exclusions**: Automatic filtering of .git/, __pycache__/, .env, credentials
- **Size Optimization**: API packages compressed to meet 8MB limit
- **Security Checks**: Prevent inclusion of sensitive files
- **Integrity Validation**: ZIP file integrity verification
#### 📊 **Platform Coverage**
- **Claude Code**: Native support (no export needed)
- **Claude Desktop**: Full support via .zip upload
- **claude.ai (Web)**: Full support via .zip upload
- **Claude API**: Programmatic integration with size constraints
### 🗺️ **Integration**
#### Export Activation Patterns
New SKILL.md activation patterns for export:
- "Export [skill-name] for Desktop"
- "Package [skill-name] for API"
- "Create cross-platform package"
- "Export with version [x.x.x]"
#### Export Workflow
```
1. User creates skill → 2. Export prompt (opt-in)
→ 3. Select variants → 4. Auto-validate
→ 5. Generate packages → 6. Create install guide
→ 7. Save to exports/ → 8. Report success
```
#### Version Detection Priority
1. User override (`--version 2.0.1`)
2. Git tags (`git describe --tags`)
3. SKILL.md frontmatter (`version: 1.2.3`)
4. Default fallback (`v1.0.0`)
### 📁 **New Files**
**Core Files:**
- `scripts/export_utils.py` (~400 lines) - Export utility module
- `exports/README.md` - Export directory documentation
- `exports/.gitignore` - Exclude generated artifacts
**Documentation:**
- `references/export-guide.md` (~500 lines) - Complete export guide
- `references/cross-platform-guide.md` (~600 lines) - Platform compatibility guide
**Enhanced Files:**
- `SKILL.md` - Added cross-platform export capability (~220 lines)
- `README.md` - Added export feature documentation (~45 lines)
### 🎯 **User Impact**
#### Immediate Benefits
- ✅ Skills work across all Claude platforms
- ✅ Easy sharing with Desktop/Web users
- ✅ Production-ready API integration
- ✅ Versioned releases with proper packaging
- ✅ Validated exports with clear documentation
#### Use Cases Enabled
- **Team Distribution**: Share skills with non-Code users
- **Production Deployment**: Deploy skills via Claude API
- **Multi-Platform Access**: Use same skill on Desktop and Web
- **Versioned Releases**: Maintain multiple skill versions
- **Open Source Sharing**: Distribute skills to community
### 🔄 **Workflow Changes**
**Before v3.2:**
```
Create skill → Use in Claude Code only
```
**After v3.2:**
```
Create skill → Optional export → Use everywhere
↓
- Desktop users upload .zip
- Web users upload .zip
- API users integrate programmatically
```
### ✅ **Validation & Quality**
#### Export Validation
- SKILL.md structure and frontmatter
- Name length ≤ 64 characters
- Description length ≤ 1024 characters
- Package size (API: < 8MB hard limit)
- No sensitive files (.env, credentials)
- ZIP file integrity
#### Package Variants
**Desktop Package:**
- Complete documentation
- All scripts and assets
- Full references
- Examples and tutorials
- Optimized for usability
**API Package:**
- Size-optimized (< 8MB)
- Essential scripts only
- Minimal documentation
- Execution-focused
- No examples (size savings)
### 🔒 **Security**
**Automatically Excluded:**
- Environment files (`.env`)
- Credentials (`credentials.json`, `secrets.json`)
- Version control (`.git/`)
- Compiled files (`__pycache__/`, `*.pyc`)
- System metadata (`.DS_Store`)
### 📊 **Performance**
- **Export Speed**: ~2-5 seconds for typical skill
- **Package Sizes**: Desktop 2-5 MB, API 0.5-2 MB
- **Compression**: ZIP_DEFLATED with level 9
- **Validation**: < 1 second overhead
### 🔄 **Backward Compatibility**
**100% Compatible** - All existing workflows unchanged:
- Existing skills continue to work in Claude Code
- No migration required
- Export is opt-in only
- Non-disruptive addition
### 📚 **Documentation References**
**New Guides:**
- `references/export-guide.md` - How to export skills
- `references/cross-platform-guide.md` - Platform compatibility
- `exports/README.md` - Using exported packages
**Updated Guides:**
- `README.md` - Added cross-platform export section
- `SKILL.md` - Added export capability
- `docs/CHANGELOG.md` - This file
### 🎉 **Summary**
v3.2 makes agent-skill-creator skills **truly universal**. Create once in Claude Code, export for everywhere:
- ✅ Desktop users get full-featured .zip packages
- ✅ Web users get browser-accessible skills
- ✅ API users get optimized programmatic integration
- ✅ All with versioning, validation, and documentation
**Breaking Changes:** NONE - Export is a pure addition, completely opt-in.
---
## [2.1.0] - October 2025
### 🎯 **MAJOR: Invisible Intelligence Layer**
**AgentDB Integration - Completely invisible to users, maximum enhancement**
### ✅ **Added**
#### 🧠 **Invisible Intelligence System**
- **AgentDB Bridge Layer**: Seamless integration that hides all complexity
- **Learning Memory System**: Agents remember and improve from experience automatically
- **Progressive Enhancement**: Start simple, gain power over time without user intervention
- **Mathematical Validation System**: Proofs for all decisions (invisible to users)
- **Smart Pattern Recognition**: AgentDB learns user preferences automatically
- **Experience Storage**: User interactions stored for continuous learning
- **Predictive Insights**: Anticipates user needs based on usage patterns
#### 🎨 **Enhanced Template System**
- **AgentDB-Enhanced Templates**: Templates include learned improvements from historical usage
- **Success Rate Integration**: Templates selected based on 94%+ historical success rates
- **Learned Improvements**: Templates automatically incorporate proven optimizations
- **Smart Caching**: Enhanced cache strategies based on usage patterns learned by AgentDB
#### 🔄 **Graceful Fallback System**
- **Multiple Operating Modes**: OFFLINE, DEGRADED, SIMULATED, RECOVERING
- **Transparent Operation**: Users see benefits, not complexity
- **Smart Recovery**: Automatic synchronization when AgentDB becomes available
- **Universal Compatibility**: Works everywhere, gets smarter when possible
#### 📈 **Learning Feedback System**
- **Subtle Progress Indicators**: Natural feedback that feels magical
- **Milestone Detection**: Automatic recognition of learning achievements
- **Pattern-Based Suggestions**: Contextual recommendations based on usage
- **Personalization Engine**: Agents adapt to individual user preferences
### 🚀 **Enhanced**
#### ⚡ **Performance Improvements**
- **Faster Response Times**: Agents optimize queries based on learned patterns
- **Better Quality Results**: Validation ensures mathematical soundness
- **Intelligent API Selection**: Choices validated by historical success rates
- **Smart Architecture**: Mathematical proofs for optimal structures
#### 🎯 **User Experience**
- **Dead Simple Interface**: Same commands, no additional complexity
- **Natural Learning**: "Agents get smarter magically" without user intervention
- **Progressive Benefits**: Improvements accumulate automatically over time
- **Backward Compatibility**: 100% compatible with all v1.0 and v2.0 commands
#### 🛡️ **Reliability & Quality**
- **Robust Error Handling**: Graceful degradation without AgentDB
- **Mathematical Validation**: All creation decisions validated with proofs
- **Quality Assurance**: Enhanced validation ensures optimal results
- **Consistent Experience**: Same reliability guarantees with enhanced intelligence
### 🏗️ **Technical Implementation**
#### Integration Architecture
```
integrations/
├── agentdb_bridge.py # Invisible AgentDB abstraction layer
├── validation_system.py # Mathematical validation with proofs
├── learning_feedback.py # Subtle learning progress indicators
└── fallback_system.py # Graceful operation without AgentDB
```
#### Enhanced Templates
- **AgentDB Integration Metadata**: Success rates, learned improvements, usage patterns
- **Smart Enhancement**: Templates automatically optimized based on historical data
- **Learning Capabilities**: Templates gain intelligence from collective usage
### 📚 **Documentation Updates**
#### Documentation Reorganization
- **New docs/ Directory**: All documentation organized in dedicated folder
- **Documentation Index**: docs/README.md provides complete navigation guide
- **User Benefits Guide**: USER_BENEFITS_GUIDE.md explains learning for end users
- **Try It Yourself**: TRY_IT_YOURSELF.md provides 5-minute hands-on demo
- **Quick Reference**: QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md with command cheat sheet
- **Learning Verification**: LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md with complete technical proof
- **Clean Root**: Only essential files (SKILL.md, README.md) in root directory
- **Fixed Links**: All documentation references updated to docs/ paths
#### Learning Verification Documentation
- **Complete Technical Proof**: 15-section verification report with evidence
- **Reflexion Memory**: Verified episode storage and retrieval with similarity scores
- **Skill Library**: Verified skill creation and semantic search capabilities
- **Causal Memory**: Verified 4 causal relationships with mathematical proofs
- **Test Script**: test_agentdb_learning.py for automated verification
- **Real Evidence**: 3 episodes, 4 causal edges, 3 skills in database
#### Enhanced Experience Documentation
- **Invisible Intelligence Section**: Explains how agents get smarter automatically
- **Progressive Enhancement Examples**: Real-world learning scenarios over time
- **Updated Feature List**: New intelligence capabilities clearly documented
- **Enhanced Examples**: Show learning and improvement patterns
- **Time Savings Calculations**: Proven 40-70% improvement metrics
- **ROI Documentation**: Real success stories and business value
#### Technical Documentation
- **Integration Architecture**: Complete invisible system documentation
- **Mathematical Validation**: Proof system implementation details
- **Learning Algorithms**: Pattern recognition and improvement mechanisms
- **Fallback Strategies**: Multiple operating modes and recovery procedures
### 🎪 **User Impact**
#### Immediate Benefits (Day 1)
- **Same Simple Commands**: No learning curve or additional complexity
- **Instant Enhancement**: Agents work better immediately with invisible optimizations
- **Mathematical Quality**: All decisions validated with proofs automatically
- **Universal Compatibility**: Works perfectly whether AgentDB is available or not
#### Progressive Benefits (After 10 Uses)
- **40% Faster Response**: AgentDB learns optimal query patterns
- **Better Results**: Quality improves based on learned preferences
- **Smart Suggestions**: Contextual recommendations based on usage patterns
- **Natural Feedback**: Subtle indicators of progress and improvement
#### Long-term Benefits (After 30 Days)
- **Predictive Capabilities**: Anticipates user needs automatically
- **Personalized Experience**: Agents adapt to individual preferences
- **Continuous Learning**: Ongoing improvement from collective usage
- **Milestone Recognition**: Achievement of learning goals automatically
### 🔒 **Backward Compatibility**
#### Zero Migration Required
- **100% Command Compatibility**: All existing commands work exactly as before
- **No Configuration Changes**: Users don't need to learn anything new
- **Automatic Enhancement**: Existing agents gain intelligence immediately
- **Gradual Adoption**: Benefits accumulate without user intervention
### 🧪 **Quality Assurance**
#### Mathematical Validation
- **Template Selection**: 94% confidence scoring with historical data
- **API Optimization**: Choices validated by success rates and performance
- **Architecture Design**: Mathematical proofs for optimal structures
- **Result Quality**: Comprehensive validation ensures reliability
#### Testing Coverage
- **Integration Tests**: All fallback modes thoroughly tested
- **Learning Validation**: Progressive enhancement verified across scenarios
- **Performance Benchmarks**: Measurable improvements documented
- **Compatibility Testing**: Works across all environments and configurations
### 🚨 **Breaking Changes**
**NONE** - This release maintains 100% backward compatibility while adding powerful invisible intelligence.
### 🔄 **Deprecations**
**NONE** - All features from v2.0 and v1.0 remain fully supported.
---
## [2.0.0] - 2025-10-22
### 🚀 Major Release - Enhanced Agent Creator
**This is a revolutionary update that introduces game-changing capabilities while maintaining 100% backward compatibility with v1.0.**
### Added
#### 🎯 Multi-Agent Architecture
- **Multi-Agent Suite Creation**: Create multiple specialized agents in single operation
- **Integrated Agent Communication**: Built-in data sharing between agents
- **Suite-Level marketplace.json**: Single installation for multiple agents
- **Shared Infrastructure**: Common utilities and validation across agents
- **Cross-Agent Workflows**: Agents can call each other and share data
#### 🎨 Template System
- **Pre-built Domain Templates**: Financial Analysis, Climate Analysis, E-commerce Analytics
- **Template Matching Algorithm**: Automatic template suggestion based on user input
- **Template Customization**: Modify templates to fit specific needs
- **Template Registry**: Central management of available templates
- **80% Faster Creation**: Template-based agents created in 15-30 minutes
#### 🚀 Batch Agent Creation
- **Simultaneous Agent Creation**: Create multiple agents in one operation
- **Workflow Relationship Analysis**: Determine optimal agent architecture
- **Intelligent Structure Decision**: Choose between integrated vs independent agents
- **75% Time Savings**: 3-agent suites created in 60 minutes vs 4 hours
#### 🎮 Interactive Configuration Wizard
- **Step-by-Step Guidance**: Interactive agent creation with user input
- **Real-Time Preview**: See exactly what will be created before implementation
- **Iterative Refinement**: Modify and adjust based on user feedback
- **Learning Mode**: Educational experience with explanations
- **Advanced Configuration Options**: Fine-tune creation parameters
#### 🧠 Transcript Processing
- **Workflow Extraction**: Automatically identify distinct workflows from transcripts
- **YouTube Video Processing**: Convert video tutorials into agent suites
- **Documentation Analysis**: Extract agents from existing process documentation
- **90% Time Savings**: Automate existing processes in minutes instead of hours
#### ✅ Enhanced Validation System
- **6-Layer Validation**: Parameter, Data Quality, Temporal, Integration, Performance, Business Logic
- **Comprehensive Error Handling**: Graceful degradation and user-friendly error messages
- **Validation Reports**: Detailed feedback on data quality and system health
- **Performance Monitoring**: Track agent performance and suggest optimizations
#### 🔧 Enhanced Testing Framework
- **Comprehensive Test Suites**: 25+ tests per agent covering all functionality
- **Integration Testing**: End-to-end workflow validation
- **Performance Benchmarking**: Response time and resource usage testing
- **Quality Metrics**: Test coverage, documentation completeness, validation coverage
#### 📚 Enhanced Documentation
- **Interactive Documentation**: Living documentation that evolves with usage
- **Migration Guide**: Step-by-step guide for v1.0 users
- **Features Guide**: Comprehensive guide to all new capabilities
- **Best Practices**: Optimization tips and usage patterns
### Enhanced
#### 🔄 Backward Compatibility
- **100% v1.0 Compatibility**: All existing commands work exactly as before
- **Gradual Adoption Path**: Users can adopt new features at their own pace
- **No Breaking Changes**: Existing agents continue to work unchanged
- **Migration Support**: Tools and guidance for upgrading workflows
#### ⚡ Performance Improvements
- **50% Faster Single Agent Creation**: 90 minutes → 45 minutes
- **80% Faster Template-Based Creation**: New capability, 15 minutes average
- **75% Faster Multi-Agent Creation**: 4 hours → 1 hour for 3-agent suites
- **90% Faster Transcript Processing**: 3 hours → 20 minutes
#### 📈 Quality Improvements
- **Test Coverage**: 85% → 88%
- **Documentation**: 5,000 → 8,000+ words per agent
- **Validation Layers**: 2 → 6 comprehensive validation layers
- **Error Handling Coverage**: 90% → 95%
### Technical Details
#### Architecture Changes
- **Enhanced marketplace.json**: Supports multi-agent configurations
- **Template Registry**: JSON-based template management system
- **Validation Framework**: Modular validation system with pluggable layers
- **Integration Layer**: Cross-agent communication and data sharing
#### New File Structure
```
agent-skill-creator/
├── templates/ # NEW: Template system
│ ├── financial-analysis.json
│ ├── climate-analysis.json
│ ├── e-commerce-analytics.json
│ └── template-registry.json
├── tests/ # ENHANCED: Comprehensive testing
│ ├── test_enhanced_agent_creation.py
│ └── test_integration_v2.py
├── docs/ # NEW: Enhanced documentation
│ ├── enhanced-features-guide.md
│ └── migration-guide-v2.md
├── SKILL.md # ENHANCED: v2.0 capabilities
├── .claude-plugin/marketplace.json # ENHANCED: v2.0 configuration
└── CHANGELOG.md # NEW: Version history
```
#### API Changes
- ** marketplace.json v2.0**: Enhanced schema supporting multi-agent configurations
- **Template API**: Standardized template format and matching algorithm
- **Validation API**: Modular validation system with configurable layers
- **Integration API**: Cross-agent communication protocols
### Migration Impact
#### For Existing Users
- **No Immediate Action Required**: All existing workflows continue to work
- **Gradual Upgrade Path**: Adopt new features incrementally
- **Performance Benefits**: Immediate 50% speed improvement for new agents
- **Learning Resources**: Comprehensive guides and tutorials available
#### For New Users
- **Enhanced Onboarding**: Interactive wizard guides through creation process
- **Template-First Approach**: Start with proven patterns for faster results
- **Best Practices Built-In**: Validation and quality standards enforced automatically
### Breaking Changes
**NONE** - This release maintains 100% backward compatibility.
### Deprecations
**NONE** - No features deprecated in this release.
### Security
- **Enhanced Input Validation**: Improved parameter validation across all agents
- **API Key Security**: Better handling of sensitive credentials
- **Data Validation**: Comprehensive validation of external API responses
- **Error Information**: Reduced information leakage in error messages
---
## [1.0.0] - 2025-10-18
### Added
#### Core Functionality
- **5-Phase Autonomous Agent Creation**: Discovery, Design, Architecture, Detection, Implementation
- **Automatic API Research**: Web search and API evaluation
- **Intelligent Analysis Definition**: Prioritization of valuable analyses
- **Production-Ready Code Generation**: Complete Python implementation without TODOs
- **Comprehensive Documentation**: 10,000+ words of documentation per agent
#### Validation System
- **Parameter Validation**: Input type and value validation
- **Data Quality Checks**: API response validation
- **Integration Testing**: Basic functionality verification
#### Template System (Prototype)
- **Basic Structure**: Foundation for template-based creation
- **Domain Detection**: Automatic identification of agent domains
#### Quality Standards
- **Code Quality**: Production-ready standards enforced
- **Documentation Standards**: Complete usage guides and API documentation
- **Testing Requirements**: Basic test suite generation
### Technical Specifications
#### Supported Domains
- **Finance**: Stock analysis, portfolio management, technical indicators
- **Agriculture**: Crop data analysis, yield predictions, weather integration
- **Climate**: Weather data analysis, anomaly detection, trend analysis
- **E-commerce**: Traffic analysis, revenue tracking, customer analytics
#### API Integration
- **API Research**: Automatic discovery and evaluation of data sources
- **Rate Limiting**: Built-in rate limiting and caching
- **Error Handling**: Robust error recovery and retry mechanisms
#### File Structure
```
agent-name/
├── .claude-plugin/marketplace.json
├── SKILL.md
├── scripts/
│ ├── fetch_data.py
│ ├── parse_data.py
│ ├── analyze_data.py
│ └── utils/
├── tests/
├── references/
├── assets/
└── README.md
```
### Known Limitations
- **Single Agent Only**: One agent per marketplace.json
- **Manual Template Selection**: No automatic template matching
- **Limited Interactive Features**: No step-by-step guidance
- **Basic Validation**: Only 2 validation layers
- **No Batch Creation**: Must create agents individually
---
## Version History Summary
### Evolution Path
**v1.0.0 (October 2025)**
- Revolutionary autonomous agent creation
- 5-phase protocol for complete agent generation
- Production-ready code and documentation
- Basic validation and testing
**v2.0.0 (October 2025)**
- Multi-agent architecture and suites
- Template system with 80% speed improvement
- Interactive configuration wizard
- Transcript processing capabilities
- Enhanced validation and testing
- 100% backward compatibility
### Impact Metrics
#### Performance Improvements
- **Agent Creation Speed**: 50-90% faster depending on complexity
- **Code Quality**: 95% error handling coverage vs 90%
- **Documentation**: 8,000+ words vs 5,000 words
- **Test Coverage**: 88% vs 85%
#### User Experience
- **Learning Curve**: Interactive wizard reduces complexity
- **Success Rate**: Higher success rates with preview system
- **Flexibility**: Multiple creation paths for different needs
- **Adoption**: Gradual migration path for existing users
#### Technical Capabilities
- **Multi-Agent Systems**: From single agents to integrated suites
- **Template Library**: 3 proven templates with extensibility
- **Process Automation**: Transcript processing enables workflow automation
- **Quality Assurance**: 6-layer validation system
### Future Roadmap
#### v2.1 (Planned)
- **Additional Templates**: Healthcare, Manufacturing, Education
- **AI-Powered Optimization**: Self-improving agents
- **Cloud Integration**: Direct deployment to cloud platforms
- **Collaboration Features**: Team-based agent creation
#### v2.2 (Planned)
- **Machine Learning Integration**: Automated model training and deployment
- **Real-Time Monitoring**: Agent health and performance dashboard
- **Advanced Analytics**: Usage pattern analysis and optimization
- **Marketplace Integration**: Share and discover agents
---
## Support and Feedback
### Getting Help
- **Documentation**: See `/docs/` directory for comprehensive guides
- **Migration Guide**: `/docs/migration-guide-v2.md` for upgrading from v1.0
- **Features Guide**: `/docs/enhanced-features-guide.md` for new capabilities
- **Issues**: Report bugs and request features via GitHub issues
### Contributing
- **Templates**: Contribute new domain templates
- **Documentation**: Help improve guides and examples
- **Testing**: Enhance test coverage and validation
- **Examples**: Share success stories and use cases
---
**Agent Creator v2.0 represents a paradigm shift in autonomous agent creation, making it possible for anyone to create sophisticated, multi-agent systems in minutes rather than hours, while maintaining the power and flexibility that advanced users require.**

272
docs/CLAUDE_SKILLS_ARCHITECTURE.md
View file

@ -1,272 +0,0 @@
# Claude Skills Architecture: Complete Guide
## 🎯 **Purpose**
This document eliminates confusion between different types of Claude Code Skills and establishes consistent terminology.
## 📚 **Standard Terminology**
### **Skill**
A **Skill** is a complete Claude Code capability implemented as a folder containing:
- `SKILL.md` file (required)
- Optional resources (scripts/, references/, assets/)
- Domain-specific functionality
**Example:** `my-skill/` containing financial data analysis
### **Component Skill**
A **Component Skill** is a specialized sub-skill that is part of a larger Skill Suite.
- Has its own `SKILL.md`
- Focuses on specific functionality
- Shares resources with other component skills
**Example:** `data-acquisition/SKILL.md` within a financial analysis suite
### **Skill Suite**
A **Skill Suite** is an integrated collection of Component Skills that work together.
- Has `marketplace.json` as manifest
- Multiple specialized component skills
- Shared resources between skills
**Example:** Complete financial analysis suite with skills for data acquisition, analysis, and reporting.
### **Marketplace Plugin**
A **Marketplace Plugin** is the `marketplace.json` file that hosts and organizes one or more Skills.
- **NOT a skill** - it's an organizational manifest
- Defines how skills should be loaded
- Can host simple skills or complex suites
## 🏗️ **Architecture Types**
### **Architecture 1: Simple Skill**
```
my-skill/
├── SKILL.md ← Single skill file
├── scripts/ ← Optional supporting code
├── references/ ← Optional documentation
└── assets/ ← Optional templates/resources
```
**When to use:**
- Focused, single functionality
- Simple workflow
- Less than 1000 lines of total code
- One main objective
**Examples:**
- Business proposal generator
- PDF data extractor
- ROI calculator
### **Architecture 2: Complex Skill Suite**
```
my-suite/ ← Complete Skill Suite
├── .claude-plugin/
│ └── marketplace.json ← Skills manifest
├── component-1/ ← Component Skill 1
│ ├── SKILL.md
│ └── scripts/
├── component-2/ ← Component Skill 2
│ ├── SKILL.md
│ └── references/
├── component-3/ ← Component Skill 3
│ ├── SKILL.md
│ └── assets/
└── shared/ ← Shared resources
├── utils/
├── config/
└── templates/
```
**When to use:**
- Multiple related workflows
- Complex functionalities that need separation
- More than 2000 lines of total code
- Multiple interconnected objectives
**Examples:**
- Complete financial analysis suite
- Project management system
- E-commerce analytics platform
### **Architecture 3: Hybrid (Simple + Components)**
```
my-hybrid-skill/ ← Main simple skill
├── SKILL.md ← Main orchestration
├── scripts/
│ ├── main.py ← Main logic
│ └── components/ ← Specialized components
├── references/
└── assets/
```
**When to use:**
- Main functionality with sub-components
- Moderate complexity
- Centralized orchestration required
## 🔍 **Deciding Which Architecture to Use**
### **Use Simple Skill when:**
- ✅ Clear main objective
- ✅ Linear and sequential workflow
- ✅ Less than 3 distinct subprocesses
- ✅ Code < 1000 lines
- ✅ One person can easily maintain
### **Use Complex Skill Suite when:**
- ✅ Multiple related objectives
- ✅ Independent but connected workflows
- ✅ More than 3 distinct subprocesses
- ✅ Code > 2000 lines
- ✅ Team or complex maintenance
### **Use Hybrid when:**
- ✅ Central orchestration is critical
- ✅ Components are optional/configurable
- ✅ Main workflow with specialized sub-tasks
## 📋 **Marketplace.json Explained**
The `marketplace.json` **IS NOT** a skill. It's an **organizational manifest**:
```json
{
"name": "my-suite",
"plugins": [
{
"name": "component-1",
"source": "./component-1/",
"skills": ["./SKILL.md"] ← Points to the actual skill
},
{
"name": "component-2",
"source": "./component-2/",
"skills": ["./SKILL.md"] ← Points to another skill
}
]
}
```
**Analogy:** Think of `marketplace.json` as a **book index** - it's not the content, just organizes and points to the chapters (skills).
## 🚫 **Terminology to Avoid**
To avoid confusion:
❌ **"Plugin"** to refer to individual skills
✅ **"Component Skill"** or **"Skill Suite"**
❌ **"Multi-plugin architecture"**
✅ **"Multi-skill suite"**
❌ **"Plugin marketplace"**
✅ **"Skill marketplace"** (when hosting skills)
## ✅ **Correct Terms**
| Situation | Correct Term | Example (standard kebab-case) |
|----------|---------------|--------------------------------|
| Single file with capability | **Simple Skill** | `pdf-generator/SKILL.md` |
| Specialized sub-capability | **Component Skill** | `data-extraction/SKILL.md` |
| Set of capabilities | **Skill Suite** | `financial-analysis-suite/` |
| Organizational file | **Marketplace Plugin** | `marketplace.json` |
| Complete system | **Skill Ecosystem** | Suite + Marketplace + Resources |
## 🏷️ **Naming Convention: Standard Kebab-Case (Agent Skills Open Standard)**
### **Purpose of Standard Kebab-Case Naming**
- **Clear Identification**: Descriptive names immediately convey the skill's purpose
- **Open Standard**: Follows the v4.0 Agent Skills Open Standard for interoperability
- **Consistent Standard**: Professional convention across all documentation and platforms
- **Simplicity**: No unnecessary suffixes -- the name speaks for itself
- **Easy Organization**: Simple identification and grouping by domain
### **Naming Rules**
**1. Standard Format**
```
{descriptive-name}/
```
**2. Simple Skills**
```
pdf-text-extractor/
csv-data-cleaner/
weekly-report-generator/
image-converter/
```
**3. Complex Skill Suites**
```
financial-analysis-suite/
e-commerce-automation/
research-workflow/
business-intelligence/
```
**4. Component Skills (within suites)**
```
data-acquisition/
technical-analysis/
reporting-generator/
user-interface/
```
**5. Formatting**
- ✅ Always lowercase
- ✅ Use hyphens to separate words (kebab-case)
- ✅ Descriptive and clear
- ✅ No unnecessary suffixes
- ❌ No underscores or spaces
- ❌ No special characters (except hyphens)
### **Transformation Examples**
| User Requirement | Generated Name |
|---------------------|-------------|
| "Extract text from PDF documents" | `pdf-text-extractor/` |
| "Clean CSV data automatically" | `csv-data-cleaner/` |
| "Complete financial analysis platform" | `financial-analysis-suite/` |
| "Generate weekly status reports" | `weekly-report-generator/` |
| "Automate e-commerce workflows" | `e-commerce-automation/` |
## 🎯 **Golden Rule**
**If it has `SKILL.md` → It's a Skill (simple or component)
If it has `marketplace.json` → It's a marketplace plugin (organization)**
## 📖 **Real-World Examples**
### **Simple Skill: Business Proposal**
```
business-proposal/
├── SKILL.md ← "Create business proposals"
├── references/
│ └── template.md
└── assets/
└── logo.png
```
### **Complex Skill Suite: Financial Analysis**
```
financial-analysis-suite/
├── .claude-plugin/marketplace.json
├── data-acquisition/SKILL.md ← "Download market data"
├── technical-analysis/SKILL.md ← "Analyze technical indicators"
├── portfolio-analysis/SKILL.md ← "Optimize portfolio"
└── reporting/SKILL.md ← "Generate reports"
```
Both are **legitimate Claude Code Skills** - just with different complexity levels.
---
## 🔄 **How This Document Helps**
1. **Clear terminology** - Everyone uses the same terms
2. **Informed decisions** - Know when to use each architecture
3. **Effective communication** - No ambiguity between skills and plugins
4. **Consistent documentation** - Standard across all agent-skill-creator documentation
**Result:** Less confusion, more clarity, better development!

297
docs/DECISION_LOGIC.md
View file

@ -1,297 +0,0 @@
# Agent Creator: Decision Logic and Architecture Selection
## 🎯 **Purpose**
This document explains the decision-making process used by the Agent Creator meta-skill to determine the appropriate architecture for Claude Skills.
## 📋 **Decision Framework**
### **Phase 1: Requirements Analysis**
During user input analysis, the Agent Creator evaluates:
#### **Complexity Indicators**
- **Number of distinct objectives**: How many different goals?
- **Workflow complexity**: Linear vs branching vs parallel
- **Data sources**: Single vs multiple API/data sources
- **Output formats**: Simple vs complex report generation
- **Integration needs**: Standalone vs interconnected systems
#### **Domain Complexity Assessment**
- **Single domain** (e.g., PDF processing) → Simple Skill likely
- **Multi-domain** (e.g., finance + reporting + optimization) → Complex Suite likely
- **Specialized expertise required** (technical, financial, legal) → Component separation beneficial
### **Phase 2: Architecture Decision Tree**
```
START: Analyze User Request
↓
┌─ Single, clear objective?
│ ├─ Yes → Continue Simple Skill Path
│ └─ No → Continue Complex Suite Path
↓
Simple Skill Path:
├─ Single data source?
│ ├─ Yes → Simple Skill confirmed
│ └─ No → Consider Hybrid architecture
├─ Linear workflow?
│ ├─ Yes → Simple Skill confirmed
│ └─ No → Consider breaking into components
└─ <1000 lines estimated code?
├─ Yes → Simple Skill confirmed
└─ No → Recommend Complex Suite
Complex Suite Path:
├─ Multiple related workflows?
│ ├─ Yes → Complex Suite confirmed
│ └─ No → Consider Simple + Extensions
├─ Team maintenance expected?
│ ├─ Yes → Complex Suite confirmed
│ └─ No → Consider advanced Simple Skill
└─ Domain expertise specialization needed?
├─ Yes → Complex Suite confirmed
└─ No → Consider Hybrid approach
```
### **Phase 3: Specific Decision Rules**
#### **Simple Skill Criteria**
✅ **Use Simple Skill when:**
- Single primary objective
- One or two related sub-tasks
- Linear workflow (A → B → C)
- Single domain expertise
- <1000 lines total code expected
- One developer can maintain
- Development time: <2 weeks
**Examples:**
- "Create PDF text extractor"
- "Automate CSV data cleaning"
- "Generate weekly status reports"
- "Convert images to web format"
#### **Complex Skill Suite Criteria**
✅ **Use Complex Suite when:**
- Multiple distinct objectives
- Parallel or branching workflows
- Multiple domain expertise areas
- >2000 lines total code expected
- Team maintenance anticipated
- Development time: >2 weeks
- Component reusability valuable
**Examples:**
- "Complete financial analysis platform"
- "E-commerce automation system"
- "Research workflow automation"
- "Business intelligence suite"
#### **Hybrid Architecture Criteria**
✅ **Use Hybrid when:**
- Core objective with optional extensions
- Configurable component selection
- Main workflow with specialized sub-tasks
- 1000-2000 lines code expected
- Central orchestration important
**Examples:**
- "Document processor with OCR and classification"
- "Data analysis with optional reporting components"
- "API client with multiple integration options"
### **Phase 4: Implementation Decision**
#### **Simple Skill Implementation**
```python
# Decision confirmed: Create Simple Skill
architecture = "simple"
base_name = generate_descriptive_name(requirements)
skill_name = base_name # Standard kebab-case naming
files_to_create = [
"SKILL.md",
"scripts/ (if needed)",
"references/ (if needed)",
"assets/ (if needed)"
]
marketplace_json = False # Single skill doesn't need manifest
```
#### **Complex Suite Implementation**
```python
# Decision confirmed: Create Complex Skill Suite
architecture = "complex_suite"
base_name = generate_descriptive_name(requirements)
suite_name = base_name # Standard kebab-case naming
components = identify_components(requirements)
component_names = list(components)
files_to_create = [
".claude-plugin/marketplace.json",
f"{component}/SKILL.md" for component in component_names,
"shared/utils/",
"shared/config/"
]
marketplace_json = True # Suite needs organization manifest
```
#### **Hybrid Implementation**
```python
# Decision confirmed: Create Hybrid Architecture
architecture = "hybrid"
base_name = generate_descriptive_name(requirements)
skill_name = base_name # Standard kebab-case naming
main_skill = "primary_skill.md"
optional_components = identify_optional_components(requirements)
component_names = list(optional_components)
files_to_create = [
"SKILL.md", # Main orchestrator
"scripts/components/", # Optional sub-components
"config/component_selection.json"
]
```
#### **Naming Convention Logic**
```python
def generate_descriptive_name(user_requirements):
"""Generate descriptive base name from user requirements"""
# Extract key concepts from user input
concepts = extract_concepts(user_requirements)
# Create descriptive base name
if len(concepts) == 1:
base_name = concepts[0]
elif len(concepts) <= 3:
base_name = "-".join(concepts)
else:
base_name = "-".join(concepts[:3]) + "-suite"
# Ensure valid filename format
base_name = sanitize_filename(base_name)
return base_name
def apply_naming_convention(base_name):
"""Apply standard kebab-case naming convention"""
# Ensure valid kebab-case format
base_name = base_name.lower().strip()
base_name = re.sub(r'[^a-z0-9-]', '-', base_name)
base_name = re.sub(r'-+', '-', base_name).strip('-')
return base_name
# Examples of naming logic:
# "extract text from PDF" → "pdf-text-extractor"
# "financial analysis with reporting" → "financial-analysis-suite"
# "clean CSV data" → "csv-data-cleaner"
```
## 🎯 **Decision Documentation**
### **DECISIONS.md Template**
Every created skill includes a `DECISIONS.md` file documenting:
```markdown
# Architecture Decisions
## Requirements Analysis
- **Primary Objectives**: [List main goals]
- **Complexity Indicators**: [Number of objectives, workflows, data sources]
- **Domain Assessment**: [Single vs multi-domain]
## Architecture Selection
- **Chosen Architecture**: [Simple Skill / Complex Suite / Hybrid]
- **Key Decision Factors**: [Why this architecture was selected]
- **Alternatives Considered**: [Other options and why rejected]
## Implementation Rationale
- **Component Breakdown**: [How functionality is organized]
- **Integration Strategy**: [How components work together]
- **Maintenance Considerations**: [Long-term maintenance approach]
## Future Evolution
- **Growth Path**: [How to evolve from simple to complex if needed]
- **Extension Points**: [Where functionality can be added]
- **Migration Strategy**: [How to change architectures if requirements change]
```
## 🔄 **Learning and Improvement**
### **Decision Quality Tracking**
The Agent Creator tracks:
- **User satisfaction** with architectural choices
- **Maintenance requirements** for each pattern
- **Evolution patterns** (simple → complex transitions)
- **Success metrics** by architecture type
### **Pattern Recognition**
Over time, the system learns:
- **Common complexity indicators** for specific domains
- **Optimal component boundaries** for multi-domain problems
- **User preference patterns** for different architectures
- **Evolution triggers** that signal need for architecture change
### **Feedback Integration**
User feedback improves future decisions:
- **Architecture mismatch** reports
- **Maintenance difficulty** feedback
- **Feature request patterns**
- **User success stories**
## 📊 **Examples of Decision Logic in Action**
### **Example 1: PDF Text Extractor Request**
**User Input:** "Create a skill to extract text from PDF documents"
**Analysis:**
- Single objective: PDF text extraction ✓
- Linear workflow: PDF → Extract → Clean ✓
- Single domain: Document processing ✓
- Estimated code: ~500 lines ✓
- Single developer maintenance ✓
**Decision:** Simple Skill
**Implementation:** `pdf-extractor/SKILL.md` with optional scripts folder
### **Example 2: Financial Analysis Platform Request**
**User Input:** "Build a complete financial analysis system with data acquisition, technical analysis, portfolio optimization, and reporting"
**Analysis:**
- Multiple objectives: 4 distinct capabilities ✗
- Complex workflows: Data → Analysis → Optimization → Reporting ✗
- Multi-domain: Data engineering, finance, reporting ✗
- Estimated code: ~5000 lines ✗
- Team maintenance likely ✗
**Decision:** Complex Skill Suite
**Implementation:** 4 component skills with marketplace.json
### **Example 3: Document Processor Request**
**User Input:** "Create a document processor that can extract text, classify documents, and optionally generate summaries"
**Analysis:**
- Core objective: Document processing ✓
- Optional components: Classification, summarization ✓
- Configurable workflow: Base + extensions ✓
- Estimated code: ~1500 lines ✓
- Central orchestration important ✓
**Decision:** Hybrid Architecture
**Implementation:** Main skill with optional component scripts
## ✅ **Quality Assurance**
### **Decision Validation**
Before finalizing architecture choice:
1. **Requirements completeness check**
2. **Complexity assessment verification**
3. **Maintenance feasibility analysis**
4. **User communication and confirmation**
### **Architecture Review**
Post-creation validation:
1. **Component boundary effectiveness**
2. **Integration success**
3. **Maintainability assessment**
4. **User satisfaction measurement**
This decision logic ensures that every created skill has the appropriate architecture for its requirements, maximizing effectiveness and minimizing maintenance overhead.

544
docs/INTERNAL_FLOW_ANALYSIS.md
View file

@ -1,544 +0,0 @@
# Agent-Skill-Creator Internal Flow: What Happens "Under the Hood"
## 🎯 **Example Scenario**
**User Command:**
```
"I'd like to automate what is being explained and described in this article [financial data analysis article content]"
```
## 🚀 **Complete Detailed Flow**
### **PHASE 0: Detection and Automatic Activation**
#### **0.1 User Intent Analysis**
Claude Code analyzes the command and detects activation patterns:
```
DETECTED PATTERNS:
✅ "automate" → Workflow automation activation
✅ "what is being explained" → External content processing
✅ "in this article" → Transcribed/intent processing
✅ Complete command → Activates Agent-Skill-Creator
```
#### **0.2 Meta-Skill Loading**
```python
# Claude Code internal system
if matches_pattern(user_input, SKILL_ACTIVATION_PATTERNS):
load_skill("agent-creator-en-v2")
activate_5_phase_process(user_input)
```
**What happens:**
- The agent-creator's `SKILL.md` is loaded into memory
- The skill context is prepared
- The 5 phases are initialized
---
### **PHASE 1: DISCOVERY - Research and Analysis**
#### **1.1 Article Content Processing**
```python
# Internal processing simulation
def analyze_article_content(article_text):
# Structured information extraction
workflows = extract_workflows(article_text)
tools_mentioned = identify_tools(article_text)
data_sources = find_data_sources(article_text)
complexity_assessment = estimate_complexity(article_text)
return {
'workflows': workflows,
'tools': tools_mentioned,
'data_sources': data_sources,
'complexity': complexity_assessment
}
```
**Practical Example - Financial Analysis Article:**
```
ANALYZED ARTICLE CONTENT:
├─ Identified Workflows:
│ ├─ "Download stock market data"
│ ├─ "Calculate technical indicators"
│ ├─ "Generate analysis charts"
│ └─ "Create weekly report"
├─ Mentioned Tools:
│ ├─ "pandas library"
│ ├─ "Alpha Vantage API"
│ ├─ "Matplotlib for charts"
│ └─ "Excel for reports"
└─ Data Sources:
├─ "Yahoo Finance API"
├─ "Local CSV files"
└─ "SQL database"
```
#### **1.2 API and Tools Research**
```bash
# Automatic WebSearch performed by Claude
WebSearch: "Best Python libraries for financial data analysis 2025"
WebSearch: "Alpha Vantage API documentation Python integration"
WebSearch: "Financial reporting automation tools Python"
```
#### **1.3 AgentDB Enhancement (if available)**
```python
# Transparent AgentDB integration
agentdb_insights = query_agentdb_for_patterns("financial_analysis")
if agentdb_insights.success_rate > 0.8:
apply_learned_patterns(agentdb_insights.patterns)
```
#### **1.4 Technology Stack Decision**
```
TECHNICAL DECISION:
✅ Python as primary language
✅ pandas for data manipulation
✅ Alpha Vantage for market data
✅ Matplotlib/Seaborn for visualizations
✅ ReportLab for PDF generation
```
---
### **PHASE 2: DESIGN - Functionality Specification**
#### **2.1 Use Case Analysis**
```python
def define_use_cases(workflows_identified):
use_cases = []
for workflow in workflows_identified:
use_case = {
'name': workflow['title'],
'description': workflow['description'],
'inputs': workflow['required_inputs'],
'outputs': workflow['expected_outputs'],
'frequency': workflow['frequency'],
'complexity': workflow['complexity_level']
}
use_cases.append(use_case)
return use_cases
```
**Defined Use Cases:**
```
USE CASE 1: Data Acquisition
- Description: Download historical stock data
- Input: List of tickers, period
- Output: DataFrame with OHLCV data
- Frequency: Daily
USE CASE 2: Technical Analysis
- Description: Calculate technical indicators
- Input: Price DataFrame
- Output: DataFrame with indicators
- Frequency: On demand
USE CASE 3: Report Generation
- Description: Create PDF report
- Input: Analysis results
- Output: Formatted report
- Frequency: Weekly
```
#### **2.2 Methodology Definition**
```python
def specify_methodologies(use_cases):
methodologies = {
'data_validation': 'Data quality validation',
'error_handling': 'Robust error handling',
'caching_strategy': 'Data caching for performance',
'logging': 'Detailed logging for debugging',
'configuration': 'Flexible configuration via JSON'
}
return methodologies
```
---
### **PHASE 3: ARCHITECTURE - Structural Decision**
#### **3.1 Complexity Analysis (DECISION_LOGIC.md applied)**
```python
# Automatic evaluation based on article content
complexity_score = calculate_complexity({
'number_of_workflows': 4, # Data + Analysis + Reports + Alerts
'workflow_complexity': 'medium', # API calls + calculations + formatting
'data_sources': 3, # Yahoo Finance + CSV + Database
'estimated_code_lines': 2500, # Above Simple Skill threshold
'domain_expertise': ['finance', 'data_science', 'reporting']
})
# Architecture decision
if complexity_score > SIMPLE_SKILL_THRESHOLD:
architecture = "complex_skill_suite"
else:
architecture = "simple_skill"
```
**In this example:**
```
ANALYSIS RESULT:
✅ Multiple distinct workflows (4)
✅ Medium-high complexity
✅ Multiple data sources
✅ Estimate > 2000 lines of code
✅ Multiple domains of expertise
DECISION: Complex Skill Suite
GENERATED NAME: financial-analysis-suite```
#### **3.2 Component Structure Definition**
```python
def design_component_skills(complexity_analysis):
if complexity_analysis.architecture == "complex_skill_suite":
components = {
'data-acquisition': 'Handle data sourcing and validation',
'technical-analysis': 'Calculate indicators and signals',
'visualization': 'Create charts and graphs',
'reporting': 'Generate professional reports'
}
return components
```
#### **3.3 Performance and Cache Planning**
```python
performance_plan = {
'data_cache': 'Cache market data for 1 day',
'calculation_cache': 'Cache expensive calculations',
'parallel_processing': 'Process multiple stocks concurrently',
'batch_operations': 'Batch API calls when possible'
}
```
---
### **PHASE 4: DETECTION - Keywords and Activation**
#### **4.1 Keyword Analysis**
```python
def determine_activation_keywords(workflows, tools):
keywords = {
'primary': [
'financial analysis',
'market data',
'technical indicators',
'investment reports'
],
'secondary': [
'automate analysis',
'generate charts',
'calculate returns',
'data extraction'
],
'domains': [
'finance',
'investments',
'quantitative analysis',
'stock market'
]
}
return keywords
```
#### **4.2 Precise Description Creation**
```python
def create_skill_descriptions(components):
descriptions = {}
for component_name, component_function in components.items():
description = f"""
Component skill for {component_function} in financial analysis.
When to use: When user mentions {determine_activation_keywords(component_name)}
Capabilities: {list_component_capabilities(component_name)}
"""
descriptions[component_name] = description
return descriptions
```
---
### **PHASE 5: IMPLEMENTATION - Code Creation**
#### **5.1 Directory Structure Creation**
```bash
# Automatically created by the system
mkdir -p financial-analysis-suite/.claude-plugin
mkdir -p financial-analysis-suite/data-acquisition/{scripts,references,assets}
mkdir -p financial-analysis-suite/technical-analysis/{scripts,references,assets}
mkdir -p financial-analysis-suite/visualization/{scripts,references,assets}
mkdir -p financial-analysis-suite/reporting/{scripts,references,assets}
mkdir -p financial-analysis-suite/shared/{utils,config,templates}
```
#### **5.2 marketplace.json Generation**
```json
{
"name": "financial-analysis-suite",
"plugins": [
{
"name": "data-acquisition",
"source": "./data-acquisition/",
"skills": ["./SKILL.md"]
},
{
"name": "technical-analysis",
"source": "./technical-analysis/",
"skills": ["./SKILL.md"]
}
]
}
```
#### **5.3 SKILL.md Files Creation**
For each component, the system generates:
```markdown
---
name: data-acquisition
description: Component skill for acquiring financial market data from multiple sources including APIs, CSV files, and real-time feeds.
---
# Financial Data Acquisition
This component skill handles all data acquisition needs for the financial analysis suite.
## When to Use This Component Skill
Use this skill when you need to:
- Download market data from APIs (Alpha Vantage, Yahoo Finance)
- Import data from CSV/Excel files
- Validate and clean financial data
- Store data in standardized format
```
#### **5.4 Python Scripts Generation**
```python
# data-acquisition/scripts/fetch_data.py
import pandas as pd
import yfinance as yf
from datetime import datetime, timedelta
class FinancialDataFetcher:
def __init__(self, config_file='config/data_sources.json'):
self.config = self.load_config(config_file)
def fetch_stock_data(self, tickers, period='1y'):
"""Fetch historical stock data for given tickers"""
data = {}
for ticker in tickers:
try:
stock = yf.Ticker(ticker)
data[ticker] = stock.history(period=period)
logger.info(f"Successfully fetched data for {ticker}")
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to fetch data for {ticker}: {e}")
return data
def validate_data_quality(self, data):
"""Validate the quality of fetched data"""
validation_results = {}
for ticker, df in data.items():
results = {
'missing_data_pct': df.isnull().sum().sum() / df.size,
'date_range': f"{df.index.min()} to {df.index.max()}",
'completeness': len(df) / 252 # Trading days
}
validation_results[ticker] = results
return validation_results
```
#### **5.5 Configuration Files Creation**
```json
// shared/config/data_sources.json
{
"api_keys": {
"alpha_vantage": "YOUR_API_KEY_HERE",
"quandl": "YOUR_QUANDL_KEY_HERE"
},
"data_sources": {
"yahoo_finance": {
"enabled": true,
"rate_limit": 2000,
"timeout": 30
},
"alpha_vantage": {
"enabled": true,
"rate_limit": 5,
"timeout": 60
}
},
"cache_settings": {
"market_data_ttl": 86400,
"calculations_ttl": 3600
}
}
```
#### **5.6 Documentation and References Generation**
```markdown
# data-acquisition/references/api_documentation.md
## Alpha Vantage API
- **Endpoint**: TIME_SERIES_DAILY
- **Rate Limit**: 5 calls/minute (free tier)
- **Data Format**: JSON
- **Authentication**: API Key in header
## Yahoo Finance (yfinance)
- **Library**: yfinance
- **Rate Limit**: None documented (be reasonable)
- **Data Format**: pandas DataFrame
- **Authentication**: None required
```
#### **5.7 Main README Creation**
```markdown
# Financial Analysis Suite
Complete automated financial analysis system that processes market data, performs technical analysis, and generates professional investment reports.
## Quick Start
1. Install dependencies: `pip install -r requirements.txt`
2. Configure API keys in `shared/config/data_sources.json`
3. Install as Claude plugin: `/plugin marketplace add ./`
4. Use: "Analyze AAPL, MSFT, GOOG performance and create weekly report"
## Components
- **Data Acquisition**: Automated market data collection
- **Technical Analysis**: Indicator calculations and signal generation
- **Visualization**: Chart creation and trend analysis
- **Reporting**: Professional PDF report generation
```
#### **5.8 Automatic Installation Test**
```python
# scripts/test_installation.py
def test_suite_installation():
"""Test that all components work correctly"""
print("🧪 Testing Financial Analysis Suite installation...")
# Test imports
try:
import pandas as pd
import yfinance as yf
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
print("✅ All dependencies imported successfully")
except ImportError as e:
print(f"❌ Missing dependency: {e}")
return False
# Test configuration
try:
with open('shared/config/data_sources.json') as f:
config = json.load(f)
print("✅ Configuration file loaded successfully")
except FileNotFoundError:
print("❌ Configuration file missing")
return False
# Test basic functionality
try:
test_data = yf.download('AAPL', period='1mo')
if not test_data.empty:
print("✅ Basic data fetching works")
else:
print("❌ Data fetching failed")
return False
except Exception as e:
print(f"❌ Basic functionality test failed: {e}")
return False
print("🎉 All tests passed! Suite is ready to use.")
return True
if __name__ == "__main__":
test_suite_installation()
```
---
## 🎯 **Final Result - What the User Receives**
After approximately **45-90 minutes** of autonomous processing, the user will have:
```
financial-analysis-suite/
├── .claude-plugin/
│ └── marketplace.json ← Suite manifest
├── data-acquisition/
│ ├── SKILL.md ← Component skill 1
│ ├── scripts/
│ │ ├── fetch_data.py ← Functional code
│ │ ├── validate_data.py ← Validation
│ │ └── cache_manager.py ← Cache
│ ├── references/
│ │ └── api_documentation.md ← Documentation
│ └── assets/
├── technical-analysis/
│ ├── SKILL.md ← Component skill 2
│ ├── scripts/
│ │ ├── indicators.py ← Technical calculations
│ │ ├── signals.py ← Signal generation
│ │ └── backtester.py ← Historical tests
│ └── references/
├── visualization/
│ ├── SKILL.md ← Component skill 3
│ └── scripts/chart_generator.py
├── reporting/
│ ├── SKILL.md ← Component skill 4
│ └── scripts/report_generator.py
├── shared/
│ ├── utils/
│ ├── config/
│ └── templates/
├── requirements.txt ← Python dependencies
├── README.md ← User guide
├── DECISIONS.md ← Decision explanations
└── test_installation.py ← Automatic test
```
**Note:** All components use standard kebab-case naming per the Agent Skills Open Standard.
## 🚀 **How to Use the Created Skill**
**Immediately after creation:**
```bash
# Install the suite
cd financial-analysis-suite
/plugin marketplace add ./
# Use the components
"Analyze technical indicators for AAPL using the data acquisition and technical analysis components"
"Generate a comprehensive financial report for portfolio [MSFT, GOOGL, TSLA]"
"Compare performance of tech stocks using the analysis suite"
```
---
## 🧠 **Intelligence Behind the Process**
### **What Makes This Possible:**
1. **Semantic Understanding**: Claude understands the article's content, not just keywords
2. **Structured Extraction**: Identifies workflows, tools, and patterns
3. **Autonomous Decision-Making**: Chooses the appropriate architecture without human intervention
4. **Functional Generation**: Creates code that actually works, not templates
5. **Continuous Learning**: With AgentDB, improves with each creation
### **Differential Compared to Simple Approaches:**
| Simple Approach | Agent-Skill-Creator |
|------------------|---------------------|
| Generates templates | Creates functional code |
| Requires programming | Fully autonomous |
| No architecture decision | Architecture intelligence |
| Basic documentation | Complete documentation |
| Manual testing | Automatic testing |
**Agent-Skill-Creator transforms articles and descriptions into fully functional, production-ready Claude Code skills!** 🎉

506
docs/LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md
View file

@ -1,506 +0,0 @@
# AgentDB Learning Capabilities Verification Report
**Date**: October 23, 2025
**Agent-Skill-Creator Version**: v2.1
**AgentDB Integration**: Active and Verified
---
## Executive Summary
✅ **ALL LEARNING CAPABILITIES VERIFIED AND WORKING**
The agent-skill-creator v2.1 with AgentDB integration demonstrates full learning capabilities across all three memory systems: Reflexion Memory (episodes), Skill Library, and Causal Memory. This report documents the verification process and provides evidence of the invisible intelligence system.
---
## 1. Baseline Assessment
### Initial State (Before Testing)
```
📊 Database Statistics
════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
causal_edges: 0 records
causal_experiments: 0 records
causal_observations: 0 records
episodes: 0 records
════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
```
**Status**: Fresh database with zero learning history
---
## 2. Reflexion Memory (Episodes)
### What It Does
Stores every agent creation as an episode with task, input, output, critique, reward, success status, latency, and tokens used. Enables retrieval of similar past experiences to inform new creations.
### Verification Results
#### Episodes Stored: 3
1. **Episode #1**: Create financial analysis agent for stock market data
- Reward: 95.0
- Success: Yes
- Latency: 18,000ms
- Critique: "Successfully created, user satisfied with API selection"
2. **Episode #2**: Create financial portfolio tracking agent
- Reward: 90.0
- Success: Yes
- Latency: 15,000ms
- Critique: "Good implementation, added RSI and MACD indicators"
3. **Episode #3**: Create cryptocurrency analysis agent
- Reward: 92.0
- Success: Yes
- Latency: 12,000ms
- Critique: "Excellent, added real-time price alerts"
#### Retrieval Test
Query: "financial analysis"
```
✅ Retrieved 3 relevant episodes
#1: Episode 1 - Similarity: 0.536
#2: Episode 2 - Similarity: 0.419
#3: Episode 3 - Similarity: 0.361
```
**Status**: ✅ **VERIFIED** - Semantic search working with similarity scoring
---
## 3. Skill Library
### What It Does
Consolidates successful patterns from episodes into reusable skills. Enables search for relevant skills based on semantic similarity to new tasks.
### Verification Results
#### Skills Created: 3
1. **yfinance_stock_data_fetcher**
- Description: Fetches stock market data using yfinance API with caching
- Code: `def fetch_stock_data(symbol, period='1mo'): ...`
2. **technical_indicators_calculator**
- Description: Calculates RSI, MACD, Bollinger Bands for stocks
- Code: `def calculate_indicators(df): ...`
3. **portfolio_performance_analyzer**
- Description: Analyzes portfolio returns, risk metrics, and diversification
- Code: `def analyze_portfolio(holdings): ...`
#### Search Test
Query: "stock"
```
✅ Found 3 matching skills
- technical_indicators_calculator
- yfinance_stock_data_fetcher
- portfolio_performance_analyzer
```
**Status**: ✅ **VERIFIED** - Skill storage and semantic search working
---
## 4. Causal Memory
### What It Does
Tracks cause-effect relationships discovered during agent creation. Calculates uplift (improvement percentage) and confidence scores to provide mathematical proofs for decisions.
### Verification Results
#### Causal Edges Stored: 4
1. **use_financial_template → agent_creation_speed**
- Uplift: **40%** (agents created 40% faster)
- Confidence: **95%**
- Sample Size: 3
- Meaning: Using financial template makes creation significantly faster
2. **use_yfinance_api → user_satisfaction**
- Uplift: **25%** (25% higher user satisfaction)
- Confidence: **90%**
- Sample Size: 3
- Meaning: yfinance API choice improves user satisfaction
3. **use_caching → performance**
- Uplift: **60%** (60% performance improvement)
- Confidence: **92%**
- Sample Size: 3
- Meaning: Implementing caching dramatically improves performance
4. **add_technical_indicators → agent_quality**
- Uplift: **30%** (30% quality improvement)
- Confidence: **85%**
- Sample Size: 2
- Meaning: Adding technical indicators significantly improves agent quality
#### Query Tests
All 4 causal edges successfully retrieved with correct uplift and confidence values.
**Status**: ✅ **VERIFIED** - Causal relationships tracked with mathematical proofs
---
## 5. Enhancement Capabilities
### What It Does
Combines all three memory systems to enhance new agent creation with learned intelligence. Provides recommendations based on historical success patterns.
### How It Works
When a new agent creation request arrives:
1. **Search Skill Library** → Find relevant successful patterns
2. **Retrieve Episodes** → Get similar past experiences
3. **Query Causal Effects** → Identify what causes improvements
4. **Generate Recommendations** → Provide data-driven suggestions
### Enhancement Example
**User Request**: "Create a comprehensive financial analysis agent with portfolio tracking"
**AgentDB Enhancement**:
- Skills found: 3 relevant skills
- Episodes retrieved: 3 similar successful creations
- Causal insights: 4 proven improvement factors
- Recommendations:
- "Found 3 relevant skills from AgentDB"
- "Found 3 successful similar attempts"
- "Causal insight: use_caching improves performance by 60%"
- "Causal insight: use_financial_template improves speed by 40%"
**Status**: ✅ **VERIFIED** - Multi-system integration working
---
## 6. Progressive Learning Timeline
### Current State (After 3 Test Creations)
| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Episodes Stored | 3 |
| Skills Consolidated | 3 |
| Causal Edges Mapped | 4 |
| Average Success Rate | 100% |
| Average Reward | 92.3 |
| Average Speed Improvement | 40% |
### Projected Growth
**After 10 Creations:**
- 40% faster creation time
- Better API selections based on success history
- Proven architectural patterns
- User sees: "⚡ Optimized based on 10 successful similar agents"
**After 30 Days:**
- Personalized recommendations based on user patterns
- Predictive insights about needed features
- Custom optimizations for workflow
- User sees: "🌟 I notice you prefer comprehensive analysis - shall I include portfolio optimization?"
**After 100+ Creations:**
- Industry best practices automatically incorporated
- Domain-specific expertise built up
- Collective intelligence from all successful patterns
- User sees: "🚀 Enhanced with insights from 100+ successful agents"
---
## 7. Invisible Intelligence Features
### What Makes It "Invisible"
✅ **Zero Configuration Required**
- AgentDB auto-initializes on first use
- No setup steps for users
- Graceful fallback if unavailable
✅ **Automatic Learning**
- Every creation stored automatically
- Patterns extracted in background
- No user intervention needed
✅ **Subtle Feedback**
- Learning progress shown naturally
- Confidence scores included in messages
- Recommendations feel like smart suggestions
✅ **Progressive Enhancement**
- Works perfectly from day 1
- Gets better over time
- User experience improves automatically
### User Experience
**What Users Type:**
```
"Create financial analysis agent"
```
**What Happens Behind the Scenes:**
1. AgentDB searches for similar episodes (0.5s)
2. Retrieves relevant skills (0.3s)
3. Queries causal effects (0.4s)
4. Generates enhanced recommendations (0.2s)
5. Applies learned optimizations (throughout creation)
6. Stores new episode for future learning (0.3s)
**What Users See:**
```
✅ Creating financial analysis agent...
⚡ Optimized based on similar successful agents
🧠 Using proven yfinance API (90% confidence)
📊 Adding technical indicators (30% quality boost)
```
---
## 8. Mathematical Validation System
### Validation Components
1. **Template Selection Validation**
- Confidence threshold: 70%
- Uses historical success rates
- Generates Merkle proofs
2. **API Selection Validation**
- Confidence threshold: 60%
- Compares multiple options
- Provides mathematical justification
3. **Architecture Validation**
- Confidence threshold: 75%
- Checks best practices compliance
- Validates structural decisions
### Example Validation
**Template Selection for Financial Agent:**
```
Base confidence: 70%
Historical success rate: 85% (from 3 past uses)
Domain matching: +10% boost
Final confidence: 95%
✅ VALIDATED - Mathematical proof: leaf:a7f3e9d2c8b4...
```
**Status**: ✅ **VERIFIED** - All decisions mathematically validated
---
## 9. Verification Commands Reference
### Check Database Growth
```bash
agentdb db stats
```
### Search for Episodes
```bash
agentdb reflexion retrieve "query text" 5 0.6
```
### Find Skills
```bash
agentdb skill search "query text" 5
```
### Query Causal Relationships
```bash
agentdb causal query "cause" "effect" 0.7 0.1 10
```
### Consolidate Skills
```bash
agentdb skill consolidate 3 0.7 7
```
---
## 10. Integration Architecture
```
User Request
↓
Agent-Skill-Creator (SKILL.md)
↓
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ AgentDB Bridge (agentdb_bridge.py) │
│ ├─ Check availability │
│ ├─ Auto-configure │
│ └─ Route to CLI │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
↓
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Real AgentDB Integration (agentdb_real_integration.py) │
│ ├─ Episode storage/retrieval │
│ ├─ Skill creation/search │
│ └─ Causal edge tracking │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
↓
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ AgentDB CLI (TypeScript/Node.js) │
│ ├─ SQLite database │
│ ├─ Vector embeddings │
│ └─ Causal inference │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
↓
Learning & Enhancement
```
---
## 11. Success Metrics
| Capability | Target | Actual | Status |
|-----------|--------|--------|--------|
| Episode Storage | 100% | 100% (3/3) | ✅ |
| Episode Retrieval | Semantic | Similarity: 0.536 | ✅ |
| Skill Creation | 100% | 100% (3/3) | ✅ |
| Skill Search | Semantic | 3/3 found | ✅ |
| Causal Edges | 100% | 100% (4/4) | ✅ |
| Causal Query | Working | All queryable | ✅ |
| Enhancement | Multi-system | All integrated | ✅ |
| Validation | 70%+ confidence | 85-95% range | ✅ |
**Overall Success Rate**: ✅ **100%** - All capabilities verified
---
## 12. Key Findings
### What Works Perfectly
1. ✅ **Episode Storage & Retrieval**
- Semantic similarity search working
- Critique summaries preserved
- Reward-based filtering functional
2. ✅ **Skill Library**
- Skills created and stored
- Semantic search operational
- Ready for consolidation
3. ✅ **Causal Memory**
- Relationships tracked accurately
- Uplift calculations correct
- Confidence scores maintained
4. ✅ **Integration**
- All systems communicate properly
- Enhancement pipeline functional
- Graceful fallback working
### Areas for Enhancement
1. **Display Labels**: Causal edge display shows "undefined" for cause/effect names
- Data is stored correctly (uplift/confidence verified)
- Minor CLI display issue
- Does not affect functionality
2. **Skill Statistics**: New skills show 0 uses until actually used
- Expected behavior
- Will populate with real agent usage
---
## 13. Recommendations
### For Users
1. **Create Multiple Agents**: The more you create, the smarter the system gets
2. **Use Similar Domains**: Build up domain expertise faster
3. **Monitor Progress**: Run `agentdb db stats` periodically
4. **Trust the System**: Enhanced recommendations are data-driven
### For Developers
1. **Monitor Episode Quality**: Ensure critiques are meaningful
2. **Track Confidence Scores**: Watch for improvement over time
3. **Review Causal Insights**: Validate uplift claims with actual data
4. **Extend Skills Library**: Add more consolidation patterns
---
## 14. Conclusion
### Summary
The agent-skill-creator v2.1 with AgentDB integration represents a **fully functional invisible intelligence system** that:
- ✅ Learns from every agent creation
- ✅ Stores experiences in three complementary memory systems
- ✅ Provides mathematical validation for all decisions
- ✅ Enhances future creations automatically
- ✅ Operates transparently without user configuration
- ✅ Improves progressively over time
### Verification Status
**🎉 ALL LEARNING CAPABILITIES VERIFIED AND OPERATIONAL**
The system is ready for production use and will continue to improve with each agent creation.
---
## 15. Next Steps
### Immediate (Now)
- ✅ Continue creating agents to populate database
- ✅ Monitor learning progression
- ✅ Verify improvements over time
### Short-term (Week 1)
- Create 10+ agents to see speed improvements
- Track confidence score trends
- Document personalization features
### Long-term (Month 1+)
- Build domain-specific expertise libraries
- Share learned patterns across users
- Contribute successful patterns back to community
---
## Appendix A: Test Script
The verification was performed using `test_agentdb_learning.py`, which:
- Simulated 3 financial agent creations
- Created 3 skills from successful patterns
- Added 4 causal relationships
- Verified all storage and retrieval mechanisms
**Location**: `/Users/francy/agent-skill-creator/test_agentdb_learning.py`
---
## Appendix B: Database Evidence
### Before Testing
```
causal_edges: 0 records
episodes: 0 records
```
### After Testing
```
causal_edges: 4 records
episodes: 3 records
skills: 3 records (queryable)
```
**Growth**: 100% success in populating all memory systems
---
**Report Generated**: October 23, 2025
**Verification Status**: ✅ COMPLETE
**System Status**: 🚀 OPERATIONAL
**Learning Status**: 🧠 ACTIVE

97
docs/NAMING_CONVENTIONS.md
View file

@ -1,97 +0,0 @@
# Naming Conventions
## Overview
All skills created by Agent-Skill-Creator follow standard kebab-case naming per the Agent Skills Open Standard. The `name` field in SKILL.md frontmatter must match the parent directory name exactly.
## Rules
### Required Format
```
{descriptive-name}/
```
### Character Rules
- **Allowed**: Lowercase letters (`a-z`), numbers (`0-9`), hyphens (`-`)
- **Length**: 1-64 characters
- Must **not** start or end with a hyphen
- Must **not** contain consecutive hyphens (`--`)
- Must match the parent directory name exactly
### Examples
**Simple Skills:**
- `pdf-text-extractor/`
- `csv-data-cleaner/`
- `weekly-report-generator/`
- `stock-analyzer/`
**Complex Suites:**
- `financial-analysis-suite/`
- `e-commerce-automation/`
- `research-workflow/`
**Component Skills (within suites):**
- `data-acquisition/`
- `technical-analysis/`
- `reporting-generator/`
## Name Generation
When creating a skill name from user input:
1. **Extract key concepts** from the user's description
2. **Build descriptive name** using `{action}-{object}` or `{domain}-{purpose}` pattern
3. **Sanitize**: lowercase, replace spaces/underscores with hyphens, strip special characters
4. **Validate**: check length (1-64), no leading/trailing hyphens, no consecutive hyphens
```python
import re
def generate_skill_name(user_input: str) -> str:
"""Generate a valid skill name from user input."""
name = user_input.lower()
name = re.sub(r'[\s_]+', '-', name)
name = re.sub(r'[^a-z0-9-]', '', name)
name = re.sub(r'-+', '-', name)
name = name.strip('-')
return name[:64]
```
## Validation
```python
import re
def validate_skill_name(name: str) -> tuple[bool, str]:
"""Validate a skill name against the Agent Skills Open Standard."""
if not name:
return False, "Name cannot be empty"
if len(name) > 64:
return False, f"Name too long: {len(name)} chars (max 64)"
if not re.match(r'^[a-z0-9]([a-z0-9-]*[a-z0-9])?$', name):
return False, "Must be lowercase alphanumeric with hyphens, no leading/trailing hyphens"
if '--' in name:
return False, "Must not contain consecutive hyphens"
return True, "Valid"
```
## Migration from v3.x
Skills created with v3.x used a `-cskill` suffix (e.g., `stock-analyzer-cskill/`). This suffix has been removed in v4.0 to comply with the Agent Skills Open Standard.
To migrate:
```bash
# Rename directory
mv stock-analyzer-cskill stock-analyzer
# Update SKILL.md frontmatter name field
# name: stock-analyzer
# Update marketplace.json name field (if present)
```
See `MIGRATION.md` for full migration instructions.

513
docs/PIPELINE_ARCHITECTURE.md
View file

@ -1,513 +0,0 @@
# Pipeline Architecture: Skills como Expertise Reutilizível em Fluxos Completos
## 🎯 **Visão Fundamental**
As Claude Skills representam **expertise reutilizível** capturada de artigos, procedimentos operacionais e conhecimentos especializados. Quando essa expertise toma a forma de fluxos sequenciais completos (pipelines), um plugin pode representar uma transformação **end-to-end** desde a entrada de dados brutos até a entrega final de valor.
## 🧠 **Natureza das Skills como Expertise Capturada**
### **O Que É Uma Skill Claude?**
Uma skill Claude é **conhecimento especializado** que foi:
- **Destilado** de fontes especializadas (artigos, manuais, procedimentos)
- **Codificado** em forma executável e replicável
- **Validado** através de práticas de engenhancement
- **Empacotado** em um sistema reutilizável
### **Transformação: De Conhecimento para Capacidade**
```
Fonte de Conhecimento Skill Claude Capacidade
├─────────────────────────┬───────────────────────────────┬───────────────────────────────┬─────────────────┐
│ Artigo sobre análise │ → │ financial-analysis │ → │ Analisa dados │
│ financeira │ │ (expertise capturada) │ │ de mercado │
│ │ │ │ │ automatica │
│ Manual de procedimento│ → │ business-process │ → │ Executa │
│ empresarial │ │ (expertise capturada) │ │ workflows │
│ │ │ │ │ padronizados │
│ Tutorial técnico │ → │ tutorial-system │ → │ Guia usuários │
│ passo a passo │ │ (expertise capturada) │ │ interativos │
└─────────────────────────┴───────────────────────────────┴─────────────────────────────┴─────────────────┘
```
### **Propriedades da Expertise Capturada**
✅ **Especialização**: Conhecimento profundo de domínio específico
✅ **Reutilização**: Aplicável a múltiplos contextos e cenários
✅ **Consistência**: Método padronizado e replicável
✅ **Evolução**: Pode ser refinado com base no uso
✅ **Escalabilidade**: Funciona com diferentes volumes e complexidades
✅ **Preservação**: Conhecimento especializado é preservado e compartilhado
## 🏗️ **Arquitetura de Pipeline: O Conceito de Fluxo Completo**
### **O Que É uma Pipeline em Contexto de Skills**
Uma **Pipeline Skill** é uma implementação que representa um **fluxo sequencial completo** onde o output de uma etapa se torna o input da próxima, transformando dados brutos através de múltiplos estágios até gerar um resultado final valioso.
### **Características de Pipeline Skills**
#### **1. Fluxo End-to-End**
```
Entrada Bruta → [Etapa 1] → [Etapa 2] → [Etapa 3] → Saída Final
```
#### **2. Orquestração Automática**
- Cada etapa é disparada automaticamente
- Dependências entre etapas são gerenciadas
- Erros em uma etapa afetam o fluxo downstream
#### **3. Transformação de Valor**
- Cada etapa adiciona valor aos dados
- O resultado final é maior que a soma das partes
- Conhecimento especializado é aplicado em cada estágio
#### **4. Componentes Conectados**
- Interface bem definida entre etapas
- Formatos de dados padronizados
- Validação em cada ponto de transição
### **Pipeline vs Componentes Separados**
| Aspecto | Pipeline Completa | Componentes Separados |
|---------|-------------------|--------------------|
| **Natureza** | Fluxo sequencial único | Múltiplos fluxos independentes |
| **Orquestração** | Automática e linear | Coordenação manual |
| **Dados** | Flui através das etapas | Isolados em cada componente |
| **Valor** | Cumulativo e integrado | Aditivo e separado |
| **Caso de Uso** | Processo único completo | Múltiplos processos variados |
## 📊 **Exemplos de Arquiteturas de Pipeline**
### **Pipeline Simples (2-3 Etapas)**
#### **Data Processing Pipeline**
```
data-processing-pipeline/
├── data-ingestion/ ← Coleta de dados brutos
│ └── output: dados_crudos.json
├── data-transformation/ ← Limpeza e estruturação
│ ├── input: dados_crudos.json
│ └── output: dados_limpos.json
└── data-analysis/ ← Análise e insights
├── input: dados_limpos.json
└── output: insights.json
```
**Fluxo de Dados:** `brutos → limpos → analisados → insights`
### **Pipelines Complexas (4+ Etapas)**
#### **Research Pipeline Acadêmica**
```
research-workflow/
├── problem-definition/ ← Definição do problema
│ └── output: research_scope.json
├── literature-search/ ← Busca de literatura
│ ├── input: research_scope.json
│ └── output: articles_found.json
├── data-collection/ ← Coleta de dados
│ ├── input: articles_found.json
│ └── output: experimental_data.json
├── analysis-engine/ ← Análise estatística
│ ├── input: experimental_data.json
│ └── output: statistical_results.json
├── visualization/ ← Visualização dos resultados
│ ├── input: statistical_results.json
│ └── output: charts.json
└── report-generation/ ← Geração de relatório
├── input: charts.json
└── output: research_report.pdf
```
**Flujo de Conhecimento:** `problema → literatura → dados → análise → visualização → relatório`
#### **Business Intelligence Pipeline**
```
business-intelligence/
├── data-sources/ ← Conexão com fontes
│ └── output: raw_data.json
├── etl-process/ ← Transformação ETL
│ ├── input: raw_data.json
│ └── output: processed_data.json
├── analytics-engine/ ← Análise de negócios
│ ├── input: processed_data.json
│ └── output: kpi_metrics.json
├── dashboard/ ← Criação de dashboards
│ ├── input: kpi_metrics.json
│ └── output: dashboard.json
└── alert-system/ Sistema de alertas
├── input: kpi_metrics.json
└── output: alerts.json
```
**Flujo de Decisão:** `dados → transformação → análise → visualização → alertas`
## 🔧 **Design Patterns para Pipeline Skills**
### **1. Standard Pipeline Pattern**
```python
class StandardPipelineSkill:
def __init__(self):
self.stages = [
DataIngestionStage(),
ProcessingStage(),
AnalysisStage(),
OutputStage()
]
def execute(self, input_data):
current_data = input_data
for stage in self.stages:
current_data = stage.process(current_data)
# Validar saída antes de passar para próxima etapa
current_data = stage.validate(current_data)
return current_data
```
### **2. Orchestrator Pattern**
```python
class PipelineOrchestrator:
def __init__(self):
self.pipelines = {
'ingestion': DataIngestionPipeline(),
'processing': ProcessingPipeline(),
'analysis': AnalysisPipeline(),
'reporting': ReportingPipeline()
}
def execute_complete_pipeline(self, input_data):
# Coordenar todas as pipelines em sequência
data = self.pipelines['ingestion'].execute(input_data)
data = self.pipelines['processing'].execute(data)
data = self.pipelines['analysis'].execute(data)
results = self.pipelines['reporting'].execute(data)
return results
```
### **3. Pipeline Manager Pattern**
```python
class PipelineManager:
def __init__(self):
self.pipeline_registry = {}
self.execution_history = []
def register_pipeline(self, name, pipeline_class):
self.pipeline_registry[name] = pipeline_class
def execute_pipeline(self, name, config):
if name not in self.pipeline_registry:
raise ValueError(f"Pipeline {name} not found")
pipeline = self.pipeline_registry[name](config)
result = pipeline.execute()
# Registrar execução para rastreabilidade
self.execution_history.append({
'name': name,
'timestamp': datetime.now(),
'config': config,
'result': result
})
return result
```
## 📋 **Processo de Criação de Pipeline Skills**
### **Fase 1: Identificação do Fluxo Natural**
Quando analisando um artigo, o Agent-Skill-Creator procura por:
- **Sequências Lógicas**: "Primeiro faça X, depois Y, então Z"
- **Transformações Progressivas**: "Converta A para B, depois analise B"
- **Etapas Conectadas**: "Extraia dados, processe, gere relatório"
- **Fluxos End-to-End**: "Da fonte à entrega final"
### **Fase 2: Detecção de Pipeline**
```python
def detect_pipeline_structure(article_content):
"""
Identifica se o artigo descreve uma pipeline completa
"""
# Padrões que indicam pipeline
pipeline_indicators = [
# Indicadores de sequência
r"(primeiro|depois|em seguida)",
r"(passo\s*1|etapa\s*1)",
r"(fase\s*[0-9]+)",
# Indicadores de transformação
r"(transforme|converta|processe)",
r"(gere|produza|cria)",
# Indicadores de fluxo
r"(fluxo completo|pipeline|workflow.*completo)",
r"(do início ao fim|end-to-end)",
r"(fonte.*destino)"
]
# Analisar padrões no conteúdo
pipeline_score = calculate_pipeline_confidence(article_content, pipeline_indicators)
if pipeline_score > 0.7:
return {
'is_pipeline': True,
'confidence': pipeline_score,
'complexity': estimate_pipeline_complexity(article_content)
}
else:
return {
'is_pipeline': False,
'confidence': pipeline_score,
'reason': 'Content suggests separate components rather than pipeline'
}
```
### **Fase 3: Arquitetura Pipeline vs Componentes**
```python
def decide_architecture_with_pipeline(article_content, pipeline_detection):
"""
Decide entre pipeline única vs componentes separados
"""
if pipeline_detection['is_pipeline'] and pipeline_detection['confidence'] > 0.8:
# Artigo descreve claramente uma pipeline
return {
'architecture': 'pipeline',
'reason': 'High-confidence pipeline pattern detected',
'stages': identify_pipeline_stages(article_content)
}
else:
# Artigo descreve componentes separados ou é ambíguo
return {
'architecture': 'components',
'reason': 'Separate components or ambiguous structure',
'components': identify_independent_workflows(article_content)
}
```
### **Fase 4: Geração de Pipeline com Kebab-Case Naming**
```python
def create_pipeline_skill(analysis_result):
"""
Cria uma pipeline skill com convenção standard kebab-case
"""
# Nome base para pipeline
base_name = generate_pipeline_name(analysis_result['stages'])
skill_name = f"{base_name}-pipeline"
# Estrutura para pipeline
directory_structure = create_pipeline_directory_structure(skill_name, analysis_result['stages'])
# SKILL.md com foco em pipeline
skill_content = create_pipeline_skill_md(skill_name, analysis_result)
return {
'skill_name': skill_name,
'architecture': 'pipeline',
'directory_structure': directory_structure,
'skill_content': skill_content
}
```
## 🎯 **Exemplos Reais de Pipeline Skills**
### **1. E-commerce Analytics Pipeline**
```
ecommerce-analytics-pipeline/
├── sales-data-ingestion/
│ └── Coleta dados de vendas de múltiplas fontes
├── data-enrichment/
│ └── Enriquece com dados de clientes
├── customer-analytics/
│ └── Análise de comportamento
├── reporting-dashboard/
│ └── Dashboard em tempo real
└── alert-engine/
└── Alertas de métricas importantes
Fluxo: `Vendas → Enriquecimento → Análise → Dashboard → Alertas`
```
### **2. Content Creation Pipeline**
```
content-creation-pipeline/
├── content-research/
│ └── Pesquisa de tendências e tópicos
├── content-generation/
│ └── Geração de conteúdo baseado em IA
├── content-optimization/
│ └── SEO e otimização
├── publishing-platform/
│ └── Publicação em múltiplos canais
└── analytics-tracking/
└── Monitoramento de performance
Fluxo: `Pesquisa → Geração → Otimização → Publicação → Análise`
```
### **3. Risk Management Pipeline**
```
risk-management/
├── risk-identification/
│ └── Identificação de riscos potenciais
├── data-collection/
│ └── Coleta de dados de risco
├── risk-assessment/
│ └── Análise e classificação
├── mitigation-strategies/
│ └── Estratégias de mitigação
└── monitoring-dashboard/
└── Dashboard de risco em tempo real
Fluxo: `Identificação → Coleta → Avaliação → Mitigação → Monitoramento`
```
### **4. HR Automation Pipeline**
```
hr-automation/
├── candidate-sourcing/
│ └── Fontes de candidatos
├── resume-screening/
│ └── Triagem inicial de currículos
├── interview-scheduling/
│ └️ Agendamento de entrevistas
├── interview-evaluation/
│ └️ Avaliação de candidatos
├── offer-management/
│ └️ Gestão de ofertas
└── onboarding-automation/
└️ Processo de integração
Fluxo: `Fontes → Triagem → Entrevistas → Avaliação → Contratação → Onboarding`
```
## 🔍 **Como Identificar Artigos Adequados para Pipeline Skills**
### **Padrões Linguísticos que Indicam Pipeline:**
- **Sequência**: "Primeiro... então... finalmente..."
- **Transformação**: "Converta... em..."
- **Processo**: "O processo envolve..."
- **Fluxo**: "O fluxo de dados é..."
- **Pipeline**: "Nossa pipeline inclui..."
### **Estruturas Organizacionais:**
- **Metodologia**: "Sua metodologia consiste em..."
- **Workflow**: "O workflow funciona assim..."
- **Processo**: "Nosso processo de..."
- **Etapas**: "As etapas são..."
### **Indicadores de Transformação:**
- **De/Para**: "De dados brutos para insights"
- **Entrada/Saída**: "Entrada: dados brutos, Saída: relatório"
- **Antes/Depois**: "Antes: dados crus, Depois: informação processada"
- **Transformação**: "Transformação de dados em"
## 📊 **Benefícios de Pipeline Skills**
### **Para o Usuário:**
- ✅ **Solução Completa**: Problema resolvido de ponta a ponta
- ✅ **Fluxo Natural**: Segue lógica do negócio/processo
- ✅ **Redução Complexidade**: Um comando para processo complexo
- ✅ **Integração Natural**: Etapas conectadas sem esforço manual
### **Para a Organização:**
- ✅ **Padronização**: Processos consistentes executados
- ✅ **Eficiência**: Redução de trabalho manual
- ✅ **Qualidade**: Expertise aplicada consistentemente
- ✌ **Escalabilidade**: Processos funcionam em diferentes volumes
### **Para a Expertise:**
- ✅ **Preservação**: Conhecimento especializado capturado
- ✅ **Difusão**: Expertise compartilhada amplamente
- ✅ **Evolução**: Melhoria contínua com uso
- ✅ **Padronização**: Métodos consistentes replicáveis
## 🔄 **Comparação: Pipeline vs Componentes**
### **Quando Usar Pipeline Skills:**
- **Processos Únicos**: Um fluxo específico a ser automatizado
- **Transformação Completa**: Dados brutos → insights finais
- **Workflow Integrado**: Etapas naturalmente conectadas
- **Valor Sequencial**: Cada etapa adiciona à anterior
### **Quando Usar Component Skills:**
- **Múltiplos Workflows**: Diferentes processos independentes
- **Modularidade**: Flexibilidade para usar componentes conforme necessário
- **Especialização**: Expertise profunda em cada componente
- **Manutenção Simples**: Alterações isoladas em componentes específicos
### **Abordagens Híbridas:**
```python
# Pipeline com componentes opcionais
data-pipeline-with-options/
├── core-pipeline/ ← Pipeline principal
│ ├── data-ingestion/
│ └── data-transformation/
│ └── data-analysis/
├── optional-ml/ ← Componente opcional
│ └── Machine learning avançado
├── optional-reporting/ ← Componente opcional
│ └── Relatórios executivos
# Múltiplas pipelines interconectadas
orchestrated-pipeline/
├── data-pipeline/
├── analytics-pipeline/
├── reporting-pipeline/
└── alerting-pipeline/
```
## 🎯 **Casos de Uso Ideais para Pipeline Skills**
### **1. Processos de Negócio End-to-End**
- Processamento de pedidos (order-to-cash)
- Gestão de relacionamento com clientes (lead-to-cash)
- Onboarding de clientes (prospect-to-customer)
- Ciclo de vida de produtos
### **2. Pesquisa e Desenvolvimento**
- Pesquisa acadêmica completa
- Desenvolvimento de produtos
- Análise de dados científicos
- Validação experimental
### **3. Operações e Produção**
- Monitoramento de qualidade
- Processos de controle de qualidade
- Gestão de riscos operacionais
- Relatórios regulatórios
### **4. Criação de Conteúdo**
- Criação de conteúdo de marketing
- Produção de materiais educacionais
- Geração de relatórios técnicos
- Publicação de conteúdo em múltiplos canais
## 🚀 **Futuro das Pipeline Skills**
### **Inteligência de Pipeline**
- Detecção automática de gargalos
- Otimização dinâmica de performance
- Autocorreção de erros em cascata
- Predição de necessidades de recursos
### **Pipelines Adaptativas**
- Configuração dinâmica de etapas
- Branching condicional baseado em dados
- Escalabilidade horizontal e vertical
- Personalização baseada em contexto
### **Ecosistema de Pipelines**
- Marketplace de pipelines reutilizáveis
- Compartilhamento de componentes entre pipelines
- Integração com outras skills e ferramentas
- Comunicação entre pipelines independentes
## 📚 **Conclusão**
**Skills Claude são a materialização de expertise reutilizível** capturada de fontes especializadas. Quando essa expertise assume a forma de fluxos sequenciais (pipelines), elas representam transformações **end-to-end** que entregam valor completo, desde dados brutos até insights acionáveis.
**The standard kebab-case naming convention ensures that captured expertise is organized, professional, and easily identifiable, enabling users and organizations to benefit from end-to-end automation of complex processes, transforming specialized knowledge into scalable practical capability.**

231
docs/QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md
View file

@ -1,231 +0,0 @@
# Quick Verification Guide: AgentDB Learning Capabilities
## 📊 Current Database State
```bash
agentdb db stats
```
**Current Status:**
- ✅ **3 episodes** stored (agent creation experiences)
- ✅ **4 causal edges** mapped (cause-effect relationships)
- ✅ **3 skills** created (reusable patterns)
---
## 🔍 How to Verify Learning
### 1. Check Reflexion Memory (Episodes)
**View similar past experiences:**
```bash
agentdb reflexion retrieve "financial analysis" 5 0.6
```
**What you'll see:**
- Past agent creations with similarity scores
- Success rates and rewards
- Critiques and lessons learned
### 2. Search Skill Library
**Find relevant skills:**
```bash
agentdb skill search "stock" 5
```
**What you'll see:**
- Reusable code patterns
- Success rates and usage statistics
- Descriptions of what each skill does
### 3. Query Causal Relationships
**What causes improvements:**
```bash
agentdb causal query "use_financial_template" "" 0.5 0.1 10
```
**What you'll see:**
- Uplift percentages (% improvement)
- Confidence scores (how certain)
- Sample sizes (data points)
---
## 📈 Evidence of Learning
### ✅ Verified Capabilities
1. **Reflexion Memory**: 3 episodes with semantic search (similarity: 0.536)
2. **Skill Library**: 3 skills searchable by semantic meaning
3. **Causal Memory**: 4 relationships with mathematical proofs:
- Financial template → 40% faster creation (95% confidence)
- YFinance API → 25% higher satisfaction (90% confidence)
- Caching → 60% better performance (92% confidence)
- Technical indicators → 30% quality boost (85% confidence)
### 📊 Growth Metrics
| Metric | Before | After | Growth |
|--------|--------|-------|--------|
| Episodes | 0 | 3 | ✅ 300% |
| Causal Edges | 0 | 4 | ✅ 400% |
| Skills | 0 | 3 | ✅ 300% |
---
## 🎯 How Learning Helps You
### Episode Memory
**Benefit**: Learns from past successes and failures
- Similar requests get better recommendations
- Proven approaches prioritized
- Mistakes not repeated
### Skill Library
**Benefit**: Reuses successful code patterns
- Faster agent creation
- Higher quality implementations
- Consistent best practices
### Causal Memory
**Benefit**: Mathematical proof of what works
- Data-driven decisions
- Confidence scores for recommendations
- Measurable improvement tracking
---
## 🚀 Progressive Improvement Timeline
### Week 1 (After ~10 uses)
- ⚡ 40% faster creation
- Better API selections
- You see: "Optimized based on 10 successful similar agents"
### Month 1 (After ~30+ uses)
- 🌟 Personalized suggestions
- Predictive insights
- You see: "I notice you prefer comprehensive analysis - shall I include portfolio optimization?"
### Year 1 (After 100+ uses)
- 🎯 Industry best practices incorporated
- Domain expertise built up
- You see: "Enhanced with insights from 500+ successful agents"
---
## 💡 Quick Commands Cheat Sheet
### Database Operations
```bash
# View all statistics
agentdb db stats
# Export database
agentdb db export > backup.json
# Import database
agentdb db import < backup.json
```
### Episode Operations
```bash
# Retrieve similar episodes
agentdb reflexion retrieve "query" 5 0.6
# Get critique summary
agentdb reflexion critique-summary "query" false
# Store episode (done automatically by agent-creator)
agentdb reflexion store SESSION_ID "task" 95 true "critique"
```
### Skill Operations
```bash
# Search skills
agentdb skill search "query" 5
# Consolidate episodes into skills
agentdb skill consolidate 3 0.7 7
# Create skill (done automatically by agent-creator)
agentdb skill create "name" "description" "code"
```
### Causal Operations
```bash
# Query by cause
agentdb causal query "use_template" "" 0.7 0.1 10
# Query by effect
agentdb causal query "" "quality" 0.7 0.1 10
# Add edge (done automatically by agent-creator)
agentdb causal add-edge "cause" "effect" 0.4 0.95 10
```
---
## 🧪 Test the Learning Yourself
### Option 1: Run the Test Script
```bash
python3 test_agentdb_learning.py
```
This populates the database with sample data and verifies all capabilities.
### Option 2: Create Actual Agents
1. Create first agent:
```
"Create financial analysis agent for stock market data"
```
2. Check database growth:
```bash
agentdb db stats
```
3. Create second similar agent:
```
"Create portfolio tracking agent with technical indicators"
```
4. Query for learned improvements:
```bash
agentdb reflexion retrieve "financial" 5 0.6
```
5. See the recommendations improve!
---
## 📚 Full Documentation
For complete details, see:
- **LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md** - Comprehensive verification report
- **README.md** - Full agent-creator documentation
- **integrations/agentdb_bridge.py** - Technical implementation
---
## ✅ Verification Checklist
- [x] AgentDB installed and available
- [x] Database initialized (agentdb.db exists)
- [x] Episodes stored (3 records)
- [x] Skills created (3 records)
- [x] Causal edges mapped (4 records)
- [x] Retrieval working (semantic search)
- [x] Enhancement pipeline functional
**Status**: 🎉 ALL LEARNING CAPABILITIES VERIFIED AND OPERATIONAL
---
**Created**: October 23, 2025
**Version**: agent-skill-creator v2.1
**AgentDB**: Active and Learning

198
docs/README.md
View file

@ -1,198 +0,0 @@
# Documentation Index
Complete documentation for Agent-Skill-Creator v2.1 with AgentDB learning capabilities.
---
## 🚀 Quick Start (New Users)
**Start with these in order:**
1. **[USER_BENEFITS_GUIDE.md](USER_BENEFITS_GUIDE.md)** ⭐ **BEST STARTING POINT**
- What AgentDB learning means for you
- Real examples of progressive improvement
- Time savings and value you get
- Zero-effort benefits explained
2. **[TRY_IT_YOURSELF.md](TRY_IT_YOURSELF.md)**
- 5-minute hands-on demo
- Step-by-step verification
- See learning capabilities in action
3. **[QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md](QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md)**
- Command reference and cheat sheet
- How to check learning is working
- Quick queries and examples
---
## 🔬 Learning & Verification
### **[LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md](LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md)**
Comprehensive 15-section verification report proving all learning capabilities work:
- Reflexion Memory verification (episodes)
- Skill Library verification
- Causal Memory verification (cause-effect relationships)
- Mathematical validation proofs
- Complete technical evidence
**Use when:** You want complete technical proof or deep understanding of how learning works.
---
## 🏗️ Architecture & Design
### **[CLAUDE_SKILLS_ARCHITECTURE.md](CLAUDE_SKILLS_ARCHITECTURE.md)**
Complete guide to Claude Skills architecture:
- Simple Skills vs Complex Skill Suites
- When to use each pattern
- Architecture decision process
- Component organization
- Best practices
**Use when:** Understanding skill structure or making architectural decisions.
### **[PIPELINE_ARCHITECTURE.md](PIPELINE_ARCHITECTURE.md)**
Detailed pipeline architecture documentation:
- 5-phase creation process
- Data flow and transformations
- Integration points
- Performance optimization
**Use when:** Understanding the creation pipeline or optimizing performance.
### **[INTERNAL_FLOW_ANALYSIS.md](INTERNAL_FLOW_ANALYSIS.md)**
Internal flow analysis and decision points:
- Phase-by-phase analysis
- Decision logic at each stage
- Error handling and recovery
- Quality assurance
**Use when:** Debugging issues or understanding internal mechanisms.
### **[DECISION_LOGIC.md](DECISION_LOGIC.md)**
Decision framework for agent creation:
- Template selection logic
- API selection criteria
- Architecture choice reasoning
- Quality metrics
**Use when:** Understanding how decisions are made or improving decision quality.
### **[NAMING_CONVENTIONS.md](NAMING_CONVENTIONS.md)**
Naming standards and conventions:
- Standard kebab-case naming convention
- Naming patterns for skills
- Directory structure conventions
- Best practices
**Use when:** Creating skills or maintaining consistency.
---
## 📋 Project Information
### **[CHANGELOG.md](CHANGELOG.md)**
Version history and updates:
- Release notes
- Feature additions
- Bug fixes
- Breaking changes
**Use when:** Checking what's new or tracking changes between versions.
---
## 📚 Documentation Map
### By Use Case
**I want to understand what learning does for me:**
→ [USER_BENEFITS_GUIDE.md](USER_BENEFITS_GUIDE.md)
**I want to verify learning is working:**
→ [TRY_IT_YOURSELF.md](TRY_IT_YOURSELF.md)
→ [QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md](QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md)
**I want technical proof:**
→ [LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md](LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md)
**I want to understand architecture:**
→ [CLAUDE_SKILLS_ARCHITECTURE.md](CLAUDE_SKILLS_ARCHITECTURE.md)
→ [PIPELINE_ARCHITECTURE.md](PIPELINE_ARCHITECTURE.md)
**I want to understand decisions:**
→ [DECISION_LOGIC.md](DECISION_LOGIC.md)
→ [INTERNAL_FLOW_ANALYSIS.md](INTERNAL_FLOW_ANALYSIS.md)
**I want naming guidelines:**
→ [NAMING_CONVENTIONS.md](NAMING_CONVENTIONS.md)
**I want to see what's changed:**
→ [CHANGELOG.md](CHANGELOG.md)
---
## 🎯 Recommended Reading Paths
### **For End Users**
1. USER_BENEFITS_GUIDE.md (understand value)
2. TRY_IT_YOURSELF.md (hands-on demo)
3. QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md (reference)
### **For Developers**
1. CLAUDE_SKILLS_ARCHITECTURE.md (architecture)
2. PIPELINE_ARCHITECTURE.md (implementation)
3. LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md (technical proof)
4. DECISION_LOGIC.md (decision framework)
### **For Contributors**
1. NAMING_CONVENTIONS.md (standards)
2. INTERNAL_FLOW_ANALYSIS.md (internals)
3. PIPELINE_ARCHITECTURE.md (architecture)
4. CHANGELOG.md (history)
---
## 🔗 Related Files
**In root directory:**
- `SKILL.md` - Main skill definition (agent-creator implementation)
- `README.md` - Project overview and quick start
- `test_agentdb_learning.py` - Automated learning verification script
**In integrations/ directory:**
- `agentdb_bridge.py` - AgentDB integration layer
- `agentdb_real_integration.py` - Real AgentDB CLI bridge
- `learning_feedback.py` - Learning feedback system
- `validation_system.py` - Mathematical validation
---
## 📊 Documentation Statistics
| Category | Files | Total Size |
|----------|-------|------------|
| User Guides | 3 | ~28 KB |
| Learning & Verification | 1 | ~15 KB |
| Architecture & Design | 5 | ~50 KB |
| Project Information | 1 | ~5 KB |
| **Total** | **10** | **~98 KB** |
---
## 💡 Quick Tips
**First time here?** Start with [USER_BENEFITS_GUIDE.md](USER_BENEFITS_GUIDE.md)
**Want to verify?** Run: `python3 ../test_agentdb_learning.py`
**Need quick reference?** Check [QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md](QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md)
**Technical details?** Read [LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md](LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md)
---
**Last Updated:** October 23, 2025
**Version:** 2.1
**Status:** ✅ All learning capabilities verified and operational

264
docs/TRY_IT_YOURSELF.md
View file

@ -1,264 +0,0 @@
# Try It Yourself: AgentDB Learning in Action
## 5-Minute Learning Demo
Follow these steps to see AgentDB learning capabilities in action.
---
## Step 1: Check Starting Point (30 seconds)
```bash
agentdb db stats
```
**Expected Output:**
```
📊 Database Statistics
════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
causal_edges: 4 records ← Already populated from test
episodes: 3 records ← Already populated from test
```
---
## Step 2: Query What Was Learned (1 minute)
### See Past Experiences
```bash
agentdb reflexion retrieve "financial" 5 0.6
```
**You'll See:**
- 3 past agent creation episodes
- Similarity scores (0.536, 0.419, 0.361)
- Success rates and rewards
- Learned critiques
### Find Reusable Skills
```bash
agentdb skill search "stock" 5
```
**You'll See:**
- 3 skills ready to reuse
- Descriptions of what each does
- Success statistics
### Discover What Works
```bash
agentdb causal query "use_financial_template" "" 0.5 0.1 10
```
**You'll See:**
- 40% speed improvement from using templates
- 95% confidence in this relationship
- Mathematical proof of effectiveness
---
## Step 3: Test Different Queries (2 minutes)
Try these queries to explore the learning:
```bash
# What improves performance?
agentdb causal query "use_caching" "" 0.5 0.1 10
# Result: 60% performance boost!
# What increases satisfaction?
agentdb causal query "use_yfinance_api" "" 0.5 0.1 10
# Result: 25% higher user satisfaction
# Find portfolio-related patterns
agentdb reflexion retrieve "portfolio" 5 0.6
# Result: Similar portfolio agent creation
# Search for analysis skills
agentdb skill search "analysis" 5
# Result: Analysis-related reusable skills
```
---
## Step 4: Understand Progressive Learning (1 minute)
### Current State
You're seeing the system after just 3 agent creations:
- ✅ 3 episodes stored
- ✅ 3 skills identified
- ✅ 4 causal relationships mapped
### After 10 Agents
The system will show:
- 40% faster creation time
- Better API recommendations
- Proven architectural patterns
- Messages like: "⚡ Optimized based on 10 successful similar agents"
### After 30+ Days
You'll experience:
- Personalized suggestions
- Predictive insights
- Custom optimizations
- Messages like: "🌟 I notice you prefer comprehensive analysis"
---
## Step 5: Create Your Own Test (Optional - 1 minute)
Run the test script to add more learning data:
```bash
python3 test_agentdb_learning.py
```
This will:
1. Add 3 financial agent episodes
2. Create 3 reusable skills
3. Map 4 causal relationships
4. Verify all capabilities
Then check the database again:
```bash
agentdb db stats
```
Watch the numbers grow!
---
## Real-World Usage
### When You Create Agents
**Your Command:**
```
"Create financial analysis agent for stock market data"
```
**What Happens Invisibly:**
1. AgentDB searches episodes (finds 3 similar)
2. Retrieves relevant skills (finds 3 matches)
3. Queries causal effects (finds 4 proven improvements)
4. Generates smart recommendations
5. Applies learned optimizations
6. Stores new experience for future learning
**What You See:**
```
✅ Creating financial analysis agent...
⚡ Optimized based on similar successful agents
🧠 Using proven yfinance API (90% confidence)
📊 Adding technical indicators (30% quality boost)
⏱️ Creation time: 36 minutes (40% faster than first attempt)
```
---
## Quick Command Reference
```bash
# Database operations
agentdb db stats # View statistics
agentdb db export > backup.json # Backup learning
# Episode operations
agentdb reflexion retrieve "query" 5 0.6 # Find similar experiences
agentdb reflexion critique-summary "query" # Get learned insights
# Skill operations
agentdb skill search "query" 5 # Find reusable patterns
agentdb skill consolidate 3 0.7 7 # Extract new skills
# Causal operations
agentdb causal query "cause" "" 0.7 0.1 10 # What causes improvements
agentdb causal query "" "effect" 0.7 0.1 10 # What improves outcome
```
---
## Verification Checklist
Try each command and check off when it works:
- [ ] `agentdb db stats` - Shows database size
- [ ] `agentdb reflexion retrieve "financial" 5 0.6` - Returns episodes
- [ ] `agentdb skill search "stock" 5` - Returns skills
- [ ] `agentdb causal query "use_financial_template" "" 0.5 0.1 10` - Returns causal edge
- [ ] Understand that each agent creation adds to learning
- [ ] Recognize that recommendations improve over time
If all work: ✅ **Learning system is fully operational!**
---
## What Makes This Special
### Traditional Systems
- Static code that never improves
- Same recommendations every time
- No learning from experience
- Manual optimization required
### AgentDB-Enhanced System
- ✅ Learns from every creation
- ✅ Better recommendations over time
- ✅ Automatic optimization
- ✅ Mathematical proof of improvements
- ✅ Invisible to users (just works)
---
## Next Steps
1. **Create More Agents**: Each one makes the system smarter
```
"Create [your workflow] agent"
```
2. **Monitor Growth**: Watch the learning expand
```bash
agentdb db stats
```
3. **Query Insights**: See what was learned
```bash
agentdb reflexion retrieve "your domain" 5 0.6
```
4. **Trust Recommendations**: They're data-driven with 70-95% confidence
---
## Documentation
- **LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md** - Full verification (15 sections)
- **QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md** - Command reference
- **TRY_IT_YOURSELF.md** - This guide
- **test_agentdb_learning.py** - Automated test script
---
## Summary
**You now know how to:**
✅ Check AgentDB learning status
✅ Query past experiences
✅ Find reusable skills
✅ Discover causal relationships
✅ Understand progressive improvement
✅ Verify the system is learning
**The system provides:**
🧠 Invisible intelligence
⚡ Progressive enhancement
🎯 Mathematical validation
📈 Continuous improvement
**Total time invested:** 5 minutes
**Value gained:** Lifetime of smarter agents
---
**Ready to create smarter agents?** The system is learning and ready to help! 🚀

425
docs/USER_BENEFITS_GUIDE.md
View file

@ -1,425 +0,0 @@
# What AgentDB Learning Means For YOU
## The Bottom Line
**You type the same simple commands. Your agents get better automatically.**
No configuration. No learning curve. No extra work. Just progressively smarter results.
---
## 🎯 What You Experience (Real Examples)
### **Your First Agent** (Day 1)
**You Type:**
```
"Create financial analysis agent for stock market data"
```
**What Happens:**
- Agent creation starts
- Takes ~60 minutes
- Researches APIs, designs system, implements code
- Creates working agent
**Result:** ✅ Perfect functional agent
---
### **Your Second Similar Agent** (Same Week)
**You Type:**
```
"Create portfolio tracking agent with stock analysis"
```
**What You See (NEW):**
```
✅ Creating portfolio tracking agent...
⚡ I found similar successful patterns from your previous agent
🧠 Using yfinance API (proven 90% reliable in your past projects)
📊 Including technical indicators (improved quality by 30% before)
⏱️ Estimated time: 36 minutes (40% faster based on learned patterns)
```
**What Changed:**
- ⚡ **40% faster** (36 min instead of 60 min)
- 🎯 **Better API choice** (proven to work for you)
- 📈 **Higher quality** (includes features that worked before)
- 🧠 **Smarter decisions** (based on your successful agents)
**Result:** ✅ Better agent in less time
---
### **After 10 Agents** (Week 2-3)
**You Type:**
```
"Create cryptocurrency trading analysis agent"
```
**What You See:**
```
✅ Creating cryptocurrency trading analysis agent...
⚡ Optimized based on 10 successful financial agents you've created
🧠 I notice you prefer comprehensive analysis with multiple indicators
📊 Automatically including:
- Real-time price tracking (worked in 8/10 past agents)
- Technical indicators RSI, MACD (95% success rate)
- Portfolio integration (you always add this later)
- Caching for performance (60% speed boost proven)
⏱️ Estimated time: 25 minutes (58% faster than your first agent)
💡 Suggestion: Based on your patterns, shall I also include:
- Portfolio optimization features? (you added this to 3 similar agents)
- Risk assessment module? (85% confidence this fits your needs)
```
**What Changed:**
- ⚡ **58% faster** (25 min vs 60 min originally)
- 🎯 **Predictive features** (suggests what you'll want)
- 🧠 **Learns your style** (knows you like comprehensive solutions)
- 💡 **Proactive suggestions** (anticipates your needs)
**Result:** ✅ Excellent agent that matches your preferences perfectly
---
### **After 30 Days** (Regular Use)
**You Type:**
```
"Create financial agent"
```
**What You See:**
```
✅ Creating financial analysis agent...
🌟 Welcome back! I've learned your preferences over 30+ days:
📊 Your Pattern Analysis:
- You create comprehensive financial agents (always include all indicators)
- You prefer yfinance + pandas-ta combination (100% satisfaction)
- You always add portfolio tracking (adding automatically)
- You value detailed reports with charts (including by default)
⚡ Creating your personalized agent with:
✓ Stock market data (yfinance - your preferred API)
✓ Technical analysis (RSI, MACD, Bollinger Bands - your favorites)
✓ Portfolio tracking (you add this 100% of the time)
✓ Risk assessment (85% confident you want this)
✓ Automated reporting (matches your past agents)
✓ Performance caching (60% speed improvement)
⏱️ Estimated time: 18 minutes (70% faster than your first attempt!)
💡 Personalized Suggestion:
- I notice you often create agents on Monday mornings
- You analyze the same 5 tech stocks in most agents
- Consider creating a master "portfolio tracker suite" to save time?
```
**What Changed:**
- 🌟 **Knows you personally** (recognizes your patterns)
- 🎯 **Anticipates needs** (includes what you always want)
- 💡 **Strategic suggestions** (sees bigger picture improvements)
- ⚡ **70% faster** (18 min vs 60 min)
- 🎨 **Matches your style** (agents feel "yours")
**Result:** ✅ Perfect agents that feel custom-made for you
---
## 🚀 The Magic: What Happens Behind the Scenes
### You Don't See (But Benefit From):
**Every Time You Create an Agent:**
1. **Episode Stored** (Invisible)
- What you asked for
- What was created
- How well it worked
- What you liked/didn't like
- Time taken, quality achieved
2. **Patterns Extracted** (Invisible)
- Your preferences identified
- Successful approaches noted
- Failures remembered (won't repeat)
- Your style learned
3. **Improvements Calculated** (Invisible)
- "Using yfinance → 25% better satisfaction"
- "Adding caching → 60% faster"
- "Financial template → 40% time savings"
- Mathematical proof: 85-95% confidence
4. **Next Agent Enhanced** (Invisible)
- Better API selections
- Proven architectures
- Your preferred features
- Optimized creation process
### You Only See:
✅ Faster creation
✅ Better recommendations
✅ Features you actually want
✅ Higher quality results
✅ Personalized experience
---
## 💰 Real-World Value
### Time Savings (Proven)
| Agent | Time | Cumulative Savings |
|-------|------|-------------------|
| 1st Agent | 60 min | 0 min |
| 2nd Agent | 36 min | 24 min saved |
| 10th Agent | 25 min | 350 min saved (5.8 hours) |
| 30th Agent | 18 min | 1,260 min saved (21 hours) |
| 100th Agent | 15 min | 4,500 min saved (75 hours) |
**After 100 agents**: You've saved almost **2 full work weeks** of time!
### Quality Improvements
- **First Agent**: Good, functional, meets requirements
- **After 10**: Excellent, includes best practices, optimized
- **After 30**: Outstanding, personalized, anticipates needs
- **After 100**: World-class, domain expertise, industry standards
### Cost Savings
If consultant rate is $100/hour:
- After 10 agents: $580 saved
- After 30 agents: $2,100 saved
- After 100 agents: $7,500 saved
**Plus**: Every agent is higher quality, so more valuable!
---
## 🎓 Learning by Example
### Example 1: Business Owner Creating Inventory Agents
**Week 1 - First Agent:**
```
You: "Create inventory tracking agent for my restaurant"
Time: 60 minutes
Result: Basic inventory tracker
```
**Week 2 - Second Agent:**
```
You: "Create inventory agent for my second restaurant location"
Time: 40 minutes (33% faster!)
Result: Better agent, learned from first one, includes features you used
```
**Month 2 - Fifth Agent:**
```
You: "Create inventory agent"
System: "I notice you always add supplier tracking and automatic alerts.
Including these by default. Time: 22 minutes"
Result: Perfect agent that matches your business needs exactly
```
**Value**: 5 restaurants, all with optimized inventory tracking, each taking less time to create.
---
### Example 2: Data Analyst Creating Research Agents
**Day 1:**
```
You: "Create climate data analysis agent"
Time: 75 minutes
Result: Works, analyzes temperature data
```
**Day 3:**
```
You: "Create weather pattern analysis agent"
Time: 45 minutes (40% faster!)
System: "Using NOAA API (worked perfectly in your climate agent)"
Result: Better integration, faster creation
```
**Week 2:**
```
You: "Create environmental impact agent"
System: "I notice you always include:
- Historical comparison charts
- Anomaly detection
- CSV export
Including these automatically."
Time: 30 minutes (60% faster!)
Result: Exactly what you need, no back-and-forth
```
**Value**: Research accelerates, each agent better than the last.
---
## 🎯 Specific Benefits You Get
### 1. **Faster Creation** (Proven 40-70% improvement)
- First agent: 60 minutes
- After learning: 18-36 minutes
- You save: 24-42 minutes per agent
### 2. **Better Recommendations** (85-95% confidence)
- APIs that actually work for your domain
- Architectures proven successful
- Features you actually use
### 3. **Fewer Mistakes** (Learning from failures)
- System remembers what didn't work
- Won't suggest failed approaches again
- Higher success rate over time
### 4. **Personalization** (Knows your style)
- Includes features you always add
- Matches your preferences
- Anticipates your needs
### 5. **Confidence** (Mathematical proof)
- "90% confidence this API will work"
- "40% faster based on 10 similar agents"
- "25% quality improvement proven"
- Data-driven, not guesses
### 6. **Strategic Insights** (Sees patterns you don't)
- "You create similar agents - consider a suite"
- "You always add X feature - automate this"
- "Monday morning pattern - schedule?"
---
## ❓ Common Questions
### "Do I need to configure anything?"
**No.** It works automatically from day one.
### "Do I need to learn AgentDB commands?"
**No.** Everything happens invisibly. Just create agents normally.
### "Will my agents work without AgentDB?"
**Yes!** AgentDB just makes creation better. Agents work independently.
### "What if AgentDB isn't available?"
System falls back gracefully. You still get great agents, just without learning enhancements.
### "Does it share my data?"
**No.** All learning is local to your database. Your patterns stay private.
### "Can I turn it off?"
Yes, but why? It only makes things better. No downsides.
---
## 🎁 The Best Part: Zero Effort
### What You Do:
```
"Create [whatever] agent"
```
### What You Get:
✅ Perfect functional agent
✅ Gets better each time automatically
✅ Learns your preferences
✅ Saves time progressively
✅ Higher quality results
✅ Personalized experience
✅ Mathematical confidence
✅ Strategic insights
### What You DON'T Do:
❌ No configuration
❌ No training
❌ No maintenance
❌ No commands to learn
❌ No databases to manage
❌ No technical knowledge needed
---
## 🏆 Success Stories
### Financial Analyst
- **Before**: Created 1 agent/week, 90 minutes each
- **After**: Creates 3 agents/week, 25 minutes each
- **Result**: 3x more agents in 83% less time
### Restaurant Chain Owner
- **Before**: Manual inventory for 5 locations
- **After**: 5 automated agents, each better than last
- **Result**: Saves 10 hours/week, better accuracy
### Research Scientist
- **Before**: 2 hours per data analysis workflow
- **After**: 30 minutes, system knows preferences
- **Result**: 4x more research capacity
---
## 🎯 Bottom Line For You
### Traditional System:
- Create agent → Works
- Create another → Same process, same time
- Create 100 → Still same process, same time
- **No learning. No improvement.**
### Agent-Skill-Creator with AgentDB:
- Create agent → Works, stores experience
- Create another → 40% faster, better choices
- Create 10 → 60% faster, knows your style
- Create 100 → 70% faster, anticipates needs
- **Continuous learning. Continuous improvement.**
### What This Means:
**Same simple commands → Progressively better results**
You type `"Create financial agent"`
- Day 1: Great agent, 60 minutes
- Week 2: Better agent, 36 minutes
- Month 1: Perfect agent, 18 minutes
- Month 6: World-class agent, 15 minutes
**That's the magic of invisible intelligence.**
---
## 🚀 Ready to Experience It?
Just start creating agents normally:
```
"Create [your workflow] agent"
```
The learning happens automatically. Each agent makes the next one better.
**No setup. No learning curve. Just progressively smarter results.**
That's what AgentDB learning means for you! 🎉
---
**Questions?** Read:
- **TRY_IT_YOURSELF.md** - See it in action (5 min)
- **QUICK_VERIFICATION_GUIDE.md** - Check it's working
- **LEARNING_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md** - Full technical details
**Want proof?** Create 2 similar agents and watch the second one be faster and better!

144
exports/README.md
View file

@ -1,144 +0,0 @@
# Exports Directory
This directory contains cross-platform export packages for skills created by agent-skill-creator.
## 📦 What's Here
This directory stores `.zip` packages optimized for different Claude platforms:
- **Desktop packages** (`*-desktop-v*.zip`) - For Claude Desktop and claude.ai manual upload
- **API packages** (`*-api-v*.zip`) - For programmatic Claude API integration
- **Installation guides** (`*_INSTALL.md`) - Platform-specific instructions for each export
## 🚀 Using Exported Packages
### For Claude Desktop
1. Locate the `-desktop-` package for your skill
2. Open Claude Desktop → Settings → Capabilities → Skills
3. Click "Upload skill" and select the `.zip` file
4. Follow any additional instructions in the corresponding `_INSTALL.md` file
### For claude.ai (Web)
1. Locate the `-desktop-` package (same as Desktop)
2. Visit https://claude.ai → Settings → Skills
3. Click "Upload skill" and select the `.zip` file
4. Confirm the upload
### For Claude API
1. Locate the `-api-` package for your skill
2. Use the Claude API to upload programmatically:
```python
import anthropic
client = anthropic.Anthropic(api_key="your-api-key")
with open('skill-name-api-v1.0.0.zip', 'rb') as f:
skill = client.skills.create(
file=f,
name="skill-name"
)
# Use in API requests
response = client.messages.create(
model="claude-sonnet-4",
messages=[{"role": "user", "content": "Your query"}],
container={"type": "custom_skill", "skill_id": skill.id},
betas=["code-execution-2025-08-25", "skills-2025-10-02"]
)
```
3. See the `_INSTALL.md` file for complete API integration instructions
## 📁 File Organization
### Naming Convention
```
skill-name-{variant}-v{version}.zip
skill-name-{variant}-v{version}_INSTALL.md
```
**Examples:**
- `financial-analysis-desktop-v1.0.0.zip`
- `financial-analysis-api-v1.0.0.zip`
- `financial-analysis-desktop-v1.0.0_INSTALL.md`
### Version Numbering
Versions follow semantic versioning (MAJOR.MINOR.PATCH):
- **MAJOR**: Breaking changes to skill behavior
- **MINOR**: New features, backward compatible
- **PATCH**: Bug fixes, optimizations
## 🔧 Generating Exports
### Automatic (Opt-In)
After creating a skill, agent-skill-creator will prompt:
```
📦 Export Options:
1. Desktop/Web (.zip for manual upload)
2. API (.zip for programmatic use)
3. Both (comprehensive package)
4. Skip (Claude Code only)
```
Choose your option and exports will be generated here automatically.
### On-Demand
Export any existing skill anytime:
```
"Export [skill-name] for Desktop"
"Export [skill-name] for API with version 2.1.0"
"Create cross-platform package for [skill-name]"
```
## 📊 Package Differences
| Feature | Desktop Package | API Package |
|---------|-----------------|-------------|
| **Size** | Full (2-5 MB typical) | Optimized (< 8MB required) |
| **Documentation** | Complete | Minimal (execution-focused) |
| **Examples** | Included | Excluded (size optimization) |
| **References** | Full | Essential only |
| **Scripts** | All | Execution-critical only |
## 🛡️ Security Notes
**What's Excluded** (for security):
- `.env` files (environment variables)
- `credentials.json` (API keys)
- `.git/` directories (version control history)
- `__pycache__/` (compiled Python)
- `.DS_Store` (macOS metadata)
**What's Included**:
- `SKILL.md` (required core functionality)
- `scripts/` (execution code)
- `references/` (documentation)
- `assets/` (templates, prompts)
- `requirements.txt` (dependencies)
- `README.md` (usage instructions)
## 📚 Additional Resources
- **Export Guide**: `../references/export-guide.md`
- **Cross-Platform Guide**: `../references/cross-platform-guide.md`
- **Main README**: `../README.md`
## ⚠️ Git Ignore
This directory is configured to ignore `.zip` files and `_INSTALL.md` files in git (they're generated artifacts). Only this README is tracked.
If you need to share exports, distribute them directly to users or host them externally.
---
**Questions?** See the export guide or cross-platform compatibility guide in the `references/` directory.

753
integrations/agentdb_bridge.py
View file

@ -1,753 +0,0 @@
#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""
AgentDB Bridge - Invisible Intelligence Layer
This module provides seamless AgentDB integration that is completely transparent
to the end user. All complexity is hidden behind simple interfaces.
The user never needs to know AgentDB exists - they just get smarter agents.
Principles:
- Zero configuration required
- Automatic setup and maintenance
- Graceful fallback if AgentDB unavailable
- Progressive enhancement without user awareness
"""
import json
import os
import subprocess
import logging
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, Any, Optional, List
from dataclasses import dataclass
from datetime import datetime
# Configure logging
logging.basicConfig(level=logging.INFO)
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@dataclass
class AgentDBIntelligence:
"""Container for AgentDB-enhanced decision making"""
template_choice: Optional[str] = None
success_probability: float = 0.0
learned_improvements: List[str] = None
historical_context: Dict[str, Any] = None
mathematical_proof: Optional[str] = None
def __post_init__(self):
if self.learned_improvements is None:
self.learned_improvements = []
if self.historical_context is None:
self.historical_context = {}
class AgentDBBridge:
"""
Invisible AgentDB integration layer.
Provides AgentDB capabilities without exposing complexity to users.
All AgentDB operations happen transparently behind the scenes.
"""
def __init__(self):
self.is_available = False
self.is_configured = False
self.error_count = 0
self.max_errors = 3 # Graceful fallback after 3 errors
# Initialize silently
self._initialize_silently()
def _initialize_silently(self):
"""Initialize AgentDB silently without user intervention"""
try:
# Step 1: Try detection first (current behavior)
cli_available = self._check_cli_availability()
npx_available = self._check_npx_availability()
if cli_available or npx_available:
self.is_available = True
self.use_cli = cli_available # Prefer native CLI
self._auto_configure()
logger.info("AgentDB initialized successfully (invisible mode)")
return
# Step 2: Try automatic installation if not found
logger.info("AgentDB not found - attempting automatic installation")
if self._attempt_automatic_install():
logger.info("AgentDB automatically installed and configured")
return
# Step 3: Fallback mode if installation fails
logger.info("AgentDB not available - using fallback mode")
except Exception as e:
logger.info(f"AgentDB initialization failed: {e} - using fallback mode")
def _check_cli_availability(self) -> bool:
"""Check if AgentDB native CLI is available"""
try:
result = subprocess.run(
["agentdb", "--help"],
capture_output=True,
text=True,
timeout=10
)
return result.returncode == 0
except (FileNotFoundError, subprocess.TimeoutExpired):
return False
def _check_npx_availability(self) -> bool:
"""Check if AgentDB is available via npx"""
try:
result = subprocess.run(
["npx", "@anthropic-ai/agentdb", "--help"],
capture_output=True,
text=True,
timeout=10
)
return result.returncode == 0
except (FileNotFoundError, subprocess.TimeoutExpired):
return False
def _attempt_automatic_install(self) -> bool:
"""Attempt to install AgentDB automatically"""
try:
# Check if npm is available first
if not self._check_npm_availability():
logger.info("npm not available - cannot install AgentDB automatically")
return False
# Try installation methods in order of preference
installation_methods = [
self._install_npm_global,
self._install_npx_fallback
]
for method in installation_methods:
try:
if method():
# Verify installation worked
if self._verify_installation():
self.is_available = True
self._auto_configure()
logger.info("AgentDB automatically installed and configured")
return True
except Exception as e:
logger.info(f"Installation method failed: {e}")
continue
logger.info("All automatic installation methods failed")
return False
except Exception as e:
logger.info(f"Automatic installation failed: {e}")
return False
def _check_npm_availability(self) -> bool:
"""Check if npm is available"""
try:
result = subprocess.run(
["npm", "--version"],
capture_output=True,
text=True,
timeout=10
)
return result.returncode == 0
except (FileNotFoundError, subprocess.TimeoutExpired):
return False
def _install_npm_global(self) -> bool:
"""Install AgentDB globally via npm"""
try:
logger.info("Attempting npm global installation of AgentDB...")
result = subprocess.run(
["npm", "install", "-g", "@anthropic-ai/agentdb"],
capture_output=True,
text=True,
timeout=300 # 5 minutes timeout
)
if result.returncode == 0:
logger.info("npm global installation successful")
return True
else:
logger.info(f"npm global installation failed: {result.stderr}")
return False
except Exception as e:
logger.info(f"npm global installation error: {e}")
return False
def _install_npx_fallback(self) -> bool:
"""Try to use npx approach (doesn't require global installation)"""
try:
logger.info("Testing npx approach for AgentDB...")
# Test if npx can download and run agentdb
result = subprocess.run(
["npx", "@anthropic-ai/agentdb", "--version"],
capture_output=True,
text=True,
timeout=60
)
if result.returncode == 0:
logger.info("npx approach successful - AgentDB available via npx")
return True
else:
logger.info(f"npx approach failed: {result.stderr}")
return False
except Exception as e:
logger.info(f"npx approach error: {e}")
return False
def _verify_installation(self) -> bool:
"""Verify that AgentDB was installed successfully"""
try:
# Check CLI availability first
if self._check_cli_availability():
logger.info("AgentDB CLI verified after installation")
return True
# Check npx availability as fallback
if self._check_npx_availability():
logger.info("AgentDB npx availability verified after installation")
return True
logger.info("AgentDB installation verification failed")
return False
except Exception as e:
logger.info(f"Installation verification error: {e}")
return False
def _auto_configure(self):
"""Auto-configure AgentDB for optimal performance"""
try:
# Create default configuration
config = {
"reflexion": {
"auto_save": True,
"compression": True
},
"causal": {
"auto_track": True,
"utility_model": "outcome_based"
},
"skills": {
"auto_extract": True,
"success_threshold": 0.8
},
"nightly_learner": {
"enabled": True,
"schedule": "2:00 AM"
}
}
# Write configuration silently
config_path = Path.home() / ".agentdb" / "config.json"
config_path.parent.mkdir(exist_ok=True)
with open(config_path, 'w') as f:
json.dump(config, f, indent=2)
self.is_configured = True
logger.info("AgentDB auto-configured successfully")
except Exception as e:
logger.warning(f"AgentDB auto-configuration failed: {e}")
def enhance_agent_creation(self, user_input: str, domain: str = None) -> AgentDBIntelligence:
"""
Enhance agent creation with AgentDB intelligence.
Returns intelligence data transparently.
"""
intelligence = AgentDBIntelligence()
if not self.is_available or not self.is_configured:
return intelligence # Return empty intelligence for fallback
try:
# Use real AgentDB commands if CLI is available
if hasattr(self, 'use_cli') and self.use_cli:
intelligence = self._enhance_with_real_agentdb(user_input, domain)
else:
# Fallback to legacy implementation
intelligence = self._enhance_with_legacy_agentdb(user_input, domain)
# Store this decision for learning
self._store_creation_decision(user_input, intelligence)
logger.info(f"AgentDB enhanced creation: template={intelligence.template_choice}")
except Exception as e:
logger.warning(f"AgentDB enhancement failed: {e}")
# Return empty intelligence on error
self.error_count += 1
if self.error_count >= self.max_errors:
logger.warning("AgentDB error threshold reached, switching to fallback mode")
self.is_available = False
return intelligence
def _enhance_with_real_agentdb(self, user_input: str, domain: str = None) -> AgentDBIntelligence:
"""Enhance using real AgentDB CLI commands"""
intelligence = AgentDBIntelligence()
try:
# 1. Search for relevant skills
skills_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"agentdb" if self.use_cli else "npx", "agentdb", "skill", "search", user_input, "5"
])
if skills_result:
# Parse skills from output
skills = self._parse_skills_from_output(skills_result)
if skills:
intelligence.learned_improvements = [f"Skill available: {skill.get('name', 'unknown')}" for skill in skills[:3]]
# 2. Retrieve relevant episodes
episodes_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"agentdb" if self.use_cli else "npx", "agentdb", "reflexion", "retrieve", user_input, "3", "0.6"
])
if episodes_result:
episodes = self._parse_episodes_from_output(episodes_result)
if episodes:
success_rate = sum(1 for e in episodes if e.get('success', False)) / len(episodes)
intelligence.success_probability = success_rate
# 3. Query causal effects
if domain:
causal_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"agentdb" if self.use_cli else "npx", "agentdb", "causal", "query",
f"use_{domain}_template", "", "0.7", "0.1", "5"
])
if causal_result:
# Parse best causal effect
effects = self._parse_causal_effects_from_output(causal_result)
if effects:
best_effect = max(effects, key=lambda x: x.get('uplift', 0))
intelligence.template_choice = f"{domain}-analysis"
intelligence.mathematical_proof = f"Causal uplift: {best_effect.get('uplift', 0):.2%}"
logger.info(f"Real AgentDB enhancement completed for {domain}")
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Real AgentDB enhancement failed: {e}")
return intelligence
def _enhance_with_legacy_agentdb(self, user_input: str, domain: str = None) -> AgentDBIntelligence:
"""Enhance using legacy AgentDB implementation"""
intelligence = AgentDBIntelligence()
try:
# Legacy implementation using npx
template_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "causal", "recall",
f"best_template_for_domain:{domain or 'unknown'}",
"--format", "json"
])
if template_result:
intelligence.template_choice = self._parse_template_result(template_result)
intelligence.success_probability = self._calculate_success_probability(
intelligence.template_choice, domain
)
# Get learned improvements
improvements_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "skills", "list",
f"domain:{domain or 'unknown'}",
"--success-rate", "0.8"
])
if improvements_result:
intelligence.learned_improvements = self._parse_improvements(improvements_result)
logger.info(f"Legacy AgentDB enhancement completed for {domain}")
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Legacy AgentDB enhancement failed: {e}")
return intelligence
def _parse_skills_from_output(self, output: str) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""Parse skills from AgentDB CLI output"""
skills = []
lines = output.split('\n')
current_skill = {}
for line in lines:
line = line.strip()
if line.startswith("#") and "Found" not in line:
if current_skill:
skills.append(current_skill)
skill_name = line.replace("#1:", "").strip()
current_skill = {"name": skill_name}
elif ":" in line and current_skill:
key, value = line.split(":", 1)
key = key.strip()
value = value.strip()
if key == "Description":
current_skill["description"] = value
elif key == "Success Rate":
try:
current_skill["success_rate"] = float(value.replace("%", "")) / 100
except ValueError:
pass
if current_skill:
skills.append(current_skill)
return skills
def _parse_episodes_from_output(self, output: str) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""Parse episodes from AgentDB CLI output"""
episodes = []
lines = output.split('\n')
current_episode = {}
for line in lines:
line = line.strip()
if line.startswith("#") and "Episode" in line:
if current_episode:
episodes.append(current_episode)
current_episode = {"episode_id": line.split()[1].replace(":", "")}
elif ":" in line and current_episode:
key, value = line.split(":", 1)
key = key.strip()
value = value.strip()
if key == "Task":
current_episode["task"] = value
elif key == "Success":
current_episode["success"] = "Yes" in value
elif key == "Reward":
try:
current_episode["reward"] = float(value)
except ValueError:
pass
if current_episode:
episodes.append(current_episode)
return episodes
def _parse_causal_effects_from_output(self, output: str) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""Parse causal effects from AgentDB CLI output"""
effects = []
lines = output.split('\n')
for line in lines:
if "→" in line and "uplift" in line.lower():
parts = line.split("→")
if len(parts) >= 2:
cause = parts[0].strip()
effect_rest = parts[1]
effect = effect_rest.split("(")[0].strip()
uplift = 0.0
if "uplift:" in effect_rest:
uplift_part = effect_rest.split("uplift:")[1].split(",")[0].strip()
try:
uplift = float(uplift_part)
except ValueError:
pass
effects.append({
"cause": cause,
"effect": effect,
"uplift": uplift
})
return effects
def _execute_agentdb_command(self, command: List[str]) -> Optional[str]:
"""Execute AgentDB command and return output"""
try:
result = subprocess.run(
command,
capture_output=True,
text=True,
timeout=30,
cwd=str(Path.cwd())
)
if result.returncode == 0:
return result.stdout.strip()
else:
logger.debug(f"AgentDB command failed: {result.stderr}")
return None
except Exception as e:
logger.debug(f"AgentDB command execution failed: {e}")
return None
def _parse_template_result(self, result: str) -> Optional[str]:
"""Parse template selection result"""
try:
if result.strip().startswith('{'):
data = json.loads(result)
return data.get('template', 'default')
else:
return result.strip()
except:
return None
def _parse_improvements(self, result: str) -> List[str]:
"""Parse learned improvements result"""
try:
if result.strip().startswith('{'):
data = json.loads(result)
return data.get('improvements', [])
else:
return [line.strip() for line in result.split('\n') if line.strip()]
except:
return []
def _calculate_success_probability(self, template: str, domain: str) -> float:
"""Calculate success probability based on historical data"""
# Simplified calculation - in real implementation this would query AgentDB
base_prob = 0.8 # Base success rate
# Increase probability for templates with good history
if template and "financial" in template.lower():
base_prob += 0.1
if template and "analysis" in template.lower():
base_prob += 0.05
return min(base_prob, 0.95) # Cap at 95%
def _store_creation_decision(self, user_input: str, intelligence: AgentDBIntelligence):
"""Store creation decision for learning"""
if not self.is_available:
return
try:
# Create session ID
session_id = f"creation-{datetime.now().strftime('%Y%m%d-%H%M%S')}"
# Store reflexion data
self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "reflexion", "store",
session_id,
"agent_creation_decision",
str(intelligence.success_probability * 100)
])
# Store causal relationship
if intelligence.template_choice:
self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "causal", "store",
f"user_input:{user_input[:50]}...",
f"template_selected:{intelligence.template_choice}",
"created_successfully"
])
logger.info(f"Stored creation decision: {session_id}")
except Exception as e:
logger.debug(f"Failed to store creation decision: {e}")
def enhance_template(self, template_name: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Enhance template with learned improvements
"""
enhancements = {
"agentdb_integration": {
"enabled": self.is_available,
"success_rate": 0.0,
"learned_improvements": [],
"historical_usage": 0
}
}
if not self.is_available:
return enhancements
try:
# Get historical success rate
success_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "causal", "recall",
f"template_success_rate:{template_name}"
])
if success_result:
try:
success_data = json.loads(success_result)
enhancements["agentdb_integration"]["success_rate"] = success_data.get("success_rate", 0.8)
enhancements["agentdb_integration"]["historical_usage"] = success_data.get("usage_count", 0)
except:
enhancements["agentdb_integration"]["success_rate"] = 0.8
# Get learned improvements
improvements_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "skills", "list",
f"template:{template_name}"
])
if improvements_result:
enhancements["agentdb_integration"]["learned_improvements"] = self._parse_improvements(improvements_result)
logger.info(f"Template {template_name} enhanced with AgentDB intelligence")
except Exception as e:
logger.debug(f"Failed to enhance template {template_name}: {e}")
return enhancements
def store_agent_experience(self, agent_name: str, experience: Dict[str, Any]):
"""
Store agent experience for learning
"""
if not self.is_available:
return
try:
session_id = f"agent-{agent_name}-{datetime.now().strftime('%Y%m%d-%H%M%S')}"
# Store reflexion
success_rate = experience.get('success_rate', 0.5)
self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "reflexion", "store",
session_id,
"agent_execution",
str(int(success_rate * 100))
])
# Store causal relationships
for cause, effect in experience.get('causal_observations', {}).items():
self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "causal", "store",
str(cause),
str(effect),
"agent_observation"
])
# Extract skills if successful
if success_rate > 0.8:
for skill_data in experience.get('successful_skills', []):
self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "skills", "store",
skill_data.get('name', 'unnamed_skill'),
json.dumps(skill_data)
])
logger.info(f"Stored experience for agent: {agent_name}")
except Exception as e:
logger.debug(f"Failed to store agent experience: {e}")
def get_learning_summary(self, agent_name: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Get learning summary for an agent (for internal use)
"""
summary = {
"total_sessions": 0,
"success_rate": 0.0,
"learned_skills": [],
"causal_patterns": []
}
if not self.is_available:
return summary
try:
# Get reflexion history
reflexion_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "reflexion", "recall",
f"agent:{agent_name}",
"--format", "json"
])
if reflexion_result:
try:
data = json.loads(reflexion_result)
summary["total_sessions"] = len(data.get('sessions', []))
if data.get('sessions'):
rewards = [s.get('reward', 0) for s in data['sessions']]
summary["success_rate"] = sum(rewards) / len(rewards) / 100
except:
pass
# Get learned skills
skills_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "skills", "list",
f"agent:{agent_name}"
])
if skills_result:
summary["learned_skills"] = self._parse_improvements(skills_result)
# Get causal patterns
causal_result = self._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "causal", "recall",
f"agent:{agent_name}",
"--format", "json"
])
if causal_result:
try:
data = json.loads(causal_result)
summary["causal_patterns"] = data.get('patterns', [])
except:
pass
except Exception as e:
logger.debug(f"Failed to get learning summary for {agent_name}: {e}")
return summary
# Global instance - invisible to users
_agentdb_bridge = None
def get_agentdb_bridge() -> AgentDBBridge:
"""Get the global AgentDB bridge instance"""
global _agentdb_bridge
if _agentdb_bridge is None:
_agentdb_bridge = AgentDBBridge()
return _agentdb_bridge
def enhance_agent_creation(user_input: str, domain: str = None) -> AgentDBIntelligence:
"""
Public interface for enhancing agent creation with AgentDB intelligence.
This is what the Agent-Creator calls internally.
The user never calls this directly - it's all hidden behind the scenes.
"""
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
return bridge.enhance_agent_creation(user_input, domain)
def enhance_template(template_name: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Enhance a template with AgentDB learned improvements.
Called internally during template selection.
"""
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
return bridge.enhance_template(template_name, domain)
def store_agent_experience(agent_name: str, experience: Dict[str, Any]):
"""
Store agent execution experience for learning.
Called internally after agent execution.
"""
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
bridge.store_agent_experience(agent_name, experience)
def get_agent_learning_summary(agent_name: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Get learning summary for an agent.
Used internally for progress tracking.
"""
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
return bridge.get_learning_summary(agent_name)
# Auto-initialize when module is imported
get_agentdb_bridge()

717
integrations/agentdb_real_integration.py
View file

@ -1,717 +0,0 @@
#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""
Real AgentDB Integration - TypeScript/Python Bridge
This module provides real integration with AgentDB CLI, handling the TypeScript/Python
communication barrier while maintaining the "invisible intelligence" experience.
Architecture: Python <-> CLI Bridge <-> AgentDB (TypeScript/Node.js)
"""
import json
import subprocess
import logging
import tempfile
import os
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, Any, List, Optional, Union
from dataclasses import dataclass, asdict
from datetime import datetime
import time
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@dataclass
class Episode:
"""Python representation of AgentDB Episode"""
session_id: str
task: str
input: Optional[str] = None
output: Optional[str] = None
critique: Optional[str] = None
reward: float = 0.0
success: bool = False
latency_ms: Optional[int] = None
tokens_used: Optional[int] = None
tags: Optional[List[str]] = None
metadata: Optional[Dict[str, Any]] = None
@dataclass
class Skill:
"""Python representation of AgentDB Skill"""
name: str
description: Optional[str] = None
code: Optional[str] = None
signature: Optional[Dict[str, Any]] = None
success_rate: float = 0.0
uses: int = 0
avg_reward: float = 0.0
avg_latency_ms: int = 0
metadata: Optional[Dict[str, Any]] = None
@dataclass
class CausalEdge:
"""Python representation of AgentDB CausalEdge"""
cause: str
effect: str
uplift: float
confidence: float = 0.5
sample_size: Optional[int] = None
mechanism: Optional[str] = None
metadata: Optional[Dict[str, Any]] = None
class AgentDBCLIException(Exception):
"""Custom exception for AgentDB CLI errors"""
pass
class RealAgentDBBridge:
"""
Real bridge to AgentDB CLI, providing Python interface while maintaining
the "invisible intelligence" experience for users.
"""
def __init__(self, db_path: Optional[str] = None):
"""
Initialize the real AgentDB bridge.
Args:
db_path: Path to AgentDB database file (default: ./agentdb.db)
"""
self.db_path = db_path or "./agentdb.db"
self.is_available = self._check_agentdb_availability()
self._setup_environment()
def _check_agentdb_availability(self) -> bool:
"""Check if AgentDB CLI is available"""
try:
result = subprocess.run(
["agentdb", "--help"],
capture_output=True,
text=True,
timeout=10
)
return result.returncode == 0
except (subprocess.TimeoutExpired, FileNotFoundError):
logger.warning("AgentDB CLI not available")
return False
def _setup_environment(self):
"""Setup environment variables for AgentDB"""
env = os.environ.copy()
env["AGENTDB_PATH"] = self.db_path
self.env = env
def _run_agentdb_command(self, command: List[str], timeout: int = 30) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Execute AgentDB CLI command and parse output.
Args:
command: Command components
timeout: Command timeout in seconds
Returns:
Parsed result dictionary
Raises:
AgentDBCLIException: If command fails
"""
if not self.is_available:
raise AgentDBCLIException("AgentDB CLI not available")
try:
full_command = ["agentdb"] + command
logger.debug(f"Running AgentDB command: {' '.join(full_command)}")
result = subprocess.run(
full_command,
capture_output=True,
text=True,
timeout=timeout,
env=self.env
)
if result.returncode != 0:
error_msg = f"AgentDB command failed: {result.stderr}"
logger.error(error_msg)
raise AgentDBCLIException(error_msg)
# Parse output (most AgentDB commands return structured text)
return self._parse_agentdb_output(result.stdout)
except subprocess.TimeoutExpired:
raise AgentDBCLIException(f"AgentDB command timed out: {' '.join(command)}")
except Exception as e:
raise AgentDBCLIException(f"Error executing AgentDB command: {str(e)}")
def _parse_agentdb_output(self, output: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Parse AgentDB CLI output into structured data.
This is a simplified parser - real implementation would need
to handle different output formats from different commands.
"""
lines = output.strip().split('\n')
# Look for JSON patterns or structured data
for line in lines:
line = line.strip()
if line.startswith('{') and line.endswith('}'):
try:
return json.loads(line)
except json.JSONDecodeError:
continue
# Fallback: extract key information using patterns
result = {
"raw_output": output,
"success": True,
"data": {}
}
# Extract common patterns - handle ANSI escape codes
if "Stored episode #" in output:
# Extract episode ID
for line in lines:
if "Stored episode #" in line:
parts = line.split('#')
if len(parts) > 1:
# Remove ANSI escape codes and extract ID
id_part = parts[1].split()[0].replace('\x1b[0m', '')
try:
result["data"]["episode_id"] = int(id_part)
except ValueError:
result["data"]["episode_id"] = id_part
break
elif "Created skill #" in output:
# Extract skill ID
for line in lines:
if "Created skill #" in line:
parts = line.split('#')
if len(parts) > 1:
# Remove ANSI escape codes and extract ID
id_part = parts[1].split()[0].replace('\x1b[0m', '')
try:
result["data"]["skill_id"] = int(id_part)
except ValueError:
result["data"]["skill_id"] = id_part
break
elif "Added causal edge #" in output:
# Extract edge ID
for line in lines:
if "Added causal edge #" in line:
parts = line.split('#')
if len(parts) > 1:
# Remove ANSI escape codes and extract ID
id_part = parts[1].split()[0].replace('\x1b[0m', '')
try:
result["data"]["edge_id"] = int(id_part)
except ValueError:
result["data"]["edge_id"] = id_part
break
elif "Retrieved" in output and "relevant episodes" in output:
# Parse episode retrieval results
result["data"]["episodes"] = self._parse_episodes_output(output)
elif "Found" in output and "matching skills" in output:
# Parse skill search results
result["data"]["skills"] = self._parse_skills_output(output)
return result
def _parse_episodes_output(self, output: str) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""Parse episodes from AgentDB output"""
episodes = []
lines = output.split('\n')
current_episode = {}
for line in lines:
line = line.strip()
if line.startswith("#") and "Episode" in line:
if current_episode:
episodes.append(current_episode)
current_episode = {"episode_id": line.split()[1].replace(":", "")}
elif ":" in line and current_episode:
key, value = line.split(":", 1)
key = key.strip()
value = value.strip()
if key == "Task":
current_episode["task"] = value
elif key == "Reward":
try:
current_episode["reward"] = float(value)
except ValueError:
pass
elif key == "Success":
current_episode["success"] = "Yes" in value
elif key == "Similarity":
try:
current_episode["similarity"] = float(value)
except ValueError:
pass
elif key == "Critique":
current_episode["critique"] = value
if current_episode:
episodes.append(current_episode)
return episodes
def _parse_skills_output(self, output: str) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""Parse skills from AgentDB output"""
skills = []
lines = output.split('\n')
current_skill = {}
for line in lines:
line = line.strip()
if line.startswith("#") and not line.startswith("═"):
if current_skill:
skills.append(current_skill)
skill_name = line.replace("#1:", "").strip()
current_skill = {"name": skill_name}
elif ":" in line and current_skill:
key, value = line.split(":", 1)
key = key.strip()
value = value.strip()
if key == "Description":
current_skill["description"] = value
elif key == "Success Rate":
try:
current_skill["success_rate"] = float(value.replace("%", "")) / 100
except ValueError:
pass
elif key == "Uses":
try:
current_skill["uses"] = int(value)
except ValueError:
pass
elif key == "Avg Reward":
try:
current_skill["avg_reward"] = float(value)
except ValueError:
pass
if current_skill:
skills.append(current_skill)
return skills
# Reflexion Memory Methods
def store_episode(self, episode: Episode) -> Optional[int]:
"""
Store a reflexion episode in AgentDB.
Args:
episode: Episode to store
Returns:
Episode ID if successful, None otherwise
"""
try:
command = [
"reflexion", "store",
episode.session_id,
episode.task,
str(episode.reward),
"true" if episode.success else "false"
]
if episode.critique:
command.append(episode.critique)
if episode.input:
command.append(episode.input)
if episode.output:
command.append(episode.output)
if episode.latency_ms:
command.append(str(episode.latency_ms))
if episode.tokens_used:
command.append(str(episode.tokens_used))
result = self._run_agentdb_command(command)
return result.get("data", {}).get("episode_id")
except AgentDBCLIException as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to store episode: {e}")
return None
def retrieve_episodes(self, task: str, k: int = 5, min_reward: float = 0.0,
only_failures: bool = False, only_successes: bool = False) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""
Retrieve relevant episodes from AgentDB.
Args:
task: Task description
k: Maximum number of episodes to retrieve
min_reward: Minimum reward threshold
only_failures: Only retrieve failed episodes
only_successes: Only retrieve successful episodes
Returns:
List of episodes
"""
try:
command = ["reflexion", "retrieve", task, str(k), str(min_reward)]
if only_failures:
command.append("true")
elif only_successes:
command.append("false")
result = self._run_agentdb_command(command)
return result.get("data", {}).get("episodes", [])
except AgentDBCLIException as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to retrieve episodes: {e}")
return []
def get_critique_summary(self, task: str, only_failures: bool = False) -> Optional[str]:
"""Get critique summary for a task"""
try:
command = ["reflexion", "critique-summary", task]
if only_failures:
command.append("true")
result = self._run_agentdb_command(command)
# The summary is usually in the raw output
return result.get("raw_output", "").split("═")[-1].strip()
except AgentDBCLIException as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to get critique summary: {e}")
return None
# Skill Library Methods
def create_skill(self, skill: Skill) -> Optional[int]:
"""
Create a skill in AgentDB.
Args:
skill: Skill to create
Returns:
Skill ID if successful, None otherwise
"""
try:
command = ["skill", "create", skill.name]
if skill.description:
command.append(skill.description)
if skill.code:
command.append(skill.code)
result = self._run_agentdb_command(command)
return result.get("data", {}).get("skill_id")
except AgentDBCLIException as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to create skill: {e}")
return None
def search_skills(self, query: str, k: int = 5, min_success_rate: float = 0.0) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""
Search for skills in AgentDB.
Args:
query: Search query
k: Maximum number of skills to retrieve
min_success_rate: Minimum success rate threshold
Returns:
List of skills
"""
try:
command = ["skill", "search", query, str(k)]
result = self._run_agentdb_command(command)
return result.get("data", {}).get("skills", [])
except AgentDBCLIException as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to search skills: {e}")
return []
def consolidate_skills(self, min_attempts: int = 3, min_reward: float = 0.7,
time_window_days: int = 7) -> Optional[int]:
"""
Consolidate episodes into skills.
Args:
min_attempts: Minimum number of attempts
min_reward: Minimum reward threshold
time_window_days: Time window in days
Returns:
Number of skills created if successful, None otherwise
"""
try:
command = [
"skill", "consolidate",
str(min_attempts),
str(min_reward),
str(time_window_days)
]
result = self._run_agentdb_command(command)
# Parse the output to get the number of skills created
output = result.get("raw_output", "")
for line in output.split('\n'):
if "Created" in line and "skills" in line:
# Extract number from line like "Created 3 skills"
parts = line.split()
for i, part in enumerate(parts):
if part == "Created" and i + 1 < len(parts):
try:
return int(parts[i + 1])
except ValueError:
break
return 0
except AgentDBCLIException as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to consolidate skills: {e}")
return None
# Causal Memory Methods
def add_causal_edge(self, edge: CausalEdge) -> Optional[int]:
"""
Add a causal edge to AgentDB.
Args:
edge: Causal edge to add
Returns:
Edge ID if successful, None otherwise
"""
try:
command = [
"causal", "add-edge",
edge.cause,
edge.effect,
str(edge.uplift)
]
if edge.confidence != 0.5:
command.append(str(edge.confidence))
if edge.sample_size:
command.append(str(edge.sample_size))
result = self._run_agentdb_command(command)
return result.get("data", {}).get("edge_id")
except AgentDBCLIException as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to add causal edge: {e}")
return None
def query_causal_effects(self, cause: Optional[str] = None, effect: Optional[str] = None,
min_confidence: float = 0.0, min_uplift: float = 0.0,
limit: int = 10) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""
Query causal effects from AgentDB.
Args:
cause: Cause to query
effect: Effect to query
min_confidence: Minimum confidence threshold
min_uplift: Minimum uplift threshold
limit: Maximum number of results
Returns:
List of causal edges
"""
try:
command = ["causal", "query"]
if cause:
command.append(cause)
if effect:
command.append(effect)
command.extend([str(min_confidence), str(min_uplift), str(limit)])
result = self._run_agentdb_command(command)
# Parse causal edges from output
return self._parse_causal_edges_output(result.get("raw_output", ""))
except AgentDBCLIException as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to query causal effects: {e}")
return []
def _parse_causal_edges_output(self, output: str) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""Parse causal edges from AgentDB output"""
edges = []
lines = output.split('\n')
for line in lines:
if "→" in line and "uplift" in line.lower():
# Parse line like: "use_template → agent_quality (uplift: 0.25, confidence: 0.95)"
parts = line.split("→")
if len(parts) >= 2:
cause = parts[0].strip()
effect_rest = parts[1]
effect = effect_rest.split("(")[0].strip()
# Extract uplift and confidence
uplift = 0.0
confidence = 0.0
if "uplift:" in effect_rest:
uplift_part = effect_rest.split("uplift:")[1].split(",")[0].strip()
try:
uplift = float(uplift_part)
except ValueError:
pass
if "confidence:" in effect_rest:
conf_part = effect_rest.split("confidence:")[1].split(")")[0].strip()
try:
confidence = float(conf_part)
except ValueError:
pass
edges.append({
"cause": cause,
"effect": effect,
"uplift": uplift,
"confidence": confidence
})
return edges
# Database Methods
def get_database_stats(self) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Get AgentDB database statistics"""
try:
result = self._run_agentdb_command(["db", "stats"])
return self._parse_database_stats(result.get("raw_output", ""))
except AgentDBCLIException as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to get database stats: {e}")
return {}
def _parse_database_stats(self, output: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Parse database statistics from AgentDB output"""
stats = {}
lines = output.split('\n')
for line in lines:
if ":" in line:
key, value = line.split(":", 1)
key = key.strip()
value = value.strip()
if key.startswith("causal_edges"):
try:
stats["causal_edges"] = int(value)
except ValueError:
pass
elif key.startswith("episodes"):
try:
stats["episodes"] = int(value)
except ValueError:
pass
elif key.startswith("causal_experiments"):
try:
stats["causal_experiments"] = int(value)
except ValueError:
pass
return stats
# Enhanced Methods for Agent-Creator Integration
def enhance_agent_creation(self, user_input: str, domain: str = None) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Enhance agent creation using AgentDB real capabilities.
This method integrates multiple AgentDB features to provide
intelligent enhancement while maintaining the "invisible" experience.
"""
enhancement = {
"templates": [],
"skills": [],
"episodes": [],
"causal_insights": [],
"recommendations": []
}
if not self.is_available:
return enhancement
try:
# 1. Search for relevant skills
skills = self.search_skills(user_input, k=3, min_success_rate=0.7)
enhancement["skills"] = skills
# 2. Retrieve relevant episodes
episodes = self.retrieve_episodes(user_input, k=5, min_reward=0.6)
enhancement["episodes"] = episodes
# 3. Query causal effects
if domain:
causal_effects = self.query_causal_effects(
cause=f"use_{domain}_template",
min_confidence=0.7,
min_uplift=0.1
)
enhancement["causal_insights"] = causal_effects
# 4. Generate recommendations
enhancement["recommendations"] = self._generate_recommendations(
user_input, enhancement
)
logger.info(f"AgentDB enhancement completed: {len(skills)} skills, {len(episodes)} episodes")
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"AgentDB enhancement failed: {e}")
return enhancement
def _generate_recommendations(self, user_input: str, enhancement: Dict[str, Any]) -> List[str]:
"""Generate recommendations based on AgentDB data"""
recommendations = []
# Skill-based recommendations
if enhancement["skills"]:
recommendations.append(
f"Found {len(enhancement['skills'])} relevant skills from AgentDB"
)
# Episode-based recommendations
if enhancement["episodes"]:
successful_episodes = [e for e in enhancement["episodes"] if e.get("success", False)]
if successful_episodes:
recommendations.append(
f"Found {len(successful_episodes)} successful similar attempts"
)
# Causal insights
if enhancement["causal_insights"]:
best_effect = max(enhancement["causal_insights"],
key=lambda x: x.get("uplift", 0),
default=None)
if best_effect:
recommendations.append(
f"Causal insight: {best_effect['cause']} improves {best_effect['effect']} by {best_effect['uplift']:.1%}"
)
return recommendations
# Global instance for backward compatibility
_agentdb_bridge = None
def get_real_agentdb_bridge(db_path: Optional[str] = None) -> RealAgentDBBridge:
"""Get the global real AgentDB bridge instance"""
global _agentdb_bridge
if _agentdb_bridge is None:
_agentdb_bridge = RealAgentDBBridge(db_path)
return _agentdb_bridge
def is_agentdb_available() -> bool:
"""Check if AgentDB is available"""
try:
bridge = get_real_agentdb_bridge()
return bridge.is_available
except:
return False

528
integrations/fallback_system.py
View file

@ -1,528 +0,0 @@
#!/usr/bin/python3
"""
Graceful Fallback System - Ensures Reliability Without AgentDB
Provides fallback mechanisms when AgentDB is unavailable.
The system is designed to be completely invisible to users - they never notice
when fallback mode is active.
All complexity is hidden behind seamless transitions.
"""
import logging
import json
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, Any, Optional, List
from dataclasses import dataclass
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@dataclass
class FallbackConfig:
"""Configuration for fallback behavior"""
enable_intelligent_fallbacks: bool = True
cache_duration_hours: int = 24
auto_retry_attempts: int = 3
fallback_timeout_seconds: int = 30
preserve_learning_when_available: bool = True
class FallbackMode:
"""
Represents different fallback modes when AgentDB is unavailable
"""
OFFLINE = "offline" # No AgentDB, use cached data only
DEGRADED = "degraded" # Basic AgentDB features, full functionality later
SIMULATED = "simulated" # Simulate AgentDB responses for learning
RECOVERING = "recovering" # AgentDB was down, now recovering
class GracefulFallbackSystem:
"""
Invisible fallback system that ensures agent-creator always works,
with or without AgentDB.
Users never see fallback messages or errors - they just get
consistent, reliable agent creation.
"""
def __init__(self, config: Optional[FallbackConfig] = None):
self.config = config or FallbackConfig()
self.current_mode = FallbackMode.OFFLINE
self.agentdb_available = self._check_agentdb_availability()
self.cache = {}
self.error_count = 0
self.last_check = None
self.learning_cache = {}
# Initialize appropriate mode
self._initialize_fallback_mode()
def _check_agentdb_availability(self) -> bool:
"""Check if AgentDB is available"""
try:
import subprocess
result = subprocess.run(
["npx", "agentdb", "--version"],
capture_output=True,
text=True,
timeout=10
)
return result.returncode == 0
except:
return False
def _initialize_fallback_mode(self):
"""Initialize appropriate fallback mode"""
if self.agentdb_available:
self.current_mode = FallbackMode.DEGRADED
self._setup_degraded_mode()
else:
self.current_mode = FallbackMode.OFFLINE
self._setup_offline_mode()
def enhance_agent_creation(self, user_input: str, domain: str = None) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Enhance agent creation with fallback intelligence.
Returns AgentDB-style intelligence data (or fallback equivalent).
"""
try:
if self.current_mode == FallbackMode.OFFLINE:
return self._offline_enhancement(user_input, domain)
elif self.current_mode == FallbackMode.DEGRADED:
return self._degraded_enhancement(user_input, domain)
elif self.current_mode == FallbackMode.SIMULATED:
return self._simulated_enhancement(user_input, domain)
else:
return self._full_enhancement(user_input, domain)
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Fallback enhancement failed: {e}")
self._fallback_to_offline()
return self._offline_enhancement(user_input, domain)
def enhance_template(self, template_name: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Enhance template with fallback intelligence.
Returns AgentDB-style enhancements (or fallback equivalent).
"""
try:
if self.current_mode == FallbackMode.OFFLINE:
return self._offline_template_enhancement(template_name, domain)
elif self.current_mode == FallbackMode.DEGRADED:
return self._degraded_template_enhancement(template_name, domain)
elif self.current_mode == Fallback_mode.SIMULATED:
return self._simulated_template_enhancement(template_name, domain)
else:
return self._full_template_enhancement(template_name, domain)
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Template enhancement fallback failed: {e}")
return self._offline_template_enhancement(template_name, domain)
def store_agent_experience(self, agent_name: str, experience: Dict[str, Any]):
"""
Store agent experience for learning with fallback.
Stores when AgentDB is available, caches when it's not.
"""
try:
if self.current_mode == FallbackMode.OFFLINE:
# Cache for later when AgentDB comes back online
self._cache_experience(agent_name, experience)
elif self.current_mode == FallbackMode.DEGRADED:
# Store basic metrics
self._degraded_store_experience(agent_name, experience)
elif self.current_mode == FallbackMode.SIMULATED:
# Simulate storage
self._simulated_store_experience(agent_name, experience)
else:
# Full AgentDB storage
self._full_store_experience(agent_name, experience)
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Experience storage fallback failed: {e}")
self._cache_experience(agent_name, experience)
def check_agentdb_status(self) -> bool:
"""
Check AgentDB status and recover if needed.
Runs automatically in background.
"""
try:
# Check if status has changed
current_availability = self._check_agentdb_availability()
if current_availability != self.agentdb_available:
if current_availability:
# AgentDB came back online
self._recover_agentdb()
else:
# AgentDB went offline
self._enter_offline_mode()
self.agentdb_available = current_availability
return current_availability
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"AgentDB status check failed: {e}")
return False
def _offline_enhancement(self, user_input: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Provide enhancement without AgentDB (offline mode)"""
return {
"template_choice": self._select_fallback_template(user_input, domain),
"success_probability": 0.75, # Conservative estimate
"learned_improvements": self._get_cached_improvements(domain),
"historical_context": {
"fallback_mode": True,
"estimated_success_rate": 0.75,
"based_on": "cached_patterns"
},
"mathematical_proof": "fallback_proof",
"fallback_active": True
}
def _degraded_enhancement(self, user_input: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Provide enhancement with limited AgentDB features"""
try:
# Try to use available AgentDB features
from integrations.agentdb_bridge import get_agentdb_bridge
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
if bridge.is_available:
# Use what's available
intelligence = bridge.enhance_agent_creation(user_input, domain)
# Mark as degraded
intelligence["degraded_mode"] = True
intelligence["fallback_active"] = False
intelligence["limited_features"] = True
return intelligence
else:
# Fallback to offline
return self._offline_enhancement(user_input, domain)
except Exception:
return self._offline_enhancement(user_input, domain)
def _simulated_enhancement(self, user_input: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Provide enhancement with simulated AgentDB responses"""
import random
# Generate realistic-looking intelligence data
templates = {
"finance": "financial-analysis",
"climate": "climate-analysis",
"ecommerce": "e-commerce-analytics",
"research": "research-data-collection"
}
template_choice = templates.get(domain, "default-template")
return {
"template_choice": template_choice,
"success_probability": random.uniform(0.8, 0.95), # High but realistic
"learned_improvements": [
f"simulated_improvement_{random.randint(1, 5)}",
f"enhanced_validation_{random.randint(1, 3)}"
],
"historical_context": {
"fallback_mode": True,
"simulated": True,
"estimated_success_rate": random.uniform(0.8, 0.9)
},
"mathematical_proof": f"simulated_proof_{random.randint(10000, 99999)}",
"fallback_active": False,
"simulated_mode": True
}
def _offline_template_enhancement(self, template_name: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Enhance template with cached data"""
cache_key = f"template_{template_name}_{domain}"
if cache_key in self.cache:
return self.cache[cache_key]
# Fallback enhancement
enhancement = {
"agentdb_integration": {
"enabled": False,
"fallback_mode": True,
"success_rate": 0.75,
"learned_improvements": self._get_cached_improvements(domain)
}
}
# Cache for future use
self.cache[cache_key] = enhancement
return enhancement
def _degraded_template_enhancement(self, template_name: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Enhance template with basic AgentDB features"""
enhancement = self._offline_template_enhancement(template_name, domain)
# Add basic AgentDB indicators
enhancement["agentdb_integration"]["limited_features"] = True
enhancement["agentdb_integration"]["degraded_mode"] = True
return enhancement
def _simulated_template_enhancement(self, template_name: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Enhance template with simulated learning"""
enhancement = self._offline_template_enhancement(template_name, domain)
# Add simulation indicators
enhancement["agentdb_integration"]["simulated_mode"] = True
enhancement["agentdb_integration"]["success_rate"] = 0.88 # Good simulated performance
return enhancement
def _full_enhancement(self, user_input: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Full enhancement with complete AgentDB features"""
try:
from integrations.agentdb_bridge import get_agentdb_bridge
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
return bridge.enhance_agent_creation(user_input, domain)
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Full enhancement failed: {e}")
return self._degraded_enhancement(user_input, domain)
def _full_template_enhancement(self, template_name: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Full template enhancement with complete AgentDB features"""
try:
from integrations.agentdb_bridge import get_agentdb_bridge
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
return bridge.enhance_template(template_name, domain)
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Full template enhancement failed: {e}")
return self._degraded_template_enhancement(template_name, domain)
def _cache_experience(self, agent_name: str, experience: Dict[str, Any]):
"""Cache experience for later storage"""
cache_key = f"experience_{agent_name}_{datetime.now().strftime('%Y%m%d-%H%M%S')}"
self.cache[cache_key] = {
"data": experience,
"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat(),
"needs_sync": True
}
def _degraded_store_experience(self, agent_name: str, experience: Dict[str, Any]):
"""Store basic experience metrics"""
try:
# Create simple summary
summary = {
"agent_name": agent_name,
"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat(),
"success_rate": experience.get("success_rate", 0.5),
"execution_time": experience.get("execution_time", 0),
"fallback_mode": True
}
# Cache for later full storage
self._cache_experience(agent_name, summary)
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Degraded experience storage failed: {e}")
def _simulated_store_experience(self, agent_name: str, experience: Dict[str, Any]):
"""Simulate experience storage"""
# Just log that it would be stored
logger.info(f"Simulated storage for {agent_name}: {experience.get('success_rate', 'unknown')} success rate")
def _full_store_experience(self, agent_name: str, experience: Dict[str, Any]):
"""Full experience storage with AgentDB"""
try:
from integrations.agentdb_bridge import get_agentdb_bridge
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
bridge.store_agent_experience(agent_name, experience)
# Sync cached experiences if needed
self._sync_cached_experiences()
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Full experience storage failed: {e}")
self._cache_experience(agent_name, experience)
def _select_fallback_template(self, user_input: str, domain: str) -> str:
"""Select appropriate template in fallback mode"""
template_map = {
"finance": "financial-analysis",
"trading": "financial-analysis",
"stock": "financial-analysis",
"climate": "climate-analysis",
"weather": "climate-analysis",
"temperature": "climate-analysis",
"ecommerce": "e-commerce-analytics",
"store": "e-commerce-analytics",
"shop": "e-commerce-analytics",
"sales": "e-commerce-analytics",
"research": "research-data-collection",
"data": "research-data-collection",
"articles": "research-data-collection"
}
# Direct domain matching
if domain and domain.lower() in template_map:
return template_map[domain.lower()]
# Keyword matching from user input
user_lower = user_input.lower()
for keyword, template in template_map.items():
if keyword in user_lower:
return template
return "default-template"
def _get_cached_improvements(self, domain: str) -> List[str]:
"""Get cached improvements for a domain"""
cache_key = f"improvements_{domain}"
# Return realistic cached improvements
improvements_map = {
"finance": [
"enhanced_rsi_calculation",
"improved_error_handling",
"smart_data_caching"
],
"climate": [
"temperature_anomaly_detection",
"seasonal_pattern_analysis",
"trend_calculation"
],
"ecommerce": [
"customer_segmentation",
"inventory_optimization",
"sales_prediction"
],
"research": [
"article_classification",
"bibliography_formatting",
"data_extraction"
]
}
return improvements_map.get(domain, ["basic_improvement"])
def _fallback_to_offline(self):
"""Enter offline mode gracefully"""
self.current_mode = FallbackMode.OFFLINE
self._setup_offline_mode()
logger.warning("Entering offline mode - AgentDB unavailable")
def _setup_offline_mode(self):
"""Setup offline mode configuration"""
# Clear any temporary AgentDB data
logger.info("Configuring offline mode - using cached data only")
def _setup_degraded_mode(self):
"""Setup degraded mode configuration"""
logger.info("Configuring degraded mode - limited AgentDB features")
def _recover_agentdb(self):
"""Recover from offline/degraded mode"""
try:
self.current_mode = FallbackMode.RECOVERING
logger.info("Recovering AgentDB connectivity...")
# Sync cached experiences
self._sync_cached_experiences()
# Re-initialize AgentDB
from .agentdb_bridge import get_agentdb_bridge
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
# Test connection
test_result = bridge._execute_agentdb_command(["npx", "agentdb", "ping"])
if test_result:
self.current_mode = FallbackMode.DEGRADED
self.agentdb_available = True
logger.info("AgentDB recovered - entering degraded mode")
else:
self._fallback_to_offline()
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"AgentDB recovery failed: {e}")
self._fallback_to_offline()
def _sync_cached_experiences(self):
"""Sync cached experiences to AgentDB when available"""
try:
if not self.agentdb_available:
return
from integrations.agentdb_bridge import get_agentdb_bridge
bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
for cache_key, cached_data in self.cache.items():
if cached_data.get("needs_sync"):
try:
# Extract data and store
experience_data = cached_data.get("data")
agent_name = cache_key.split("_")[1]
bridge.store_agent_experience(agent_name, experience_data)
# Mark as synced
cached_data["needs_sync"] = False
logger.info(f"Synced cached experience for {agent_name}")
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to sync cached experience {cache_key}: {e}")
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to sync cached experiences: {e}")
def get_fallback_status(self) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Get current fallback status (for internal monitoring)"""
return {
"current_mode": self.current_mode,
"agentdb_available": self.agentdb_available,
"error_count": self.error_count,
"cache_size": len(self.cache),
"learning_cache_size": len(self.learning_cache),
"last_check": self.last_check
}
# Global fallback system (invisible to users)
_graceful_fallback = None
def get_graceful_fallback_system(config: Optional[FallbackConfig] = None) -> GracefulFallbackSystem:
"""Get the global graceful fallback system instance"""
global _graceful_fallback
if _graceful_fallback is None:
_graceful_fallback = GracefulFallbackSystem(config)
return _graceful_fallback
def enhance_with_fallback(user_input: str, domain: str = None) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Enhance agent creation with fallback support.
Automatically handles AgentDB availability.
"""
system = get_graceful_fallback_system()
return system.enhance_agent_creation(user_input, domain)
def enhance_template_with_fallback(template_name: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Enhance template with fallback support.
Automatically handles AgentDB availability.
"""
system = get_graceful_fallback_system()
return system.enhance_template(template_name, domain)
def store_experience_with_fallback(agent_name: str, experience: Dict[str, Any]):
"""
Store agent experience with fallback support.
Automatically handles AgentDB availability.
"""
system = get_graceful_fallback_system()
system.store_agent_experience(agent_name, experience)
def check_fallback_status() -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Get fallback system status for internal monitoring.
"""
system = get_graceful_fallback_system()
return system.get_fallback_status()
# Auto-initialize when module is imported
get_graceful_fallback_system()

390
integrations/learning_feedback.py
View file

@ -1,390 +0,0 @@
#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""
Learning Feedback System - Subtle Progress Indicators
Provides subtle, non-intrusive feedback about agent learning progress.
Users see natural improvement without being overwhelmed with technical details.
All feedback is designed to feel like "smart magic" rather than "system notifications".
"""
import json
import time
import logging
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, Any, List, Optional
from dataclasses import dataclass
from datetime import datetime, timedelta
from agentdb_bridge import get_agentdb_bridge
from validation_system import get_validation_system
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@dataclass
class LearningMilestone:
"""Represents a learning milestone achieved by an agent"""
milestone_type: str
description: str
impact: str # How this benefits the user
confidence: float
timestamp: datetime
class LearningFeedbackSystem:
"""
Provides subtle feedback about agent learning progress.
All feedback is designed to feel natural and helpful,
not technical or overwhelming.
"""
def __init__(self):
self.agentdb_bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
self.validation_system = get_validation_system()
self.feedback_history = []
self.user_patterns = {}
self.milestones_achieved = []
def analyze_agent_usage(self, agent_name: str, user_input: str, execution_time: float,
success: bool, result_quality: float) -> Optional[str]:
"""
Analyze agent usage and provide subtle feedback if appropriate.
Returns feedback message or None if no feedback needed.
"""
try:
# Track user patterns
self._track_user_pattern(agent_name, user_input, execution_time)
# Check for learning milestones
milestone = self._check_for_milestone(agent_name, execution_time, success, result_quality)
if milestone:
self.milestones_achieved.append(milestone)
return self._format_milestone_feedback(milestone)
# Check for improvement indicators
improvement = self._detect_improvement(agent_name, execution_time, result_quality)
if improvement:
return self._format_improvement_feedback(improvement)
# Check for pattern recognition
pattern_feedback = self._generate_pattern_feedback(agent_name, user_input)
if pattern_feedback:
return pattern_feedback
except Exception as e:
logger.debug(f"Failed to analyze agent usage: {e}")
return None
def _track_user_pattern(self, agent_name: str, user_input: str, execution_time: float):
"""Track user interaction patterns"""
if agent_name not in self.user_patterns:
self.user_patterns[agent_name] = {
"queries": [],
"times": [],
"successes": [],
"execution_times": [],
"first_interaction": datetime.now()
}
pattern = self.user_patterns[agent_name]
pattern["queries"].append(user_input)
pattern["times"].append(execution_time)
pattern["successes"].append(success)
pattern["execution_times"].append(execution_time)
# Keep only last 100 interactions
for key in ["queries", "times", "successes", "execution_times"]:
if len(pattern[key]) > 100:
pattern[key] = pattern[key][-100:]
def _check_for_milestone(self, agent_name: str, execution_time: float,
success: bool, result_quality: float) -> Optional[LearningMilestone]:
"""Check if user achieved a learning milestone"""
pattern = self.user_patterns.get(agent_name, {})
# Milestone 1: First successful execution
if len(pattern.get("successes", [])) == 1 and success:
return LearningMilestone(
milestone_type="first_success",
description="First successful execution",
impact=f"Agent {agent_name} is now active and learning",
confidence=0.9,
timestamp=datetime.now()
)
# Milestone 2: Consistency (10 successful uses)
success_count = len([s for s in pattern.get("successes", []) if s])
if success_count == 10:
return LearningMilestone(
milestone_type="consistency",
description="10 successful executions",
impact=f"Agent {agent_name} is reliable and consistent",
confidence=0.85,
timestamp=datetime.now()
)
# Milestone 3: Speed improvement (20% faster than average)
if len(pattern.get("execution_times", [])) >= 10:
recent_times = pattern["execution_times"][-5:]
early_times = pattern["execution_times"][:5]
recent_avg = sum(recent_times) / len(recent_times)
early_avg = sum(early_times) / len(early_times)
if early_avg > 0 and recent_avg < early_avg * 0.8: # 20% improvement
return LearningMilestone(
milestone_type="speed_improvement",
description="20% faster execution speed",
impact=f"Agent {agent_name} has optimized and become faster",
confidence=0.8,
timestamp=datetime.now()
)
# Milestone 4: Long-term relationship (30 days)
if pattern.get("first_interaction"):
days_since_first = (datetime.now() - pattern["first_interaction"]).days
if days_since_first >= 30:
return LearningMilestone(
milestone_type="long_term_usage",
description="30 days of consistent usage",
impact=f"Agent {agent_name} has learned your preferences over time",
confidence=0.95,
timestamp=datetime.now()
)
return None
def _detect_improvement(self, agent_name: str, execution_time: float,
result_quality: float) -> Optional[Dict[str, Any]]:
"""Detect if agent shows improvement signs"""
pattern = self.user_patterns.get(agent_name, {})
if len(pattern.get("execution_times", [])) < 5:
return None
recent_times = pattern["execution_times"][-3:]
avg_recent = sum(recent_times) / len(recent_times)
# Check speed improvement
if avg_recent < 2.0: # Fast execution
return {
"type": "speed",
"message": f"⚡ Agent is responding quickly",
"detail": f"Average time: {avg_recent:.1f}s"
}
# Check quality improvement
if result_quality > 0.9:
return {
"type": "quality",
"message": f"✨ High quality results detected",
"detail": f"Result quality: {result_quality:.1%}"
}
return None
def _generate_pattern_feedback(self, agent_name: str, user_input: str) -> Optional[str]:
"""Generate feedback based on user interaction patterns"""
pattern = self.user_patterns.get(agent_name, {})
if len(pattern.get("queries", [])) < 5:
return None
queries = pattern["queries"]
# Check for time-based patterns
hour = datetime.now().hour
weekday = datetime.now().weekday()
# Morning patterns
if 6 <= hour <= 9 and len([q for q in queries[-5:] if "morning" in q.lower() or "today" in q.lower()]) >= 3:
return f"🌅 Good morning! {agent_name} is ready for your daily analysis"
# Friday patterns
if weekday == 4 and len([q for q in queries[-10:] if "week" in q.lower() or "friday" in q.lower()]) >= 2:
return f"📊 {agent_name} is preparing your weekly summary"
# End of month patterns
day_of_month = datetime.now().day
if day_of_month >= 28 and len([q for q in queries[-10:] if "month" in q.lower()]) >= 2:
return f"📈 {agent_name} is ready for your monthly reports"
return None
def _format_milestone_feedback(self, milestone: LearningMilestone) -> str:
"""Format milestone feedback to feel natural and encouraging"""
messages = {
"first_success": [
f"🎉 Congratulations! {milestone.description}",
f"🎉 Agent is now active and ready to assist you!"
],
"consistency": [
f"🎯 Excellent! {milestone.description}",
f"🎯 Your agent has proven its reliability"
],
"speed_improvement": [
f"⚡ Amazing! {milestone.description}",
f"⚡ Your agent is getting much faster with experience"
],
"long_term_usage": [
f"🌟 Fantastic! {milestone.description}",
f"🌟 Your agent has learned your preferences and patterns"
]
}
message_set = messages.get(milestone.milestone_type, ["✨ Milestone achieved!"])
return message_set[0] if message_set else f"✨ {milestone.description}"
def _format_improvement_feedback(self, improvement: Dict[str, Any]) -> str:
"""Format improvement feedback to feel helpful but not overwhelming"""
if improvement["type"] == "speed":
return f"{improvement['message']} ({improvement['detail']})"
elif improvement["type"] == "quality":
return f"{improvement['message']} ({improvement['detail']})"
else:
return improvement["message"]
def get_learning_summary(self, agent_name: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Get comprehensive learning summary for an agent"""
try:
# Get AgentDB learning summary
agentdb_summary = self.agentdb_bridge.get_learning_summary(agent_name)
# Get validation summary
validation_summary = self.validation_system.get_validation_summary()
# Get user patterns
pattern = self.user_patterns.get(agent_name, {})
# Calculate user statistics
total_queries = len(pattern.get("queries", []))
success_rate = (sum(pattern.get("successes", [])) / len(pattern.get("successes", [False])) * 100) if pattern.get("successes") else 0
avg_time = sum(pattern.get("execution_times", [])) / len(pattern.get("execution_times", [1])) if pattern.get("execution_times") else 0
# Get milestones
milestones = [m for m in self.milestones_achieved if m.description and agent_name.lower() in m.description.lower()]
return {
"agent_name": agent_name,
"agentdb_learning": agentdb_summary,
"validation_performance": validation_summary,
"user_statistics": {
"total_queries": total_queries,
"success_rate": success_rate,
"average_time": avg_time,
"first_interaction": pattern.get("first_interaction"),
"last_interaction": datetime.now() if pattern else None
},
"milestones_achieved": [
{
"type": m.milestone_type,
"description": m.description,
"impact": m.impact,
"confidence": m.confidence,
"timestamp": m.timestamp.isoformat()
}
for m in milestones
],
"learning_progress": self._calculate_progress_score(agent_name)
}
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to get learning summary: {e}")
return {"error": str(e)}
def _calculate_progress_score(self, agent_name: str) -> float:
"""Calculate overall learning progress score"""
score = 0.0
# AgentDB contributions (40%)
try:
agentdb_summary = self.agentdb_bridge.get_learning_summary(agent_name)
if agentdb_summary and agentdb_summary.get("total_sessions", 0) > 0:
score += min(0.4, agentdb_summary["success_rate"] * 0.4)
except:
pass
# User engagement (30%)
pattern = self.user_patterns.get(agent_name, {})
if pattern.get("successes"):
engagement_rate = sum(pattern["successes"]) / len(pattern["successes"])
score += min(0.3, engagement_rate * 0.3)
# Milestones (20%)
milestone_score = min(len(self.milestones_achieved) / 4, 0.2) # Max 4 milestones
score += milestone_score
# Consistency (10%)
if len(pattern.get("successes", [])) >= 10:
consistency = sum(pattern["successes"][-10:]) / 10
score += min(0.1, consistency * 0.1)
return min(score, 1.0)
def suggest_personalization(self, agent_name: str) -> Optional[str]:
"""
Suggest personalization based on learned patterns.
Returns subtle suggestion or None.
"""
try:
pattern = self.user_patterns.get(agent_name, {})
# Check if user always asks for similar things
recent_queries = pattern.get("queries", [])[-10:]
# Look for common themes
themes = {}
for query in recent_queries:
words = query.lower().split()
for word in words:
if len(word) > 3: # Ignore short words
themes[word] = themes.get(word, 0) + 1
# Find most common theme
if themes:
top_theme = max(themes, key=themes.get)
if themes[top_theme] >= 3: # Appears in 3+ recent queries
return f"🎯 I notice you often ask about {top_theme}. Consider creating a specialized agent for this."
except Exception as e:
logger.debug(f"Failed to suggest personalization: {e}")
return None
# Global feedback system (invisible to users)
_learning_feedback_system = None
def get_learning_feedback_system() -> LearningFeedbackSystem:
"""Get the global learning feedback system instance"""
global _learning_feedback_system
if _learning_feedback_system is None:
_learning_feedback_system = LearningFeedbackSystem()
return _learning_feedback_system
def analyze_agent_execution(agent_name: str, user_input: str, execution_time: float,
success: bool, result_quality: float) -> Optional[str]:
"""
Analyze agent execution and provide learning feedback.
Called automatically after each agent execution.
"""
system = get_learning_feedback_system()
return system.analyze_agent_usage(agent_name, user_input, execution_time, success, result_quality)
def get_agent_learning_summary(agent_name: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Get comprehensive learning summary for an agent.
Used internally for progress tracking.
"""
system = get_learning_feedback_system()
return system.get_learning_summary(agent_name)
def suggest_agent_personalization(agent_name: str) -> Optional[str]:
"""
Suggest personalization based on learned patterns.
Used when appropriate to enhance user experience.
"""
system = get_learning_feedback_system()
return system.suggest_personalization(agent_name)
# Auto-initialize when module is imported
get_learning_feedback_system()

466
integrations/validation_system.py
View file

@ -1,466 +0,0 @@
#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""
Mathematical Validation System - Invisible but Powerful
Provides mathematical proofs and validation for all agent creation decisions.
Users never see this complexity - they just get higher quality agents.
All validation happens transparently in the background.
"""
import hashlib
import json
import logging
from pathlib import Path
from typing import Dict, Any, Optional, List
from dataclasses import dataclass
from datetime import datetime
from agentdb_bridge import get_agentdb_bridge
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@dataclass
class ValidationResult:
"""Container for validation results with mathematical proofs"""
is_valid: bool
confidence: float
proof_hash: str
validation_type: str
details: Dict[str, Any]
recommendations: List[str]
class MathematicalValidationSystem:
"""
Invisible validation system that provides mathematical proofs for all decisions.
Users never interact with this directly - it runs automatically
and ensures all agent creation decisions are mathematically sound.
"""
def __init__(self):
self.validation_history = []
self.agentdb_bridge = get_agentdb_bridge()
def validate_template_selection(self, template: str, user_input: str, domain: str) -> ValidationResult:
"""
Validate template selection with mathematical proof.
This runs automatically during agent creation.
"""
try:
# Get historical success data from AgentDB
historical_data = self._get_template_historical_data(template, domain)
# Calculate confidence score
confidence = self._calculate_template_confidence(template, historical_data, user_input)
# Generate mathematical proof
proof_data = {
"template": template,
"domain": domain,
"user_input_hash": self._hash_input(user_input),
"historical_success_rate": historical_data.get("success_rate", 0.8),
"usage_count": historical_data.get("usage_count", 0),
"calculated_confidence": confidence,
"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat()
}
proof_hash = self._generate_merkle_proof(proof_data)
# Determine validation result
is_valid = confidence > 0.7 # 70% confidence threshold
recommendations = []
if not is_valid:
recommendations.append("Consider using a more specialized template")
recommendations.append("Add more specific details about your requirements")
result = ValidationResult(
is_valid=is_valid,
confidence=confidence,
proof_hash=proof_hash,
validation_type="template_selection",
details=proof_data,
recommendations=recommendations
)
# Store validation for learning
self._store_validation_result(result)
logger.info(f"Template validation: {template} - {confidence:.1%} confidence - {'✓' if is_valid else '✗'}")
return result
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Template validation failed: {e}")
return self._create_fallback_validation("template_selection", template)
def validate_api_selection(self, apis: List[Dict], domain: str) -> ValidationResult:
"""
Validate API selection with mathematical proof.
Runs automatically during Phase 1 of agent creation.
"""
try:
# Calculate API confidence scores
api_scores = []
for api in apis:
score = self._calculate_api_confidence(api, domain)
api_scores.append((api, score))
# Sort by confidence
api_scores.sort(key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True)
best_api = api_scores[0][0]
confidence = api_scores[0][1]
# Generate proof
proof_data = {
"selected_api": best_api["name"],
"domain": domain,
"confidence_score": confidence,
"all_apis": [{"name": api["name"], "score": score} for api, score in api_scores],
"selection_criteria": ["rate_limit", "data_coverage", "reliability"],
"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat()
}
proof_hash = self._generate_merkle_proof(proof_data)
# Validation result
is_valid = confidence > 0.6 # 60% confidence for APIs
recommendations = []
if not is_valid:
recommendations.append("Consider premium API for better data quality")
recommendations.append("Verify rate limits meet your requirements")
result = ValidationResult(
is_valid=is_valid,
confidence=confidence,
proof_hash=proof_hash,
validation_type="api_selection",
details=proof_data,
recommendations=recommendations
)
self._store_validation_result(result)
return result
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"API validation failed: {e}")
return self._create_fallback_validation("api_selection", apis[0] if apis else None)
def validate_architecture(self, structure: Dict, complexity: str, domain: str) -> ValidationResult:
"""
Validate architectural decisions with mathematical proof.
Runs automatically during Phase 3 of agent creation.
"""
try:
# Calculate architecture confidence
confidence = self._calculate_architecture_confidence(structure, complexity, domain)
# Generate proof
proof_data = {
"complexity": complexity,
"domain": domain,
"structure_score": confidence,
"structure_analysis": self._analyze_structure(structure),
"best_practices_compliance": self._check_best_practices(structure),
"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat()
}
proof_hash = self._generate_merkle_proof(proof_data)
# Validation result
is_valid = confidence > 0.75 # 75% confidence for architecture
recommendations = []
if not is_valid:
recommendations.append("Consider simplifying the agent structure")
recommendations.append("Add more modular components")
result = ValidationResult(
is_valid=is_valid,
confidence=confidence,
proof_hash=proof_hash,
validation_type="architecture",
details=proof_data,
recommendations=recommendations
)
self._store_validation_result(result)
return result
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Architecture validation failed: {e}")
return self._create_fallback_validation("architecture", structure)
def _get_template_historical_data(self, template: str, domain: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Get historical data for template from AgentDB or fallback"""
# Try to get from AgentDB
try:
result = self.agentdb_bridge._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "causal", "recall",
f"template_success_rate:{template}",
"--format", "json"
])
if result:
return json.loads(result)
except:
pass
# Fallback data
return {
"success_rate": 0.85,
"usage_count": 100,
"last_updated": datetime.now().isoformat()
}
def _calculate_template_confidence(self, template: str, historical_data: Dict, user_input: str) -> float:
"""Calculate confidence score for template selection"""
base_confidence = 0.7
# Historical success rate influence
success_rate = historical_data.get("success_rate", 0.8)
historical_weight = min(0.2, historical_data.get("usage_count", 0) / 1000)
# Domain matching influence
domain_boost = 0.1 if self._domain_matches_template(template, user_input) else 0
# Calculate final confidence
confidence = base_confidence + (success_rate * 0.2) + domain_boost
return min(confidence, 0.95) # Cap at 95%
def _calculate_api_confidence(self, api: Dict, domain: str) -> float:
"""Calculate confidence score for API selection"""
score = 0.5 # Base score
# Data coverage
if api.get("data_coverage", "").lower() in ["global", "worldwide", "unlimited"]:
score += 0.2
# Rate limit consideration
rate_limit = api.get("rate_limit", "").lower()
if "unlimited" in rate_limit:
score += 0.2
elif "free" in rate_limit:
score += 0.1
# Type consideration
api_type = api.get("type", "").lower()
if api_type in ["free", "freemium"]:
score += 0.1
return min(score, 1.0)
def _calculate_architecture_confidence(self, structure: Dict, complexity: str, domain: str) -> float:
"""Calculate confidence score for architecture"""
score = 0.6 # Base score
# Structure complexity
if structure.get("type") == "modular":
score += 0.2
elif structure.get("type") == "integrated":
score += 0.1
# Directories present
required_dirs = ["scripts", "tests", "references"]
found_dirs = sum(1 for dir in required_dirs if dir in structure.get("directories", []))
score += (found_dirs / len(required_dirs)) * 0.1
# Complexity matching
complexity_match = {
"low": {"simple": 0.2, "modular": 0.1},
"medium": {"modular": 0.2, "integrated": 0.1},
"high": {"integrated": 0.2, "modular": 0.0}
}
if complexity in complexity_match:
structure_type = structure.get("type", "")
score += complexity_match[complexity].get(structure_type, 0)
return min(score, 1.0)
def _domain_matches_template(self, template: str, user_input: str) -> bool:
"""Check if template domain matches user input"""
domain_keywords = {
"financial": ["finance", "stock", "trading", "investment", "money", "market"],
"climate": ["climate", "weather", "temperature", "environment", "carbon"],
"ecommerce": ["ecommerce", "store", "shop", "sales", "customer", "inventory"]
}
template_lower = template.lower()
input_lower = user_input.lower()
for domain, keywords in domain_keywords.items():
if domain in template_lower:
return any(keyword in input_lower for keyword in keywords)
return False
def _analyze_structure(self, structure: Dict) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Analyze agent structure"""
return {
"has_scripts": "scripts" in structure.get("directories", []),
"has_tests": "tests" in structure.get("directories", []),
"has_references": "references" in structure.get("directories", []),
"has_utils": "utils" in structure.get("directories", []),
"directory_count": len(structure.get("directories", [])),
"type": structure.get("type", "unknown")
}
def _check_best_practices(self, structure: Dict) -> List[str]:
"""Check compliance with best practices"""
practices = []
# Check for required directories
required = ["scripts", "tests"]
missing = [dir for dir in required if dir not in structure.get("directories", [])]
if missing:
practices.append(f"Missing directories: {', '.join(missing)}")
# Check for utils subdirectory
if "scripts" in structure.get("directories", []):
if "utils" not in structure:
practices.append("Missing utils subdirectory in scripts")
return practices
def _generate_merkle_proof(self, data: Dict) -> str:
"""Generate Merkle proof for mathematical validation"""
try:
# Convert data to JSON string
data_str = json.dumps(data, sort_keys=True)
# Create hash
proof_hash = hashlib.sha256(data_str.encode()).hexdigest()
# Create Merkle root (simplified for single node)
merkle_root = f"leaf:{proof_hash}"
return merkle_root
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Failed to generate Merkle proof: {e}")
return "fallback_proof"
def _hash_input(self, user_input: str) -> str:
"""Create hash of user input"""
return hashlib.sha256(user_input.encode()).hexdigest()[:16]
def _store_validation_result(self, result: ValidationResult) -> None:
"""Store validation result for learning"""
try:
# Store in AgentDB for learning
self.agentdb_bridge._execute_agentdb_command([
"npx", "agentdb", "reflexion", "store",
f"validation-{datetime.now().strftime('%Y%m%d-%H%M%S')}",
result.validation_type,
str(int(result.confidence * 100))
])
# Add to local history
self.validation_history.append({
"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat(),
"type": result.validation_type,
"confidence": result.confidence,
"is_valid": result.is_valid,
"proof_hash": result.proof_hash
})
# Keep only last 100 validations
if len(self.validation_history) > 100:
self.validation_history = self.validation_history[-100:]
except Exception as e:
logger.debug(f"Failed to store validation result: {e}")
def _create_fallback_validation(self, validation_type: str, subject: Any) -> ValidationResult:
"""Create fallback validation when system fails"""
return ValidationResult(
is_valid=True, # Assume valid for safety
confidence=0.5, # Medium confidence
proof_hash="fallback_proof",
validation_type=validation_type,
details={"fallback": True, "subject": str(subject)},
recommendations=["Consider reviewing manually"]
)
def get_validation_summary(self) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Get summary of all validations (for internal use)"""
if not self.validation_history:
return {
"total_validations": 0,
"average_confidence": 0.0,
"success_rate": 0.0,
"validation_types": {}
}
total = len(self.validation_history)
avg_confidence = sum(v["confidence"] for v in self.validation_history) / total
success_rate = sum(1 for v in self.validation_history if v["is_valid"]) / total
types = {}
for validation in self.validation_history:
vtype = validation["type"]
if vtype not in types:
types[vtype] = {"count": 0, "avg_confidence": 0.0}
types[vtype]["count"] += 1
types[vtype]["avg_confidence"] += validation["confidence"]
for vtype in types:
types[vtype]["avg_confidence"] /= types[vtype]["count"]
return {
"total_validations": total,
"average_confidence": avg_confidence,
"success_rate": success_rate,
"validation_types": types
}
# Global validation system (invisible to users)
_validation_system = None
def get_validation_system() -> MathematicalValidationSystem:
"""Get the global validation system instance"""
global _validation_system
if _validation_system is None:
_validation_system = MathematicalValidationSystem()
return _validation_system
def validate_template_selection(template: str, user_input: str, domain: str) -> ValidationResult:
"""
Validate template selection with mathematical proof.
Called automatically during agent creation.
"""
system = get_validation_system()
return system.validate_template_selection(template, user_input, domain)
def validate_api_selection(apis: List[Dict], domain: str) -> ValidationResult:
"""
Validate API selection with mathematical proof.
Called automatically during Phase 1.
"""
system = get_validation_system()
return system.validate_api_selection(apis, domain)
def validate_architecture(structure: Dict, complexity: str, domain: str) -> ValidationResult:
"""
Validate architectural decisions with mathematical proof.
Called automatically during Phase 3.
"""
system = get_validation_system()
return system.validate_architecture(structure, complexity, domain)
def get_validation_summary() -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""
Get validation summary for internal monitoring.
"""
system = get_validation_system()
return system.get_validation_summary()
# Auto-initialize when module is imported
get_validation_system()

801
references/ACTIVATION_BEST_PRACTICES.md
View file

@ -1,801 +0,0 @@
# Activation Best Practices
**Version:** 1.0
**Purpose:** Proven strategies and practical guidance for creating skills with reliable activation
---
## Overview
This guide compiles best practices, lessons learned, and proven strategies for implementing the 3-Layer Activation System. Follow these guidelines to achieve 95%+ activation reliability consistently.
### Target Audience
- **Skill Creators**: Building new skills with robust activation
- **Advanced Users**: Optimizing existing skills
- **Teams**: Establishing activation standards
### Success Criteria
✅ **95%+ activation reliability** across diverse user queries
✅ **Zero false positives** (no incorrect activations)
✅ **Natural language support** (users don't need special phrases)
✅ **Maintainable** (easy to update and extend)
---
## 🎯 Golden Rules
### Rule #1: Always Use All 3 Layers
**Don't:**
```json
{
"plugins": [{
"description": "Stock analysis tool"
}]
}
```
❌ Only Layer 3 (description) = ~70% reliability
**Do:**
```json
{
"activation": {
"keywords": ["analyze stock", "RSI indicator", ...],
"patterns": ["(?i)(analyze)\\s+.*\\s+stock", ...]
},
"plugins": [{
"description": "Comprehensive stock analysis tool with RSI, MACD..."
}]
}
```
✅ All 3 layers = 95%+ reliability
---
### Rule #2: Keywords Must Be Complete Phrases
**Don't:**
```json
"keywords": [
"create", // ❌ Too generic
"agent", // ❌ Too broad
"stock" // ❌ Single word
]
```
**Do:**
```json
"keywords": [
"create an agent for", // ✅ Complete phrase
"analyze stock", // ✅ Verb + entity
"technical analysis for" // ✅ Specific context
]
```
**Why?** Single words match everything, causing false positives.
---
### Rule #3: Patterns Must Include Action Verbs
**Don't:**
```json
"patterns": [
"(?i)(stock|stocks?)" // ❌ No action
]
```
**Do:**
```json
"patterns": [
"(?i)(analyze|analysis)\\s+.*\\s+stock" // ✅ Verb + entity
]
```
**Why?** Passive patterns activate on mentions, not intentions.
---
### Rule #4: Description Must Be Rich, Not Generic
**Don't:**
```
"Stock analysis tool"
```
❌ 3 keywords, too vague
**Do:**
```
"Comprehensive technical analysis tool for stocks and ETFs. Analyzes price movements,
volume patterns, and momentum indicators including RSI (Relative Strength Index),
MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence), Bollinger Bands, moving averages,
and chart patterns. Generates buy and sell signals based on technical indicators."
```
✅ 60+ keywords, specific capabilities
---
### Rule #5: Define Negative Scope
**Don't:**
```json
{
// No when_not_to_use section
}
```
**Do:**
```json
"usage": {
"when_not_to_use": [
"User asks for fundamental analysis (P/E ratios, earnings)",
"User wants news or sentiment analysis",
"User asks general questions about how markets work"
]
}
```
**Why?** Prevents false positives and helps users understand boundaries.
---
## 📋 Layer-by-Layer Best Practices
### Layer 1: Keywords
#### ✅ Do's
1. **Use complete phrases (2+ words)**
```json
"analyze stock" // Good
"create an agent for" // Good
"RSI indicator" // Good
```
2. **Cover all major capabilities**
- 3-5 keywords per capability
- Action keywords: "create", "analyze", "compare"
- Domain keywords: "stock", "RSI", "MACD"
- Workflow keywords: "automate workflow", "daily I have to"
3. **Include domain-specific terms**
```json
"RSI indicator"
"MACD crossover"
"Bollinger Bands"
```
4. **Use natural variations**
```json
"analyze stock"
"stock analysis"
```
#### ❌ Don'ts
1. **No single words**
```json
"stock" // ❌ Too broad
"analysis" // ❌ Too generic
```
2. **No overly generic phrases**
```json
"data analysis" // ❌ Every skill does analysis
"help me" // ❌ Too vague
```
3. **No redundancy**
```json
"analyze stock"
"analyze stocks" // ❌ Covered by pattern
"stock analyzer" // ❌ Slight variation
```
4. **Don't exceed 20 keywords**
- More keywords = diluted effectiveness
- Focus on quality, not quantity
---
### Layer 2: Patterns
#### ✅ Do's
1. **Always start with (?i) for case-insensitivity**
```regex
(?i)(analyze|analysis)\s+.*\s+stock
```
2. **Include action verb groups**
```regex
(create|build|develop|make) // Synonyms
(analyze|analysis|examine) // Variations
```
3. **Allow flexible word order**
```regex
(?i)(analyze)\\s+.*\\s+(stock)
```
Matches: "analyze AAPL stock", "analyze this stock's performance"
4. **Use optional groups for articles**
```regex
(an?\\s+)?agent
```
Matches: "an agent", "a agent", "agent"
5. **Combine verb + entity + context**
```regex
(?i)(create|build)\\s+(an?\\s+)?agent\\s+(for|to|that)
```
#### ❌ Don'ts
1. **No single-word patterns**
```regex
(?i)(stock) // ❌ Matches everything
```
2. **No overly specific patterns**
```regex
(?i)analyze AAPL stock using RSI // ❌ Too narrow
```
3. **Don't forget to escape special regex characters**
```regex
(?i)interface{} // ❌ Invalid
(?i)interface\\{\\} // ✅ Correct
```
4. **Don't create conflicting patterns**
```json
"patterns": [
"(?i)(create)\\s+.*\\s+agent",
"(?i)(create)\\s+(an?\\s+)?agent" // ❌ Redundant
]
```
#### Pattern Categories (Use 1-2 from each)
**Action + Object:**
```regex
(?i)(create|build)\\s+(an?\\s+)?agent\\s+for
```
**Domain-Specific:**
```regex
(?i)(analyze|analysis)\\s+.*\\s+(stock|ticker)
```
**Workflow:**
```regex
(?i)(every day|daily)\\s+(I|we)\\s+(have to|need)
```
**Transformation:**
```regex
(?i)(turn|convert)\\s+.*\\s+into\\s+(an?\\s+)?agent
```
**Comparison:**
```regex
(?i)(compare|rank)\\s+.*\\s+stocks?
```
---
### Layer 3: Description
#### ✅ Do's
1. **Start with primary use case**
```
"Comprehensive technical analysis tool for stocks and ETFs..."
```
2. **Include all Layer 1 keywords naturally**
```
"...analyzes price movements... RSI (Relative Strength Index)...
MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence)... Bollinger Bands..."
```
3. **Use full names for acronyms (first mention)**
```
"RSI (Relative Strength Index)" ✅
"RSI" ❌ (first mention)
```
4. **Mention target user persona**
```
"...Perfect for traders needing technical analysis..."
```
5. **Include specific capabilities**
```
"Generates buy and sell signals based on technical indicators"
```
6. **Add synonyms and variations**
```
"analyzes", "monitors", "tracks", "evaluates", "assesses"
```
#### ❌ Don'ts
1. **No keyword stuffing**
```
"Stock stock stocks analyze analysis analyzer technical..." // ❌
```
2. **No vague descriptions**
```
"A tool for data analysis" // ❌ Too generic
```
3. **No missing domain context**
```
"Calculates indicators" // ❌ What kind?
```
4. **Don't exceed 500 characters**
- Claude has limits on description processing
- Focus on quality keywords, not length
---
## 🧪 Testing Best Practices
### Test Query Design
#### ✅ Do's
1. **Create diverse test queries**
```json
"test_queries": [
"Analyze AAPL stock using RSI", // Direct keyword
"What's the technical analysis for MSFT?", // Pattern
"Show me chart patterns for AMD", // Description
"Compare AAPL vs GOOGL momentum" // Natural variation
]
```
2. **Cover all capabilities**
- At least 2 queries per major capability
- Mix of direct and natural language
- Edge cases and variations
3. **Document expected activation layer**
```json
"test_queries": [
"Analyze stock AAPL // Layer 1: keyword 'analyze stock'"
]
```
4. **Include negative tests**
```json
"negative_tests": [
"What's the P/E ratio of AAPL? // Should NOT activate"
]
```
#### ❌ Don'ts
1. **No duplicate or near-duplicate queries**
```json
"Analyze AAPL stock"
"Analyze AAPL stock price" // ❌ Too similar
```
2. **No overly similar queries**
- Test different phrasings, not same query repeatedly
3. **Don't skip negative tests**
- False positives are worse than false negatives
---
### Testing Process
**Phase 1: Layer Testing**
```bash
# Test each layer independently
1. Test all keywords (expect 100% success)
2. Test all patterns (expect 100% success)
3. Test description with edge cases (expect 90%+ success)
```
**Phase 2: Integration Testing**
```bash
# Test complete system
1. Test all test_queries (expect 95%+ success)
2. Test negative queries (expect 0% activation)
3. Document any failures
```
**Phase 3: Iteration**
```bash
# Fix and retest
1. Analyze failures
2. Update keywords/patterns/description
3. Retest
4. Repeat until 95%+ success
```
---
## 🎯 Common Patterns by Domain
### Financial/Stock Analysis
**Keywords:**
```json
[
"analyze stock",
"technical analysis for",
"RSI indicator",
"MACD indicator",
"buy signal for",
"compare stocks"
]
```
**Patterns:**
```json
[
"(?i)(analyze|analysis)\\s+.*\\s+(stock|ticker)",
"(?i)(RSI|MACD|Bollinger)\\s+(for|of|indicator)",
"(?i)(buy|sell)\\s+signal\\s+for"
]
```
---
### Data Extraction/Processing
**Keywords:**
```json
[
"extract from PDF",
"parse article",
"convert PDF to",
"extract text from"
]
```
**Patterns:**
```json
[
"(?i)(extract|parse|get)\\s+.*\\s+from\\s+(pdf|article|web)",
"(?i)(convert|transform)\\s+pdf\\s+to"
]
```
---
### Workflow Automation
**Keywords:**
```json
[
"automate workflow",
"create an agent for",
"every day I have to",
"turn process into agent"
]
```
**Patterns:**
```json
[
"(?i)(create|build)\\s+(an?\\s+)?agent\\s+for",
"(?i)(automate|automation)\\s+(workflow|process)",
"(?i)(every day|daily)\\s+I\\s+(have to|need)"
]
```
---
### Data Analysis/Comparison
**Keywords:**
```json
[
"compare data",
"rank by",
"top states by",
"analyze trend"
]
```
**Patterns:**
```json
[
"(?i)(compare|rank)\\s+.*\\s+(by|using|with)",
"(?i)(top|best)\\s+\\d*\\s+(states|countries|items)",
"(?i)(analyze|analysis)\\s+.*\\s+(trend|pattern)"
]
```
---
## 🚫 Common Mistakes & Fixes
### Mistake #1: Keywords Too Generic
**Problem:**
```json
"keywords": ["data", "analysis", "create"]
```
**Impact:** False positives - activates for everything
**Fix:**
```json
"keywords": [
"analyze stock data",
"technical analysis",
"create an agent for"
]
```
---
### Mistake #2: Patterns Too Broad
**Problem:**
```regex
(?i)(data|information)
```
**Impact:** Matches every query with "data"
**Fix:**
```regex
(?i)(analyze|process)\\s+.*\\s+(stock|market)\\s+(data|information)
```
---
### Mistake #3: Missing Action Verbs
**Problem:**
```json
"keywords": ["stock market", "financial data"]
```
**Impact:** No clear user intent, passive activation
**Fix:**
```json
"keywords": [
"analyze stock market",
"process financial data",
"monitor stock performance"
]
```
---
### Mistake #4: Insufficient Test Coverage
**Problem:**
```json
"test_queries": [
"Analyze AAPL",
"Analyze MSFT"
]
```
**Impact:** Only tests one pattern, misses variations
**Fix:**
```json
"test_queries": [
"Analyze AAPL stock using RSI", // Keyword test
"What's the technical analysis for MSFT?", // Pattern test
"Show me chart patterns for AMD", // Description test
"Compare AAPL vs GOOGL momentum", // Combination test
"Is there a buy signal for NVDA?", // Signal test
...10+ total covering all capabilities
]
```
---
### Mistake #5: No Negative Scope
**Problem:**
```json
{
// No when_not_to_use section
}
```
**Impact:** False positives, user confusion
**Fix:**
```json
"usage": {
"when_not_to_use": [
"User asks for fundamental analysis",
"User wants news/sentiment analysis",
"User asks how markets work (education)"
]
}
```
---
## ✅ Pre-Deployment Checklist
### Layer 1: Keywords
- [ ] 10-15 complete keyword phrases defined
- [ ] All keywords are 2+ words
- [ ] No overly generic keywords
- [ ] Keywords cover all major capabilities
- [ ] 3+ keywords per capability
### Layer 2: Patterns
- [ ] 5-7 regex patterns defined
- [ ] All patterns start with (?i)
- [ ] All patterns include action verb + entity
- [ ] Patterns tested with regex tester
- [ ] No patterns too broad or too narrow
### Layer 3: Description
- [ ] 300-500 character description
- [ ] 60+ unique keywords included
- [ ] All Layer 1 keywords mentioned naturally
- [ ] Primary use case stated first
- [ ] Target user persona mentioned
### Usage Section
- [ ] 5+ when_to_use cases documented
- [ ] 3+ when_not_to_use cases documented
- [ ] Example query provided
- [ ] Counter-examples documented
### Testing
- [ ] 10+ test queries covering all layers
- [ ] Queries tested in Claude Code
- [ ] Negative queries tested (no false positives)
- [ ] Overall success rate 95%+
- [ ] Failures documented and fixed
### Documentation
- [ ] README includes activation section
- [ ] 10+ activation phrase examples
- [ ] Troubleshooting section included
- [ ] Tips for reliable activation provided
---
## 🎓 Learning from Examples
### Excellent Example: stock-analyzer
**What makes it excellent:**
✅ **Complete keyword coverage (15 keywords)**
```json
"keywords": [
"analyze stock", // Primary action
"technical analysis for", // Domain-specific
"RSI indicator", // Specific feature 1
"MACD indicator", // Specific feature 2
"Bollinger Bands", // Specific feature 3
"buy signal for", // Use case 1
"compare stocks", // Use case 2
...
]
```
✅ **Well-crafted patterns (7 patterns)**
```json
"patterns": [
"(?i)(analyze|analysis)\\s+.*\\s+(stock|ticker)", // General
"(?i)(technical|chart)\\s+analysis\\s+(for|of)", // Specific
"(?i)(RSI|MACD|Bollinger)\\s+(for|of|indicator)", // Features
"(?i)(buy|sell)\\s+signal\\s+for", // Signals
...
]
```
✅ **Rich description (80+ keywords)**
```
"Comprehensive technical analysis tool for stocks and ETFs.
Analyzes price movements, volume patterns, and momentum indicators
including RSI (Relative Strength Index), MACD (Moving Average
Convergence Divergence), Bollinger Bands..."
```
✅ **Complete testing (12 positive + 7 negative queries)**
✅ **Clear boundaries (when_not_to_use section)**
**Result:** 98% activation reliability
**Location:** `references/examples/stock-analyzer/`
---
## 📚 Additional Resources
### Documentation
- **Complete Guide**: `phase4-detection.md`
- **Pattern Library**: `activation-patterns-guide.md`
- **Testing Guide**: `activation-testing-guide.md`
- **Quality Checklist**: `activation-quality-checklist.md`
### Templates
- **Marketplace Template**: `templates/marketplace-robust-template.json`
- **README Template**: `templates/README-activation-template.md`
### Examples
- **Complete Example**: `examples/stock-analyzer/`
---
## 🔄 Continuous Improvement
### Monitor Activation Performance
**Track metrics:**
- Activation success rate (target: 95%+)
- False positive rate (target: 0%)
- False negative rate (target: <5%)
- User feedback on activation issues
### Iterate Based on Feedback
**When to update:**
1. False negatives: Add keywords/patterns for missed queries
2. False positives: Narrow patterns, enhance when_not_to_use
3. New capabilities: Update all 3 layers
4. User confusion: Improve documentation
### Version Your Activation System
```json
{
"metadata": {
"version": "1.1.0",
"activation_version": "3.0",
"last_activation_update": "2025-10-23"
}
}
```
---
## 🎯 Quick Reference
### Minimum Requirements
- **Keywords**: 10+ complete phrases
- **Patterns**: 5+ regex with verbs + entities
- **Description**: 300+ chars, 60+ keywords
- **Usage**: 5+ when_to_use, 3+ when_not_to_use
- **Testing**: 10+ test queries, 95%+ success rate
### Target Goals
- **Keywords**: 12-15 phrases
- **Patterns**: 7 patterns
- **Description**: 400+ chars, 80+ keywords
- **Testing**: 15+ test queries, 98%+ success rate
- **False Positives**: 0%
### Quality Grades
- **A (Excellent)**: 95%+ success, 0% false positives
- **B (Good)**: 90-94% success, <1% false positives
- **C (Acceptable)**: 85-89% success, <2% false positives
- **F (Needs Work)**: <85% success or >2% false positives
**Only Grade A skills should be deployed to production.**
---
**Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-23
**Maintained By:** Agent-Skill-Creator Team

699
references/activation-patterns-guide.md
View file

@ -1,699 +0,0 @@
# Enhanced Activation Patterns Guide v3.1
**Version:** 3.1
**Purpose:** Library of enhanced regex patterns for 98%+ skill activation reliability
---
## Overview
This guide provides enhanced regex patterns for Layer 2 (Patterns) of the 3-Layer Activation System. All patterns are expanded to cover natural language variations and achieve 98%+ activation reliability.
### **Enhanced Pattern Structure**
```regex
(?i) → Case insensitive flag
(verb|synonyms|variations) → Expanded action verb group
\s+ → Required whitespace
(optional\s+)? → Optional modifiers
(entity|object|domain_specific) → Target entity with domain terms
\s+(connector|context) → Context connector with flexibility
```
### **Enhancement Features v3.1:**
- **Flexible Word Order**: Allows different sentence structures
- **Synonym Coverage**: 5-7 variations per action verb
- **Domain Specificity**: Technical and business language
- **Natural Language**: Conversational and informal patterns
- **Workflow Integration**: Process and automation language
### Pattern Structure
```regex
(?i) → Case insensitive flag
(verb|synonyms) → Action verb group
\s+ → Required whitespace
(optional\s+)? → Optional modifiers
(entity|object) → Target entity
\s+(connector) → Context connector
```
---
## 🚀 Enhanced Pattern Library v3.1
### **🔥 Critical Enhancement: Expanded Coverage Patterns**
#### **Problem Solved**: Natural Language Variations
**Issue**: Traditional patterns fail for natural language variations like "extract and analyze data from this website"
**Solution**: Expanded patterns covering 5x more variations
### **Pattern Categories Enhanced:**
#### **1. Data Processing & Analysis Patterns (NEW v3.1)**
#### Pattern 1.1: Data Extraction (Enhanced)
```regex
(?i)(extract|scrape|get|pull|retrieve|harvest|collect|obtain)\s+(and\s+)?(analyze|process|handle|work\s+with|examine|study|evaluate)\s+(data|information|content|details|records|dataset|metrics)\s+(from|on|of|in)\s+(website|site|url|webpage|api|database|file|source)
```
**Expanded Matches:**
- ✅ "extract data from website" (traditional)
- ✅ "extract and analyze data from this site" (enhanced)
- ✅ "scrape information from this webpage" (synonym)
- ✅ "get and process content from API" (workflow)
- ✅ "pull metrics from database" (technical)
- ✅ "harvest records from file" (advanced)
- ✅ "collect details from source" (business)
#### Pattern 1.2: Data Normalization (Enhanced)
```regex
(?i)(normalize|clean|format|standardize|structure|organize)\s+(extracted|web|scraped|collected|gathered|pulled|retrieved)\s+(data|information|content|records|metrics|dataset)
```
**Expanded Matches:**
- ✅ "normalize data" (traditional)
- ✅ "normalize extracted data" (enhanced)
- ✅ "clean scraped information" (synonym)
- ✅ "format collected records" (workflow)
- ✅ "standardize gathered metrics" (technical)
- ✅ "organize pulled dataset" (advanced)
#### Pattern 1.3: Data Analysis (Enhanced)
```regex
(?i)(analyze|process|handle|work\s+with|examine|study|evaluate|review|assess|explore|investigate)\s+(web|online|site|website|digital)\s+(data|information|content|metrics|records|dataset)
```
**Expanded Matches:**
- ✅ "analyze data" (traditional)
- ✅ "process online information" (enhanced)
- ✅ "handle web content" (synonym)
- ✅ "examine site metrics" (workflow)
- ✅ "study digital records" (technical)
- ✅ "evaluate dataset from website" (advanced)
### **2. Workflow & Automation Patterns (NEW v3.1)**
#### Pattern 2.1: Repetitive Task Automation (Enhanced)
```regex
(?i)(every|daily|weekly|monthly|regularly|constantly|always)\s+(I|we)\s+(have to|need to|must|should|got to)\s+(extract|process|handle|work\s+with|analyze|manage|deal\s+with)\s+(data|information|reports|metrics|records)
```
**Expanded Matches:**
- ✅ "every day I have to extract data" (traditional)
- ✅ "daily I need to process information" (enhanced)
- ✅ "weekly we must handle reports" (business context)
- ✅ "regularly I have to analyze metrics" (formal)
- ✅ "constantly I need to work with data" (continuous)
- ✅ "always I must manage records" (obligation)
#### Pattern 2.2: Process Automation (Enhanced)
```regex
(?i)(automate|automation)\s+(this\s+)?(workflow|process|task|job|routine|procedure|system)\s+(that|which)\s+(involves|includes|handles|deals\s+with|processes|extracts|analyzes)\s+(data|information|content)
```
**Expanded Matches:**
- ✅ "automate workflow" (traditional)
- ✅ "automate this process that handles data" (enhanced)
- ✅ "automation for routine involving information" (formal)
- ✅ "automate job that processes content" (technical)
- ✅ "automation for procedure that deals with metrics" (business)
### **3. Technical & Business Language Patterns (NEW v3.1)**
#### Pattern 3.1: Technical Operations (Enhanced)
```regex
(?i)(web\s+scraping|data\s+mining|API\s+integration|ETL\s+process|data\s+extraction|content\s+parsing|information\s+retrieval|data\s+processing)\s+(for|of|to|from)\s+(website|site|api|database|source)
```
**Expanded Matches:**
- ✅ "web scraping for data" (traditional)
- ✅ "data mining from website" (enhanced)
- ✅ "API integration with source" (technical)
- ✅ "ETL process for information" (enterprise)
- ✅ "data extraction from site" (direct)
- ✅ "content parsing of API" (detailed)
#### Pattern 3.2: Business Operations (Enhanced)
```regex
(?i)(process\s+business\s+data|handle\s+reports|analyze\s+metrics|work\s+with\s+datasets|manage\s+information|extract\s+insights|normalize\s+business\s+records)\s+(for|in|from)\s+(reports|analytics|dashboard|meetings)
```
**Expanded Matches:**
- ✅ "process business data" (traditional)
- ✅ "handle reports for analytics" (enhanced)
- ✅ "analyze metrics in dashboard" (technical)
- ✅ "work with datasets from meetings" (workflow)
- ✅ "manage information for reports" (management)
- ✅ "extract insights from analytics" (analysis)
### **4. Natural Language & Conversational Patterns (NEW v3.1)**
#### Pattern 4.1: Question-Based Requests (Enhanced)
```regex
(?i)(how\s+to|what\s+can\s+I|can\s+you|help\s+me|I\s+need\s+to)\s+(extract|get|pull|scrape|analyze|process|handle)\s+(data|information|content)\s+(from|on|of)\s+(this|that|the)\s+(website|site|page|source)
```
**Expanded Matches:**
- ✅ "how to extract data" (traditional)
- ✅ "what can I extract from this site" (enhanced)
- ✅ "can you scrape information from this page" (direct)
- ✅ "help me process content from source" (assistance)
- ✅ "I need to get data from the website" (need)
- ✅ "pull information from that site" (informal)
#### Pattern 4.2: Command-Based Requests (Enhanced)
```regex
(?i)(extract|get|scrape|pull|retrieve|collect|harvest)\s+(data|information|content|details|metrics|records)\s+(from|on|of|in)\s+(this|that|the)\s+(website|site|webpage|api|file|source)
```
**Expanded Matches:**
- ✅ "extract data from website" (traditional)
- ✅ "get information from this site" (enhanced)
- ✅ "scrape content from webpage" (specific)
- ✅ "pull metrics from API" (technical)
- ✅ "collect details from file" (formal)
- ✅ "harvest records from source" (advanced)
---
## 📚 Original Pattern Library (Legacy Support)
### **1. Creation Patterns**
#### Pattern 1.1: Agent/Skill Creation
```regex
(?i)(create|build|develop|make|generate|design)\s+(an?\s+)?(agent|skill|workflow)\s+(for|to|that)
```
**Matches:**
- "create an agent for"
- "build a skill to"
- "develop agent that"
- "make a workflow for"
- "generate skill to"
**Use For:** Skills that create agents, automation, or workflows
---
#### Pattern 1.2: Custom Solution Creation
```regex
(?i)(create|build)\s+a?\s+custom\s+(solution|tool|automation|system)\s+(for|to)
```
**Matches:**
- "create a custom solution for"
- "build custom tool to"
- "create custom automation for"
**Use For:** Custom development skills
---
### 2. Automation Patterns
#### Pattern 2.1: Direct Automation Request
```regex
(?i)(automate|automation|streamline)\s+(this\s+)?(workflow|process|task|job|repetitive)
```
**Matches:**
- "automate this workflow"
- "automation process"
- "streamline task"
- "automate repetitive job"
**Use For:** Workflow automation skills
---
#### Pattern 2.2: Repetitive Task Pattern
```regex
(?i)(every day|daily|repeatedly|constantly|regularly)\s+(I|we)\s+(have to|need to|do|must)
```
**Matches:**
- "every day I have to"
- "daily we need to"
- "repeatedly I do"
- "regularly we must"
**Use For:** Repetitive workflow detection
---
#### Pattern 2.3: Need Automation
```regex
(?i)need\s+to\s+automate\s+.*
```
**Matches:**
- "need to automate this process"
- "need to automate data entry"
- "need to automate reporting"
- "need to automate this codebase"
**Use For:** Explicit automation needs
---
### 3. Transformation Patterns
#### Pattern 3.1: Convert/Transform
```regex
(?i)(turn|convert|transform|change)\s+(this\s+)?(process|workflow|task|data)\s+into\s+(an?\s+)?(agent|automation|system)
```
**Matches:**
- "turn this process into an agent"
- "turn this codebase into an agent"
- "convert workflow to automation"
- "convert workflow in this repo/codebase into automation"
- "transform task into system"
- "transform this codebase tasks into system"
**Use For:** Process transformation skills
---
#### Pattern 3.2: From X to Y
```regex
(?i)(from|convert)\s+([A-Za-z]+)\s+(to|into)\s+([A-Za-z]+)
```
**Matches:**
- "from PDF to text"
- "convert CSV to JSON"
- "from article to code"
- "from repository to code"
- "from codebasee to code"
- "from github repo to code"
**Use For:** Format conversion, data transformation
---
### 4. Analysis Patterns
#### Pattern 4.1: General Analysis
```regex
(?i)(analyze|analysis|examine|study)\s+.*\s+(data|information|metrics|performance|results)
```
**Matches:**
- "analyze sales data"
- "analysis of performance metrics"
- "examine customer information"
**Use For:** Data analysis skills
---
#### Pattern 4.2: Domain-Specific Analysis
```regex
(?i)(analyze|analysis|monitor|track)\s+.*\s+(stock|crop|customer|user|product)s?
```
**Matches:**
- "analyze stock performance"
- "monitor crop conditions"
- "track customer behavior"
- "track prices"
- "monitor weather"
**Use For:** Domain-specific analytics
---
#### Pattern 4.3: Technical Analysis
```regex
(?i)(technical|chart)\s+(analysis|indicators?)\s+(for|of|on)
```
**Matches:**
- "technical analysis for AAPL"
- "chart indicators of SPY"
- "technical analysis on stocks"
**Use For:** Financial/technical analysis skills
---
### 5. Comparison Patterns
#### Pattern 5.1: Direct Comparison
```regex
(?i)(compare|comparison)\s+.*\s+(vs|versus|against|with|to)
```
**Matches:**
- "compare AAPL vs MSFT"
- "comparison of stocks against benchmark"
- "compare performance with last year"
**Use For:** Comparison and benchmarking skills
---
#### Pattern 5.2: Year-over-Year
```regex
(?i)(this year|this week|this month|this quarter|today|current)\s+(vs|versus|against|compared to)\s+(last year|last week|last month|last quarter|last day|previous|prior)
```
**Matches:**
- "this year vs last year"
- "current versus previous year"
- "this year compared to prior year"
- "this week vs last week"
- "current versus previous week"
- "this quarter compared to prior quarter"
**Use For:** Temporal comparison skills
---
### 6. Ranking & Sorting Patterns
#### Pattern 6.1: Top N Pattern
```regex
(?i)(top|best|leading|biggest|highest)\s+(\d+)?\s*(states|countries|stocks|products|customers)?
```
**Matches:**
- "top 10 states"
- "best performing stocks"
- "leading products"
- "biggest countries"
**Use For:** Ranking and leaderboard skills
---
#### Pattern 6.2: Ranking Request
```regex
(?i)(rank|ranking|sort|list)\s+.*\s+(by|based on)\s+(.*?)
```
**Matches:**
- "rank states by production"
- "ranking based on performance"
- "sort stocks by volatility"
**Use For:** Sorting and organization skills
---
### 7. Extraction Patterns
#### Pattern 7.1: Extract From Source
```regex
(?i)(extract|parse|get|retrieve)\s+.*\s+(from)\s+(pdf|article|web|url|file|document|page)
```
**Matches:**
- "extract text from PDF"
- "parse data from article"
- "get information from web page"
**Use For:** Data extraction skills
---
#### Pattern 7.2: Implementation From Source
```regex
(?i)(implement|build|create|generate)\s+(.*?)\s+(from)\s+(article|paper|documentation|tutorial)
```
**Matches:**
- "implement algorithm from paper"
- "create code from tutorial"
- "generate prototype from article"
**Use For:** Code generation from documentation
---
### 8. Reporting Patterns
#### Pattern 8.1: Generate Report
```regex
(?i)(generate|create|produce|build)\s+(an?\s+)?(report|dashboard|summary|overview)\s+(for|about|on)
```
**Matches:**
- "generate a report for sales"
- "create dashboard about performance"
- "produce summary on metrics"
**Use For:** Reporting and visualization skills
---
#### Pattern 8.2: Report Request
```regex
(?i)(show|give|provide)\s+me\s+(an?\s+)?(report|summary|overview|dashboard)
```
**Matches:**
- "show me a report"
- "give me summary"
- "provide overview"
**Use For:** Data presentation skills
---
### 9. Monitoring Patterns
#### Pattern 9.1: Monitor/Track
```regex
(?i)(monitor|track|watch|observe)\s+.*\s+(for|about)\s+(changes|updates|alerts|notifications)
```
**Matches:**
- "monitor stocks for changes"
- "track repositories for updates"
- "watch prices for alerts"
**Use For:** Monitoring and alerting skills
---
#### Pattern 9.2: Notification Request
```regex
(?i)(notify|alert|inform)\s+me\s+(when|if|about)
```
**Matches:**
- "notify me when price drops"
- "alert me if error occurs"
- "inform me about changes"
**Use For:** Notification systems
---
### 10. Search & Query Patterns
#### Pattern 10.1: What/How Questions
```regex
(?i)(what|how|which|where)\s+(is|are|was|were)\s+.*\s+(of|for|in)
```
**Matches:**
- "what is production of corn"
- "how are conditions for soybeans"
- "which stocks are best"
**Use For:** Query and search skills
---
#### Pattern 10.2: Data Request
```regex
(?i)(show|get|fetch|retrieve|find)\s+.*\s+(data|information|stats|metrics)
```
**Matches:**
- "show me crop data"
- "get stock information"
- "fetch performance metrics"
**Use For:** Data retrieval skills
---
## 🎯 Pattern Combinations
### Combo 1: Analysis + Domain
```regex
(?i)(analyze|analysis)\s+.*\s+(stock|crop|customer|product)s?\s+(using|with|via)
```
**Example:** "analyze stocks using RSI"
---
### Combo 2: Extract + Implement
```regex
(?i)(extract|parse)\s+.*\s+and\s+(implement|build|create)
```
**Example:** "extract algorithm and implement in Python"
---
### Combo 3: Monitor + Report
```regex
(?i)(monitor|track)\s+.*\s+and\s+(generate|create|send)\s+(report|alert)
```
**Example:** "monitor prices and generate alerts"
---
## 🚫 Anti-Patterns (Avoid These)
### Anti-Pattern 1: Too Broad
```regex
❌ (?i)(data)
❌ (?i)(analysis)
❌ (?i)(create)
```
**Problem:** Matches everything, high false positive rate
---
### Anti-Pattern 2: No Action Verb
```regex
❌ (?i)(stock|stocks?)
❌ (?i)(pdf|document)
```
**Problem:** Passive, no user intent
---
### Anti-Pattern 3: Overly Specific
```regex
❌ (?i)analyze AAPL stock using RSI indicator
```
**Problem:** Too narrow, misses variations
---
## ✅ Pattern Quality Checklist
For each pattern, verify:
- [ ] Includes action verb(s)
- [ ] Includes target entity/object
- [ ] Case insensitive (`(?i)`)
- [ ] Flexible (captures variations)
- [ ] Not too broad (false positives)
- [ ] Not too narrow (false negatives)
- [ ] Tested with 5+ example queries
- [ ] Documented with match examples
---
## 🧪 Pattern Testing Template
```markdown
### Pattern: {pattern-name}
**Regex:**
```regex
{regex-pattern}
```
**Should Match:**
✅ "{example-1}"
✅ "{example-2}"
✅ "{example-3}"
**Should NOT Match:**
❌ "{counter-example-1}"
❌ "{counter-example-2}"
**Test Results:**
- Tested: {date}
- Pass rate: {X/Y}
- Issues: {none/list}
```
---
## 📖 Usage Examples
### Example 1: Stock Analysis Skill
**Selected Patterns:**
```json
"patterns": [
"(?i)(analyze|analysis)\\s+.*\\s+(stock|stocks?|ticker)s?",
"(?i)(technical|chart)\\s+(analysis|indicators?)\\s+(for|of)",
"(?i)(buy|sell)\\s+(signal|recommendation)\\s+(for|using)",
"(?i)(compare|rank)\\s+.*\\s+stocks?\\s+(using|by)"
]
```
### Example 2: PDF Extraction Skill
**Selected Patterns:**
```json
"patterns": [
"(?i)(extract|parse|get)\\s+.*\\s+(from)\\s+(pdf|document)",
"(?i)(convert|transform)\\s+pdf\\s+(to|into)",
"(?i)(read|process)\\s+.*\\s+pdf"
]
```
### Example 3: Agent Creation Skill
**Selected Patterns:**
```json
"patterns": [
"(?i)(create|build)\\s+(an?\\s+)?(agent|skill)\\s+for",
"(?i)(automate|automation)\\s+(workflow|process)",
"(?i)(every day|daily)\\s+I\\s+(have to|need to)",
"(?i)turn\\s+.*\\s+into\\s+(an?\\s+)?agent"
]
```
---
## 🔄 Pattern Maintenance
### When to Update Patterns
1. **False Negatives:** Valid queries not matching
2. **False Positives:** Invalid queries matching
3. **New Use Cases:** Skill capabilities expanded
4. **User Feedback:** Reported activation issues
### Update Process
1. Identify issue (false negative/positive)
2. Analyze query pattern
3. Update or add pattern
4. Test with 10+ variations
5. Document changes
6. Update marketplace.json
---
## 📚 Additional Resources
- See `phase4-detection.md` for complete detection guide
- See `activation-testing-guide.md` for testing procedures
- See `ACTIVATION_BEST_PRACTICES.md` for best practices
---
**Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-23
**Maintained By:** Agent-Skill-Creator Team

339
references/activation-quality-checklist.md
View file

@ -1,339 +0,0 @@
# Activation Quality Checklist
**Version:** 1.0
**Purpose:** Ensure high-quality activation system for all created skills
---
## Overview
Use this checklist during Phase 4 (Detection) to ensure the skill has robust, reliable activation. **All items must be checked before proceeding to Phase 5.**
**Target:** 95%+ activation reliability with zero false positives
---
## ✅ Layer 1: Keywords Quality
### Quantity
- [ ] **Minimum 10 keywords defined**
- [ ] **Maximum 20 keywords** (more can dilute effectiveness)
- [ ] At least 3 categories covered (action, workflow, domain)
### Quality
- [ ] **All keywords are complete phrases** (not single words)
- [ ] No keywords shorter than 2 words
- [ ] **No overly generic keywords** (e.g., "data", "analysis" alone)
- [ ] Each keyword is unique and non-redundant
### Coverage
- [ ] Keywords cover main capability: {{capability-1}}
- [ ] Keywords cover secondary capability: {{capability-2}}
- [ ] Keywords cover tertiary capability: {{capability-3}}
- [ ] **At least 3 keywords per major capability**
### Specificity
- [ ] Keywords include action verbs (create, analyze, extract)
- [ ] Keywords include domain entities (agent, stock, crop)
- [ ] Keywords include context modifiers when appropriate
### Examples
- [ ] ✅ Good: "create an agent for"
- [ ] ✅ Good: "stock technical analysis"
- [ ] ✅ Good: "harvest progress data"
- [ ] ❌ Bad: "create" (single word)
- [ ] ❌ Bad: "data analysis" (too generic)
- [ ] ❌ Bad: "help me" (too vague)
---
## ✅ Layer 2: Patterns Quality
### Quantity
- [ ] **Minimum 5 patterns defined**
- [ ] **Maximum 10 patterns** (more can create conflicts)
- [ ] At least 3 pattern types covered (action, transformation, query)
### Structure
- [ ] **All patterns start with (?i)** for case-insensitivity
- [ ] All patterns include action verb group
- [ ] Patterns allow for flexible word order where appropriate
- [ ] **No patterns match single words only**
### Specificity vs Flexibility
- [ ] Patterns are specific enough (avoid false positives)
- [ ] Patterns are flexible enough (capture variations)
- [ ] Patterns require both verb AND entity/context
- [ ] **Tested each pattern independently**
### Quality Checks
- [ ] **Pattern 1: Action + Object pattern exists**
- Example: `(?i)(create|build)\s+(an?\s+)?agent\s+for`
- [ ] **Pattern 2: Domain-specific pattern exists**
- Example: `(?i)(analyze|monitor)\s+.*\s+(stock|crop)`
- [ ] **Pattern 3: Workflow pattern exists** (if applicable)
- Example: `(?i)(every day|daily)\s+I\s+(have to|need)`
- [ ] **Pattern 4: Transformation pattern exists** (if applicable)
- Example: `(?i)(convert|transform)\s+.*\s+into`
- [ ] Pattern 5-7: Additional patterns cover edge cases
### Testing
- [ ] **Each pattern tested with 5+ positive examples**
- [ ] Each pattern tested with 2+ negative examples
- [ ] No pattern has >20% false positive rate
- [ ] Combined patterns achieve >80% coverage
---
## ✅ Layer 3: Description Quality
### Content Requirements
- [ ] **60+ unique keywords included in description**
- [ ] All major capabilities explicitly mentioned
- [ ] **Each capability has synonyms** in parentheses
- [ ] Technology/API/data source names included
- [ ] 3-5 example use cases mentioned
### Structure
- [ ] Description starts with primary use case
- [ ] **"Activates for queries about:"** section included
- [ ] **"Does NOT activate for:"** section included
- [ ] Length is 300-500 characters (comprehensive but not excessive)
### Keyword Integration
- [ ] All Layer 1 keywords appear in description
- [ ] Domain-specific terms well-represented
- [ ] Action verbs prominently featured
- [ ] Geographic/temporal qualifiers included (if relevant)
### Clarity
- [ ] Description is readable and natural
- [ ] No keyword stuffing (keywords flow naturally)
- [ ] Technical terms explained where necessary
- [ ] **User can understand when to use skill**
---
## ✅ Usage Section Quality
### when_to_use
- [ ] **Minimum 5 use cases listed**
- [ ] Use cases are specific and actionable
- [ ] Use cases cover all major capabilities
- [ ] Use cases use natural language
### when_not_to_use
- [ ] **Minimum 3 counter-cases listed**
- [ ] Counter-cases prevent common false positives
- [ ] Counter-cases clearly distinguish from similar skills
- [ ] Each counter-case explains WHY not to use
### Example
- [ ] **Concrete example query provided**
- [ ] Example demonstrates typical usage
- [ ] Example would actually activate the skill
---
## ✅ Test Queries Quality
### Quantity
- [ ] **Minimum 10 test queries defined**
- [ ] At least 2 queries per major capability
- [ ] Mix of query types (direct, natural, edge cases)
### Coverage
- [ ] Tests cover Layer 1 (keywords)
- [ ] Tests cover Layer 2 (patterns)
- [ ] Tests cover Layer 3 (description/NLU)
- [ ] Tests cover all capabilities
- [ ] Tests include edge cases
### Quality
- [ ] Queries use natural language
- [ ] Queries are realistic user requests
- [ ] Queries vary in phrasing and structure
- [ ] **Each query documented with expected activation layer**
### Negative Tests
- [ ] **Minimum 3 negative test cases** (should NOT activate)
- [ ] Negative cases test counter-examples from when_not_to_use
- [ ] Negative cases documented separately
---
## ✅ Integration & Conflicts
### Conflict Check
- [ ] **Reviewed other existing skills in ecosystem**
- [ ] No keyword conflicts with other skills
- [ ] Patterns don't overlap significantly with other skills
- [ ] Clear differentiation from similar skills
### Priority
- [ ] Activation priority is appropriate
- [ ] More specific skills have higher priority if needed
- [ ] Domain-specific skills prioritized over general skills
---
## ✅ Documentation
### In marketplace.json
- [ ] **activation section complete**
- [ ] **usage section complete**
- [ ] **test_queries array populated**
- [ ] All JSON is valid (no syntax errors)
### In SKILL.md
- [ ] Keywords section included
- [ ] Activation examples (positive and negative)
- [ ] Use cases clearly documented
### In README.md
- [ ] **Activation section included** (see template)
- [ ] 10+ activation phrase examples
- [ ] Counter-examples documented
- [ ] Activation tips provided
---
## ✅ Testing Validation
### Layer Testing
- [ ] **Layer 1 (Keywords) tested individually**
- Pass rate: ___% (target: 100%)
- [ ] **Layer 2 (Patterns) tested individually**
- Pass rate: ___% (target: 100%)
- [ ] **Layer 3 (Description) tested with edge cases**
- Pass rate: ___% (target: 90%+)
### Integration Testing
- [ ] **All test_queries tested in Claude Code**
- Pass rate: ___% (target: 95%+)
- [ ] Negative tests verified (no false positives)
- Pass rate: ___% (target: 100%)
### Results
- [ ] **Overall success rate: ____%** (target: >=95%)
- [ ] **False positive rate: ____%** (target: 0%)
- [ ] **False negative rate: ____%** (target: <5%)
---
## ✅ Final Verification
### Pre-Deployment
- [ ] All above checklists completed
- [ ] Test report documented
- [ ] Issues identified and fixed
- [ ] **Activation success rate >= 95%**
### Documentation Complete
- [ ] marketplace.json reviewed and validated
- [ ] SKILL.md includes activation section
- [ ] README.md includes activation examples
- [ ] TESTING.md created (if complex skill)
### Sign-Off
- [ ] Creator reviewed activation system
- [ ] Test results satisfactory
- [ ] Ready for Phase 5 (Implementation)
---
## 📊 Scoring System
### Minimum Requirements
| Layer | Minimum Score | Target Score |
|-------|---------------|--------------|
| Keywords (Layer 1) | 10 keywords | 12-15 keywords |
| Patterns (Layer 2) | 5 patterns | 7 patterns |
| Description (Layer 3) | 300 chars, 60+ keywords | 400 chars, 80+ keywords |
| Test Queries | 10 queries | 15+ queries |
| Success Rate | 90% | 95%+ |
### Grading
**A (Excellent):** 95%+ success rate, all requirements met
**B (Good):** 90-94% success rate, most requirements met
**C (Acceptable):** 85-89% success rate, minimum requirements met
**F (Needs Work):** <85% success rate, requirements not met
**Only Grade A skills should proceed to implementation.**
---
## 🚨 Common Issues Checklist
### Issue: Low Activation Rate (<90%)
**Check:**
- [ ] Are keywords too specific/narrow?
- [ ] Are patterns too restrictive?
- [ ] Is description missing key concepts?
- [ ] Are test queries realistic?
### Issue: False Positives
**Check:**
- [ ] Are keywords too generic?
- [ ] Are patterns too broad?
- [ ] Is description unclear about scope?
- [ ] Are when_not_to_use cases defined?
### Issue: Inconsistent Activation
**Check:**
- [ ] Are all 3 layers properly configured?
- [ ] Is JSON syntax valid?
- [ ] Are patterns properly escaped?
- [ ] Has testing been thorough?
---
## 📝 Quick Reference
### Minimum Requirements Summary
**Must Have:**
- ✅ 10+ keywords (complete phrases)
- ✅ 5+ patterns (with verbs + entities)
- ✅ 300+ char description (60+ keywords)
- ✅ 5+ when_to_use cases
- ✅ 3+ when_not_to_use cases
- ✅ 10+ test queries
- ✅ 95%+ success rate
**Should Have:**
- ⭐ 15 keywords
- ⭐ 7 patterns
- ⭐ 400+ char description (80+ keywords)
- ⭐ 15+ test queries
- ⭐ 98%+ success rate
- ⭐ Zero false positives
---
## 📚 Additional Resources
- `phase4-detection.md` - Complete detection methodology
- `activation-patterns-guide.md` - Pattern library
- `activation-testing-guide.md` - Testing procedures
- `marketplace-robust-template.json` - Template with placeholders
- `README-activation-template.md` - README template
---
**Status:** ___ (In Progress / Complete)
**Reviewer:** ___
**Date:** ___
**Success Rate:** ___%
**Grade:** ___ (A / B / C / F)
---
**Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-23
**Maintained By:** Agent-Skill-Creator Team

613
references/activation-testing-guide.md
View file

@ -1,613 +0,0 @@
# Activation Testing Guide
**Version:** 1.0
**Purpose:** Comprehensive guide for testing skill activation reliability
---
## Overview
This guide provides procedures, templates, and checklists for testing the 3-Layer Activation System to ensure skills activate correctly and reliably.
### Testing Philosophy
**Goal:** 95%+ activation reliability
**Approach:** Test each layer independently, then integration
**Metrics:**
- **True Positives:** Valid queries that correctly activate
- **True Negatives:** Invalid queries that correctly don't activate
- **False Positives:** Invalid queries that incorrectly activate
- **False Negatives:** Valid queries that fail to activate
**Target:** Zero false positives, <5% false negatives
---
## 🧪 Testing Methodology
### Phase 1: Layer 1 Testing (Keywords)
#### Objective
Verify that exact keyword phrases activate the skill.
#### Procedure
**Step 1:** List all keywords from marketplace.json
**Step 2:** Create test query for each keyword
**Step 3:** Test each query manually
**Step 4:** Document results
#### Template
```markdown
## Layer 1: Keywords Testing
**Keyword 1:** "create an agent for"
Test Queries:
1. "create an agent for processing invoices"
- ✅ Activated
- Via: Keyword match
2. "I want to create an agent for data analysis"
- ✅ Activated
- Via: Keyword match
3. "Create An Agent For automation" // Case variation
- ✅ Activated
- Via: Keyword match (case-insensitive)
**Keyword 2:** "automate workflow"
...
```
#### Pass Criteria
- [ ] 100% of keyword test queries activate
- [ ] Case-insensitive matching works
- [ ] Embedded keywords activate (keyword within longer query)
---
### Phase 2: Layer 2 Testing (Patterns)
#### Objective
Verify that regex patterns capture expected variations.
#### Procedure
**Step 1:** List all patterns from marketplace.json
**Step 2:** Create 5+ test queries per pattern
**Step 3:** Test pattern matching (can use regex tester)
**Step 4:** Test in Claude Code
**Step 5:** Document results
#### Template
```markdown
## Layer 2: Patterns Testing
**Pattern 1:** `(?i)(create|build)\s+(an?\s+)?agent\s+for`
Designed to Match:
- Verbs: create, build
- Optional article: a, an
- Entity: agent
- Connector: for
Test Queries:
1. "create an agent for automation"
- ✅ Matches pattern
- ✅ Activated in Claude Code
2. "build a agent for processing"
- ✅ Matches pattern
- ✅ Activated
3. "create agent for data" // No article
- ✅ Matches pattern
- ✅ Activated
4. "Build Agent For Tasks" // Different case
- ✅ Matches pattern
- ✅ Activated
5. "I want to create an agent for reporting" // Embedded
- ✅ Matches pattern
- ✅ Activated
Should NOT Match:
6. "agent creation guide"
- ❌ No action verb
- ❌ Correctly did not activate
7. "create something for automation"
- ❌ No "agent" keyword
- ❌ Correctly did not activate
```
#### Pass Criteria
- [ ] 100% of positive test queries match pattern
- [ ] 100% of positive queries activate in Claude Code
- [ ] 0% of negative queries match pattern
- [ ] Pattern is flexible (captures variations)
- [ ] Pattern is specific (no false positives)
---
### Phase 3: Layer 3 Testing (Description + NLU)
#### Objective
Verify that description helps Claude understand intent for edge cases.
#### Procedure
**Step 1:** Create queries that DON'T match keywords/patterns
**Step 2:** Verify these still activate via description understanding
**Step 3:** Document which queries activate
#### Template
```markdown
## Layer 3: Description + NLU Testing
**Queries that don't match Keywords or Patterns:**
1. "I keep doing this task manually, can you help automate it?"
- ❌ No keyword match
- ❌ No pattern match
- ✅ Should activate via description understanding
- Result: {activated/did not activate}
2. "This process is repetitive and takes hours daily"
- ❌ No keyword match
- ❌ No pattern match
- ✅ Should activate (describes repetitive workflow)
- Result: {activated/did not activate}
3. "Help me build something to handle this workflow"
- ❌ No exact keyword
- ⚠️ Might match pattern
- ✅ Should activate
- Result: {activated/did not activate}
```
#### Pass Criteria
- [ ] Edge case queries activate when appropriate
- [ ] Natural language variations work
- [ ] Description provides fallback coverage
---
### Phase 4: Integration Testing
#### Objective
Test complete system with real-world query variations.
#### Procedure
**Step 1:** Create 10+ realistic query variations per capability
**Step 2:** Test all queries in actual Claude Code environment
**Step 3:** Track activation success rate
**Step 4:** Identify gaps
#### Template
```markdown
## Integration Testing
**Capability:** Agent Creation
**Test Queries:**
| # | Query | Expected | Actual | Layer | Status |
|---|-------|----------|--------|-------|--------|
| 1 | "create an agent for PDFs" | Activate | Activated | Keyword | ✅ |
| 2 | "build automation for emails" | Activate | Activated | Pattern | ✅ |
| 3 | "daily I process invoices manually" | Activate | Activated | Desc | ✅ |
| 4 | "make agent for data entry" | Activate | Activated | Pattern | ✅ |
| 5 | "automate my workflow for reports" | Activate | Activated | Keyword | ✅ |
| 6 | "I need help with automation" | Activate | NOT activated | - | ❌ |
| 7 | "turn this into automated process" | Activate | Activated | Pattern | ✅ |
| 8 | "create skill for stock analysis" | Activate | Activated | Keyword | ✅ |
| 9 | "repeatedly doing this task" | Activate | Activated | Desc | ✅ |
| 10 | "can you help automate this?" | Activate | Activated | Desc | ✅ |
**Results:**
- Total queries: 10
- Activated correctly: 9
- Failed to activate: 1 (Query #6)
- Success rate: 90%
**Issues:**
- Query #6 too generic, needs more specific keywords
```
#### Pass Criteria
- [ ] 95%+ success rate
- [ ] All capability variations covered
- [ ] Realistic query phrasings tested
- [ ] Edge cases documented
---
### Phase 5: Negative Testing (False Positives)
#### Objective
Ensure skill does NOT activate for out-of-scope queries.
#### Procedure
**Step 1:** List out-of-scope use cases (when_not_to_use)
**Step 2:** Create queries for each
**Step 3:** Verify skill does NOT activate
**Step 4:** Document any false positives
#### Template
```markdown
## Negative Testing
**Out of Scope:** General programming questions
Test Queries (Should NOT Activate):
1. "How do I write a for loop in Python?"
- Result: Did not activate ✅
2. "What's the difference between list and tuple?"
- Result: Did not activate ✅
3. "Help me debug this code"
- Result: Did not activate ✅
**Out of Scope:** Using existing skills
Test Queries (Should NOT Activate):
4. "Run the invoice processor skill"
- Result: Did not activate ✅
5. "Show me existing agents"
- Result: Did not activate ✅
**Results:**
- Total negative queries: 5
- Correctly did not activate: 5
- False positives: 0
- Success rate: 100%
```
#### Pass Criteria
- [ ] 100% of out-of-scope queries do NOT activate
- [ ] Zero false positives
- [ ] when_not_to_use cases covered
---
## 📋 Complete Testing Checklist
### Pre-Testing Setup
- [ ] marketplace.json has activation section
- [ ] Keywords defined (10-15)
- [ ] Patterns defined (5-7)
- [ ] Description includes keywords
- [ ] when_to_use / when_not_to_use defined
- [ ] test_queries array populated
### Layer 1: Keywords
- [ ] All keywords tested individually
- [ ] Case-insensitive matching verified
- [ ] Embedded keywords work
- [ ] 100% activation rate
### Layer 2: Patterns
- [ ] Each pattern tested with 5+ queries
- [ ] Pattern matches verified (regex tester)
- [ ] Claude Code activation verified
- [ ] No false positives
- [ ] Flexible enough for variations
### Layer 3: Description
- [ ] Edge cases tested
- [ ] Natural language variations work
- [ ] Fallback coverage confirmed
### Integration
- [ ] 10+ realistic queries per capability tested
- [ ] 95%+ success rate achieved
- [ ] All capabilities covered
- [ ] Results documented
### Negative Testing
- [ ] Out-of-scope queries tested
- [ ] Zero false positives
- [ ] when_not_to_use cases verified
### Documentation
- [ ] Test results documented
- [ ] Issues logged
- [ ] Recommendations made
- [ ] marketplace.json updated if needed
---
## 📊 Test Report Template
```markdown
# Activation Test Report
**Skill Name:** {skill-name}
**Version:** {version}
**Test Date:** {date}
**Tested By:** {name}
**Environment:** Claude Code {version}
---
## Executive Summary
- **Overall Success Rate:** {X}%
- **Total Queries Tested:** {N}
- **True Positives:** {N}
- **True Negatives:** {N}
- **False Positives:** {N}
- **False Negatives:** {N}
---
## Layer 1: Keywords Testing
**Keywords Tested:** {count}
**Success Rate:** {X}%
### Results
| Keyword | Test Queries | Passed | Failed |
|---------|--------------|--------|--------|
| {keyword-1} | {N} | {N} | {N} |
| {keyword-2} | {N} | {N} | {N} |
**Issues:**
- {issue-1}
- {issue-2}
---
## Layer 2: Patterns Testing
**Patterns Tested:** {count}
**Success Rate:** {X}%
### Results
| Pattern | Test Queries | Passed | Failed |
|---------|--------------|--------|--------|
| {pattern-1} | {N} | {N} | {N} |
| {pattern-2} | {N} | {N} | {N} |
**Issues:**
- {issue-1}
- {issue-2}
---
## Layer 3: Description Testing
**Edge Cases Tested:** {count}
**Success Rate:** {X}%
**Results:**
- Activated via description: {N}
- Failed to activate: {N}
---
## Integration Testing
**Total Test Queries:** {count}
**Success Rate:** {X}%
**Breakdown by Capability:**
| Capability | Queries | Success | Rate |
|------------|---------|---------|------|
| {cap-1} | {N} | {N} | {X}% |
| {cap-2} | {N} | {N} | {X}% |
---
## Negative Testing
**Out-of-Scope Queries:** {count}
**False Positives:** {N}
**Success Rate:** {X}%
---
## Issues & Recommendations
### Critical Issues
1. {issue-description}
- Impact: {high/medium/low}
- Recommendation: {action}
### Minor Issues
1. {issue-description}
- Impact: {low}
- Recommendation: {action}
### Recommendations
1. {recommendation-1}
2. {recommendation-2}
---
## Conclusion
{Summary of test results and next steps}
**Status:** {PASS / NEEDS WORK / FAIL}
---
**Appendix A:** Full Test Query List
**Appendix B:** Failed Query Analysis
**Appendix C:** Updated marketplace.json (if changes needed)
```
---
## 🔄 Iterative Testing Process
### Step 1: Initial Test
- Run complete test suite
- Document results
- Identify failures
### Step 2: Analysis
- Analyze failed queries
- Determine root cause
- Plan fixes
### Step 3: Fix
- Update keywords/patterns/description
- Document changes
### Step 4: Retest
- Test only failed queries
- Verify fixes work
- Ensure no regressions
### Step 5: Full Regression Test
- Run complete test suite again
- Verify 95%+ success rate
- Document final results
---
## 🎯 Sample Test Suite
### Example: Agent Creation Skill
```markdown
## Test Suite: Agent Creation Skill
### Layer 1 Tests (Keywords)
**Keyword:** "create an agent for"
- ✅ "create an agent for processing PDFs"
- ✅ "I want to create an agent for automation"
- ✅ "Create An Agent For daily tasks"
**Keyword:** "automate workflow"
- ✅ "automate workflow for invoices"
- ✅ "need to automate workflow"
- ✅ "Automate Workflow handling"
[... more keywords]
### Layer 2 Tests (Patterns)
**Pattern:** `(?i)(create|build)\s+(an?\s+)?agent`
- ✅ "create an agent for X"
- ✅ "build a agent for Y"
- ✅ "create agent for Z"
- ✅ "Build Agent for tasks"
- ❌ "agent creation guide" (should not match)
[... more patterns]
### Integration Tests
**Capability:** Agent Creation
1. ✅ "create an agent for processing CSVs"
2. ✅ "build automation for email handling"
3. ✅ "automate this workflow: download, process, upload"
4. ✅ "every day I have to categorize files manually"
5. ✅ "turn this process into an automated agent"
6. ✅ "I need a skill for data extraction"
7. ✅ "daily workflow automation needed"
8. ✅ "repeatedly doing manual data entry"
9. ✅ "develop an agent to monitor APIs"
10. ✅ "make something to handle invoices automatically"
**Success Rate:** 10/10 = 100%
### Negative Tests
**Should NOT Activate:**
1. ✅ "How do I use an existing agent?" (did not activate)
2. ✅ "Explain what agents are" (did not activate)
3. ✅ "Debug this code" (did not activate)
4. ✅ "Write a Python function" (did not activate)
5. ✅ "Run the invoice agent" (did not activate)
**Success Rate:** 5/5 = 100%
```
---
## 📚 Additional Resources
- `phase4-detection.md` - Detection methodology
- `activation-patterns-guide.md` - Pattern library
- `activation-quality-checklist.md` - Quality standards
- `ACTIVATION_BEST_PRACTICES.md` - Best practices
---
## 🔧 Troubleshooting
### Issue: Low Success Rate (<90%)
**Diagnosis:**
1. Review failed queries
2. Check if keywords/patterns too narrow
3. Verify description includes key concepts
**Solution:**
1. Add more keyword variations
2. Broaden patterns slightly
3. Enhance description with synonyms
### Issue: False Positives
**Diagnosis:**
1. Review activated queries
2. Check if patterns too broad
3. Verify keywords not too generic
**Solution:**
1. Narrow patterns (add context requirements)
2. Use complete phrases for keywords
3. Add negative scope to description
### Issue: Inconsistent Activation
**Diagnosis:**
1. Test same query multiple times
2. Check for Claude Code updates
3. Verify marketplace.json structure
**Solution:**
1. Use all 3 layers (keywords + patterns + description)
2. Increase keyword/pattern coverage
3. Validate JSON syntax
---
**Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-23
**Maintained By:** Agent-Skill-Creator Team

963
references/claude-llm-protocols-guide.md
View file

@ -1,963 +0,0 @@
# Claude LLM Protocols Guide: Complete Skill Creation System
**Version:** 1.0
**Purpose:** Comprehensive guide for Claude LLM to follow during skill creation via Agent-Skill-Creator
**Target:** Ensure consistent, high-quality skill creation following all defined protocols
---
## 🎯 **Overview**
This guide defines the complete set of protocols that Claude LLM must follow when creating skills through the Agent-Skill-Creator system. The protocols ensure autonomy, quality, and consistency while integrating advanced capabilities like context-aware activation and multi-intent detection.
### **Protocol Hierarchy**
```
Autonomous Creation Protocol (Master Protocol)
├── Phase 1: Discovery Protocol
├── Phase 2: Design Protocol
├── Phase 3: Architecture Protocol
├── Phase 4: Detection Protocol (Enhanced with Fase 1)
├── Phase 5: Implementation Protocol
├── Phase 6: Testing Protocol
└── AgentDB Learning Protocol
```
---
## 🤖 **Autonomous Creation Protocol (Master Protocol)**
### **When to Apply**
Always. This is the master protocol that governs all skill creation activities.
### **Core Principles**
#### **🔓 Autonomy Rules**
- ✅ **Claude DECIDES** which API to use (doesn't ask user)
- ✅ **Claude DEFINES** which analyses to perform (based on value)
- ✅ **Claude STRUCTURES** optimally (best practices)
- ✅ **Claude IMPLEMENTS** complete code (no placeholders)
- ✅ **Claude LEARNS** from experience (AgentDB integration)
#### **⭐ Quality Standards**
- ✅ Production-ready code (no TODOs)
- ✅ Useful documentation (not "see docs")
- ✅ Real configs (no placeholders)
- ✅ Robust error handling
- ✅ Intelligence validated with mathematical proofs
#### **📦 Completeness Requirements**
- ✅ Complete SKILL.md (5000+ words)
- ✅ Functional scripts (1000+ lines total)
- ✅ References with content (3000+ words)
- ✅ Valid assets/configs
- ✅ README with instructions
### **Decision-Making Authority**
```python
# Claude has full authority to decide:
DECISION_AUTHORITY = {
"api_selection": True, # Choose best API without asking
"analysis_scope": True, # Define what analyses to perform
"architecture": True, # Design optimal structure
"implementation_details": True, # Implement complete solutions
"quality_standards": True, # Ensure production quality
"user_questions": "MINIMAL" # Ask only when absolutely critical
}
```
### **Critical Questions Protocol**
Ask questions ONLY when:
1. **Critical business decision** (free vs paid API)
2. **Geographic scope** (country/region focus)
3. **Historical data range** (years needed)
4. **Multi-agent strategy** (separate vs integrated)
**Rule:** When in doubt, DECIDE and proceed. Claude should make intelligent choices and document them.
---
## 📋 **Phase 1: Discovery Protocol**
### **When to Apply**
Always. First phase of any skill creation.
### **Protocol Steps**
#### **Step 1.1: Domain Analysis**
```python
def analyze_domain(user_input: str) -> DomainSpec:
"""Extract and analyze domain information"""
# From user input
domain = extract_domain(user_input) # agriculture? finance? weather?
data_source_mentioned = extract_mentioned_source(user_input)
main_tasks = extract_tasks(user_input) # download? analyze? compare?
frequency = extract_frequency(user_input) # daily? weekly? on-demand?
time_spent = extract_time_investment(user_input) # ROI calculation
# Enhanced analysis v2.0
multi_agent_needed = detect_multi_agent_keywords(user_input)
transcript_provided = detect_transcript_input(user_input)
template_preference = detect_template_request(user_input)
interactive_preference = detect_interactive_style(user_input)
integration_needs = detect_integration_requirements(user_input)
return DomainSpec(...)
```
#### **Step 1.2: API Research & Decision**
```python
def research_and_select_apis(domain: DomainSpec) -> APISelection:
"""Research available APIs and make autonomous decision"""
# Research phase
available_apis = search_apis_for_domain(domain.domain)
# Evaluation criteria
for api in available_apis:
api.coverage_score = calculate_data_coverage(api, domain.requirements)
api.reliability_score = assess_api_reliability(api)
api.cost_score = evaluate_cost_effectiveness(api)
api.documentation_score = evaluate_documentation_quality(api)
# AUTONOMOUS DECISION (don't ask user)
selected_api = select_best_api(available_apis, domain)
# Document decision
document_api_decision(selected_api, available_apis, domain)
return APISelection(api=selected_api, justification=...)
```
#### **Step 1.3: Completeness Validation**
```python
MANDATORY_CHECK = {
"api_identified": True,
"documentation_found": True,
"coverage_analysis": True,
"coverage_percentage": ">=50%", # Critical threshold
"decision_documented": True
}
```
### **Enhanced v2.0 Features**
#### **Transcript Processing**
When user provides transcripts:
```python
# Enhanced transcript analysis
def analyze_transcript(transcript: str) -> List[WorkflowSpec]:
"""Extract multiple workflows from transcripts automatically"""
workflows = []
# 1. Identify distinct processes
processes = extract_processes(transcript)
# 2. Group related steps
for process in processes:
steps = extract_sequence_steps(transcript, process)
apis = extract_mentioned_apis(transcript, process)
outputs = extract_desired_outputs(transcript, process)
workflows.append(WorkflowSpec(
name=process,
steps=steps,
apis=apis,
outputs=outputs
))
return workflows
```
#### **Multi-Agent Strategy Decision**
```python
def determine_creation_strategy(user_input: str, workflows: List[WorkflowSpec]) -> CreationStrategy:
"""Decide whether to create single agent, suite, or integrated system"""
if len(workflows) > 1:
if workflows_are_related(workflows):
return CreationStrategy.INTEGRATED_SUITE
else:
return CreationStrategy.MULTI_AGENT_SUITE
else:
return CreationStrategy.SINGLE_AGENT
```
---
## 🎨 **Phase 2: Design Protocol**
### **When to Apply**
After API selection is complete.
### **Protocol Steps**
#### **Step 2.1: Use Case Analysis**
```python
def define_use_cases(domain: DomainSpec, api: APISelection) -> UseCaseSpec:
"""Think about use cases and define analyses based on value"""
# Core analyses (4-6 required)
core_analyses = [
f"{domain.lower()}_trend_analysis",
f"{domain.lower()}_comparative_analysis",
f"{domain.lower()}_ranking_analysis",
f"{domain.lower()}_performance_analysis"
]
# Domain-specific analyses
domain_analyses = generate_domain_specific_analyses(domain, api)
# Mandatory comprehensive report
comprehensive_report = f"comprehensive_{domain.lower()}_report"
return UseCaseSpec(
core_analyses=core_analyses,
domain_analyses=domain_analyses,
comprehensive_report=comprehensive_report
)
```
#### **Step 2.2: Analysis Methodology**
```python
def define_methodologies(use_cases: UseCaseSpec) -> MethodologySpec:
"""Specify methodologies for each analysis"""
methodologies = {}
for analysis in use_cases.all_analyses:
methodologies[analysis] = {
"data_requirements": define_data_requirements(analysis),
"statistical_methods": select_statistical_methods(analysis),
"visualization_needs": determine_visualization_needs(analysis),
"output_format": define_output_format(analysis)
}
return MethodologySpec(methodologies=methodologies)
```
#### **Step 2.3: Value Proposition**
```python
def calculate_value_proposition(domain: DomainSpec, analyses: UseCaseSpec) -> ValueSpec:
"""Calculate ROI and value proposition"""
current_manual_time = domain.time_spent_hours * 52 # Annual
automated_time = 0.5 # Estimated automated time per task
time_saved_annual = (current_manual_time - automated_time) * 52
roi_calculation = {
"time_before": current_manual_time,
"time_after": automated_time,
"time_saved": time_saved_annual,
"value_proposition": f"Save {time_saved_annual:.1f} hours annually"
}
return ValueSpec(roi=roi_calculation)
```
---
## 🏗️ **Phase 3: Architecture Protocol**
### **When to Apply**
After design specifications are complete.
### **Protocol Steps**
#### **Step 3.1: Modular Architecture Design**
```python
def design_architecture(use_cases: UseCaseSpec, api: APISelection) -> ArchitectureSpec:
"""Structure optimally following best practices"""
# MANDATORY structure
required_structure = {
"main_scripts": [
f"{api.name.lower()}_client.py",
f"{domain.lower()}_analyzer.py",
f"{domain.lower()}_comparator.py",
f"comprehensive_{domain.lower()}_report.py"
],
"utils": {
"helpers.py": "MANDATORY - temporal context and common utilities",
"validators/": "MANDATORY - 4 validators minimum"
},
"tests/": "MANDATORY - comprehensive test suite",
"references/": "MANDATORY - documentation and guides"
}
return ArchitectureSpec(structure=required_structure)
```
#### **Step 3.2: Modular Parser Architecture (MANDATORY)**
```python
# Rule: If API returns N data types → create N specific parsers
def create_modular_parsers(api_data_types: List[str]) -> ParserSpec:
"""Create one parser per data type - MANDATORY"""
parsers = {}
for data_type in api_data_types:
parser_name = f"parse_{data_type.lower()}"
parsers[parser_name] = {
"function_signature": f"def {parser_name}(data: dict) -> pd.DataFrame:",
"validation_rules": generate_validation_rules(data_type),
"error_handling": create_error_handling(data_type)
}
return ParserSpec(parsers=parsers)
```
#### **Step 3.3: Validation System (MANDATORY)**
```python
def create_validation_system(domain: str, data_types: List[str]) -> ValidationSpec:
"""Create comprehensive validation system - MANDATORY"""
# MANDATORY: 4 validators minimum
validators = {
f"validate_{domain.lower()}_data": create_domain_validator(),
f"validate_{domain.lower()}_entity": create_entity_validator(),
f"validate_{domain.lower()}_temporal": create_temporal_validator(),
f"validate_{domain.lower()}_completeness": create_completeness_validator()
}
# Additional validators per data type
for data_type in data_types:
validators[f"validate_{data_type.lower()}"] = create_type_validator(data_type)
return ValidationSpec(validators=validators)
```
#### **Step 3.4: Helper Functions (MANDATORY)**
```python
# MANDATORY: utils/helpers.py with temporal context
def create_helpers_module() -> HelperSpec:
"""Create helper functions module - MANDATORY"""
helpers = {
# Temporal context functions
"get_current_year": "lambda: datetime.now().year",
"get_seasonal_context": "determine_current_season()",
"get_time_period_description": "generate_time_description()",
# Common utilities
"safe_float_conversion": "convert_to_float_safely()",
"format_currency": "format_as_currency()",
"calculate_growth_rate": "compute_growth_rate()",
"handle_missing_data": "process_missing_values()"
}
return HelperSpec(functions=helpers)
```
---
## 🎯 **Phase 4: Detection Protocol (Enhanced with Fase 1)**
### **When to Apply**
After architecture is designed.
### **Enhanced 4-Layer Detection System**
```python
def create_detection_system(domain: str, capabilities: List[str]) -> DetectionSpec:
"""Create 4-layer detection with Fase 1 enhancements"""
# Layer 1: Keywords (Expanded 50-80 keywords)
keyword_spec = {
"total_target": "50-80 keywords",
"categories": {
"core_capabilities": "10-15 keywords",
"synonym_variations": "10-15 keywords",
"direct_variations": "8-12 keywords",
"domain_specific": "5-8 keywords",
"natural_language": "5-10 keywords"
}
}
# Layer 2: Patterns (10-15 patterns)
pattern_spec = {
"total_target": "10-15 patterns",
"enhanced_patterns": [
"data_extraction_patterns",
"processing_patterns",
"workflow_automation_patterns",
"technical_operations_patterns",
"natural_language_patterns"
]
}
# Layer 3: Description + NLU
description_spec = {
"minimum_length": "300-500 characters",
"keyword_density": "include 60+ unique keywords",
"semantic_richness": "comprehensive concept coverage"
}
# Layer 4: Context-Aware Filtering (Fase 1 enhancement)
context_spec = {
"required_context": {
"domains": [domain, get_related_domains(domain)],
"tasks": capabilities,
"confidence_threshold": 0.8
},
"excluded_context": {
"domains": get_excluded_domains(domain),
"tasks": ["tutorial", "help", "debugging"],
"query_types": ["question", "definition"]
},
"context_weights": {
"domain_relevance": 0.35,
"task_relevance": 0.30,
"intent_strength": 0.20,
"conversation_coherence": 0.15
}
}
# Multi-Intent Detection (Fase 1 enhancement)
intent_spec = {
"primary_intents": get_primary_intents(domain),
"secondary_intents": get_secondary_intents(capabilities),
"contextual_intents": get_contextual_intents(),
"intent_combinations": generate_supported_combinations()
}
return DetectionSpec(
keywords=keyword_spec,
patterns=pattern_spec,
description=description_spec,
context=context_spec,
intents=intent_spec
)
```
### **Keywords Generation Protocol**
```python
def generate_expanded_keywords(domain: str, capabilities: List[str]) -> KeywordSpec:
"""Generate 50-80 expanded keywords using Fase 1 system"""
# Use synonym expansion system
base_keywords = generate_base_keywords(domain, capabilities)
expanded_keywords = expand_with_synonyms(base_keywords, domain)
# Category organization
categorized_keywords = {
"core_capabilities": extract_core_capabilities(expanded_keywords),
"synonym_variations": extract_synonyms(expanded_keywords),
"direct_variations": generate_direct_variations(base_keywords),
"domain_specific": generate_domain_specific(domain),
"natural_language": generate_natural_variations(base_keywords)
}
return KeywordSpec(
total=len(expanded_keywords),
categories=categorized_keywords,
minimum_target=50 # Target: 50-80 keywords
)
```
### **Pattern Generation Protocol**
```python
def generate_enhanced_patterns(domain: str, keywords: KeywordSpec) -> PatternSpec:
"""Generate 10-15 enhanced patterns using Fase 1 system"""
# Use activation patterns guide
base_patterns = generate_base_patterns(domain)
enhanced_patterns = enhance_patterns_with_synonyms(base_patterns)
# Pattern categories
pattern_categories = {
"data_extraction": create_data_extraction_patterns(domain),
"processing_workflow": create_processing_patterns(domain),
"technical_operations": create_technical_patterns(domain),
"natural_language": create_conversational_patterns(domain)
}
return PatternSpec(
patterns=enhanced_patterns,
categories=pattern_categories,
minimum_target=10 # Target: 10-15 patterns
)
```
---
## ⚙️ **Phase 5: Implementation Protocol**
### **When to Apply**
After detection system is designed.
### **Critical Implementation Order (MANDATORY)**
#### **Step 5.1: Create marketplace.json IMMEDIATELY**
```python
# STEP 0.1: Create basic structure
def create_marketplace_json_first(domain: str, description: str) -> bool:
"""Create marketplace.json BEFORE any other files - MANDATORY"""
marketplace_template = {
"name": f"{domain.lower()}-skill-name",
"owner": {"name": "Agent Creator", "email": "noreply@example.com"},
"metadata": {
"description": description, # Will be synchronized later
"version": "1.0.0",
"created": datetime.now().strftime("%Y-%m-%d"),
"language": "en-US"
},
"plugins": [{
"name": f"{domain.lower()}-plugin",
"description": description, # MUST match SKILL.md description
"source": "./",
"strict": false,
"skills": ["./"]
}],
"activation": {
"keywords": [], # Will be populated in Phase 4
"patterns": [] # Will be populated in Phase 4
},
"capabilities": {},
"usage": {
"example": "",
"when_to_use": [],
"when_not_to_use": []
},
"test_queries": []
}
# Create file immediately
with open('.claude-plugin/marketplace.json', 'w') as f:
json.dump(marketplace_template, f, indent=2)
return True
```
#### **Step 5.2: Validate marketplace.json**
```python
def validate_marketplace_json() -> ValidationResult:
"""Validate marketplace.json immediately after creation - MANDATORY"""
validation_checks = {
"syntax_valid": validate_json_syntax('.claude-plugin/marketplace.json'),
"required_fields": check_required_fields('.claude-plugin/marketplace.json'),
"structure_valid": validate_marketplace_structure('.claude-plugin/marketplace.json')
}
if not all(validation_checks.values()):
raise ValidationError("marketplace.json validation failed - FIX BEFORE CONTINUING")
return ValidationResult(passed=True, checks=validation_checks)
```
#### **Step 5.3: Create SKILL.md with Frontmatter**
```python
def create_skill_md(domain: str, description: str, detection_spec: DetectionSpec) -> bool:
"""Create SKILL.md with proper frontmatter - MANDATORY"""
frontmatter = f"""---
name: {domain.lower()}-skill-name
description: {description}
---
# {domain.title()} Skill
[... rest of SKILL.md content ...]
"""
with open('SKILL.md', 'w') as f:
f.write(frontmatter)
return True
```
#### **Step 5.4: CRITICAL Synchronization Check**
```python
def synchronize_descriptions() -> bool:
"""MANDATORY: SKILL.md description MUST EQUAL marketplace.json description"""
skill_description = extract_frontmatter_description('SKILL.md')
marketplace_description = extract_marketplace_description('.claude-plugin/marketplace.json')
if skill_description != marketplace_description:
# Fix marketplace.json to match SKILL.md
update_marketplace_description('.claude-plugin/marketplace.json', skill_description)
print("🔧 FIXED: Synchronized SKILL.md description with marketplace.json")
return True
```
#### **Step 5.5: Implementation Order (MANDATORY)**
```python
# Implementation sequence
IMPLEMENTATION_ORDER = {
1: "utils/helpers.py (MANDATORY)",
2: "utils/validators/ (MANDATORY - 4 validators minimum)",
3: "Modular parsers (1 per data type - MANDATORY)",
4: "Main analysis scripts",
5: "comprehensive_{domain}_report() (MANDATORY)",
6: "tests/ directory",
7: "README.md and documentation"
}
```
### **Code Implementation Standards**
#### **No Placeholders Rule**
```python
# ❌ FORBIDDEN - No placeholders or TODOs
def analyze_data(data):
# TODO: implement analysis
pass
# ✅ REQUIRED - Complete implementation
def analyze_data(data: pd.DataFrame) -> Dict[str, Any]:
"""Analyze domain data with comprehensive metrics"""
if data.empty:
raise ValueError("Data cannot be empty")
# Complete implementation with error handling
try:
analysis_results = {
"trend_analysis": calculate_trends(data),
"performance_metrics": calculate_performance(data),
"statistical_summary": generate_statistics(data)
}
return analysis_results
except Exception as e:
logger.error(f"Analysis failed: {e}")
raise AnalysisError(f"Unable to analyze data: {e}")
```
#### **Documentation Standards**
```python
# ✅ REQUIRED: Complete docstrings
def calculate_growth_rate(values: List[float]) -> float:
"""
Calculate compound annual growth rate (CAGR) for a series of values.
Args:
values: List of numeric values in chronological order
Returns:
Compound annual growth rate as decimal (0.15 = 15%)
Raises:
ValueError: If less than 2 values or contains non-numeric data
Example:
>>> calculate_growth_rate([100, 115, 132.25])
0.15 # 15% CAGR
"""
# Implementation...
```
---
## 🧪 **Phase 6: Testing Protocol**
### **When to Apply**
After implementation is complete.
### **Mandatory Test Requirements**
#### **Step 6.1: Test Suite Structure**
```python
MANDATORY_TEST_STRUCTURE = {
"tests/": {
"test_integration.py": "≥5 end-to-end tests - MANDATORY",
"test_parse.py": "1 test per parser - MANDATORY",
"test_analyze.py": "1 test per analysis function - MANDATORY",
"test_helpers.py": "≥3 tests - MANDATORY",
"test_validation.py": "≥5 tests - MANDATORY"
},
"total_minimum_tests": 25, # Absolute minimum
"all_tests_must_pass": True # No exceptions
}
```
#### **Step 6.2: Integration Tests (MANDATORY)**
```python
def create_integration_tests() -> List[TestSpec]:
"""Create ≥5 end-to-end integration tests - MANDATORY"""
integration_tests = [
{
"name": "test_full_workflow_integration",
"description": "Test complete workflow from API to report",
"steps": [
"test_api_connection",
"test_data_parsing",
"test_analysis_execution",
"test_report_generation"
]
},
{
"name": "test_error_handling_integration",
"description": "Test error handling throughout system",
"steps": [
"test_api_failure_handling",
"test_invalid_data_handling",
"test_missing_data_handling"
]
}
# ... 3+ more integration tests
]
return integration_tests
```
#### **Step 6.3: Test Execution & Validation**
```python
def execute_all_tests() -> TestResult:
"""Execute ALL tests and ensure they pass - MANDATORY"""
test_results = {}
# Execute each test file
for test_file in MANDATORY_TEST_STRUCTURE["tests/"]:
test_results[test_file] = execute_test_file(f"tests/{test_file}")
# Validate all tests pass
failed_tests = [test for test, result in test_results.items() if not result.passed]
if failed_tests:
raise TestError(f"FAILED TESTS: {failed_tests} - FIX BEFORE DELIVERY")
print("✅ ALL TESTS PASSED - Ready for delivery")
return TestResult(passed=True, results=test_results)
```
---
## 🧠 **AgentDB Learning Protocol**
### **When to Apply**
After successful skill creation and testing.
### **Automatic Episode Storage**
```python
def store_creation_episode(user_input: str, creation_result: CreationResult) -> str:
"""Store successful creation episode for future learning - AUTOMATIC"""
try:
bridge = get_real_agentdb_bridge()
episode = Episode(
session_id=f"agent-creation-{datetime.now().strftime('%Y%m%d-%H%M%S')}",
task=user_input,
input=f"Domain: {creation_result.domain}, API: {creation_result.api}",
output=f"Created: {creation_result.agent_name}/ with {creation_result.file_count} files",
critique=f"Success: {'✅ High quality' if creation_result.all_tests_passed else '⚠️ Needs refinement'}",
reward=0.9 if creation_result.all_tests_passed else 0.7,
success=creation_result.all_tests_passed,
latency_ms=creation_result.creation_time_seconds * 1000,
tokens_used=creation_result.estimated_tokens,
tags=[creation_result.domain, creation_result.api, creation_result.architecture_type],
metadata={
"agent_name": creation_result.agent_name,
"domain": creation_result.domain,
"api": creation_result.api,
"complexity": creation_result.complexity,
"files_created": creation_result.file_count,
"validation_passed": creation_result.all_tests_passed
}
)
episode_id = bridge.store_episode(episode)
print(f"🧠 Episode stored for learning: #{episode_id}")
# Create skill if successful
if creation_result.all_tests_passed and bridge.is_available:
skill = Skill(
name=f"{creation_result.domain}_agent_template",
description=f"Proven template for {creation_result.domain} agents",
code=f"API: {creation_result.api}, Structure: {creation_result.architecture}",
success_rate=1.0,
uses=1,
avg_reward=0.9,
metadata={"domain": creation_result.domain, "api": creation_result.api}
)
skill_id = bridge.create_skill(skill)
print(f"🎯 Skill created: #{skill_id}")
return episode_id
except Exception as e:
# AgentDB failure should not break agent creation
print("🔄 AgentDB learning unavailable - agent creation completed successfully")
return None
```
### **Learning Progress Integration**
```python
def provide_learning_feedback(episode_count: int, success_rate: float) -> str:
"""Provide subtle feedback about learning progress"""
if episode_count == 1:
return "🎉 First agent created successfully!"
elif episode_count == 10:
return "⚡ Agent creation optimized based on 10 successful patterns"
elif episode_count >= 30:
return "🌟 I've learned your preferences - future creations will be optimized"
return ""
```
---
## 🚨 **Critical Protocol Violations & Prevention**
### **Common Violations to Avoid**
#### **❌ Forbidden Actions**
```python
FORBIDDEN_ACTIONS = {
"asking_user_questions": "Except for critical business decisions",
"creating_placeholders": "No TODOs or pass statements",
"skipping_validations": "All validations must pass",
"ignoring_mandatory_structure": "Required files/dirs must be created",
"poor_documentation": "Must include complete docstrings and comments",
"failing_tests": "All tests must pass before delivery"
}
```
#### **⚠️ Quality Gates**
```python
QUALITY_GATES = {
"pre_implementation": [
"marketplace.json created and validated",
"SKILL.md created with frontmatter",
"descriptions synchronized"
],
"post_implementation": [
"all mandatory files created",
"no placeholders or TODOs",
"complete error handling",
"comprehensive documentation"
],
"pre_delivery": [
"all tests created (≥25)",
"all tests pass",
"marketplace test command successful",
"AgentDB episode stored"
]
}
```
### **Delivery Validation Protocol**
```python
def final_delivery_validation() -> ValidationResult:
"""Final MANDATORY validation before delivery"""
validation_steps = [
("marketplace_syntax", validate_marketplace_syntax),
("description_sync", validate_description_synchronization),
("import_validation", validate_all_imports),
("placeholder_check", check_no_placeholders),
("test_execution", execute_all_tests),
("marketplace_installation", test_marketplace_installation)
]
results = {}
for step_name, validation_func in validation_steps:
try:
results[step_name] = validation_func()
except Exception as e:
results[step_name] = ValidationResult(passed=False, error=str(e))
failed_steps = [step for step, result in results.items() if not result.passed]
if failed_steps:
raise ValidationError(f"DELIVERY BLOCKED - Failed validations: {failed_steps}")
return ValidationResult(passed=True, validations=results)
```
---
## 📋 **Complete Protocol Checklist**
### **Pre-Creation Validation**
- [ ] User request triggers skill creation protocol
- [ ] Agent-Skill-Cursor activates correctly
- [ ] Initial domain analysis complete
### **Phase 1: Discovery**
- [ ] Domain identified and analyzed
- [ ] API researched and selected (with justification)
- [ ] API completeness analysis completed (≥50% coverage)
- [ ] Multi-agent/transcript analysis if applicable
- [ ] Creation strategy determined
### **Phase 2: Design**
- [ ] Use cases defined (4-6 analyses + comprehensive report)
- [ ] Methodologies specified for each analysis
- [ ] Value proposition and ROI calculated
- [ ] Design decisions documented
### **Phase 3: Architecture**
- [ ] Modular architecture designed
- [ ] Parser architecture planned (1 per data type)
- [ ] Validation system planned (4+ validators)
- [ ] Helper functions specified
- [ ] File structure finalized
### **Phase 4: Detection (Enhanced)**
- [ ] 50-80 keywords generated across 5 categories
- [ ] 10-15 enhanced patterns created
- [ ] Context-aware filters configured
- [ ] Multi-intent detection configured
- [ ] marketplace.json activation section populated
### **Phase 5: Implementation**
- [ ] marketplace.json created FIRST and validated
- [ ] SKILL.md created with synchronized description
- [ ] utils/helpers.py implemented (MANDATORY)
- [ ] utils/validators/ implemented (4+ validators)
- [ ] Modular parsers implemented (1 per data type)
- [ ] Main analysis scripts implemented
- [ ] comprehensive_{domain}_report() implemented (MANDATORY)
- [ ] No placeholders or TODOs anywhere
- [ ] Complete error handling throughout
- [ ] Comprehensive documentation written
### **Phase 6: Testing**
- [ ] tests/ directory created
- [ ] ≥25 tests implemented across all categories
- [ ] ALL tests pass
- [ ] Integration tests successful
- [ ] Marketplace installation test successful
### **Final Delivery**
- [ ] Final validation passed
- [ ] AgentDB episode stored
- [ ] Learning feedback provided if applicable
- [ ] Ready for user delivery
---
## 🎯 **Protocol Success Metrics**
### **Quality Indicators**
- **Activation Reliability**: ≥99.5%
- **False Positive Rate**: <1%
- **Code Coverage**: ≥90%
- **Test Pass Rate**: 100%
- **Documentation Completeness**: 100%
- **User Satisfaction**: ≥95%
### **Learning Indicators**
- **Episodes Stored**: 100% of successful creations
- **Pattern Recognition**: Improves with each creation
- **Decision Quality**: Enhanced by AgentDB learning
- **Template Success Rate**: Tracked and optimized
---
**Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-24
**Maintained By:** Agent-Skill-Creator Team

685
references/context-aware-activation.md
View file

@ -1,685 +0,0 @@
# Context-Aware Activation System v1.0
**Version:** 1.0
**Purpose:** Advanced context filtering for precise skill activation and false positive reduction
**Target:** Reduce false positives from 2% to <1% while maintaining 99.5%+ reliability
---
## 🎯 **Overview**
Context-Aware Activation enhances the 3-Layer Activation System by analyzing the semantic and contextual environment of user queries to ensure skills activate only in appropriate situations.
### **Problem Solved**
**Before:** Skills activated based purely on keyword/pattern matching, leading to false positives in inappropriate contexts
**After:** Skills evaluate contextual relevance before activation, dramatically reducing inappropriate activations
---
## 🧠 **Context Analysis Framework**
### **Multi-Dimensional Context Analysis**
The system evaluates query context across multiple dimensions:
#### **1. Domain Context**
```json
{
"domain_context": {
"current_domain": "finance",
"confidence": 0.92,
"related_domains": ["trading", "investment", "market"],
"excluded_domains": ["healthcare", "education", "entertainment"]
}
}
```
#### **2. Task Context**
```json
{
"task_context": {
"current_task": "analysis",
"task_stage": "exploration",
"task_complexity": "medium",
"required_capabilities": ["data_processing", "calculation"]
}
}
```
#### **3. User Intent Context**
```json
{
"intent_context": {
"primary_intent": "analyze",
"secondary_intents": ["compare", "evaluate"],
"intent_strength": 0.87,
"urgency_level": "medium"
}
}
```
#### **4. Conversational Context**
```json
{
"conversational_context": {
"conversation_stage": "problem_identification",
"previous_queries": ["stock market trends", "investment analysis"],
"context_coherence": 0.94,
"topic_consistency": 0.89
}
}
```
---
## 🔍 **Context Detection Algorithms**
### **Semantic Context Extraction**
```python
def extract_semantic_context(query, conversation_history=None):
"""Extract semantic context from query and conversation"""
context = {
'entities': extract_named_entities(query),
'concepts': extract_key_concepts(query),
'relationships': extract_entity_relationships(query),
'sentiment': analyze_sentiment(query),
'urgency': detect_urgency(query)
}
# Analyze conversation history if available
if conversation_history:
context['conversation_coherence'] = analyze_coherence(
query, conversation_history
)
context['topic_evolution'] = track_topic_evolution(
conversation_history
)
return context
def extract_named_entities(query):
"""Extract named entities from query"""
entities = {
'organizations': [],
'locations': [],
'persons': [],
'products': [],
'technical_terms': []
}
# Use NLP library or pattern matching
# Implementation depends on available tools
return entities
def extract_key_concepts(query):
"""Extract key concepts and topics"""
concepts = {
'primary_domain': identify_primary_domain(query),
'secondary_domains': identify_secondary_domains(query),
'technical_concepts': extract_technical_terms(query),
'business_concepts': extract_business_terms(query)
}
return concepts
```
### **Context Relevance Scoring**
```python
def calculate_context_relevance(query, skill_config, extracted_context):
"""Calculate how relevant the query context is to the skill"""
relevance_scores = {}
# Domain relevance
relevance_scores['domain'] = calculate_domain_relevance(
skill_config['expected_domains'],
extracted_context['concepts']['primary_domain']
)
# Task relevance
relevance_scores['task'] = calculate_task_relevance(
skill_config['supported_tasks'],
extracted_context['intent_context']['primary_intent']
)
# Capability relevance
relevance_scores['capability'] = calculate_capability_relevance(
skill_config['capabilities'],
extracted_context['required_capabilities']
)
# Context coherence
relevance_scores['coherence'] = extracted_context.get(
'conversation_coherence', 0.5
)
# Calculate weighted overall relevance
weights = {
'domain': 0.3,
'task': 0.25,
'capability': 0.25,
'coherence': 0.2
}
overall_relevance = sum(
score * weights[category]
for category, score in relevance_scores.items()
)
return {
'overall_relevance': overall_relevance,
'category_scores': relevance_scores,
'recommendation': evaluate_relevance_threshold(overall_relevance)
}
def evaluate_relevance_threshold(relevance_score):
"""Determine activation recommendation based on relevance"""
if relevance_score >= 0.9:
return {'activate': True, 'confidence': 'high', 'reason': 'Strong context match'}
elif relevance_score >= 0.7:
return {'activate': True, 'confidence': 'medium', 'reason': 'Good context match'}
elif relevance_score >= 0.5:
return {'activate': False, 'confidence': 'low', 'reason': 'Weak context match'}
else:
return {'activate': False, 'confidence': 'very_low', 'reason': 'Poor context match'}
```
---
## 🚫 **Context Filtering System**
### **Negative Context Detection**
```python
def detect_negative_context(query, skill_config):
"""Detect contexts where skill should NOT activate"""
negative_indicators = {
'excluded_domains': [],
'conflicting_intents': [],
'inappropriate_contexts': [],
'resource_constraints': []
}
# Check for excluded domains
excluded_domains = skill_config.get('contextual_filters', {}).get('excluded_domains', [])
query_domains = identify_query_domains(query)
for domain in query_domains:
if domain in excluded_domains:
negative_indicators['excluded_domains'].append({
'domain': domain,
'reason': f'Domain "{domain}" is explicitly excluded'
})
# Check for conflicting intents
conflicting_intents = identify_conflicting_intents(query, skill_config)
negative_indicators['conflicting_intents'] = conflicting_intents
# Check for inappropriate contexts
inappropriate_contexts = check_context_appropriateness(query, skill_config)
negative_indicators['inappropriate_contexts'] = inappropriate_contexts
# Calculate negative score
negative_score = calculate_negative_score(negative_indicators)
return {
'should_block': negative_score > 0.7,
'negative_score': negative_score,
'indicators': negative_indicators,
'recommendation': generate_block_recommendation(negative_score)
}
def check_context_appropriateness(query, skill_config):
"""Check if query context is appropriate for skill activation"""
inappropriate = []
# Check if user is asking for help with existing tools
if any(phrase in query.lower() for phrase in [
'how to use', 'help with', 'tutorial', 'guide', 'explain'
]):
if 'tutorial' not in skill_config.get('capabilities', {}):
inappropriate.append({
'type': 'help_request',
'reason': 'User requesting help, not task execution'
})
# Check if user is asking about theory or education
if any(phrase in query.lower() for phrase in [
'what is', 'explain', 'define', 'theory', 'concept', 'learn about'
]):
if 'educational' not in skill_config.get('capabilities', {}):
inappropriate.append({
'type': 'educational_query',
'reason': 'User asking for education, not task execution'
})
# Check if user is trying to debug or troubleshoot
if any(phrase in query.lower() for phrase in [
'debug', 'error', 'problem', 'issue', 'fix', 'troubleshoot'
]):
if 'debugging' not in skill_config.get('capabilities', {}):
inappropriate.append({
'type': 'debugging_query',
'reason': 'User asking for debugging help'
})
return inappropriate
```
### **Context-Aware Decision Engine**
```python
def make_context_aware_decision(query, skill_config, conversation_history=None):
"""Make final activation decision considering all context factors"""
# Extract context
context = extract_semantic_context(query, conversation_history)
# Calculate relevance
relevance = calculate_context_relevance(query, skill_config, context)
# Check for negative indicators
negative_context = detect_negative_context(query, skill_config)
# Get confidence threshold from skill config
confidence_threshold = skill_config.get(
'contextual_filters', {}
).get('confidence_threshold', 0.7)
# Make decision
should_activate = True
decision_reasons = []
# Check negative context first (blocking condition)
if negative_context['should_block']:
should_activate = False
decision_reasons.append(f"Blocked: {negative_context['recommendation']['reason']}")
# Check relevance threshold
elif relevance['overall_relevance'] < confidence_threshold:
should_activate = False
decision_reasons.append(f"Low relevance: {relevance['overall_relevance']:.2f} < {confidence_threshold}")
# Check confidence level
elif relevance['recommendation']['confidence'] == 'low':
should_activate = False
decision_reasons.append(f"Low confidence: {relevance['recommendation']['reason']}")
# If passing all checks, recommend activation
else:
decision_reasons.append(f"Approved: {relevance['recommendation']['reason']}")
return {
'should_activate': should_activate,
'confidence': relevance['recommendation']['confidence'],
'relevance_score': relevance['overall_relevance'],
'negative_score': negative_context['negative_score'],
'decision_reasons': decision_reasons,
'context_analysis': {
'relevance': relevance,
'negative_context': negative_context,
'extracted_context': context
}
}
```
---
## 📋 **Enhanced Marketplace Configuration**
### **Context-Aware Configuration Structure**
```json
{
"name": "skill-name",
"activation": {
"keywords": [...],
"patterns": [...],
"_comment": "NEW: Context-aware filtering",
"contextual_filters": {
"required_context": {
"domains": ["finance", "trading", "investment"],
"tasks": ["analysis", "calculation", "comparison"],
"entities": ["stock", "ticker", "market"],
"confidence_threshold": 0.8
},
"excluded_context": {
"domains": ["healthcare", "education", "entertainment"],
"tasks": ["tutorial", "help", "debugging"],
"query_types": ["question", "definition", "explanation"],
"user_states": ["learning", "exploring"]
},
"context_weights": {
"domain_relevance": 0.35,
"task_relevance": 0.30,
"intent_strength": 0.20,
"conversation_coherence": 0.15
},
"activation_rules": {
"min_relevance_score": 0.75,
"max_negative_score": 0.3,
"required_coherence": 0.6,
"context_consistency_check": true
}
}
},
"capabilities": {
"technical_analysis": true,
"data_processing": true,
"_comment": "NEW: Context capabilities",
"context_requirements": {
"min_confidence": 0.8,
"required_domains": ["finance"],
"supported_tasks": ["analysis", "calculation"]
}
}
}
```
---
## 🧪 **Context Testing Framework**
### **Context Test Generation**
```python
def generate_context_test_cases(skill_config):
"""Generate test cases for context-aware activation"""
test_cases = []
# Positive context tests (should activate)
positive_contexts = [
{
'query': 'Analyze AAPL stock using RSI indicator',
'context': {'domain': 'finance', 'task': 'analysis', 'intent': 'analyze'},
'expected': True,
'reason': 'Perfect domain and task match'
},
{
'query': 'I need to compare MSFT vs GOOGL performance',
'context': {'domain': 'finance', 'task': 'comparison', 'intent': 'compare'},
'expected': True,
'reason': 'Domain match with supported task'
}
]
# Negative context tests (should NOT activate)
negative_contexts = [
{
'query': 'Explain what stock analysis is',
'context': {'domain': 'education', 'task': 'explanation', 'intent': 'learn'},
'expected': False,
'reason': 'Educational context, not task execution'
},
{
'query': 'How to use the stock analyzer tool',
'context': {'domain': 'help', 'task': 'tutorial', 'intent': 'learn'},
'expected': False,
'reason': 'Tutorial request, not analysis task'
},
{
'query': 'Debug my stock analysis code',
'context': {'domain': 'programming', 'task': 'debugging', 'intent': 'fix'},
'expected': False,
'reason': 'Debugging context, not supported capability'
}
]
# Edge case tests
edge_cases = [
{
'query': 'Stock market trends for healthcare companies',
'context': {'domain': 'finance', 'subdomain': 'healthcare', 'task': 'analysis'},
'expected': True,
'reason': 'Finance domain with healthcare subdomain - should activate'
},
{
'query': 'Teach me about technical analysis',
'context': {'domain': 'education', 'topic': 'technical_analysis'},
'expected': False,
'reason': 'Educational context despite relevant topic'
}
]
test_cases.extend(positive_contexts)
test_cases.extend(negative_contexts)
test_cases.extend(edge_cases)
return test_cases
def run_context_aware_tests(skill_config, test_cases):
"""Run context-aware activation tests"""
results = []
for i, test_case in enumerate(test_cases):
query = test_case['query']
expected = test_case['expected']
reason = test_case['reason']
# Simulate context analysis
decision = make_context_aware_decision(query, skill_config)
result = {
'test_id': i + 1,
'query': query,
'expected': expected,
'actual': decision['should_activate'],
'correct': expected == decision['should_activate'],
'confidence': decision['confidence'],
'relevance_score': decision['relevance_score'],
'decision_reasons': decision['decision_reasons'],
'test_reason': reason
}
results.append(result)
# Log result
status = "✅" if result['correct'] else "❌"
print(f"{status} Test {i+1}: {query}")
if not result['correct']:
print(f" Expected: {expected}, Got: {decision['should_activate']}")
print(f" Reasons: {'; '.join(decision['decision_reasons'])}")
# Calculate metrics
total_tests = len(results)
correct_tests = sum(1 for r in results if r['correct'])
accuracy = correct_tests / total_tests if total_tests > 0 else 0
return {
'total_tests': total_tests,
'correct_tests': correct_tests,
'accuracy': accuracy,
'results': results
}
```
---
## 📊 **Performance Monitoring**
### **Context-Aware Metrics**
```python
class ContextAwareMonitor:
"""Monitor context-aware activation performance"""
def __init__(self):
self.metrics = {
'total_queries': 0,
'context_filtered': 0,
'false_positives_prevented': 0,
'context_analysis_time': [],
'relevance_scores': [],
'negative_contexts_detected': []
}
def log_context_decision(self, query, decision, actual_outcome=None):
"""Log context-aware activation decision"""
self.metrics['total_queries'] += 1
# Track context filtering
if not decision['should_activate'] and decision['relevance_score'] > 0.5:
self.metrics['context_filtered'] += 1
# Track prevented false positives (if we have feedback)
if actual_outcome == 'false_positive_prevented':
self.metrics['false_positives_prevented'] += 1
# Track relevance scores
self.metrics['relevance_scores'].append(decision['relevance_score'])
# Track negative contexts
if decision['negative_score'] > 0.5:
self.metrics['negative_contexts_detected'].append({
'query': query,
'negative_score': decision['negative_score'],
'reasons': decision['decision_reasons']
})
def generate_performance_report(self):
"""Generate context-aware performance report"""
total = self.metrics['total_queries']
if total == 0:
return "No data available"
context_filter_rate = self.metrics['context_filtered'] / total
avg_relevance = sum(self.metrics['relevance_scores']) / len(self.metrics['relevance_scores'])
report = f"""
Context-Aware Performance Report
================================
Total Queries Analyzed: {total}
Queries Filtered by Context: {self.metrics['context_filtered']} ({context_filter_rate:.1%})
False Positives Prevented: {self.metrics['false_positives_prevented']}
Average Relevance Score: {avg_relevance:.3f}
Top Negative Context Categories:
"""
# Analyze negative contexts
negative_reasons = {}
for context in self.metrics['negative_contexts_detected']:
for reason in context['reasons']:
negative_reasons[reason] = negative_reasons.get(reason, 0) + 1
for reason, count in sorted(negative_reasons.items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True)[:5]:
report += f" - {reason}: {count}\n"
return report
```
---
## 🔄 **Integration with Existing System**
### **Enhanced 3-Layer Activation**
```python
def enhanced_three_layer_activation(query, skill_config, conversation_history=None):
"""Enhanced 3-layer activation with context awareness"""
# Layer 1: Keyword matching (existing)
keyword_match = check_keyword_matching(query, skill_config['activation']['keywords'])
# Layer 2: Pattern matching (existing)
pattern_match = check_pattern_matching(query, skill_config['activation']['patterns'])
# Layer 3: Description understanding (existing)
description_match = check_description_relevance(query, skill_config)
# NEW: Layer 4: Context-aware filtering
context_decision = make_context_aware_decision(query, skill_config, conversation_history)
# Make final decision
base_match = keyword_match or pattern_match or description_match
if not base_match:
return {
'should_activate': False,
'reason': 'No base layer match',
'layers_matched': [],
'context_filtered': False
}
if not context_decision['should_activate']:
return {
'should_activate': False,
'reason': f'Context filtered: {"; ".join(context_decision["decision_reasons"])}',
'layers_matched': get_matched_layers(keyword_match, pattern_match, description_match),
'context_filtered': True,
'context_score': context_decision['relevance_score']
}
return {
'should_activate': True,
'reason': f'Approved: {context_decision["recommendation"]["reason"]}',
'layers_matched': get_matched_layers(keyword_match, pattern_match, description_match),
'context_filtered': False,
'context_score': context_decision['relevance_score'],
'confidence': context_decision['confidence']
}
```
---
## ✅ **Implementation Checklist**
### **Configuration Requirements**
- [ ] Add `contextual_filters` section to marketplace.json
- [ ] Define `required_context` domains and tasks
- [ ] Define `excluded_context` for false positive prevention
- [ ] Set appropriate `confidence_threshold`
- [ ] Configure `context_weights` for domain-specific needs
### **Testing Requirements**
- [ ] Generate context test cases for each skill
- [ ] Test positive context scenarios
- [ ] Test negative context scenarios
- [ ] Validate edge cases and boundary conditions
- [ ] Monitor false positive reduction
### **Performance Requirements**
- [ ] Context analysis time < 100ms
- [ ] Relevance calculation accuracy > 90%
- [ ] False positive reduction > 50%
- [ ] No negative impact on true positive rate
---
## 📈 **Expected Outcomes**
### **Performance Improvements**
- **False Positive Rate**: 2% → **<1%**
- **Context Precision**: 60% → **85%**
- **User Satisfaction**: 85% → **95%**
- **Activation Reliability**: 98% → **99.5%**
### **User Experience Benefits**
- Skills activate only in appropriate contexts
- Reduced confusion and frustration
- More predictable and reliable behavior
- Better understanding of skill capabilities
---
**Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-24
**Maintained By:** Agent-Skill-Creator Team

BIN
references/examples/exports/stock-analyzer-api-v1.0.0.zip
View file

Binary file not shown.

BIN
references/examples/exports/stock-analyzer-desktop-v1.0.0.zip
View file

Binary file not shown.

238
references/examples/exports/stock-analyzer-v1.0.0_INSTALL.md
View file

@ -1,238 +0,0 @@
# stock-analyzer - Installation Guide
**Version:** v1.0.0
**Generated:** 2025-10-24 12:56:28
---
## 📦 Export Packages
### Desktop/Web Package
**File:** `stock-analyzer-desktop-v1.0.0.zip`
**Size:** 0.01 MB
**Files:** 4 files included
✅ Optimized for Claude Desktop and claude.ai manual upload
### API Package
**File:** `stock-analyzer-api-v1.0.0.zip`
**Size:** 0.01 MB
**Files:** 4 files included
✅ Optimized for programmatic Claude API integration
---
## 🚀 Installation Instructions
### For Claude Desktop
1. **Locate the Desktop package**
- File: `{skill}-desktop-{version}.zip`
2. **Open Claude Desktop**
- Launch the Claude Desktop application
3. **Navigate to Skills settings**
- Go to: **Settings → Capabilities → Skills**
4. **Upload the skill**
- Click: **Upload skill**
- Select the desktop package .zip file
- Wait for upload confirmation
5. **Verify installation**
- The skill should now appear in your Skills list
- Try using it with a relevant query
✅ **Your skill is now available in Claude Desktop!**
---
### For claude.ai (Web Interface)
1. **Locate the Desktop package**
- File: `{skill}-desktop-{version}.zip`
- (Same package as Desktop - optimized for both)
2. **Visit claude.ai**
- Open https://claude.ai in your browser
- Log in to your account
3. **Open Settings**
- Click your profile icon
- Select **Settings**
4. **Navigate to Skills**
- Click on the **Skills** section
5. **Upload the skill**
- Click: **Upload skill**
- Select the desktop package .zip file
- Confirm the upload
6. **Start using**
- Create a new conversation
- The skill will activate automatically when relevant
✅ **Your skill is now available at claude.ai!**
---
### For Claude API (Programmatic Integration)
1. **Locate the API package**
- File: `{skill}-api-{version}.zip`
- Optimized for API use (smaller, execution-focused)
2. **Install required packages**
```bash
pip install anthropic
```
3. **Upload skill programmatically**
```python
import anthropic
client = anthropic.Anthropic(api_key="your-api-key")
# Upload the skill
with open('{skill}-api-{version}.zip', 'rb') as f:
skill = client.skills.create(
file=f,
name="{skill}"
)
print(f"Skill uploaded! ID: {{skill.id}}")
```
4. **Use in API requests**
```python
response = client.messages.create(
model="claude-sonnet-4",
messages=[
{{"role": "user", "content": "Your query here"}}
],
container={{
"type": "custom_skill",
"skill_id": skill.id
}},
betas=[
"code-execution-2025-08-25",
"skills-2025-10-02"
]
)
print(response.content)
```
5. **Important API requirements**
- Must include beta headers: `code-execution-2025-08-25` and `skills-2025-10-02`
- Maximum 8 skills per request
- Skills run in isolated containers (no network access, no pip install)
✅ **Your skill is now integrated with the Claude API!**
---
## 📋 Platform Comparison
| Feature | Claude Code | Desktop/Web | Claude API |
|---------|-------------|-------------|------------|
| **Installation** | Plugin command | Manual upload | Programmatic |
| **Updates** | Git pull | Re-upload .zip | New upload |
| **Version Control** | ✅ Native | ⚠️ Manual | ✅ Versioned |
| **Team Sharing** | ✅ Via plugins | ❌ Individual | ✅ Via API |
| **marketplace.json** | ✅ Used | ❌ Ignored | ❌ Not used |
---
## ⚙️ Technical Details
### What's Included
**Desktop Package:**
- SKILL.md (core functionality)
- Complete scripts/ directory
- Full references/ documentation
- All assets/ and templates
- README.md and requirements.txt
**API Package:**
- SKILL.md (required)
- Essential scripts only
- Minimal documentation (execution-focused)
- Size-optimized (< 8MB)
### What's Excluded (Security)
For both packages:
- `.git/` (version control history)
- `__pycache__/` (compiled Python)
- `.env` files (environment variables)
- `credentials.json` (API keys/secrets)
- `.DS_Store` (system metadata)
For API package additionally:
- `.claude-plugin/` (Claude Code specific)
- Large documentation files
- Example files (size optimization)
---
## 🔧 Troubleshooting
### Upload fails with "File too large"
**Desktop/Web:**
- Maximum size varies by platform
- Try the API package instead (smaller)
- Contact support if needed
**API:**
- Maximum: 8MB
- The API package is already optimized
- May need to reduce documentation or scripts
### Skill doesn't activate
**Check:**
1. SKILL.md has valid frontmatter
2. `name:` field is present and ≤ 64 characters
3. `description:` field is present and ≤ 1024 characters
4. Description clearly explains when to use the skill
### API errors
**Common issues:**
- Missing beta headers (required!)
- Skill ID incorrect (check `skill.id` after upload)
- Network/pip install attempted (not allowed in API environment)
---
## 📚 Additional Resources
- **Export Guide:** See `references/export-guide.md` in the main repository
- **Cross-Platform Guide:** See `references/cross-platform-guide.md`
- **Main Documentation:** See the main README.md
---
## ✅ Verification Checklist
After installation, verify:
- [ ] Skill appears in Skills list
- [ ] Skill activates with relevant queries
- [ ] Scripts execute correctly
- [ ] Documentation is accessible
- [ ] No error messages on activation
---
**Need help?** Refer to the platform-specific documentation or the main repository guides.
**Generated by:** agent-skill-creator v3.2 cross-platform export system

806
references/multi-intent-detection.md
View file

@ -1,806 +0,0 @@
# Multi-Intent Detection System v1.0
**Version:** 1.0
**Purpose:** Advanced detection and handling of complex user queries with multiple intentions
**Target:** Support complex queries with 95%+ intent accuracy and proper capability routing
---
## 🎯 **Overview**
Multi-Intent Detection extends the activation system to handle complex user queries that contain multiple intentions, requiring the skill to understand and prioritize different user goals within a single request.
### **Problem Solved**
**Before:** Skills could only handle single-intent queries, failing when users expressed multiple goals or complex requirements
**After:** Skills can detect, prioritize, and handle multiple intents within a single query, routing to appropriate capabilities
---
## 🧠 **Multi-Intent Architecture**
### **Intent Classification Hierarchy**
```
Primary Intent (Main Goal)
├── Secondary Intent 1 (Sub-goal)
├── Secondary Intent 2 (Additional requirement)
├── Tertiary Intent (Context/Modifier)
└── Meta Intent (How to present results)
```
### **Intent Types**
#### **1. Primary Intents**
The main action or goal the user wants to accomplish:
- `analyze` - Analyze data or information
- `create` - Create new content or agent
- `compare` - Compare multiple items
- `monitor` - Track or watch something
- `transform` - Convert or change format
#### **2. Secondary Intents**
Additional requirements or sub-goals:
- `and_visualize` - Also create visualization
- `and_save` - Also save results
- `and_explain` - Also provide explanation
- `and_compare` - Also do comparison
- `and_alert` - Also set up alerts
#### **3. Contextual Intents**
Modifiers that affect how results should be presented:
- `quick_summary` - Brief overview
- `detailed_analysis` - In-depth analysis
- `step_by_step` - Process explanation
- `real_time` - Live/current data
- `historical` - Historical data
#### **4. Meta Intents**
How the user wants to interact:
- `just_show_me` - Direct results
- `teach_me` - Educational approach
- `help_me_decide` - Decision support
- `automate_for_me` - Automation request
---
## 🔍 **Intent Detection Algorithms**
### **Multi-Intent Parser**
```python
def parse_multiple_intents(query, skill_capabilities):
"""Parse multiple intents from a complex user query"""
# Step 1: Identify primary intent
primary_intent = extract_primary_intent(query)
# Step 2: Identify secondary intents
secondary_intents = extract_secondary_intents(query)
# Step 3: Identify contextual modifiers
contextual_intents = extract_contextual_intents(query)
# Step 4: Identify meta intent
meta_intent = extract_meta_intent(query)
# Step 5: Validate against skill capabilities
validated_intents = validate_intents_against_capabilities(
primary_intent, secondary_intents, contextual_intents, skill_capabilities
)
return {
'primary_intent': validated_intents['primary'],
'secondary_intents': validated_intents['secondary'],
'contextual_intents': validated_intents['contextual'],
'meta_intent': validated_intents['meta'],
'intent_combinations': generate_intent_combinations(validated_intents),
'confidence_scores': calculate_intent_confidence(query, validated_intents),
'execution_plan': create_execution_plan(validated_intents)
}
def extract_primary_intent(query):
"""Extract the primary intent from the query"""
intent_patterns = {
'analyze': [
r'(?i)(analyze|analysis|examine|study|evaluate|review)\s+',
r'(?i)(what\s+is|how\s+does)\s+.*\s+(perform|work|behave)',
r'(?i)(tell\s+me\s+about|explain)\s+'
],
'create': [
r'(?i)(create|build|make|generate|develop)\s+',
r'(?i)(I\s+need|I\s+want)\s+(a|an)\s+',
r'(?i)(help\s+me\s+)(create|build|make)\s+'
],
'compare': [
r'(?i)(compare|comparison|vs|versus)\s+',
r'(?i)(which\s+is\s+better|what\s+is\s+the\s+difference)\s+',
r'(?i)(rank|rating|scoring)\s+'
],
'monitor': [
r'(?i)(monitor|track|watch|observe)\s+',
r'(?i)(keep\s+an\s+eye\s+on|follow)\s+',
r'(?i)(alert\s+me\s+when|notify\s+me)\s+'
],
'transform': [
r'(?i)(convert|transform|change|turn)\s+.*\s+(into|to)\s+',
r'(?i)(format|structure|organize)\s+',
r'(?i)(extract|parse|process)\s+'
]
}
best_match = None
highest_score = 0
for intent, patterns in intent_patterns.items():
for pattern in patterns:
if re.search(pattern, query):
score = calculate_intent_match_score(query, intent, pattern)
if score > highest_score:
highest_score = score
best_match = intent
return best_match or 'unknown'
def extract_secondary_intents(query):
"""Extract secondary intents from conjunctions and phrases"""
secondary_patterns = {
'and_visualize': [
r'(?i)(and\s+)?(show|visualize|display|chart|graph)\s+',
r'(?i)(create\s+)?(visualization|chart|graph|dashboard)\s+'
],
'and_save': [
r'(?i)(and\s+)?(save|store|export|download)\s+',
r'(?i)(keep|record|archive)\s+(the\s+)?(results|data)\s+'
],
'and_explain': [
r'(?i)(and\s+)?(explain|clarify|describe|detail)\s+',
r'(?i)(what\s+does\s+this\s+mean|why\s+is\s+this)\s+'
],
'and_compare': [
r'(?i)(and\s+)?(compare|vs|versus|against)\s+',
r'(?i)(relative\s+to|compared\s+with)\s+'
],
'and_alert': [
r'(?i)(and\s+)?(alert|notify|warn)\s+(me\s+)?(when|if)\s+',
r'(?i)(set\s+up\s+)?(notification|alert)\s+'
]
}
detected_intents = []
for intent, patterns in secondary_patterns.items():
for pattern in patterns:
if re.search(pattern, query):
detected_intents.append(intent)
break
return detected_intents
def extract_contextual_intents(query):
"""Extract contextual modifiers and presentation preferences"""
contextual_patterns = {
'quick_summary': [
r'(?i)(quick|brief|short|summary|overview)\s+',
r'(?i)(just\s+the\s+highlights|key\s+points)\s+'
],
'detailed_analysis': [
r'(?i)(detailed|in-depth|comprehensive|thorough)\s+',
r'(?i)(deep\s+dive|full\s+analysis)\s+'
],
'step_by_step': [
r'(?i)(step\s+by\s+step|how\s+to|process|procedure)\s+',
r'(?i)(walk\s+me\s+through|guide\s+me)\s+'
],
'real_time': [
r'(?i)(real\s+time|live|current|now|today)\s+',
r'(?i)(right\s+now|as\s+of\s+today)\s+'
],
'historical': [
r'(?i)(historical|past|previous|last\s+year|ytd)\s+',
r'(?i)(over\s+the\s+last\s+|historically)\s+'
]
}
detected_intents = []
for intent, patterns in contextual_patterns.items():
for pattern in patterns:
if re.search(pattern, query):
detected_intents.append(intent)
break
return detected_intents
```
### **Intent Validation System**
```python
def validate_intents_against_capabilities(primary, secondary, contextual, capabilities):
"""Validate detected intents against skill capabilities"""
validated = {
'primary': None,
'secondary': [],
'contextual': [],
'meta': None,
'validation_issues': []
}
# Validate primary intent
if primary in capabilities.get('primary_intents', []):
validated['primary'] = primary
else:
validated['validation_issues'].append(
f"Primary intent '{primary}' not supported by skill"
)
# Validate secondary intents
for intent in secondary:
if intent in capabilities.get('secondary_intents', []):
validated['secondary'].append(intent)
else:
validated['validation_issues'].append(
f"Secondary intent '{intent}' not supported by skill"
)
# Validate contextual intents
for intent in contextual:
if intent in capabilities.get('contextual_intents', []):
validated['contextual'].append(intent)
else:
validated['validation_issues'].append(
f"Contextual intent '{intent}' not supported by skill"
)
# If no valid primary intent, try to find best alternative
if not validated['primary'] and secondary:
validated['primary'] = find_best_alternative_primary(primary, secondary, capabilities)
validated['validation_issues'].append(
f"Used alternative primary intent: {validated['primary']}"
)
return validated
def generate_intent_combinations(validated_intents):
"""Generate possible combinations of validated intents"""
combinations = []
primary = validated_intents['primary']
secondary = validated_intents['secondary']
contextual = validated_intents['contextual']
if primary:
# Base combination: primary only
combinations.append({
'combination_id': 'primary_only',
'intents': [primary],
'priority': 1,
'complexity': 'low'
})
# Primary + each secondary
for sec_intent in secondary:
combinations.append({
'combination_id': f'primary_{sec_intent}',
'intents': [primary, sec_intent],
'priority': 2,
'complexity': 'medium'
})
# Primary + all secondary
if len(secondary) > 1:
combinations.append({
'combination_id': 'primary_all_secondary',
'intents': [primary] + secondary,
'priority': 3,
'complexity': 'high'
})
# Add contextual modifiers
for combo in combinations:
for context in contextual:
new_combo = combo.copy()
new_combo['intents'] = combo['intents'] + [context]
new_combo['combination_id'] = f"{combo['combination_id']}_{context}"
new_combo['priority'] = combo['priority'] + 0.1
new_combo['complexity'] = increase_complexity(combo['complexity'])
combinations.append(new_combo)
# Sort by priority and complexity
combinations.sort(key=lambda x: (x['priority'], x['complexity']))
return combinations
def create_execution_plan(validated_intents):
"""Create an execution plan for handling multiple intents"""
plan = {
'steps': [],
'parallel_tasks': [],
'sequential_dependencies': [],
'estimated_complexity': 'medium',
'estimated_time': 'medium'
}
primary = validated_intents['primary']
secondary = validated_intents['secondary']
contextual = validated_intents['contextual']
if primary:
# Step 1: Execute primary intent
plan['steps'].append({
'step_id': 1,
'intent': primary,
'action': f'execute_{primary}',
'dependencies': [],
'estimated_time': 'medium'
})
# Step 2: Execute secondary intents (can be parallel if compatible)
for i, intent in enumerate(secondary):
if can_execute_parallel(primary, intent):
plan['parallel_tasks'].append({
'task_id': f'secondary_{i}',
'intent': intent,
'action': f'execute_{intent}',
'dependencies': ['step_1']
})
else:
plan['steps'].append({
'step_id': len(plan['steps']) + 1,
'intent': intent,
'action': f'execute_{intent}',
'dependencies': [f'step_{len(plan["steps"])}'],
'estimated_time': 'short'
})
# Step 3: Apply contextual modifiers
for i, intent in enumerate(contextual):
plan['steps'].append({
'step_id': len(plan['steps']) + 1,
'intent': intent,
'action': f'apply_{intent}',
'dependencies': ['step_1'] + [f'secondary_{j}' for j in range(len(secondary))],
'estimated_time': 'short'
})
# Calculate overall complexity
total_intents = 1 + len(secondary) + len(contextual)
if total_intents <= 2:
plan['estimated_complexity'] = 'low'
elif total_intents <= 4:
plan['estimated_complexity'] = 'medium'
else:
plan['estimated_complexity'] = 'high'
return plan
```
---
## 📋 **Enhanced Marketplace Configuration**
### **Multi-Intent Configuration Structure**
```json
{
"name": "skill-name",
"activation": {
"keywords": [...],
"patterns": [...],
"contextual_filters": {...},
"_comment": "NEW: Multi-intent detection (v1.0)",
"intent_hierarchy": {
"primary_intents": {
"analyze": {
"description": "Analyze data or information",
"keywords": ["analyze", "examine", "evaluate", "study"],
"required_capabilities": ["data_processing", "analysis"],
"base_confidence": 0.9
},
"compare": {
"description": "Compare multiple items",
"keywords": ["compare", "versus", "vs", "ranking"],
"required_capabilities": ["comparison", "evaluation"],
"base_confidence": 0.85
},
"monitor": {
"description": "Track or monitor data",
"keywords": ["monitor", "track", "watch", "alert"],
"required_capabilities": ["monitoring", "notification"],
"base_confidence": 0.8
}
},
"secondary_intents": {
"and_visualize": {
"description": "Also create visualization",
"keywords": ["show", "chart", "graph", "visualize"],
"required_capabilities": ["visualization"],
"compatibility": ["analyze", "compare", "monitor"],
"confidence_modifier": 0.1
},
"and_save": {
"description": "Also save results",
"keywords": ["save", "export", "download", "store"],
"required_capabilities": ["file_operations"],
"compatibility": ["analyze", "compare", "transform"],
"confidence_modifier": 0.05
},
"and_explain": {
"description": "Also provide explanation",
"keywords": ["explain", "clarify", "describe", "detail"],
"required_capabilities": ["explanation", "reporting"],
"compatibility": ["analyze", "compare", "transform"],
"confidence_modifier": 0.05
}
},
"contextual_intents": {
"quick_summary": {
"description": "Provide brief overview",
"keywords": ["quick", "summary", "brief", "overview"],
"impact": "reduce_detail",
"confidence_modifier": 0.02
},
"detailed_analysis": {
"description": "Provide in-depth analysis",
"keywords": ["detailed", "comprehensive", "thorough", "in-depth"],
"impact": "increase_detail",
"confidence_modifier": 0.03
},
"real_time": {
"description": "Use current/live data",
"keywords": ["real-time", "live", "current", "now"],
"impact": "require_live_data",
"confidence_modifier": 0.04
}
},
"intent_combinations": {
"analyze_and_visualize": {
"description": "Analyze data and create visualization",
"primary": "analyze",
"secondary": ["and_visualize"],
"confidence_threshold": 0.85,
"execution_order": ["analyze", "and_visualize"]
},
"compare_and_explain": {
"description": "Compare items and explain differences",
"primary": "compare",
"secondary": ["and_explain"],
"confidence_threshold": 0.8,
"execution_order": ["compare", "and_explain"]
},
"monitor_and_alert": {
"description": "Monitor data and send alerts",
"primary": "monitor",
"secondary": ["and_alert"],
"confidence_threshold": 0.8,
"execution_order": ["monitor", "and_alert"]
}
},
"intent_processing": {
"max_secondary_intents": 3,
"max_contextual_intents": 2,
"parallel_execution_threshold": 0.8,
"fallback_to_primary": true,
"intent_confidence_threshold": 0.7
}
}
},
"capabilities": {
"primary_intents": ["analyze", "compare", "monitor"],
"secondary_intents": ["and_visualize", "and_save", "and_explain"],
"contextual_intents": ["quick_summary", "detailed_analysis", "real_time"],
"supported_combinations": [
"analyze_and_visualize",
"compare_and_explain",
"monitor_and_alert"
]
}
}
```
---
## 🧪 **Multi-Intent Testing Framework**
### **Test Case Generation**
```python
def generate_multi_intent_test_cases(skill_config):
"""Generate test cases for multi-intent detection"""
test_cases = []
# Single intent tests (baseline)
single_intents = [
{
'query': 'Analyze AAPL stock',
'intents': {'primary': 'analyze', 'secondary': [], 'contextual': []},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'low'
},
{
'query': 'Compare MSFT vs GOOGL',
'intents': {'primary': 'compare', 'secondary': [], 'contextual': []},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'low'
}
]
# Double intent tests
double_intents = [
{
'query': 'Analyze AAPL stock and show me a chart',
'intents': {'primary': 'analyze', 'secondary': ['and_visualize'], 'contextual': []},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'medium'
},
{
'query': 'Compare these stocks and explain the differences',
'intents': {'primary': 'compare', 'secondary': ['and_explain'], 'contextual': []},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'medium'
},
{
'query': 'Monitor this stock and alert me on changes',
'intents': {'primary': 'monitor', 'secondary': ['and_alert'], 'contextual': []},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'medium'
}
]
# Triple intent tests
triple_intents = [
{
'query': 'Analyze AAPL stock, show me a chart, and save the results',
'intents': {'primary': 'analyze', 'secondary': ['and_visualize', 'and_save'], 'contextual': []},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'high'
},
{
'query': 'Compare these stocks, explain differences, and give me a quick summary',
'intents': {'primary': 'compare', 'secondary': ['and_explain'], 'contextual': ['quick_summary']},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'high'
}
]
# Complex natural language tests
complex_queries = [
{
'query': 'I need to analyze the performance of these tech stocks, create some visualizations to compare them, and save everything to a file for my presentation',
'intents': {'primary': 'analyze', 'secondary': ['and_visualize', 'and_compare', 'and_save'], 'contextual': []},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'very_high'
},
{
'query': 'Can you help me monitor my portfolio in real-time and send me alerts if anything significant happens, with detailed analysis of what\'s going on?',
'intents': {'primary': 'monitor', 'secondary': ['and_alert', 'and_explain'], 'contextual': ['real_time', 'detailed_analysis']},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'very_high'
}
]
# Edge cases and invalid combinations
edge_cases = [
{
'query': 'Analyze this stock and teach me how to cook',
'intents': {'primary': 'analyze', 'secondary': [], 'contextual': []},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'low',
'note': 'Unsupported secondary intent should be filtered out'
},
{
'query': 'Compare these charts while explaining that theory',
'intents': {'primary': 'compare', 'secondary': ['and_explain'], 'contextual': []},
'expected': True,
'complexity': 'medium',
'note': 'Mixed context - should prioritize domain-relevant parts'
}
]
test_cases.extend(single_intents)
test_cases.extend(double_intents)
test_cases.extend(triple_intents)
test_cases.extend(complex_queries)
test_cases.extend(edge_cases)
return test_cases
def run_multi_intent_tests(skill_config, test_cases):
"""Run multi-intent detection tests"""
results = []
for i, test_case in enumerate(test_cases):
query = test_case['query']
expected_intents = test_case['intents']
expected = test_case['expected']
# Parse intents from query
detected_intents = parse_multiple_intents(query, skill_config['capabilities'])
# Validate results
result = {
'test_id': i + 1,
'query': query,
'expected_intents': expected_intents,
'detected_intents': detected_intents,
'expected_activation': expected,
'actual_activation': detected_intents['primary_intent'] is not None,
'intent_accuracy': calculate_intent_accuracy(expected_intents, detected_intents),
'complexity_match': test_case['complexity'] == detected_intents.get('complexity', 'unknown'),
'notes': test_case.get('note', '')
}
# Determine if test passed
primary_correct = expected_intents['primary'] == detected_intents.get('primary_intent')
secondary_correct = set(expected_intents['secondary']) == set(detected_intents.get('secondary_intents', []))
activation_correct = expected == result['actual_activation']
result['test_passed'] = primary_correct and secondary_correct and activation_correct
results.append(result)
# Log result
status = "✅" if result['test_passed'] else "❌"
print(f"{status} Test {i+1}: {query[:60]}...")
if not result['test_passed']:
print(f" Expected primary: {expected_intents['primary']}, Got: {detected_intents.get('primary_intent')}")
print(f" Expected secondary: {expected_intents['secondary']}, Got: {detected_intents.get('secondary_intents', [])}")
# Calculate metrics
total_tests = len(results)
passed_tests = sum(1 for r in results if r['test_passed'])
accuracy = passed_tests / total_tests if total_tests > 0 else 0
avg_intent_accuracy = sum(r['intent_accuracy'] for r in results) / total_tests if total_tests > 0 else 0
return {
'total_tests': total_tests,
'passed_tests': passed_tests,
'accuracy': accuracy,
'avg_intent_accuracy': avg_intent_accuracy,
'results': results
}
```
---
## 📊 **Performance Monitoring**
### **Multi-Intent Metrics**
```python
class MultiIntentMonitor:
"""Monitor multi-intent detection performance"""
def __init__(self):
self.metrics = {
'total_queries': 0,
'single_intent_queries': 0,
'multi_intent_queries': 0,
'intent_detection_accuracy': [],
'intent_combination_success': [],
'complexity_distribution': {'low': 0, 'medium': 0, 'high': 0, 'very_high': 0},
'execution_plan_accuracy': []
}
def log_intent_detection(self, query, detected_intents, execution_success=None):
"""Log intent detection results"""
self.metrics['total_queries'] += 1
# Count intent types
total_intents = 1 + len(detected_intents.get('secondary_intents', [])) + len(detected_intents.get('contextual_intents', []))
if total_intents == 1:
self.metrics['single_intent_queries'] += 1
else:
self.metrics['multi_intent_queries'] += 1
# Track complexity distribution
complexity = detected_intents.get('complexity', 'medium')
if complexity in self.metrics['complexity_distribution']:
self.metrics['complexity_distribution'][complexity] += 1
# Track execution success if provided
if execution_success is not None:
self.metrics['execution_plan_accuracy'].append(execution_success)
def calculate_multi_intent_rate(self):
"""Calculate the rate of multi-intent queries"""
if self.metrics['total_queries'] == 0:
return 0.0
return self.metrics['multi_intent_queries'] / self.metrics['total_queries']
def generate_performance_report(self):
"""Generate multi-intent performance report"""
total = self.metrics['total_queries']
if total == 0:
return "No data available"
multi_intent_rate = self.calculate_multi_intent_rate()
avg_execution_accuracy = (sum(self.metrics['execution_plan_accuracy']) / len(self.metrics['execution_plan_accuracy'])
if self.metrics['execution_plan_accuracy'] else 0)
report = f"""
Multi-Intent Detection Performance Report
========================================
Total Queries Analyzed: {total}
Single-Intent Queries: {self.metrics['single_intent_queries']} ({(self.metrics['single_intent_queries']/total)*100:.1f}%)
Multi-Intent Queries: {self.metrics['multi_intent_queries']} ({multi_intent_rate*100:.1f}%)
Complexity Distribution:
- Low: {self.metrics['complexity_distribution']['low']} ({(self.metrics['complexity_distribution']['low']/total)*100:.1f}%)
- Medium: {self.metrics['complexity_distribution']['medium']} ({(self.metrics['complexity_distribution']['medium']/total)*100:.1f}%)
- High: {self.metrics['complexity_distribution']['high']} ({(self.metrics['complexity_distribution']['high']/total)*100:.1f}%)
- Very High: {self.metrics['complexity_distribution']['very_high']} ({(self.metrics['complexity_distribution']['very_high']/total)*100:.1f}%)
Execution Plan Accuracy: {avg_execution_accuracy*100:.1f}%
"""
return report
```
---
## ✅ **Implementation Checklist**
### **Configuration Requirements**
- [ ] Add `intent_hierarchy` section to marketplace.json
- [ ] Define supported `primary_intents` with capabilities
- [ ] Define supported `secondary_intents` with compatibility rules
- [ ] Define supported `contextual_intents` with impact modifiers
- [ ] Configure `intent_combinations` with execution plans
- [ ] Set appropriate `intent_processing` thresholds
### **Testing Requirements**
- [ ] Generate multi-intent test cases for each combination
- [ ] Test single-intent queries (baseline)
- [ ] Test double-intent queries
- [ ] Test triple-intent queries
- [ ] Test complex natural language queries
- [ ] Validate edge cases and invalid combinations
### **Performance Requirements**
- [ ] Intent detection accuracy > 95%
- [ ] Multi-intent processing time < 200ms
- [ ] Execution plan accuracy > 90%
- [ ] Support for up to 5 concurrent intents
- [ ] Graceful fallback to primary intent
---
## 📈 **Expected Outcomes**
### **Performance Improvements**
- **Multi-Intent Support**: 0% → **100%**
- **Complex Query Handling**: 20% → **95%**
- **User Intent Accuracy**: 70% → **95%**
- **Natural Language Understanding**: 60% → **90%**
### **User Experience Benefits**
- Natural handling of complex requests
- Better understanding of user goals
- More comprehensive responses
- Reduced need for follow-up queries
---
**Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-24
**Maintained By:** Agent-Skill-Creator Team

783
references/phase6-testing.md
View file

@ -1,783 +0,0 @@
# Phase 6: Test Suite Generation (NEW v2.0!)
## Objective
**GENERATE** comprehensive test suite that validates ALL functions of the created skill.
**LEARNING:** us-crop-monitor v1.0 had ZERO tests. When expanding to v2.0, it was difficult to ensure nothing broke. v2.0 has 25 tests (100% passing) that ensure reliability.
---
## Why Are Tests Critical?
### Benefits for Developer:
- ✅ Ensures code works before distribution
- ✅ Detects bugs early (not after client installs!)
- ✅ Allows confident changes (regression testing)
- ✅ Documents expected behavior
### Benefits for Client:
- ✅ Confidence in skill ("100% tested")
- ✅ Fewer bugs in production
- ✅ More professional (commercially viable)
### Benefits for Agent-Creator:
- ✅ Validates that generated skill actually works
- ✅ Catch errors before considering "done"
- ✅ Automatic quality gate
---
## Test Structure
### tests/ Directory
```
{skill-name}/
└── tests/
├── test_fetch.py # Tests API client
├── test_parse.py # Tests parsers
├── test_analyze.py # Tests analyses
├── test_integration.py # Tests end-to-end
├── test_validation.py # Tests validators
├── test_helpers.py # Tests helpers (year detection, etc.)
└── README.md # How to run tests
```
---
## Template 1: test_fetch.py
**Objective:** Validate API client works
```python
#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""
Test suite for {API} client.
Tests all fetch methods with real API data.
"""
import sys
from pathlib import Path
sys.path.insert(0, str(Path(__file__).parent.parent / 'scripts'))
from fetch_{api} import {ApiClient}, DataNotFoundError
def test_get_{metric1}():
"""Test fetching {metric1} data."""
print("\nTesting get_{metric1}()...")
try:
client = {ApiClient}()
# Test with valid parameters
result = client.get_{metric1}(
{entity}='{valid_entity}',
year=2024
)
# Validations
assert 'data' in result, "Missing 'data' in result"
assert 'metadata' in result, "Missing 'metadata'"
assert len(result['data']) > 0, "No data returned"
assert result['metadata']['from_cache'] in [True, False]
print(f" ✓ Fetched {len(result['data'])} records")
print(f" ✓ Metadata present")
print(f" ✓ From cache: {result['metadata']['from_cache']}")
return True
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✗ FAILED: {e}")
return False
def test_get_{metric2}():
"""Test fetching {metric2} data."""
# Similar structure...
pass
def test_error_handling():
"""Test that errors are handled correctly."""
print("\nTesting error handling...")
try:
client = {ApiClient}()
# Test invalid entity (should raise)
try:
result = client.get_{metric1}({entity}='INVALID_ENTITY', year=2024)
print(" ✗ Should have raised DataNotFoundError")
return False
except DataNotFoundError:
print(" ✓ Correctly raises DataNotFoundError for invalid entity")
# Test invalid year (should raise)
try:
result = client.get_{metric1}({entity}='{valid}', year=2099)
print(" ✗ Should have raised ValidationError")
return False
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✓ Correctly raises error for future year")
return True
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✗ Unexpected error: {e}")
return False
def main():
"""Run all fetch tests."""
print("=" * 70)
print("FETCH TESTS - {API} Client")
print("=" * 70)
results = []
# Test each get_* method
results.append(("get_{metric1}", test_get_{metric1}()))
results.append(("get_{metric2}", test_get_{metric2}()))
# ... add test for ALL get_* methods
results.append(("error_handling", test_error_handling()))
# Summary
print("\n" + "=" * 70)
print("SUMMARY")
print("=" * 70)
passed = sum(1 for _, r in results if r)
total = len(results)
for name, result in results:
status = "✓ PASS" if result else "✗ FAIL"
print(f"{status}: {name}()")
print(f"\nResults: {passed}/{total} tests passed")
return passed == total
if __name__ == "__main__":
success = main()
sys.exit(0 if success else 1)
```
**Rule:** ONE test function for EACH `get_*()` method implemented!
---
## Template 2: test_parse.py
**Objective:** Validate parsers
```python
#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""
Test suite for data parsers.
Tests all parse_* modules.
"""
import sys
from pathlib import Path
sys.path.insert(0, str(Path(__file__).parent.parent / 'scripts'))
from parse_{type1} import parse_{type1}_response
from parse_{type2} import parse_{type2}_response
def test_parse_{type1}():
"""Test {type1} parser."""
print("\nTesting parse_{type1}_response()...")
# Sample data (real structure from API)
sample_data = [
{
'field1': 'value1',
'field2': 'value2',
'Value': '123',
# ... real API fields
}
]
try:
df = parse_{type1}_response(sample_data)
# Validations
assert not df.empty, "DataFrame is empty"
assert 'Value' in df.columns or '{metric}_value' in df.columns
assert len(df) == len(sample_data)
print(f" ✓ Parsed {len(df)} records")
print(f" ✓ Columns: {list(df.columns)}")
return True
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✗ FAILED: {e}")
import traceback
traceback.print_exc()
return False
def test_parse_empty_data():
"""Test parser handles empty data gracefully."""
print("\nTesting empty data handling...")
try:
from parse_{type1} import ParseError
try:
df = parse_{type1}_response([])
print(" ✗ Should have raised ParseError")
return False
except ParseError as e:
print(f" ✓ Correctly raises ParseError: {e}")
return True
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✗ Unexpected error: {e}")
return False
def main():
results = []
# Test each parser
results.append(("parse_{type1}", test_parse_{type1}()))
results.append(("parse_{type2}", test_parse_{type2}()))
# ... for ALL parsers
results.append(("empty_data", test_parse_empty_data()))
# Summary
passed = sum(1 for _, r in results if r)
print(f"\nResults: {passed}/{len(results)} passed")
return passed == len(results)
if __name__ == "__main__":
sys.exit(0 if main() else 1)
```
---
## Template 3: test_integration.py
**Objective:** End-to-end tests (MOST IMPORTANT!)
```python
#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""
Integration tests for {skill-name}.
Tests all analysis functions with REAL API data.
"""
import sys
from pathlib import Path
sys.path.insert(0, str(Path(__file__).parent.parent / 'scripts'))
from analyze_{domain} import (
{function1},
{function2},
{function3},
# ... import ALL functions
)
def test_{function1}():
"""Test {function1} with auto-year detection."""
print("\n1. Testing {function1}()...")
try:
# Test WITHOUT year (auto-detection)
result = {function1}({entity}='{valid_entity}')
# Validations
assert 'year' in result, "Missing year"
assert 'year_requested' in result, "Missing year_requested"
assert 'year_info' in result, "Missing year_info"
assert result['year'] >= 2024, "Year too old"
assert result['year_requested'] is None, "Should auto-detect"
print(f" ✓ Auto-year detection: {result['year']}")
print(f" ✓ Year info: {result['year_info']}")
print(f" ✓ Data present: {list(result.keys())}")
return True
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✗ FAILED: {e}")
import traceback
traceback.print_exc()
return False
def test_{function1}_with_explicit_year():
"""Test {function1} with explicit year."""
print("\n2. Testing {function1}() with explicit year...")
try:
# Test WITH year specified
result = {function1}({entity}='{valid_entity}', year=2024)
assert result['year'] == 2024, f"Expected 2024, got {result['year']}"
assert result['year_requested'] == 2024
print(f" ✓ Uses specified year: {result['year']}")
return True
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✗ FAILED: {e}")
return False
def test_all_functions_exist():
"""Verify all expected functions are implemented."""
print("\nVerifying all functions exist...")
expected_functions = [
'{function1}',
'{function2}',
'{function3}',
# ... ALL functions
]
missing = []
for func_name in expected_functions:
if func_name not in globals():
missing.append(func_name)
if missing:
print(f" ✗ Missing functions: {missing}")
return False
else:
print(f" ✓ All {len(expected_functions)} functions present")
return True
def main():
"""Run all integration tests."""
print("\n" + "=" * 70)
print("{SKILL NAME} - INTEGRATION TEST SUITE")
print("=" * 70)
results = []
# Test each function
results.append(("{function1} auto-year", test_{function1}()))
results.append(("{function1} explicit-year", test_{function1}_with_explicit_year()))
# ... repeat for ALL functions
results.append(("all_functions_exist", test_all_functions_exist()))
# Summary
print("\n" + "=" * 70)
print("FINAL SUMMARY")
print("=" * 70)
passed = sum(1 for _, r in results if r)
total = len(results)
print(f"\n✓ Passed: {passed}/{total}")
print(f"✗ Failed: {total - passed}/{total}")
if passed == total:
print("\n🎉 ALL TESTS PASSED! SKILL IS PRODUCTION READY!")
else:
print(f"\n⚠ {total - passed} test(s) failed - FIX BEFORE RELEASE")
print("=" * 70)
return passed == total
if __name__ == "__main__":
success = main()
sys.exit(0 if success else 1)
```
**Rule:** Minimum 2 tests per analysis function (auto-year + explicit-year)
---
## Template 4: test_helpers.py
**Objective:** Test year detection helpers
```python
#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""
Test suite for utility helpers.
Tests temporal context detection.
"""
import sys
from pathlib import Path
from datetime import datetime
sys.path.insert(0, str(Path(__file__).parent.parent / 'scripts'))
from utils.helpers import (
get_current_{domain}_year,
should_try_previous_year,
format_year_message
)
def test_get_current_year():
"""Test current year detection."""
print("\nTesting get_current_{domain}_year()...")
try:
year = get_current_{domain}_year()
current_year = datetime.now().year
assert year == current_year, f"Expected {current_year}, got {year}"
print(f" ✓ Correctly returns: {year}")
return True
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✗ FAILED: {e}")
return False
def test_should_try_previous_year():
"""Test seasonal fallback logic."""
print("\nTesting should_try_previous_year()...")
try:
# Test with None (current year)
result = should_try_previous_year()
print(f" ✓ Current year fallback: {result}")
# Test with specific year
result_past = should_try_previous_year(2023)
print(f" ✓ Past year fallback: {result_past}")
return True
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✗ FAILED: {e}")
return False
def test_format_year_message():
"""Test year message formatting."""
print("\nTesting format_year_message()...")
try:
# Test auto-detected
msg1 = format_year_message(2025, None)
assert "auto-detected" in msg1.lower() or "2025" in msg1
print(f" ✓ Auto-detected: {msg1}")
# Test requested
msg2 = format_year_message(2024, 2024)
assert "2024" in msg2
print(f" ✓ Requested: {msg2}")
# Test fallback
msg3 = format_year_message(2024, 2025)
assert "not" in msg3.lower() or "fallback" in msg3.lower()
print(f" ✓ Fallback: {msg3}")
return True
except Exception as e:
print(f" ✗ FAILED: {e}")
return False
def main():
results = []
results.append(("get_current_year", test_get_current_year()))
results.append(("should_try_previous_year", test_should_try_previous_year()))
results.append(("format_year_message", test_format_year_message()))
passed = sum(1 for _, r in results if r)
print(f"\nResults: {passed}/{len(results)} passed")
return passed == len(results)
if __name__ == "__main__":
sys.exit(0 if main() else 1)
```
---
## Quality Rules for Tests
### 1. ALL tests must use REAL DATA
❌ **FORBIDDEN:**
```python
def test_function():
# Mock data
mock_data = {'fake': 'data'}
result = function(mock_data)
assert result == 'expected'
```
✅ **MANDATORY:**
```python
def test_function():
# Real API call
client = ApiClient()
result = client.get_real_data(entity='REAL', year=2024)
# Validate real response
assert len(result['data']) > 0
assert 'metadata' in result
```
**Why?**
- Tests with mocks don't guarantee API is working
- Real tests detect API changes
- Client needs to know it works with REAL data
---
### 2. Tests must be FAST
**Goal:** Complete suite in < 60 seconds
**Techniques:**
- Use cache: First test populates cache, rest use cached
- Limit requests: Don't test 100 entities, test 2-3
- Parallel where possible
```python
# Example: Populate cache once
@classmethod
def setUpClass(cls):
"""Populate cache before all tests."""
client = ApiClient()
client.get_data('ENTITY1', 2024) # Cache for other tests
# Tests then use cached data (fast)
```
---
### 3. Tests must PASS 100%
**Quality Gate:** Skill is only "done" when ALL tests pass.
```python
if __name__ == "__main__":
success = main()
if not success:
print("\n❌ SKILL NOT READY - FIX FAILING TESTS")
sys.exit(1)
else:
print("\n✅ SKILL READY FOR DISTRIBUTION")
sys.exit(0)
```
---
## Test Coverage Requirements
### Minimum Mandatory:
**Per module:**
- `fetch_{api}.py`: 1 test per `get_*()` method + 1 error handling test
- Each `parse_{type}.py`: 1 test per main function
- `analyze_{domain}.py`: 2 tests per analysis (auto-year + explicit-year)
- `utils/helpers.py`: 3 tests (get_year, should_fallback, format_message)
**Expected total:** 15-30 tests depending on skill size
**Example (us-crop-monitor v2.0):**
- test_fetch.py: 6 tests (5 get_* + 1 error)
- test_parse.py: 4 tests (4 parsers)
- test_analyze.py: 11 tests (11 functions)
- test_helpers.py: 3 tests
- test_integration.py: 1 end-to-end test
- **Total:** 25 tests
---
## How to Run Tests
### Individual:
```bash
python3 tests/test_fetch.py
python3 tests/test_integration.py
```
### Complete suite:
```bash
# Run all
for test in tests/test_*.py; do
python3 $test || exit 1
done
# Or with pytest (if available)
pytest tests/
```
### In CI/CD:
```yaml
# .github/workflows/test.yml
name: Test Suite
on: [push]
jobs:
test:
runs-on: ubuntu-latest
steps:
- uses: actions/checkout@v2
- run: pip install -r requirements.txt
- run: python3 tests/test_integration.py
```
---
## Output Example
**When tests pass:**
```
======================================================================
US CROP MONITOR - INTEGRATION TEST SUITE
======================================================================
1. current_condition_report()...
✓ Year: 2025 | Week: 39
✓ Good+Excellent: 66.0%
2. week_over_week_comparison()...
✓ Year: 2025 | Weeks: 39 vs 38
✓ Delta: -2.2 pts
...
======================================================================
FINAL SUMMARY
======================================================================
✓ Passed: 25/25 tests
✗ Failed: 0/25 tests
🎉 ALL TESTS PASSED! SKILL IS PRODUCTION READY!
======================================================================
```
**When tests fail:**
```
8. yield_analysis()...
✗ FAILED: 'yield_bu_per_acre' not in result
...
FINAL SUMMARY:
✓ Passed: 24/25
✗ Failed: 1/25
❌ SKILL NOT READY - FIX FAILING TESTS
```
---
## Integration with Agent-Creator
### When to generate tests:
**In Phase 5 (Implementation):**
Updated order:
```
...
8. Implement analyze (analyses)
9. CREATE TESTS (← here!)
- Generate test_fetch.py
- Generate test_parse.py
- Generate test_analyze.py
- Generate test_helpers.py
- Generate test_integration.py
10. RUN TESTS
- Run test suite
- If fails → FIX and re-run
- Only continue when 100% passing
11. Create examples/
...
```
### Quality Gate:
```python
# Agent-creator should do:
print("Running test suite...")
exit_code = subprocess.run(['python3', 'tests/test_integration.py']).returncode
if exit_code != 0:
print("❌ Tests failed - aborting skill generation")
print("Fix errors above and try again")
sys.exit(1)
print("✅ All tests passed - continuing...")
```
---
## Testing Checklist
Before considering skill "done":
- [ ] tests/ directory created
- [ ] test_fetch.py with 1 test per get_*() method
- [ ] test_parse.py with 1 test per parser
- [ ] test_analyze.py with 2 tests per function (auto-year + explicit)
- [ ] test_helpers.py with year detection tests
- [ ] test_integration.py with end-to-end test
- [ ] ALL tests passing (100%)
- [ ] Test suite executes in < 60 seconds
- [ ] README in tests/ explaining how to run
---
## Real Example: us-crop-monitor v2.0
**Tests created:**
- `test_new_metrics.py` - 5 tests (fetch methods)
- `test_year_detection.py` - 2 tests (auto-detection)
- `test_all_year_detection.py` - 4 tests (all functions)
- `test_new_analyses.py` - 3 tests (new analyses)
- `tests/test_integrated_validation.py` - 11 tests (comprehensive)
**Total:** 25 tests, 100% passing
**Result:**
```
✓ Passed: 25/25 tests
🎉 ALL TESTS PASSED! SKILL IS PRODUCTION READY!
```
**Benefit:** Full confidence v2.0 works before distribution!
---
## Conclusion
**ALWAYS generate test suite!**
Skills without tests = prototypes
Skills with tests = professional products ✅
**ROI:** Tests cost +2h to create, but save 10-20h of debugging later!

352
references/synonym-expansion-system.md
View file

@ -1,352 +0,0 @@
# Synonym Expansion System v3.1
**Purpose**: Comprehensive synonym and natural language expansion library for 98%+ skill activation reliability.
---
## 🎯 **Problem Solved: Natural Language Gap**
**Issue**: Skills fail to activate because users use natural language variations, synonyms, and conversational phrasing that traditional keyword systems don't cover.
**Example Problem:**
- User says: "I need to get information from this website"
- Skill keywords: ["extract data", "analyze data"]
- Result: ❌ Skill doesn't activate, Claude ignores it
**Enhanced Solution:**
- Expanded keywords: ["extract data", "analyze data", "get information", "scrape content", "pull details", "harvest data", "collect metrics"]
- Result: ✅ Skill activates reliably
---
## 📚 **Synonym Library by Category**
### **1. Data & Information Synonyms**
#### **1.1 Core Data Synonyms**
```json
{
"data": ["information", "content", "details", "records", "dataset", "metrics", "figures", "statistics", "values", "numbers"],
"information": ["data", "content", "details", "facts", "insights", "knowledge", "records", "metrics"],
"content": ["data", "information", "material", "text", "details", "content", "substance"],
"details": ["data", "information", "specifics", "particulars", "facts", "records", "data points"],
"records": ["data", "information", "entries", "logs", "files", "documents", "records"],
"dataset": ["data", "information", "collection", "records", "files", "database", "records"],
"metrics": ["data", "measurements", "statistics", "figures", "indicators", "numbers", "values"],
"statistics": ["data", "metrics", "figures", "numbers", "measurements", "analytics", "data"]
}
```
#### **1.2 Technical Data Synonyms**
```json
{
"extract": ["scrape", "get", "pull", "retrieve", "collect", "harvest", "obtain", "gather", "acquire", "fetch"],
"scrape": ["extract", "get", "pull", "harvest", "collect", "gather", "acquire", "mine", "pull"],
"retrieve": ["extract", "get", "pull", "fetch", "obtain", "collect", "gather", "acquire", "harvest"],
"collect": ["extract", "gather", "harvest", "acquire", "obtain", "pull", "get", "scrape", "fetch"],
"harvest": ["extract", "collect", "gather", "acquire", "obtain", "pull", "get", "scrape", "mine"]
}
```
### **2. Action & Processing Synonyms**
#### **2.1 Analysis & Processing Synonyms**
```json
{
"analyze": ["process", "handle", "work with", "examine", "study", "evaluate", "review", "assess", "explore", "investigate", "scrutinize"],
"process": ["analyze", "handle", "work with", "manage", "deal with", "work through", "examine", "study"],
"handle": ["process", "manage", "deal with", "work with", "work on", "handle", "address", "process"],
"work with": ["process", "handle", "manage", "deal with", "work on", "process", "handle", "address"],
"examine": ["analyze", "study", "review", "inspect", "check", "look at", "evaluate", "assess"],
"study": ["analyze", "examine", "review", "investigate", "research", "explore", "evaluate", "assess"]
}
```
#### **2.2 Transformation & Normalization Synonyms**
```json
{
"normalize": ["clean", "format", "standardize", "structure", "organize", "regularize", "standardize", "clean", "format"],
"clean": ["normalize", "format", "structure", "organize", "standardize", "regularize", "tidy", "format"],
"format": ["normalize", "clean", "structure", "organize", "standardize", "regularize", "arrange", "organize"],
"structure": ["normalize", "organize", "format", "clean", "standardize", "regularize", "arrange", "organize"],
"organize": ["normalize", "structure", "format", "clean", "standardize", "regularize", "arrange", "structure"]
}
```
### **3. Source & Location Synonyms**
#### **3.1 Website & Source Synonyms**
```json
{
"website": ["site", "webpage", "web site", "online site", "digital platform", "internet site", "url"],
"site": ["website", "webpage", "web site", "online site", "digital platform", "internet page", "url"],
"webpage": ["website", "site", "web page", "online page", "internet page", "digital page"],
"source": ["origin", "location", "place", "point", "spot", "area", "region", "position"],
"api": ["application programming interface", "web service", "service", "endpoint", "interface"],
"database": ["db", "data store", "data repository", "information base", "record system"]
}
```
### **4. Workflow & Business Synonyms**
#### **4.1 Repetitive Task Synonyms**
```json
{
"every day": ["daily", "each day", "per day", "daily routine", "day to day"],
"daily": ["every day", "each day", "per day", "day to day", "daily routine", "regularly"],
"have to": ["need to", "must", "should", "got to", "required to", "obligated to"],
"need to": ["have to", "must", "should", "got to", "required to", "obligated to"],
"regularly": ["every day", "daily", "consistently", "frequently", "often", "routinely"],
"repeatedly": ["regularly", "frequently", "often", "consistently", "day after day"]
}
```
#### **4.2 Business Process Synonyms**
```json
{
"reports": ["analytics", "analysis", "metrics", "statistics", "findings", "results", "outcomes"],
"metrics": ["reports", "analytics", "statistics", "figures", "measurements", "data", "indicators"],
"analytics": ["reports", "metrics", "statistics", "analysis", "insights", "findings", "intelligence"],
"dashboard": ["reports", "analytics", "overview", "summary", "display", "panel", "interface"],
"meetings": ["discussions", "reviews", "presentations", "briefings", "sessions", "gatherings"]
}
```
---
## 🔄 **Synonym Expansion Algorithm**
### **Core Expansion Function**
```python
def expand_with_synonyms(base_keywords, domain):
"""
Expand keywords with comprehensive synonym coverage
"""
expanded_keywords = set(base_keywords)
# 1. Core synonym expansion
for keyword in base_keywords:
if keyword in SYNONYM_LIBRARY:
expanded_keywords.update(SYNONYM_LIBRARY[keyword])
# 2. Reverse lookup (find synonyms that match)
expanded_keywords.update(find_synonym_matches(base_keywords))
# 3. Domain-specific expansion
if domain in DOMAIN_SYNONYMS:
expanded_keywords.update(DOMAIN_SYNONYMS[domain])
# 4. Combination generation
expanded_keywords.update(generate_combinations(base_keywords))
# 5. Natural language variations
expanded_keywords.update(generate_natural_variations(base_keywords))
return list(expanded_keywords)
```
### **Combination Generator**
```python
def generate_combinations(keywords):
"""
Generate natural combinations of keywords
"""
combinations = set()
# Action + Data combinations
actions = ["extract", "get", "pull", "scrape", "harvest", "collect"]
data_types = ["data", "information", "content", "records", "metrics"]
sources = ["from website", "from site", "from API", "from database", "from file"]
for action in actions:
for data_type in data_types:
for source in sources:
combinations.add(f"{action} {data_type} {source}")
return combinations
```
### **Natural Language Generator**
```python
def generate_natural_variations(keywords):
"""
Generate conversational and informal variations
"""
variations = set()
# Question forms
prefixes = ["how to", "what can I", "can you", "help me", "I need to"]
for keyword in keywords:
for prefix in prefixes:
variations.add(f"{prefix} {keyword}")
# Command forms
for keyword in keywords:
variations.add(f"{keyword} from this site")
variations.add(f"{keyword} from the website")
variations.add(f"{keyword} from that source")
return variations
```
---
## 📊 **Domain-Specific Synonym Libraries**
### **Finance Domain**
```json
{
"stock": ["equity", "share", "security", "ticker", "instrument", "investment"],
"analyze": ["research", "evaluate", "assess", "review", "examine", "study", "investigate"],
"technical": ["chart", "graph", "indicator", "signal", "pattern", "trend", "analysis"],
"investment": ["portfolio", "trading", "investing", "asset", "holding", "position"]
}
```
### **E-commerce Domain**
```json
{
"product": ["item", "goods", "merchandise", "inventory", "stock", "offering"],
"customer": ["client", "buyer", "shopper", "user", "consumer", "purchaser"],
"order": ["purchase", "transaction", "sale", "buy", "acquisition", "booking"],
"inventory": ["stock", "goods", "items", "products", "merchandise", "supply"]
}
```
### **Healthcare Domain**
```json
{
"patient": ["client", "individual", "person", "case", "member"],
"treatment": ["care", "therapy", "procedure", "intervention", "service"],
"medical": ["health", "clinical", "therapeutic", "diagnostic", "healing"],
"records": ["files", "documents", "charts", "history", "profile", "information"]
}
```
### **Technology Domain**
```json
{
"system": ["platform", "software", "application", "tool", "solution", "program"],
"user": ["person", "individual", "customer", "client", "member", "participant"],
"feature": ["capability", "function", "ability", "functionality", "option"],
"performance": ["speed", "efficiency", "optimization", "throughput", "capacity"]
}
```
---
## 🎯 **Implementation Examples**
### **Example 1: Data Extraction Skill**
```python
# Input:
base_keywords = ["extract data", "normalize data", "analyze data"]
domain = "data_extraction"
# Output (68 keywords total):
expanded_keywords = [
# Base (3)
"extract data", "normalize data", "analyze data",
# Synonym expansions (15)
"scrape data", "get data", "pull data", "harvest data", "collect data",
"clean data", "format data", "structure data", "organize data",
"process data", "handle data", "work with data", "examine data",
# Domain-specific (8)
"web scraping", "data mining", "API integration", "ETL process",
"content parsing", "information retrieval", "data processing",
# Combinations (20)
"extract and analyze data", "get and process information",
"scrape and normalize content", "pull and structure records",
"harvest and format metrics", "collect and organize dataset",
# Natural language (22)
"how to extract data", "what can I scrape from this site",
"can you process information", "help me handle records",
"I need to normalize information", "pull data from website"
]
```
### **Example 2: Finance Analysis Skill**
```python
# Input:
base_keywords = ["analyze stock", "technical analysis", "RSI indicator"]
domain = "finance"
# Output (45 keywords total):
expanded_keywords = [
# Base (3)
"analyze stock", "technical analysis", "RSI indicator",
# Synonym expansions (12)
"evaluate equity", "research security", "review ticker",
"chart analysis", "graph indicator", "signal pattern",
"trend analysis", "pattern detection", "investment analysis",
# Domain-specific (10)
"portfolio analysis", "trading signals", "asset evaluation",
"market analysis", "equity research", "investment research",
"performance metrics", "risk assessment", "return analysis",
# Combinations (10)
"analyze stock performance", "evaluate equity risk",
"research technical indicators", "review market trends",
# Natural language (10)
"how to analyze this stock", "can you evaluate the security",
"help me research the ticker", "I need technical analysis"
]
```
---
## ✅ **Quality Assurance Checklist**
### **Synonym Coverage:**
- [ ] Each core keyword has 5-8 synonyms
- [ ] Technical terminology included
- [ ] Business language covered
- [ ] Conversational variations present
- [ ] Domain-specific terms added
### **Natural Language:**
- [ ] Question forms included ("how to", "what can I")
- [ ] Command forms included ("extract from")
- [ ] Informal variations included ("get data")
- [ ] Workflow language included ("daily I have to")
### **Domain Specificity:**
- [ ] Industry-specific terminology included
- [ ] Technical jargon covered
- [] Business language present
- [ ] Contextual variations added
### **Testing Requirements:**
- [ ] 50+ keywords generated per skill
- [ ] 20+ natural language variations
- [ ] 98%+ activation reliability
- [ ] False negatives < 5%
---
## 🚀 **Usage in Agent-Skill-Creator**
### **Phase 4 Integration:**
1. **Generate base keywords** (traditional method)
2. **Apply synonym expansion** (enhanced method)
3. **Add domain-specific terms** (specialized coverage)
4. **Generate combinations** (pattern-based)
5. **Include natural language** (conversational)
### **Template Integration:**
- Enhanced keyword generation in phase4-detection.md
- Synonym libraries in activation-patterns-guide.md
- Domain examples in marketplace-robust-template.json
### **Result:**
- 50+ keywords per skill (vs 10-15 traditional)
- 98%+ activation reliability (vs 70% traditional)
- Natural language support (vs formal only)
- Domain-specific coverage (vs generic only)

569
references/tools/activation-tester.md
View file

@ -1,569 +0,0 @@
# Activation Test Automation Framework v1.0
**Version:** 1.0
**Purpose:** Automated testing system for skill activation reliability
**Target:** 99.5% activation reliability with <1% false positives
---
## 🎯 **Overview**
This framework provides automated tools to test, validate, and monitor skill activation reliability across the 3-Layer Activation System (Keywords, Patterns, Description + NLU).
### **Problem Solved**
**Before:** Manual testing was time-consuming, inconsistent, and missed edge cases
**After:** Automated testing provides consistent validation, comprehensive coverage, and continuous monitoring
---
## 🛠️ **Core Components**
### **1. Activation Test Suite Generator**
Automatically generates comprehensive test cases for any skill based on its marketplace.json configuration.
### **2. Regex Pattern Validator**
Validates regex patterns against test cases and identifies potential issues.
### **3. Coverage Analyzer**
Calculates activation coverage and identifies gaps in keyword/pattern combinations.
### **4. Continuous Monitor**
Monitors skill activation in real-time and tracks performance metrics.
---
## 📁 **Framework Structure**
```
references/tools/activation-tester/
├── core/
│ ├── test-generator.md # Test case generation logic
│ ├── pattern-validator.md # Regex validation tools
│ ├── coverage-analyzer.md # Coverage calculation
│ └── performance-monitor.md # Continuous monitoring
├── scripts/
│ ├── run-full-test-suite.sh # Complete automation script
│ ├── quick-validation.sh # Fast validation checks
│ ├── regression-test.sh # Regression testing
│ └── performance-benchmark.sh # Performance testing
├── templates/
│ ├── test-report-template.md # Standardized reporting
│ ├── coverage-report-template.md # Coverage analysis
│ └── performance-dashboard.md # Metrics visualization
└── examples/
├── stock-analyzer-test-suite.md # Example test suite
└── agent-creator-test-suite.md # Example reference test
```
---
## 🧪 **Test Generation System**
### **Keyword Test Generation**
For each keyword in marketplace.json, the system generates:
```bash
generate_keyword_tests() {
local keyword="$1"
local skill_context="$2"
# 1. Exact match test
echo "Test: \"${keyword}\""
# 2. Embedded in sentence
echo "Test: \"I need to ${keyword} for my project\""
# 3. Case variations
echo "Test: \"$(echo ${keyword} | tr '[:lower:]' '[:upper:]')\""
# 4. Natural language variations
echo "Test: \"Can you help me ${keyword}?\""
# 5. Context-specific variations
echo "Test: \"${keyword} in ${skill_context}\""
}
```
### **Pattern Test Generation**
For each regex pattern, generate comprehensive test cases:
```bash
generate_pattern_tests() {
local pattern="$1"
local description="$2"
# Extract pattern components
local verbs=$(extract_verbs "$pattern")
local entities=$(extract_entities "$pattern")
local contexts=$(extract_contexts "$pattern")
# Generate positive test cases
for verb in $verbs; do
for entity in $entities; do
echo "Test: \"${verb} ${entity}\""
echo "Test: \"I want to ${verb} ${entity} now\""
echo "Test: \"Can you ${verb} ${entity} for me?\""
done
done
# Generate negative test cases
generate_negative_cases "$pattern"
}
```
### **Integration Test Generation**
Creates realistic user queries combining multiple elements:
```bash
generate_integration_tests() {
local capabilities=("$@")
for capability in "${capabilities[@]}"; do
# Natural language variations
echo "Test: \"How can I ${capability}?\""
echo "Test: \"I need help with ${capability}\""
echo "Test: \"Can you ${capability} for me?\""
# Workflow context
echo "Test: \"Every day I have to ${capability}\""
echo "Test: \"I want to automate ${capability}\""
# Complex queries
echo "Test: \"${capability} and show me results\""
echo "Test: \"Help me understand ${capability} better\""
done
}
```
---
## 🔍 **Pattern Validation System**
### **Regex Pattern Analyzer**
Validates regex patterns for common issues:
```python
def analyze_pattern(pattern):
"""Analyze regex pattern for potential issues"""
issues = []
suggestions = []
# Check for common regex problems
if pattern.count('*') > 2:
issues.append("Too many wildcards - may cause false positives")
if not re.search(r'\(\?\:i\)', pattern):
suggestions.append("Add case-insensitive flag: (?i)")
if pattern.startswith('.*') and pattern.endswith('.*'):
issues.append("Pattern too broad - may match anything")
# Calculate pattern specificity
specificity = calculate_specificity(pattern)
return {
'issues': issues,
'suggestions': suggestions,
'specificity': specificity,
'risk_level': assess_risk(pattern)
}
```
### **Pattern Coverage Test**
Tests pattern against comprehensive query variations:
```bash
test_pattern_coverage() {
local pattern="$1"
local test_queries=("$@")
local matches=0
local total=${#test_queries[@]}
for query in "${test_queries[@]}"; do
if [[ $query =~ $pattern ]]; then
((matches++))
echo "✅ Match: '$query'"
else
echo "❌ No match: '$query'"
fi
done
local coverage=$((matches * 100 / total))
echo "Pattern coverage: ${coverage}%"
if [[ $coverage -lt 80 ]]; then
echo "⚠️ Low coverage - consider expanding pattern"
fi
}
```
---
## 📊 **Coverage Analysis System**
### **Multi-Layer Coverage Calculator**
Calculates coverage across all three activation layers:
```python
def calculate_activation_coverage(skill_config):
"""Calculate comprehensive activation coverage"""
keywords = skill_config['activation']['keywords']
patterns = skill_config['activation']['patterns']
description = skill_config['metadata']['description']
# Layer 1: Keyword coverage
keyword_coverage = {
'total_keywords': len(keywords),
'categories': categorize_keywords(keywords),
'synonym_coverage': calculate_synonym_coverage(keywords),
'natural_language_coverage': calculate_nl_coverage(keywords)
}
# Layer 2: Pattern coverage
pattern_coverage = {
'total_patterns': len(patterns),
'pattern_types': categorize_patterns(patterns),
'regex_complexity': calculate_pattern_complexity(patterns),
'overlap_analysis': analyze_pattern_overlap(patterns)
}
# Layer 3: Description coverage
description_coverage = {
'keyword_density': calculate_keyword_density(description, keywords),
'semantic_richness': analyze_semantic_content(description),
'concept_coverage': extract_concepts(description)
}
# Overall coverage score
overall_score = calculate_overall_coverage(
keyword_coverage, pattern_coverage, description_coverage
)
return {
'overall_score': overall_score,
'keyword_coverage': keyword_coverage,
'pattern_coverage': pattern_coverage,
'description_coverage': description_coverage,
'recommendations': generate_recommendations(overall_score)
}
```
### **Gap Identification**
Identifies gaps in activation coverage:
```python
def identify_activation_gaps(skill_config, test_results):
"""Identify gaps in activation coverage"""
gaps = []
# Analyze failed test queries
failed_queries = [q for q in test_results if not q['activated']]
# Categorize failures
failure_categories = categorize_failures(failed_queries)
# Identify missing keyword categories
missing_categories = find_missing_keyword_categories(
skill_config['activation']['keywords'],
failure_categories
)
# Identify pattern weaknesses
pattern_gaps = find_pattern_gaps(
skill_config['activation']['patterns'],
failed_queries
)
# Generate specific recommendations
for category in missing_categories:
gaps.append({
'type': 'missing_keyword_category',
'category': category,
'suggestion': f"Add 5-10 keywords from {category} category"
})
for gap in pattern_gaps:
gaps.append({
'type': 'pattern_gap',
'gap_type': gap['type'],
'suggestion': gap['suggestion']
})
return gaps
```
---
## 🚀 **Automation Scripts**
### **Full Test Suite Runner**
```bash
#!/bin/bash
# run-full-test-suite.sh
run_full_test_suite() {
local skill_path="$1"
local output_dir="$2"
echo "🧪 Running Full Activation Test Suite"
echo "Skill: $skill_path"
echo "Output: $output_dir"
# 1. Parse skill configuration
echo "📋 Parsing skill configuration..."
parse_skill_config "$skill_path"
# 2. Generate test cases
echo "🎲 Generating test cases..."
generate_all_test_cases "$skill_path"
# 3. Run keyword tests
echo "🔑 Testing keyword activation..."
run_keyword_tests "$skill_path"
# 4. Run pattern tests
echo "🔍 Testing pattern matching..."
run_pattern_tests "$skill_path"
# 5. Run integration tests
echo "🔗 Testing integration scenarios..."
run_integration_tests "$skill_path"
# 6. Run negative tests
echo "🚫 Testing false positives..."
run_negative_tests "$skill_path"
# 7. Calculate coverage
echo "📊 Calculating coverage..."
calculate_coverage "$skill_path"
# 8. Generate report
echo "📄 Generating test report..."
generate_test_report "$skill_path" "$output_dir"
echo "✅ Test suite completed!"
echo "📁 Report available at: $output_dir/activation-test-report.html"
}
```
### **Quick Validation Script**
```bash
#!/bin/bash
# quick-validation.sh
quick_validation() {
local skill_path="$1"
echo "⚡ Quick Activation Validation"
# Fast JSON validation
if ! python3 -m json.tool "$skill_path/marketplace.json" > /dev/null 2>&1; then
echo "❌ Invalid JSON in marketplace.json"
return 1
fi
# Check required fields
check_required_fields "$skill_path"
# Validate regex patterns
validate_patterns "$skill_path"
# Quick keyword count check
keyword_count=$(jq '.activation.keywords | length' "$skill_path/marketplace.json")
if [[ $keyword_count -lt 20 ]]; then
echo "⚠️ Low keyword count: $keyword_count (recommend 50+)"
fi
# Pattern count check
pattern_count=$(jq '.activation.patterns | length' "$skill_path/marketplace.json")
if [[ $pattern_count -lt 8 ]]; then
echo "⚠️ Low pattern count: $pattern_count (recommend 10+)"
fi
echo "✅ Quick validation completed"
}
```
---
## 📈 **Performance Monitoring**
### **Real-time Activation Monitor**
```python
class ActivationMonitor:
"""Monitor skill activation performance in real-time"""
def __init__(self, skill_name):
self.skill_name = skill_name
self.activation_log = []
self.performance_metrics = {
'total_activations': 0,
'successful_activations': 0,
'failed_activations': 0,
'average_response_time': 0,
'activation_by_layer': {
'keywords': 0,
'patterns': 0,
'description': 0
}
}
def log_activation(self, query, activated, layer, response_time):
"""Log activation attempt"""
self.activation_log.append({
'timestamp': datetime.now(),
'query': query,
'activated': activated,
'layer': layer,
'response_time': response_time
})
self.update_metrics(activated, layer, response_time)
def calculate_reliability_score(self):
"""Calculate current reliability score"""
if self.performance_metrics['total_activations'] == 0:
return 0.0
success_rate = (
self.performance_metrics['successful_activations'] /
self.performance_metrics['total_activations']
)
return success_rate
def generate_alerts(self):
"""Generate performance alerts"""
alerts = []
reliability = self.calculate_reliability_score()
if reliability < 0.95:
alerts.append({
'type': 'low_reliability',
'message': f'Reliability dropped to {reliability:.2%}',
'severity': 'high'
})
avg_response_time = self.performance_metrics['average_response_time']
if avg_response_time > 5.0:
alerts.append({
'type': 'slow_response',
'message': f'Average response time: {avg_response_time:.2f}s',
'severity': 'medium'
})
return alerts
```
---
## 📋 **Usage Examples**
### **Example 1: Testing Stock Analyzer Skill**
```bash
# Run full test suite
./run-full-test-suite.sh \
/path/to/stock-analyzer \
/output/test-results
# Quick validation
./quick-validation.sh /path/to/stock-analyzer
# Monitor performance
./performance-benchmark.sh stock-analyzer```
### **Example 2: Integration with Development Workflow**
```yaml
# .github/workflows/activation-testing.yml
name: Activation Testing
on: [push, pull_request]
jobs:
test-activation:
runs-on: ubuntu-latest
steps:
- uses: actions/checkout@v2
- name: Run Activation Tests
run: |
./references/tools/activation-tester/scripts/run-full-test-suite.sh \
./references/examples/stock-analyzer \
./test-results
- name: Upload Test Results
uses: actions/upload-artifact@v2
with:
name: activation-test-results
path: ./test-results/
```
---
## ✅ **Quality Standards**
### **Test Coverage Requirements**
- [ ] 100% keyword coverage testing
- [ ] 95%+ pattern coverage validation
- [ ] All capability variations tested
- [ ] Edge cases documented and tested
- [ ] Negative testing for false positives
### **Performance Benchmarks**
- [ ] Activation reliability: 99.5%+
- [ ] False positive rate: <1%
- [ ] Test execution time: <30 seconds
- [ ] Memory usage: <100MB
- [ ] Response time: <2 seconds average
### **Reporting Standards**
- [ ] Automated test report generation
- [ ] Performance metrics dashboard
- [ ] Historical trend analysis
- [ ] Actionable recommendations
- [ ] Integration with CI/CD pipeline
---
## 🔄 **Continuous Improvement**
### **Feedback Loop Integration**
1. **Collect** activation data from real usage
2. **Analyze** performance metrics and failure patterns
3. **Identify** optimization opportunities
4. **Implement** improvements to keywords/patterns
5. **Validate** improvements with automated testing
6. **Deploy** updated configurations
### **A/B Testing Framework**
- Test different keyword combinations
- Compare pattern performance
- Validate description effectiveness
- Measure user satisfaction impact
---
## 📚 **Additional Resources**
- `../activation-testing-guide.md` - Manual testing procedures
- `../activation-patterns-guide.md` - Pattern library
- `../phase4-detection.md` - Detection methodology
- `../synonym-expansion-system.md` - Keyword expansion
---
**Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-24
**Maintained By:** Agent-Skill-Creator Team

651
references/tools/intent-analyzer.md
View file

@ -1,651 +0,0 @@
# Intent Analyzer Tools v1.0
**Version:** 1.0
**Purpose:** Development and testing tools for multi-intent detection system
**Target:** Validate intent detection with 95%+ accuracy
---
## 🛠️ **Intent Analysis Toolkit**
### **Core Tools**
1. **Intent Parser Validator** - Test intent parsing accuracy
2. **Intent Combination Analyzer** - Analyze intent compatibility
3. **Natural Language Intent Simulator** - Test complex queries
4. **Performance Benchmark Suite** - Measure detection performance
---
## 🔍 **Intent Parser Validator**
### **Usage**
```bash
# Basic intent parsing test
./intent-parser-validator.sh <skill-config> <test-query>
# Batch testing with query file
./intent-parser-validator.sh <skill-config> --batch <queries.txt>
# Full validation suite
./intent-parser-validator.sh <skill-config> --full-suite
```
### **Implementation**
```bash
#!/bin/bash
# intent-parser-validator.sh
validate_intent_parsing() {
local skill_config="$1"
local query="$2"
echo "🔍 Analyzing query: \"$query\""
# Extract intents using Python implementation
python3 << EOF
import json
import sys
sys.path.append('..')
# Load skill configuration
with open('$skill_config', 'r') as f:
config = json.load(f)
# Import intent parser (simplified implementation)
def parse_intent_simple(query):
"""Simplified intent parsing for validation"""
# Primary intent detection
primary_patterns = {
'analyze': ['analyze', 'examine', 'evaluate', 'study'],
'create': ['create', 'build', 'make', 'generate'],
'compare': ['compare', 'versus', 'vs', 'ranking'],
'monitor': ['monitor', 'track', 'watch', 'alert'],
'transform': ['convert', 'transform', 'change', 'turn']
}
# Secondary intent detection
secondary_patterns = {
'and_visualize': ['show', 'chart', 'graph', 'visualize'],
'and_save': ['save', 'export', 'download', 'store'],
'and_explain': ['explain', 'clarify', 'describe', 'detail']
}
query_lower = query.lower()
# Find primary intent
primary_intent = None
for intent, keywords in primary_patterns.items():
if any(keyword in query_lower for keyword in keywords):
primary_intent = intent
break
# Find secondary intents
secondary_intents = []
for intent, keywords in secondary_patterns.items():
if any(keyword in query_lower for keyword in keywords):
secondary_intents.append(intent)
return {
'primary_intent': primary_intent,
'secondary_intents': secondary_intents,
'confidence': 0.8 if primary_intent else 0.0,
'complexity': 'high' if len(secondary_intents) > 1 else 'medium' if secondary_intents else 'low'
}
# Parse the query
result = parse_intent_simple('$query')
print("Intent Analysis Results:")
print("=" * 30)
print(f"Primary Intent: {result['primary_intent']}")
print(f"Secondary Intents: {', '.join(result['secondary_intents'])}")
print(f"Confidence: {result['confidence']:.2f}")
print(f"Complexity: {result['complexity']}")
# Validate against skill capabilities
capabilities = config.get('capabilities', {})
supported_primary = capabilities.get('primary_intents', [])
supported_secondary = capabilities.get('secondary_intents', [])
validation_issues = []
if result['primary_intent'] not in supported_primary:
validation_issues.append(f"Primary intent '{result['primary_intent']}' not supported")
for sec_intent in result['secondary_intents']:
if sec_intent not in supported_secondary:
validation_issues.append(f"Secondary intent '{sec_intent}' not supported")
if validation_issues:
print("Validation Issues:")
for issue in validation_issues:
print(f" - {issue}")
else:
print("✅ All intents supported by skill")
EOF
}
```
---
## 🔄 **Intent Combination Analyzer**
### **Purpose**
Analyze compatibility and execution order of intent combinations.
### **Implementation**
```python
def analyze_intent_combination(primary_intent, secondary_intents, skill_config):
"""Analyze intent combination compatibility and execution plan"""
# Get supported combinations from skill config
supported_combinations = skill_config.get('intent_hierarchy', {}).get('intent_combinations', {})
# Check for exact combination match
combination_key = f"{primary_intent}_and_{'_and_'.join(secondary_intents)}"
if combination_key in supported_combinations:
return {
'supported': True,
'combination_type': 'predefined',
'execution_plan': supported_combinations[combination_key],
'confidence': 0.95
}
# Check for partial matches
for sec_intent in secondary_intents:
partial_key = f"{primary_intent}_and_{sec_intent}"
if partial_key in supported_combinations:
return {
'supported': True,
'combination_type': 'partial_match',
'execution_plan': supported_combinations[partial_key],
'additional_intents': [i for i in secondary_intents if i != sec_intent],
'confidence': 0.8
}
# Check if individual intents are supported
capabilities = skill_config.get('capabilities', {})
primary_supported = primary_intent in capabilities.get('primary_intents', [])
secondary_supported = all(intent in capabilities.get('secondary_intents', []) for intent in secondary_intents)
if primary_supported and secondary_supported:
return {
'supported': True,
'combination_type': 'dynamic',
'execution_plan': generate_dynamic_execution_plan(primary_intent, secondary_intents),
'confidence': 0.7
}
return {
'supported': False,
'reason': 'One or more intents not supported',
'fallback_intent': primary_intent if primary_supported else None
}
def generate_dynamic_execution_plan(primary_intent, secondary_intents):
"""Generate execution plan for non-predefined combinations"""
plan = {
'steps': [
{
'step': 1,
'intent': primary_intent,
'action': f'execute_{primary_intent}',
'dependencies': []
}
],
'parallel_steps': []
}
# Add secondary intents
for i, intent in enumerate(secondary_intents):
if can_execute_parallel(primary_intent, intent):
plan['parallel_steps'].append({
'step': f'parallel_{i}',
'intent': intent,
'action': f'execute_{intent}',
'dependencies': ['step_1']
})
else:
plan['steps'].append({
'step': len(plan['steps']) + 1,
'intent': intent,
'action': f'execute_{intent}',
'dependencies': [f'step_{len(plan["steps"])}']
})
return plan
def can_execute_parallel(primary_intent, secondary_intent):
"""Determine if intents can be executed in parallel"""
parallel_pairs = {
'analyze': ['and_visualize', 'and_save'],
'compare': ['and_visualize', 'and_explain'],
'monitor': ['and_alert', 'and_save']
}
return secondary_intent in parallel_pairs.get(primary_intent, [])
```
---
## 🗣️ **Natural Language Intent Simulator**
### **Purpose**
Generate and test natural language variations of intent combinations.
### **Implementation**
```python
class NaturalLanguageIntentSimulator:
"""Generate natural language variations for intent testing"""
def __init__(self):
self.templates = {
'single_intent': [
"I need to {intent} {entity}",
"Can you {intent} {entity}?",
"Please {intent} {entity}",
"Help me {intent} {entity}",
"{intent} {entity} for me"
],
'double_intent': [
"I need to {intent1} {entity} and {intent2} the results",
"Can you {intent1} {entity} and also {intent2}?",
"Please {intent1} {entity} and {intent2} everything",
"Help me {intent1} {entity} and {intent2} the output",
"{intent1} {entity} and then {intent2}"
],
'triple_intent': [
"I need to {intent1} {entity}, {intent2} the results, and {intent3}",
"Can you {intent1} {entity}, {intent2} it, and {intent3} everything?",
"Please {intent1} {entity}, {intent2} the analysis, and {intent3}",
"Help me {intent1} {entity}, {intent2} the data, and {intent3} the results"
]
}
self.intent_variations = {
'analyze': ['analyze', 'examine', 'evaluate', 'study', 'review', 'assess'],
'create': ['create', 'build', 'make', 'generate', 'develop', 'design'],
'compare': ['compare', 'comparison', 'versus', 'vs', 'rank', 'rating'],
'monitor': ['monitor', 'track', 'watch', 'observe', 'follow', 'keep an eye on'],
'transform': ['convert', 'transform', 'change', 'turn', 'format', 'structure']
}
self.secondary_variations = {
'and_visualize': ['show me', 'visualize', 'create a chart', 'graph', 'display'],
'and_save': ['save', 'export', 'download', 'store', 'keep', 'record'],
'and_explain': ['explain', 'describe', 'detail', 'clarify', 'break down']
}
self.entities = {
'finance': ['AAPL stock', 'MSFT shares', 'market data', 'portfolio performance', 'stock prices'],
'general': ['this data', 'the information', 'these results', 'the output', 'everything']
}
def generate_variations(self, primary_intent, secondary_intents=[], domain='finance'):
"""Generate natural language variations for intent combinations"""
variations = []
entity_list = self.entities[domain]
# Single intent variations
if not secondary_intents:
for template in self.templates['single_intent']:
for primary_verb in self.intent_variations.get(primary_intent, [primary_intent]):
for entity in entity_list[:3]: # Limit to avoid too many variations
query = template.format(intent=primary_verb, entity=entity)
variations.append({
'query': query,
'expected_intents': {
'primary': primary_intent,
'secondary': [],
'contextual': []
},
'complexity': 'low'
})
# Double intent variations
elif len(secondary_intents) == 1:
secondary_intent = secondary_intents[0]
for template in self.templates['double_intent']:
for primary_verb in self.intent_variations.get(primary_intent, [primary_intent]):
for secondary_verb in self.secondary_variations.get(secondary_intent, [secondary_intent.replace('and_', '')]):
for entity in entity_list[:2]:
query = template.format(
intent1=primary_verb,
intent2=secondary_verb,
entity=entity
)
variations.append({
'query': query,
'expected_intents': {
'primary': primary_intent,
'secondary': [secondary_intent],
'contextual': []
},
'complexity': 'medium'
})
# Triple intent variations
elif len(secondary_intents) >= 2:
for template in self.templates['triple_intent']:
for primary_verb in self.intent_variations.get(primary_intent, [primary_intent]):
for entity in entity_list[:2]:
secondary_verbs = [
self.secondary_variations.get(intent, [intent.replace('and_', '')])[0]
for intent in secondary_intents[:2]
]
query = template.format(
intent1=primary_verb,
intent2=secondary_verbs[0],
intent3=secondary_verbs[1],
entity=entity
)
variations.append({
'query': query,
'expected_intents': {
'primary': primary_intent,
'secondary': secondary_intents[:2],
'contextual': []
},
'complexity': 'high'
})
return variations
def generate_test_suite(self, skill_config, num_variations=10):
"""Generate complete test suite for a skill"""
test_suite = []
# Get supported intents from skill config
capabilities = skill_config.get('capabilities', {})
primary_intents = capabilities.get('primary_intents', [])
secondary_intents = capabilities.get('secondary_intents', [])
# Generate single intent tests
for primary in primary_intents[:3]: # Limit to avoid too many tests
variations = self.generate_variations(primary, [], 'finance')
test_suite.extend(variations[:num_variations])
# Generate double intent tests
for primary in primary_intents[:2]:
for secondary in secondary_intents[:2]:
variations = self.generate_variations([primary], [secondary], 'finance')
test_suite.extend(variations[:num_variations//2])
# Generate triple intent tests
for primary in primary_intents[:1]:
combinations = []
for i, sec1 in enumerate(secondary_intents[:2]):
for sec2 in secondary_intents[i+1:i+2]:
combinations.append([sec1, sec2])
for combo in combinations:
variations = self.generate_variations(primary, combo, 'finance')
test_suite.extend(variations[:num_variations//4])
return test_suite
```
---
## 📊 **Performance Benchmark Suite**
### **Benchmark Metrics**
1. **Intent Detection Accuracy** - % of correctly identified intents
2. **Processing Speed** - Time taken to parse intents
3. **Complexity Handling** - Success rate by complexity level
4. **Natural Language Understanding** - Success with varied phrasing
### **Implementation**
```python
class IntentBenchmarkSuite:
"""Performance benchmarking for intent detection"""
def __init__(self):
self.results = {
'accuracy_by_complexity': {'low': [], 'medium': [], 'high': [], 'very_high': []},
'processing_times': [],
'intent_accuracy': {'primary': [], 'secondary': [], 'contextual': []},
'natural_language_success': []
}
def run_benchmark(self, skill_config, test_cases):
"""Run complete benchmark suite"""
print("🚀 Starting Intent Detection Benchmark")
print(f"Test cases: {len(test_cases)}")
for i, test_case in enumerate(test_cases):
query = test_case['query']
expected = test_case['expected_intents']
complexity = test_case['complexity']
# Measure processing time
start_time = time.time()
# Parse intents (using simplified implementation)
detected = self.parse_intents(query, skill_config)
end_time = time.time()
processing_time = end_time - start_time
# Calculate accuracy
primary_correct = detected['primary_intent'] == expected['primary']
secondary_correct = set(detected.get('secondary_intents', [])) == set(expected['secondary'])
contextual_correct = set(detected.get('contextual_intents', [])) == set(expected['contextual'])
overall_accuracy = primary_correct and secondary_correct and contextual_correct
# Store results
self.results['accuracy_by_complexity'][complexity].append(overall_accuracy)
self.results['processing_times'].append(processing_time)
self.results['intent_accuracy']['primary'].append(primary_correct)
self.results['intent_accuracy']['secondary'].append(secondary_correct)
self.results['intent_accuracy']['contextual'].append(contextual_correct)
# Check if natural language (non-obvious phrasing)
is_natural_language = self.is_natural_language(query, expected)
if is_natural_language:
self.results['natural_language_success'].append(overall_accuracy)
# Progress indicator
if (i + 1) % 10 == 0:
print(f"Processed {i + 1}/{len(test_cases)} test cases...")
return self.generate_benchmark_report()
def parse_intents(self, query, skill_config):
"""Simplified intent parsing for benchmarking"""
# This would use the actual intent parsing implementation
# For now, simplified version for demonstration
query_lower = query.lower()
# Primary intent detection
primary_patterns = {
'analyze': ['analyze', 'examine', 'evaluate', 'study'],
'create': ['create', 'build', 'make', 'generate'],
'compare': ['compare', 'versus', 'vs', 'ranking'],
'monitor': ['monitor', 'track', 'watch', 'alert']
}
primary_intent = None
for intent, keywords in primary_patterns.items():
if any(keyword in query_lower for keyword in keywords):
primary_intent = intent
break
# Secondary intent detection
secondary_patterns = {
'and_visualize': ['show', 'chart', 'graph', 'visualize'],
'and_save': ['save', 'export', 'download', 'store'],
'and_explain': ['explain', 'clarify', 'describe', 'detail']
}
secondary_intents = []
for intent, keywords in secondary_patterns.items():
if any(keyword in query_lower for keyword in keywords):
secondary_intents.append(intent)
return {
'primary_intent': primary_intent,
'secondary_intents': secondary_intents,
'contextual_intents': [],
'confidence': 0.8 if primary_intent else 0.0
}
def is_natural_language(self, query, expected_intents):
"""Check if query uses natural language vs. direct commands"""
natural_indicators = [
'i need to', 'can you', 'help me', 'please', 'would like',
'interested in', 'thinking about', 'wondering if'
]
direct_indicators = [
'analyze', 'create', 'compare', 'monitor',
'show', 'save', 'explain'
]
query_lower = query.lower()
natural_score = sum(1 for indicator in natural_indicators if indicator in query_lower)
direct_score = sum(1 for indicator in direct_indicators if indicator in query_lower)
return natural_score > direct_score
def generate_benchmark_report(self):
"""Generate comprehensive benchmark report"""
total_tests = sum(len(accuracies) for accuracies in self.results['accuracy_by_complexity'].values())
if total_tests == 0:
return "No test results available"
# Calculate accuracy by complexity
accuracy_by_complexity = {}
for complexity, accuracies in self.results['accuracy_by_complexity'].items():
if accuracies:
accuracy_by_complexity[complexity] = sum(accuracies) / len(accuracies)
else:
accuracy_by_complexity[complexity] = 0.0
# Calculate overall metrics
avg_processing_time = sum(self.results['processing_times']) / len(self.results['processing_times'])
primary_intent_accuracy = sum(self.results['intent_accuracy']['primary']) / len(self.results['intent_accuracy']['primary'])
secondary_intent_accuracy = sum(self.results['intent_accuracy']['secondary']) / len(self.results['intent_accuracy']['secondary'])
# Calculate natural language success rate
nl_success_rate = 0.0
if self.results['natural_language_success']:
nl_success_rate = sum(self.results['natural_language_success']) / len(self.results['natural_language_success'])
report = f"""
Intent Detection Benchmark Report
=================================
Overall Performance:
- Total Tests: {total_tests}
- Average Processing Time: {avg_processing_time:.3f}s
Accuracy by Complexity:
"""
for complexity, accuracy in accuracy_by_complexity.items():
test_count = len(self.results['accuracy_by_complexity'][complexity])
report += f"- {complexity.capitalize()}: {accuracy:.1%} ({test_count} tests)\n"
report += f"""
Intent Detection Accuracy:
- Primary Intent: {primary_intent_accuracy:.1%}
- Secondary Intent: {secondary_intent_accuracy:.1%}
- Natural Language Queries: {nl_success_rate:.1%}
Performance Assessment:
"""
# Performance assessment
overall_accuracy = sum(accuracy_by_complexity.values()) / len(accuracy_by_complexity)
if overall_accuracy >= 0.95:
report += "✅ EXCELLENT - Intent detection performance is outstanding\n"
elif overall_accuracy >= 0.85:
report += "✅ GOOD - Intent detection performance is solid\n"
elif overall_accuracy >= 0.70:
report += "⚠️ ACCEPTABLE - Intent detection needs some improvement\n"
else:
report += "❌ NEEDS IMPROVEMENT - Intent detection requires significant work\n"
if avg_processing_time <= 0.1:
report += "✅ Processing speed is excellent\n"
elif avg_processing_time <= 0.2:
report += "✅ Processing speed is good\n"
else:
report += "⚠️ Processing speed could be improved\n"
return report
```
---
## ✅ **Usage Examples**
### **Example 1: Basic Intent Analysis**
```bash
# Test single intent
./intent-parser-validator.sh ./marketplace.json "Analyze AAPL stock"
# Test multiple intents
./intent-parser-validator.sh ./marketplace.json "Analyze AAPL stock and show me a chart"
# Batch testing
echo -e "Analyze AAPL stock\nCompare MSFT vs GOOGL\nMonitor my portfolio" > queries.txt
./intent-parser-validator.sh ./marketplace.json --batch queries.txt
```
### **Example 2: Natural Language Generation**
```python
# Generate test variations
simulator = NaturalLanguageIntentSimulator()
variations = simulator.generate_variations('analyze', ['and_visualize'], 'finance')
for variation in variations[:5]:
print(f"Query: {variation['query']}")
print(f"Expected: {variation['expected_intents']}")
print()
```
### **Example 3: Performance Benchmarking**
```python
# Generate test suite
simulator = NaturalLanguageIntentSimulator()
test_suite = simulator.generate_test_suite(skill_config, num_variations=20)
# Run benchmarks
benchmark = IntentBenchmarkSuite()
report = benchmark.run_benchmark(skill_config, test_suite)
print(report)
```
---
**Version:** 1.0
**Last Updated:** 2025-10-24
**Maintained By:** Agent-Skill-Creator Team

720
references/tools/test-automation-scripts.sh
View file

@ -1,720 +0,0 @@
#!/bin/bash
# Test Automation Scripts for Activation Testing v1.0
# Purpose: Automated testing suite for skill activation reliability
set -euo pipefail
# Configuration
SCRIPT_DIR="$(cd "$(dirname "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")" && pwd)"
RESULTS_DIR="${RESULTS_DIR:-$(pwd)/test-results}"
TEMP_DIR="${TEMP_DIR:-/tmp/activation-tests}"
# Colors for output
RED='\033[0;31m'
GREEN='\033[0;32m'
YELLOW='\033[1;33m'
BLUE='\033[0;34m'
NC='\033[0m' # No Color
# Logging
log() { echo -e "${BLUE}[$(date '+%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S')]${NC} $1"; }
success() { echo -e "${GREEN}[SUCCESS]${NC} $1"; }
warning() { echo -e "${YELLOW}[WARNING]${NC} $1"; }
error() { echo -e "${RED}[ERROR]${NC} $1"; }
# Initialize directories
init_directories() {
local skill_path="$1"
local skill_name=$(basename "$skill_path")
RESULTS_DIR="${RESULTS_DIR}/${skill_name}"
TEMP_DIR="${TEMP_DIR}/${skill_name}"
mkdir -p "$RESULTS_DIR"/{reports,logs,coverage,performance}
mkdir -p "$TEMP_DIR"/{tests,patterns,validation}
log "Initialized directories for $skill_name"
}
# Parse skill configuration
parse_skill_config() {
local skill_path="$1"
local config_file="$skill_path/marketplace.json"
if [[ ! -f "$config_file" ]]; then
error "marketplace.json not found in $skill_path"
return 1
fi
# Validate JSON syntax
if ! python3 -m json.tool "$config_file" > /dev/null 2>&1; then
error "Invalid JSON syntax in $config_file"
return 1
fi
# Extract key information
local skill_name=$(jq -r '.name' "$config_file")
local keyword_count=$(jq '.activation.keywords | length' "$config_file")
local pattern_count=$(jq '.activation.patterns | length' "$config_file")
log "Parsed config for $skill_name"
log "Keywords: $keyword_count, Patterns: $pattern_count"
# Save parsed data
jq '.name' "$config_file" > "$TEMP_DIR/skill_name.txt"
jq '.activation.keywords[]' "$config_file" > "$TEMP_DIR/keywords.txt"
jq '.activation.patterns[]' "$config_file" > "$TEMP_DIR/patterns.txt"
jq '.usage.test_queries[]' "$config_file" > "$TEMP_DIR/test_queries.txt"
}
# Generate test cases from keywords
generate_keyword_tests() {
local skill_path="$1"
local keywords_file="$TEMP_DIR/keywords.txt"
local output_file="$TEMP_DIR/tests/keyword_tests.json"
log "Generating keyword test cases..."
# Remove quotes and create test variations
local keyword_tests=()
while IFS= read -r keyword; do
# Clean keyword (remove quotes)
keyword=$(echo "$keyword" | tr -d '"' | tr -d "'" | xargs)
if [[ -n "$keyword" && "$keyword" != "_comment:"* ]]; then
# Generate test variations
keyword_tests+=("$keyword") # Exact match
keyword_tests+=("I need to $keyword") # Natural language
keyword_tests+=("Can you $keyword for me?") # Question form
keyword_tests+=("Please $keyword") # Polite request
keyword_tests+=("Help me $keyword") # Help request
keyword_tests+=("$keyword now") # Urgent
keyword_tests+=("I want to $keyword") # Want statement
keyword_tests+=("Need to $keyword") # Need statement
fi
done < "$keywords_file"
# Save to JSON
printf '%s\n' "${keyword_tests[@]}" | jq -R . | jq -s . > "$output_file"
local test_count=$(jq length "$output_file")
success "Generated $test_count keyword test cases"
}
# Generate test cases from patterns
generate_pattern_tests() {
local patterns_file="$TEMP_DIR/patterns.txt"
local output_file="$TEMP_DIR/tests/pattern_tests.json"
log "Generating pattern test cases..."
local pattern_tests=()
while IFS= read -r pattern; do
# Clean pattern (remove quotes)
pattern=$(echo "$pattern" | tr -d '"' | tr -d "'" | xargs)
if [[ -n "$pattern" && "$pattern" != "_comment:"* ]] && [[ "$pattern" =~ \(.*\) ]]; then
# Extract test keywords from pattern
local test_words=$(echo "$pattern" | grep -o '[a-zA-Z-]+' | head -10)
# Generate combinations
for word1 in $(echo "$test_words" | head -5); do
for word2 in $(echo "$test_words" | tail -5); do
if [[ "$word1" != "$word2" ]]; then
pattern_tests+=("$word1 $word2")
pattern_tests+=("I need to $word1 $word2")
pattern_tests+=("Can you $word1 $word2 for me?")
fi
done
done
fi
done < "$patterns_file"
# Save to JSON
printf '%s\n' "${pattern_tests[@]}" | jq -R . | jq -s . > "$output_file"
local test_count=$(jq length "$output_file")
success "Generated $test_count pattern test cases"
}
# Validate regex patterns
validate_patterns() {
local patterns_file="$TEMP_DIR/patterns.txt"
local validation_file="$RESULTS_DIR/logs/pattern_validation.log"
log "Validating regex patterns..."
{
echo "Pattern Validation Results - $(date)"
echo "====================================="
while IFS= read -r pattern; do
# Clean pattern
pattern=$(echo "$pattern" | tr -d '"' | tr -d "'" | xargs)
if [[ -n "$pattern" && "$pattern" != "_comment:"* ]] && [[ "$pattern" =~ \(.*\) ]]; then
echo -e "\nPattern: $pattern"
# Test pattern validity
if python3 -c "
import re
import sys
try:
re.compile(r'$pattern')
print('✅ Valid regex')
except re.error as e:
print(f'❌ Invalid regex: {e}')
sys.exit(1)
"; then
echo "✅ Pattern is syntactically valid"
else
echo "❌ Pattern has syntax errors"
fi
# Check for common issues
if [[ "$pattern" =~ \.\* ]]; then
echo "⚠️ Contains wildcard .* (may be too broad)"
fi
if [[ ! "$pattern" =~ \(.*i.*\) ]]; then
echo "⚠️ Missing case-insensitive flag (?i)"
fi
if [[ "$pattern" =~ \^.*\$ ]]; then
echo "✅ Has proper boundaries"
else
echo "⚠️ May match partial strings"
fi
fi
done < "$patterns_file"
} > "$validation_file"
success "Pattern validation completed - see $validation_file"
}
# Run keyword tests
run_keyword_tests() {
local skill_path="$1"
local test_file="$TEMP_DIR/tests/keyword_tests.json"
local results_file="$RESULTS_DIR/logs/keyword_test_results.json"
log "Running keyword activation tests..."
# This would integrate with Claude Code to test actual activation
# For now, we simulate the testing
python3 << EOF
import json
import random
from datetime import datetime
# Load test cases
with open('$test_file', 'r') as f:
test_cases = json.load(f)
# Simulate test results (in real implementation, this would call Claude Code)
results = []
for i, query in enumerate(test_cases):
# Simulate activation success with 95% probability
activated = random.random() < 0.95
layer = "keyword" if activated else "none"
results.append({
"id": i + 1,
"query": query,
"expected": True,
"actual": activated,
"layer": layer,
"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat()
})
# Calculate metrics
total_tests = len(results)
successful = sum(1 for r in results if r["actual"])
success_rate = successful / total_tests if total_tests > 0 else 0
# Save results
with open('$results_file', 'w') as f:
json.dump({
"summary": {
"total_tests": total_tests,
"successful": successful,
"failed": total_tests - successful,
"success_rate": success_rate
},
"results": results
}, f, indent=2)
print(f"Keyword tests: {successful}/{total_tests} passed ({success_rate:.1%})")
EOF
local success_rate=$(jq -r '.summary.success_rate' "$results_file")
success "Keyword tests completed with ${success_rate} success rate"
}
# Run pattern tests
run_pattern_tests() {
local test_file="$TEMP_DIR/tests/pattern_tests.json"
local patterns_file="$TEMP_DIR/patterns.txt"
local results_file="$RESULTS_DIR/logs/pattern_test_results.json"
log "Running pattern matching tests..."
python3 << EOF
import json
import re
from datetime import datetime
# Load test cases and patterns
with open('$test_file', 'r') as f:
test_cases = json.load(f)
patterns = []
with open('$patterns_file', 'r') as f:
for line in f:
pattern = line.strip().strip('"')
if pattern and not pattern.startswith('_comment:') and '(' in pattern:
patterns.append(pattern)
# Test each query against patterns
results = []
for i, query in enumerate(test_cases):
matched = False
matched_pattern = None
for pattern in patterns:
try:
if re.search(pattern, query, re.IGNORECASE):
matched = True
matched_pattern = pattern
break
except re.error:
continue
results.append({
"id": i + 1,
"query": query,
"matched": matched,
"pattern": matched_pattern,
"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat()
})
# Calculate metrics
total_tests = len(results)
matched = sum(1 for r in results if r["matched"])
match_rate = matched / total_tests if total_tests > 0 else 0
# Save results
with open('$results_file', 'w') as f:
json.dump({
"summary": {
"total_tests": total_tests,
"matched": matched,
"unmatched": total_tests - matched,
"match_rate": match_rate,
"patterns_tested": len(patterns)
},
"results": results
}, f, indent=2)
print(f"Pattern tests: {matched}/{total_tests} matched ({match_rate:.1%})")
EOF
local match_rate=$(jq -r '.summary.match_rate' "$results_file")
success "Pattern tests completed with ${match_rate} match rate"
}
# Calculate coverage
calculate_coverage() {
local skill_path="$1"
local coverage_file="$RESULTS_DIR/coverage/coverage_report.json"
log "Calculating activation coverage..."
python3 << EOF
import json
from datetime import datetime
# Load configuration
config_file = "$skill_path/marketplace.json"
with open(config_file, 'r') as f:
config = json.load(f)
# Extract data
keywords = [k for k in config['activation']['keywords'] if not k.startswith('_comment')]
patterns = [p for p in config['activation']['patterns'] if not p.startswith('_comment')]
test_queries = config.get('usage', {}).get('test_queries', [])
# Calculate keyword coverage
keyword_categories = {
'core': [k for k in keywords if any(word in k.lower() for word in ['analyze', 'process', 'create'])],
'synonyms': [k for k in keywords if len(k.split()) > 3],
'natural': [k for k in keywords if any(word in k.lower() for word in ['how to', 'can you', 'help me'])],
'domain': [k for k in keywords if any(word in k.lower() for word in ['technical', 'business', 'data'])]
}
# Calculate pattern complexity
pattern_complexity = []
for pattern in patterns:
complexity = len(pattern.split('|')) + len(pattern.split('\\s+'))
pattern_complexity.append(complexity)
avg_complexity = sum(pattern_complexity) / len(pattern_complexity) if pattern_complexity else 0
# Test query coverage analysis
query_categories = {
'simple': [q for q in test_queries if len(q.split()) <= 5],
'complex': [q for q in test_queries if len(q.split()) > 5],
'questions': [q for q in test_queries if '?' in q or any(q.lower().startswith(w) for w in ['how', 'what', 'can', 'help'])],
'commands': [q for q in test_queries if not any(q.lower().startswith(w) for w in ['how', 'what', 'can', 'help'])]
}
# Overall coverage score
keyword_score = min(len(keywords) / 50, 1.0) * 100 # Target: 50 keywords
pattern_score = min(len(patterns) / 10, 1.0) * 100 # Target: 10 patterns
query_score = min(len(test_queries) / 20, 1.0) * 100 # Target: 20 test queries
complexity_score = min(avg_complexity / 15, 1.0) * 100 # Target: avg complexity 15
overall_score = (keyword_score + pattern_score + query_score + complexity_score) / 4
coverage_report = {
"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat(),
"overall_score": overall_score,
"keyword_analysis": {
"total": len(keywords),
"categories": {cat: len(items) for cat, items in keyword_categories.items()},
"score": keyword_score
},
"pattern_analysis": {
"total": len(patterns),
"average_complexity": avg_complexity,
"score": pattern_score
},
"test_query_analysis": {
"total": len(test_queries),
"categories": {cat: len(items) for cat, items in query_categories.items()},
"score": query_score
},
"recommendations": []
}
# Generate recommendations
if len(keywords) < 50:
coverage_report["recommendations"].append(f"Add {50 - len(keywords)} more keywords for better coverage")
if len(patterns) < 10:
coverage_report["recommendations"].append(f"Add {10 - len(patterns)} more patterns for better matching")
if len(test_queries) < 20:
coverage_report["recommendations"].append(f"Add {20 - len(test_queries)} more test queries")
if overall_score < 80:
coverage_report["recommendations"].append("Overall coverage below 80% - consider expanding activation system")
# Save report
with open('$coverage_file', 'w') as f:
json.dump(coverage_report, f, indent=2)
print(f"Overall coverage score: {overall_score:.1f}%")
print(f"Keywords: {len(keywords)}, Patterns: {len(patterns)}, Test queries: {len(test_queries)}")
EOF
local overall_score=$(jq -r '.overall_score' "$coverage_file")
success "Coverage analysis completed - Overall score: ${overall_score}%"
}
# Generate test report
generate_test_report() {
local skill_path="$1"
local output_dir="$2"
log "Generating comprehensive test report..."
local skill_name=$(cat "$TEMP_DIR/skill_name.txt" | tr -d '"')
local report_file="$output_dir/activation-test-report.html"
# Load all test results
local keyword_results=$(cat "$RESULTS_DIR/logs/keyword_test_results.json" 2>/dev/null || echo '{"summary": {"success_rate": 0}}')
local pattern_results=$(cat "$RESULTS_DIR/logs/pattern_test_results.json" 2>/dev/null || echo '{"summary": {"match_rate": 0}}')
local coverage_results=$(cat "$RESULTS_DIR/coverage/coverage_report.json" 2>/dev/null || echo '{"overall_score": 0}')
# Extract metrics
local keyword_rate=$(echo "$keyword_results" | jq -r '.summary.success_rate // 0')
local pattern_rate=$(echo "$pattern_results" | jq -r '.summary.match_rate // 0')
local coverage_score=$(echo "$coverage_results" | jq -r '.overall_score // 0')
# Calculate overall score
local overall_score=$(python3 -c "
k_rate = $keyword_rate
p_rate = $pattern_rate
c_score = $coverage_score
overall = (k_rate + p_rate + c_score/100) / 3 * 100
print(f'{overall:.1f}')
")
# Generate HTML report
cat > "$report_file" << EOF
<!DOCTYPE html>
<html lang="en">
<head>
<meta charset="UTF-8">
<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0">
<title>Activation Test Report - $skill_name</title>
<style>
body { font-family: Arial, sans-serif; margin: 40px; background: #f5f5f5; }
.container { max-width: 1200px; margin: 0 auto; background: white; padding: 30px; border-radius: 8px; box-shadow: 0 2px 10px rgba(0,0,0,0.1); }
h1 { color: #333; border-bottom: 3px solid #007bff; padding-bottom: 10px; }
h2 { color: #555; margin-top: 30px; }
.metrics { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(auto-fit, minmax(250px, 1fr)); gap: 20px; margin: 20px 0; }
.metric-card { background: #f8f9fa; padding: 20px; border-radius: 8px; border-left: 4px solid #007bff; }
.metric-value { font-size: 2em; font-weight: bold; color: #007bff; }
.metric-label { color: #666; margin-top: 5px; }
.score-excellent { color: #28a745; }
.score-good { color: #ffc107; }
.score-poor { color: #dc3545; }
.status { padding: 10px; border-radius: 4px; margin: 10px 0; }
.status.pass { background: #d4edda; color: #155724; border: 1px solid #c3e6cb; }
.status.warning { background: #fff3cd; color: #856404; border: 1px solid #ffeaa7; }
.status.fail { background: #f8d7da; color: #721c24; border: 1px solid #f5c6cb; }
.timestamp { color: #666; font-size: 0.9em; margin-top: 20px; }
table { width: 100%; border-collapse: collapse; margin: 20px 0; }
th, td { padding: 12px; text-align: left; border-bottom: 1px solid #ddd; }
th { background: #f8f9fa; font-weight: 600; }
.recommendations { background: #e7f3ff; padding: 20px; border-radius: 8px; border-left: 4px solid #0066cc; }
</style>
</head>
<body>
<div class="container">
<h1>🧪 Activation Test Report</h1>
<p><strong>Skill:</strong> $skill_name</p>
<p><strong>Test Date:</strong> $(date)</p>
<div class="metrics">
<div class="metric-card">
<div class="metric-value $(echo $overall_score | awk '{if ($1 >= 95) print "score-excellent"; else if ($1 >= 80) print "score-good"; else print "score-poor"}')">${overall_score}%</div>
<div class="metric-label">Overall Score</div>
</div>
<div class="metric-card">
<div class="metric-value $(echo $keyword_rate | awk '{if ($1 >= 0.95) print "score-excellent"; else if ($1 >= 0.80) print "score-good"; else print "score-poor"}')">${keyword_rate}</div>
<div class="metric-label">Keyword Success Rate</div>
</div>
<div class="metric-card">
<div class="metric-value $(echo $pattern_rate | awk '{if ($1 >= 0.95) print "score-excellent"; else if ($1 >= 0.80) print "score-good"; else print "score-poor"}')">${pattern_rate}</div>
<div class="metric-label">Pattern Match Rate</div>
</div>
<div class="metric-card">
<div class="metric-value $(echo $coverage_score | awk '{if ($1 >= 80) print "score-excellent"; else if ($1 >= 60) print "score-good"; else print "score-poor"}')">${coverage_score}%</div>
<div class="metric-label">Coverage Score</div>
</div>
</div>
<h2>📊 Test Status</h2>
$(python3 -c "
score = $overall_score
if score >= 95:
print('<div class=\"status pass\">✅ EXCELLENT - Skill activation reliability is excellent (95%+)</div>')
elif score >= 80:
print('<div class=\"status warning\">⚠️ GOOD - Skill activation reliability is good but could be improved</div>')
else:
print('<div class=\"status fail\">❌ NEEDS IMPROVEMENT - Skill activation reliability is below acceptable levels</div>')
")
<h2>📈 Detailed Results</h2>
<table>
<tr><th>Test Type</th><th>Total</th><th>Successful</th><th>Success Rate</th><th>Status</th></tr>
<tr>
<td>Keyword Tests</td>
<td>$(echo "$keyword_results" | jq -r '.summary.total_tests // 0')</td>
<td>$(echo "$keyword_results" | jq -r '.summary.successful // 0')</td>
<td>${keyword_rate}</td>
<td>$(echo "$keyword_rate" | awk '{if ($1 >= 0.95) print "✅ Pass"; else if ($1 >= 0.80) print "⚠️ Warning"; else print "❌ Fail"}')</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>Pattern Tests</td>
<td>$(echo "$pattern_results" | jq -r '.summary.total_tests // 0')</td>
<td>$(echo "$pattern_results" | jq -r '.summary.matched // 0')</td>
<td>${pattern_rate}</td>
<td>$(echo "$pattern_rate" | awk '{if ($1 >= 0.95) print "✅ Pass"; else if ($1 >= 0.80) print "⚠️ Warning"; else print "❌ Fail"}')</td>
</tr>
</table>
<h2>🎯 Recommendations</h2>
<div class="recommendations">
<ul>
$(echo "$coverage_results" | jq -r '.recommendations[]? // "No specific recommendations"' | sed 's/^/ <li>/;s/$/<\/li>/')
</ul>
</div>
<div class="timestamp">Report generated on $(date) by Activation Test Automation Framework v1.0</div>
</div>
</body>
</html>
EOF
success "Test report generated: $report_file"
}
# Main function - run full test suite
run_full_test_suite() {
local skill_path="$1"
local output_dir="${2:-$RESULTS_DIR}"
if [[ -z "$skill_path" ]]; then
error "Skill path is required"
echo "Usage: $0 full-test-suite <skill-path> [output-dir]"
return 1
fi
if [[ ! -d "$skill_path" ]]; then
error "Skill directory not found: $skill_path"
return 1
fi
log "🚀 Starting Full Activation Test Suite"
log "Skill: $skill_path"
log "Output: $output_dir"
# Initialize
init_directories "$skill_path"
# Parse configuration
parse_skill_config "$skill_path"
# Generate test cases
generate_keyword_tests "$skill_path"
generate_pattern_tests "$skill_path"
# Validate patterns
validate_patterns "$skill_path"
# Run tests
run_keyword_tests "$skill_path"
run_pattern_tests "$skill_path"
# Calculate coverage
calculate_coverage "$skill_path"
# Generate report
mkdir -p "$output_dir"
generate_test_report "$skill_path" "$output_dir"
success "✅ Full test suite completed!"
log "📁 Report available at: $output_dir/activation-test-report.html"
}
# Quick validation function
quick_validation() {
local skill_path="$1"
if [[ -z "$skill_path" ]]; then
error "Skill path is required"
echo "Usage: $0 quick-validation <skill-path>"
return 1
fi
log "⚡ Running Quick Activation Validation"
local config_file="$skill_path/marketplace.json"
# Check if marketplace.json exists
if [[ ! -f "$config_file" ]]; then
error "marketplace.json not found in $skill_path"
return 1
fi
# Validate JSON
if ! python3 -m json.tool "$config_file" > /dev/null 2>&1; then
error "❌ Invalid JSON in marketplace.json"
return 1
fi
success "✅ JSON syntax is valid"
# Check required fields
local required_fields=("name" "metadata" "plugins" "activation")
for field in "${required_fields[@]}"; do
if ! jq -e ".$field" "$config_file" > /dev/null 2>&1; then
error "❌ Missing required field: $field"
return 1
fi
done
success "✅ All required fields present"
# Check activation structure
if ! jq -e '.activation.keywords' "$config_file" > /dev/null 2>&1; then
error "❌ Missing activation.keywords"
return 1
fi
if ! jq -e '.activation.patterns' "$config_file" > /dev/null 2>&1; then
error "❌ Missing activation.patterns"
return 1
fi
success "✅ Activation structure is valid"
# Check counts
local keyword_count=$(jq '.activation.keywords | length' "$config_file")
local pattern_count=$(jq '.activation.patterns | length' "$config_file")
local test_query_count=$(jq '.usage.test_queries | length' "$config_file" 2>/dev/null || echo "0")
log "📊 Current metrics:"
log " Keywords: $keyword_count (recommend 50+)"
log " Patterns: $pattern_count (recommend 10+)"
log " Test queries: $test_query_count (recommend 20+)"
# Provide recommendations
if [[ $keyword_count -lt 50 ]]; then
warning "Consider adding $((50 - keyword_count)) more keywords for better coverage"
fi
if [[ $pattern_count -lt 10 ]]; then
warning "Consider adding $((10 - pattern_count)) more patterns for better matching"
fi
if [[ $test_query_count -lt 20 ]]; then
warning "Consider adding $((20 - test_query_count)) more test queries"
fi
success "✅ Quick validation completed"
}
# Help function
show_help() {
cat << EOF
Activation Test Automation Framework v1.0
Usage: $0 <command> [options]
Commands:
full-test-suite <skill-path> [output-dir] Run complete test suite
quick-validation <skill-path> Fast validation checks
help Show this help message
Examples:
$0 full-test-suite ./references/examples/stock-analyzer ./test-results
$0 quick-validation ./references/examples/stock-analyzer
Environment Variables:
RESULTS_DIR Directory for test results (default: ./test-results)
TEMP_DIR Temporary directory for test files (default: /tmp/activation-tests)
EOF
}
# Main script logic
case "${1:-}" in
"full-test-suite")
run_full_test_suite "$2" "$3"
;;
"quick-validation")
quick_validation "$2"
;;
"help"|"--help"|"-h")
show_help
;;
*)
error "Unknown command: ${1:-}"
show_help
exit 1
;;
esac

30
scenarios/SC-001-valid-frontmatter-happy.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,30 +0,0 @@
# SC-001: Valid SKILL.md Frontmatter Generation
> Covers: FR-001 — Generated SKILL.md files MUST have valid frontmatter per the Agent Skills spec (name <=64 chars lowercase+hyphens, description <=1024 chars, both required)
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked with a workflow description: "Create a skill for processing daily CSV files"
- The pipeline completes all 5 phases successfully
## When
- Phase 5 (Implementation) generates the SKILL.md file
## Then
- The generated SKILL.md begins with a YAML frontmatter block delimited by `---`
- The `name` field is present, lowercase, uses only hyphens as separators, and is <=64 characters (e.g., `csv-daily-processor`)
- The `description` field is present and is between 1 and 1024 characters
- The frontmatter block is valid YAML that can be parsed without errors
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill with input: "Create a skill for processing daily CSV files"
2. Read the generated `SKILL.md` file
3. Parse the YAML frontmatter between the `---` delimiters using Python `yaml.safe_load()`
4. Assert `name` is present, matches regex `^[a-z][a-z0-9-]*[a-z0-9]$`, and `len(name) <= 64`
5. Assert `description` is present and `1 <= len(description) <= 1024`
**Expected evidence**: YAML frontmatter parses successfully. `name` is a valid lowercase-kebab string <=64 chars. `description` is a non-empty string <=1024 chars. No YAML parsing errors.

32
scenarios/SC-002-invalid-frontmatter-missing-name.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,32 +0,0 @@
# SC-002: Validation Fails When Frontmatter Missing Name
> Covers: FR-001, FR-011, FR-012 — Generated SKILL.md MUST have valid frontmatter; Validation MUST check name format
> Type: Failure
## Given
- A skill directory `test-skill/` exists with a SKILL.md that has frontmatter missing the `name` field:
```yaml
---
description: "A test skill"
---
```
## When
- The validation function `validate_skill("test-skill/")` is invoked
## Then
- The validation result `valid` is `False`
- The `errors` list contains a message indicating the `name` field is missing
- The validation does NOT pass silently
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create a temporary directory `test-skill/` with a SKILL.md containing only a `description` field in frontmatter
2. Call `validate_skill("test-skill/")`
3. Assert `result.valid is False`
4. Assert any item in `result.errors` contains the substring `name`
**Expected evidence**: `valid: False`, `errors` list includes an entry like `"Missing required field: name"`.

31
scenarios/SC-003-invalid-frontmatter-missing-description.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,31 +0,0 @@
# SC-003: Validation Fails When Frontmatter Missing Description
> Covers: FR-001, FR-011, FR-012 — Generated SKILL.md MUST have valid frontmatter; Validation MUST check description length
> Type: Failure
## Given
- A skill directory `test-skill/` exists with a SKILL.md that has frontmatter missing the `description` field:
```yaml
---
name: test-skill
---
```
## When
- The validation function `validate_skill("test-skill/")` is invoked
## Then
- The validation result `valid` is `False`
- The `errors` list contains a message indicating the `description` field is missing
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create a temporary directory `test-skill/` with a SKILL.md containing only a `name` field in frontmatter
2. Call `validate_skill("test-skill/")`
3. Assert `result.valid is False`
4. Assert any item in `result.errors` contains the substring `description`
**Expected evidence**: `valid: False`, `errors` list includes an entry like `"Missing required field: description"`.

27
scenarios/SC-004-name-matches-directory.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-004: Generated SKILL.md Name Matches Parent Directory
> Covers: FR-002 — Generated SKILL.md `name` field MUST match the parent directory name
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked with: "Create a skill for weather alerts"
- Phase 3 creates a directory named `weather-alerts/`
## When
- Phase 5 generates the SKILL.md inside `weather-alerts/`
## Then
- The `name` field in SKILL.md frontmatter is exactly `weather-alerts`
- The directory name and the `name` field are identical strings
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill to generate a skill
2. Read the parent directory name of the generated SKILL.md
3. Parse the YAML frontmatter and extract the `name` field
4. Assert `name == parent_directory_name`
**Expected evidence**: `name: weather-alerts` in frontmatter, parent directory is `weather-alerts/`. Both strings are identical.

27
scenarios/SC-005-name-directory-mismatch-fails-validation.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-005: Validation Fails When Name Does Not Match Directory
> Covers: FR-002, FR-012 — Validation MUST check directory name match
> Type: Failure
## Given
- A skill directory named `my-skill/` exists
- The SKILL.md inside has `name: different-skill` in frontmatter
## When
- The validation function `validate_skill("my-skill/")` is invoked
## Then
- The validation result `valid` is `False`
- The `errors` list contains a message about name/directory mismatch
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create directory `my-skill/` with SKILL.md containing `name: different-skill`
2. Call `validate_skill("my-skill/")`
3. Assert `result.valid is False`
4. Assert `result.errors` contains a message referencing directory name mismatch
**Expected evidence**: `valid: False`, error message like `"name 'different-skill' does not match directory name 'my-skill'"`.

28
scenarios/SC-006-skillmd-under-500-lines.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,28 +0,0 @@
# SC-006: Generated SKILL.md Is Under 500 Lines
> Covers: FR-003 — Generated SKILL.md body MUST be <500 lines, with detailed content in `references/`
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked with a complex workflow description that would produce substantial documentation
- Input: "Create a skill for managing a full CI/CD pipeline with build, test, deploy stages, rollback procedures, monitoring integration, and multi-environment support"
## When
- Phase 5 generates the SKILL.md and all supporting files
## Then
- The generated SKILL.md file has fewer than 500 lines total
- A `references/` directory exists alongside SKILL.md containing detailed documentation
- The SKILL.md body contains cross-reference pointers (e.g., `See references/deployment-guide.md`) to the detailed content
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill with the complex workflow description
2. Count the lines in the generated SKILL.md: `wc -l skill-name/SKILL.md`
3. Verify `references/` directory exists and contains at least one file
4. Grep for cross-reference patterns in SKILL.md: `grep -c 'references/' skill-name/SKILL.md`
**Expected evidence**: SKILL.md line count is less than 500. `references/` directory contains one or more `.md` files. SKILL.md body contains at least one reference to `references/`.

26
scenarios/SC-007-skillmd-over-500-lines-fails.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,26 +0,0 @@
# SC-007: Validation Fails When SKILL.md Exceeds 500 Lines
> Covers: FR-003, FR-011 — Validation MUST check generated SKILL.md is <500 lines
> Type: Failure
## Given
- A skill directory `verbose-skill/` exists
- The SKILL.md inside contains 650 lines (valid frontmatter but excessive body content)
## When
- The validation function `validate_skill("verbose-skill/")` is invoked
## Then
- The validation result reports a warning or error about SKILL.md exceeding 500 lines
- The `errors` or `warnings` list contains a message about line count
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create directory `verbose-skill/` with a SKILL.md that has valid frontmatter and 650 lines of body content
2. Call `validate_skill("verbose-skill/")`
3. Assert that `result.errors` or `result.warnings` contains a message about exceeding 500 lines
**Expected evidence**: Validation output includes a message like `"SKILL.md exceeds 500 lines (650 lines found)"`.

27
scenarios/SC-008-metaskill-own-skillmd-under-500.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-008: Meta-Skill's Own SKILL.md Is Under 500 Lines
> Covers: FR-004, FR-021 — The meta-skill's own SKILL.md MUST be <500 lines
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The agent-skill-creator repository has been updated to v4.0
- The meta-skill's own SKILL.md exists at `agent-skill-creator/SKILL.md`
## When
- The file is inspected for line count
## Then
- The meta-skill's SKILL.md has fewer than 500 lines
- Detailed content that was previously in the monolithic SKILL.md (4,116 lines) has been moved to `references/`
- The SKILL.md body contains cross-references to files in `references/`
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Run: `wc -l /Users/francylisboacharuto/agent-skill-creator/SKILL.md`
2. Run: `ls /Users/francylisboacharuto/agent-skill-creator/references/`
3. Run: `grep -c 'references/' /Users/francylisboacharuto/agent-skill-creator/SKILL.md`
**Expected evidence**: Line count output is less than 500. `references/` contains multiple files. Grep shows at least 3 cross-references.

27
scenarios/SC-009-no-marketplace-json-simple-skill.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-009: Simple Generated Skills Do Not Include marketplace.json
> Covers: FR-005 — Generated skills MUST NOT include `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` for simple skills
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked to create a simple (single-skill) skill
- Input: "Create a skill for formatting markdown tables"
## When
- Phase 5 generates the complete skill directory
## Then
- The generated skill directory does NOT contain a `.claude-plugin/` subdirectory
- The generated skill directory does NOT contain a `marketplace.json` file at any level
- The skill activates solely via its SKILL.md file
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill to generate a simple skill
2. Run: `find markdown-table-formatter/ -name "marketplace.json" -o -name ".claude-plugin" | wc -l`
3. Verify the count is 0
**Expected evidence**: `find` returns 0 results. No `.claude-plugin/` directory or `marketplace.json` file exists anywhere in the generated skill directory.

29
scenarios/SC-010-marketplace-json-complex-suite.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,29 +0,0 @@
# SC-010: Complex Skill Suite May Include Standard marketplace.json
> Covers: FR-006 — Generated skills for complex suites MAY include a marketplace.json with ONLY official Claude Code fields
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked to create a complex skill suite with multiple sub-skills
- Input: "Create a skill suite for full-stack web development with separate skills for frontend, backend, and deployment"
## When
- Phase 5 generates the complete skill suite directory
## Then
- If a `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` is generated, it contains ONLY official fields: `name`, `plugins[].name`, `plugins[].description`, `plugins[].source`, `plugins[].skills`
- No non-standard fields are present (no `version`, no `author`, no `repository`, no `tags`)
- The JSON is valid and parseable
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill with the complex suite input
2. If `.claude-plugin/marketplace.json` exists, parse it with `json.load()`
3. Assert all keys are in the official set: `{"name", "plugins"}`
4. For each plugin, assert keys are subset of: `{"name", "description", "source", "skills"}`
5. Assert no extra keys exist at any level
**Expected evidence**: JSON parses cleanly. Only official fields present. No non-standard fields like `version`, `author`, `repository`, or `tags`.

29
scenarios/SC-011-no-cskill-suffix.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,29 +0,0 @@
# SC-011: Generated Skill Names Do Not Use -cskill Suffix
> Covers: FR-007 — The `-cskill` naming suffix MUST be removed from all generated skill names
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked with: "Create a skill for code review automation"
## When
- Phase 3 (Architecture) generates the directory structure
- Phase 5 (Implementation) generates all files
## Then
- The generated directory name does NOT end with `-cskill` (e.g., `code-review-automation/` not `code-review-automation-cskill/`)
- The `name` field in SKILL.md frontmatter does NOT contain `-cskill`
- No file content references the `-cskill` suffix as a naming convention
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill to generate the skill
2. Run: `ls -d */` to see generated directory name
3. Assert directory name does not end with `-cskill`
4. Run: `grep -r "cskill" code-review-automation/ | wc -l`
5. Assert count is 0
**Expected evidence**: Directory is named `code-review-automation/` (not `code-review-automation-cskill/`). Grep for "cskill" returns 0 matches.

27
scenarios/SC-012-cskill-suffix-rejected.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-012: User Requesting -cskill Suffix Gets Deprecation Notice
> Covers: FR-007 — Edge case from Section 2.3: User requests -cskill suffix
> Type: Edge Case
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked with: "Create a skill called my-tool-cskill for file conversion"
## When
- The meta-skill processes the name and enters Phase 3 (Architecture)
## Then
- The user is informed that the `-cskill` suffix is deprecated and will not be used
- The generated directory and `name` field use `my-tool` or `file-conversion` (without `-cskill`)
- A warning message is displayed to the user about the deprecation
## Verification Method
**Method**: Manual test
**Steps**:
1. Invoke the meta-skill with: "Create a skill called my-tool-cskill for file conversion"
2. Observe the meta-skill's output during Phase 3
3. Verify a deprecation notice is displayed
4. Check the generated directory name does not end in `-cskill`
**Expected evidence**: Output contains a message like "The -cskill suffix is deprecated" or "Generating without -cskill suffix". Generated directory is `my-tool/` or `file-conversion/`, not `my-tool-cskill/`.

27
scenarios/SC-013-license-field-present.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-013: Generated Skills Include License Field
> Covers: FR-008 — Generated skills MUST include `license` field in frontmatter
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked to create a skill
- Input: "Create a skill for API health monitoring"
## When
- Phase 5 generates the SKILL.md
## Then
- The SKILL.md frontmatter includes a `license` field
- The license value is a recognized SPDX identifier (e.g., `MIT`, `Apache-2.0`, `ISC`)
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill to generate the skill
2. Parse the YAML frontmatter of the generated SKILL.md
3. Assert `license` key is present in frontmatter
4. Assert value is a non-empty string
**Expected evidence**: Frontmatter contains `license: MIT` (or another valid SPDX identifier).

34
scenarios/SC-014-metadata-author-version.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,34 +0,0 @@
# SC-014: Generated Skills Include Metadata with Author and Version
> Covers: FR-009 — Generated skills MUST include `metadata` field with `author` and `version`
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked to create a skill
- Input: "Create a skill for database migration management"
## When
- Phase 5 generates the SKILL.md
## Then
- The SKILL.md frontmatter includes a `metadata` mapping
- The `metadata` contains an `author` field with a non-empty string
- The `metadata` contains a `version` field (e.g., `1.0.0`)
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill to generate the skill
2. Parse the YAML frontmatter of the generated SKILL.md
3. Assert `metadata` key is present and is a dict
4. Assert `metadata.author` is a non-empty string
5. Assert `metadata.version` is a non-empty string matching semver pattern `^\d+\.\d+\.\d+`
**Expected evidence**: Frontmatter contains:
```yaml
metadata:
author: "Some Author"
version: "1.0.0"
```

29
scenarios/SC-015-compatibility-field-platform-specific.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,29 +0,0 @@
# SC-015: Compatibility Field Included When Platform-Specific Features Used
> Covers: FR-010 — Generated skills SHOULD include `compatibility` field when platform-specific features are used
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked to create a skill that uses platform-specific features
- Input: "Create a skill that uses Claude Code's allowed-tools feature to restrict tool access to only Bash and Read"
## When
- Phase 5 generates the SKILL.md
## Then
- The SKILL.md frontmatter includes a `compatibility` field
- The `compatibility` value describes which platforms or features are required (<=500 chars)
- The `allowed-tools` experimental field is also present in frontmatter
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill with the platform-specific input
2. Parse the YAML frontmatter
3. Assert `compatibility` key is present
4. Assert `len(compatibility) <= 500`
5. Assert the value references the platform-specific constraint
**Expected evidence**: Frontmatter contains `compatibility: "Requires Claude Code for allowed-tools support"` (or similar). Length is <=500 chars.

33
scenarios/SC-016-validation-all-spec-rules.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,33 +0,0 @@
# SC-016: Validation Checks All Official Spec Rules
> Covers: FR-011, FR-012, NFR-003 — Validation MUST check every generated skill against official spec rules
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A fully valid skill directory `valid-skill/` exists with:
- `name: valid-skill` (matches directory)
- `description: "A valid test skill for verification"` (<=1024 chars)
- Valid YAML frontmatter structure
- SKILL.md body <500 lines
## When
- The validation function `validate_skill("valid-skill/")` is invoked
## Then
- The validation result `valid` is `True`
- The `errors` list is empty
- The `warnings` list may contain non-blocking suggestions
- All spec rules have been checked (name format, description length, frontmatter structure, directory name match)
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create a fully compliant skill directory `valid-skill/` with correct frontmatter
2. Call `validate_skill("valid-skill/")`
3. Assert `result.valid is True`
4. Assert `len(result.errors) == 0`
5. Verify the function checks at minimum: name format, description length, frontmatter structure, directory match
**Expected evidence**: `valid: True`, `errors: []`. Function returns a ValidationResult with all four required check categories evaluated.

32
scenarios/SC-017-validation-invalid-name-format.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,32 +0,0 @@
# SC-017: Validation Fails on Invalid Name Format
> Covers: FR-012 — Validation MUST check name format (lowercase+hyphens only)
> Type: Failure
## Given
- A skill directory `My_Skill/` exists with SKILL.md containing:
```yaml
---
name: My_Skill
description: "A skill with invalid name format"
---
```
## When
- The validation function `validate_skill("My_Skill/")` is invoked
## Then
- The validation result `valid` is `False`
- The `errors` list contains a message about invalid name format (uppercase letters and underscores not allowed)
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create directory `My_Skill/` with SKILL.md containing `name: My_Skill`
2. Call `validate_skill("My_Skill/")`
3. Assert `result.valid is False`
4. Assert `result.errors` contains a message about name format violation
**Expected evidence**: `valid: False`, error message like `"name 'My_Skill' contains invalid characters. Must be lowercase alphanumeric and hyphens only."`.

30
scenarios/SC-018-security-scan-hardcoded-key.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,30 +0,0 @@
# SC-018: Security Scan Detects Hardcoded API Key
> Covers: FR-013 — Security scan MUST check for hardcoded API keys, secrets, and .env files
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A generated skill directory `leaky-skill/` contains a script `scripts/main.py` with:
```python
API_KEY = "sk-proj-abc123def456ghi789jkl012mno345pqr678stu901vwx234"
```
## When
- The security scan is run as part of validation (or independently)
## Then
- The security scan fails
- The `security` list in the validation result contains a finding about the hardcoded API key
- The finding identifies the file (`scripts/main.py`) and the pattern matched
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create `leaky-skill/scripts/main.py` with a hardcoded API key string
2. Call `validate_skill("leaky-skill/")` or the dedicated security scan function
3. Assert `result.security` is non-empty
4. Assert a security finding references `scripts/main.py` and mentions "hardcoded" or "API key" or "secret"
**Expected evidence**: Security findings list includes an entry like `"Hardcoded secret detected in scripts/main.py: possible API key on line 1"`.

29
scenarios/SC-019-security-scan-env-file.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,29 +0,0 @@
# SC-019: Security Scan Detects .env File in Skill Directory
> Covers: FR-013 — Security scan MUST check for .env files
> Type: Failure
## Given
- A generated skill directory `env-skill/` contains a `.env` file with:
```
DATABASE_URL=postgres://user:password@host:5432/db
SECRET_KEY=supersecretvalue123
```
## When
- The security scan is run on `env-skill/`
## Then
- The security scan reports a finding about the `.env` file
- The `security` list contains a warning that `.env` files should not be included in skills
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create `env-skill/` with a valid SKILL.md and a `.env` file containing secrets
2. Run the security scan
3. Assert security findings reference the `.env` file
**Expected evidence**: Security finding like `"Sensitive file detected: .env should not be included in skill directory"`.

29
scenarios/SC-020-security-scan-clean-skill.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,29 +0,0 @@
# SC-020: Security Scan Passes on Clean Skill
> Covers: FR-013 — Security scan MUST check for hardcoded secrets (negative case: no findings)
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A generated skill directory `clean-skill/` contains:
- SKILL.md with valid frontmatter
- `scripts/main.py` using environment variables: `os.environ.get("API_KEY")`
- No `.env` files
- No hardcoded secrets
## When
- The security scan is run on `clean-skill/`
## Then
- The security scan passes with no findings
- The `security` list in the validation result is empty
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create `clean-skill/` with SKILL.md and scripts using `os.environ.get()` for all secrets
2. Run the security scan
3. Assert `result.security` is empty or `len(result.security) == 0`
**Expected evidence**: `security: []` -- no security issues found.

30
scenarios/SC-021-security-scan-shell-injection.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,30 +0,0 @@
# SC-021: Security Scan Detects Shell Injection Patterns
> Covers: FR-014 — Security scan SHOULD check for shell injection patterns in generated scripts
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A generated skill directory `unsafe-skill/` contains `scripts/runner.py` with:
```python
import subprocess
user_input = input("Enter filename: ")
subprocess.call(f"cat {user_input}", shell=True)
```
## When
- The security scan is run on `unsafe-skill/`
## Then
- The security scan identifies a shell injection risk
- The `security` list contains a finding about `subprocess.call` with `shell=True` and unsanitized input
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Create `unsafe-skill/scripts/runner.py` with `subprocess.call(..., shell=True)` using f-string interpolation
2. Run the security scan
3. Assert security findings reference shell injection or `shell=True`
**Expected evidence**: Security finding like `"Potential shell injection in scripts/runner.py: subprocess.call with shell=True and string interpolation"`.

29
scenarios/SC-022-install-sh-generated.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,29 +0,0 @@
# SC-022: Generated Skills Include install.sh
> Covers: FR-015 — Generated skills MUST include an `install.sh` script that auto-detects the platform
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked with: "Create a skill for log analysis"
## When
- Phase 5 generates the complete skill directory
## Then
- An `install.sh` file exists in the root of the generated skill directory
- The file is executable (`chmod +x`)
- The script contains platform auto-detection logic (checks for `~/.claude/`, `~/.github/`, etc.)
- Running `./install.sh --dry-run` shows what would happen without making changes
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill to generate the skill
2. Run: `test -f log-analysis/install.sh && echo "EXISTS" || echo "MISSING"`
3. Run: `test -x log-analysis/install.sh && echo "EXECUTABLE" || echo "NOT EXECUTABLE"`
4. Run: `grep -c "auto-detect\|platform\|claude\|copilot\|cursor" log-analysis/install.sh`
5. Run: `./log-analysis/install.sh --dry-run`
**Expected evidence**: File exists and is executable. Script contains platform detection strings. Dry run outputs detected platform and intended installation path without making changes.

27
scenarios/SC-023-install-sh-primary-platforms.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-023: install.sh Supports Primary Platform Paths
> Covers: FR-016 — install.sh MUST support ~/.claude/skills/, ~/.github/skills/, .claude/skills/, .github/skills/
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A generated skill `log-analysis/` with a valid `install.sh`
- The test environment has `~/.claude/` directory present
## When
- `./install.sh --platform claude-code` is run
## Then
- The skill is copied to `~/.claude/skills/log-analysis/`
- The SKILL.md and all supporting files are present in the destination
- Exit code is 0
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Run: `./log-analysis/install.sh --platform claude-code`
2. Run: `test -f ~/.claude/skills/log-analysis/SKILL.md && echo "INSTALLED" || echo "FAILED"`
3. Run: `echo $?` after install to check exit code
**Expected evidence**: Exit code 0. File `~/.claude/skills/log-analysis/SKILL.md` exists. All skill files are present in the destination.

27
scenarios/SC-024-install-sh-project-level.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-024: install.sh Supports Project-Level Installation
> Covers: FR-016 — install.sh MUST support .claude/skills/ (project) and .github/skills/ (project)
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A generated skill `log-analysis/` with a valid `install.sh`
- The current directory is a project root (e.g., `/tmp/my-project/`)
## When
- `./install.sh --project` is run from `/tmp/my-project/`
## Then
- The skill is copied to `.claude/skills/log-analysis/` relative to the current directory
- If `.claude/` does not exist, it is created
- Exit code is 0
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Create a temp project directory: `mkdir -p /tmp/my-project && cd /tmp/my-project`
2. Run: `path/to/log-analysis/install.sh --project`
3. Run: `test -f /tmp/my-project/.claude/skills/log-analysis/SKILL.md && echo "INSTALLED" || echo "FAILED"`
**Expected evidence**: Exit code 0. `.claude/skills/log-analysis/SKILL.md` exists relative to the project root.

27
scenarios/SC-025-install-sh-extended-platforms.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-025: install.sh Supports Extended Platforms and Custom Path
> Covers: FR-017 — install.sh SHOULD support .cursor/rules/, .codex/skills/, and custom paths via --path
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A generated skill `log-analysis/` with a valid `install.sh`
## When
- `./install.sh --platform cursor` is run
- Alternatively, `./install.sh --path /custom/skills/path/` is run
## Then
- For `--platform cursor`: skill is copied to `.cursor/rules/log-analysis/`
- For `--path /custom/skills/path/`: skill is copied to `/custom/skills/path/log-analysis/`
- Exit code is 0 in both cases
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Run: `./log-analysis/install.sh --path /tmp/custom-skills/`
2. Run: `test -f /tmp/custom-skills/log-analysis/SKILL.md && echo "INSTALLED" || echo "FAILED"`
3. Verify exit code is 0
**Expected evidence**: Exit code 0. Skill files exist at the custom path. SKILL.md is present.

27
scenarios/SC-026-install-sh-platform-not-detected.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-026: install.sh Falls Back When No Platform Detected
> Covers: FR-015, Edge case from 2.3 — install.sh target platform not detected: fall back to interactive prompt
> Type: Edge Case
## Given
- A generated skill with a valid `install.sh`
- The system has NONE of the standard platform directories (`~/.claude/`, `~/.github/`, `.cursor/`, etc.)
## When
- `./install.sh` is run without `--platform` or `--path` flags
## Then
- The script does NOT silently fail
- The script outputs a message listing available platforms and asks the user to specify one
- Exit code is 2 (Platform not detected)
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. In a clean environment without any platform directories, run: `./install.sh`
2. Check the output for a prompt or platform list
3. Check exit code: `echo $?`
**Expected evidence**: Exit code 2. Output contains a message like "No supported platform detected. Please specify with --platform or --path." Lists available platform options.

29
scenarios/SC-027-install-sh-validation-fails.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,29 +0,0 @@
# SC-027: install.sh Exits 1 When SKILL.md Is Invalid
> Covers: FR-015 — install.sh exit code 1: Validation failed (SKILL.md invalid)
> Type: Failure
## Given
- A skill directory with an invalid SKILL.md (missing required `name` field)
- The `install.sh` script exists in the directory
## When
- `./install.sh --platform claude-code` is run
## Then
- The install script detects the invalid SKILL.md before copying
- The script exits with code 1
- An error message about SKILL.md validation failure is displayed
- No files are copied to the destination
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Create a skill directory with an invalid SKILL.md (missing `name`)
2. Run: `./install.sh --platform claude-code`
3. Check exit code: `echo $?`
4. Verify destination directory does not exist
**Expected evidence**: Exit code 1. Output includes "Validation failed" or "Invalid SKILL.md". No files copied to `~/.claude/skills/`.

26
scenarios/SC-028-install-sh-permission-denied.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,26 +0,0 @@
# SC-028: install.sh Exits 3 on Permission Denied
> Covers: FR-015 — install.sh exit code 3: Permission denied
> Type: Failure
## Given
- A valid skill directory with `install.sh`
- The target directory `/root/protected/skills/` exists but is not writable by the current user
## When
- `./install.sh --path /root/protected/skills/` is run
## Then
- The install script detects the permission issue
- The script exits with code 3
- An error message about insufficient permissions is displayed
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Run: `./install.sh --path /root/protected/skills/`
2. Check exit code: `echo $?`
**Expected evidence**: Exit code 3. Output includes "Permission denied" or "Cannot write to target directory".

27
scenarios/SC-029-install-sh-dry-run.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
# SC-029: install.sh Dry Run Shows Actions Without Executing
> Covers: FR-015 — install.sh --dry-run support
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A valid skill directory `log-analysis/` with `install.sh`
- `~/.claude/` directory exists
## When
- `./install.sh --dry-run` is run
## Then
- The script outputs what it would do (detected platform, source path, destination path)
- No files are actually copied
- Exit code is 0
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Run: `./log-analysis/install.sh --dry-run`
2. Capture output
3. Verify no files were created: `test -d ~/.claude/skills/log-analysis/ && echo "EXISTS" || echo "NOT CREATED"`
**Expected evidence**: Output shows "Would install to ~/.claude/skills/log-analysis/" (or similar). Destination directory does not exist after dry run. Exit code 0.

33
scenarios/SC-030-readme-multiplatform-instructions.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,33 +0,0 @@
# SC-030: Generated README.md Includes Multi-Platform Installation
> Covers: FR-018, FR-026 — README MUST include installation instructions for at least 5 platforms with copy-paste commands
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked with: "Create a skill for git commit message generation"
## When
- Phase 5 generates the README.md
## Then
- The generated README.md contains a "Cross-Platform Installation" section (or equivalent)
- The section includes copy-paste commands for at least 5 platforms:
- Claude Code
- GitHub Copilot
- Cursor
- Windsurf
- Cline (or Codex CLI, or Gemini CLI)
- Each platform section includes the exact shell command to install
## Verification Method
**Method**: CLI command
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill to generate the skill
2. Run: `grep -i "claude code\|copilot\|cursor\|windsurf\|cline\|codex\|gemini" git-commit-generator/README.md | wc -l`
3. Assert count >= 5
4. Run: `grep -c "install\|cp\|copy\|mkdir" git-commit-generator/README.md`
5. Assert count >= 5 (at least one command per platform)
**Expected evidence**: README.md contains a "Cross-Platform Installation" section. At least 5 distinct platforms are listed with shell commands like `cp -r` or `./install.sh --platform`.

28
scenarios/SC-031-export-desktop-zip.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,28 +0,0 @@
# SC-031: Export System Produces Desktop/Web .zip Package
> Covers: FR-019 — Export system MUST continue to support Desktop/Web .zip variant
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A valid skill directory `log-analysis/` exists with all required files
- The export system (`scripts/export_utils.py`) is available
## When
- `export_skill("log-analysis/", variants=["desktop"])` is called
## Then
- A `.zip` file is generated for the Desktop/Web variant
- The zip contains the SKILL.md and all supporting files
- The zip is a valid archive that can be extracted
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Call `export_skill("log-analysis/", variants=["desktop"])`
2. Assert the returned dict contains a path to a `.zip` file
3. Run: `unzip -t <output.zip>` to verify archive integrity
4. Assert SKILL.md is present in the archive listing
**Expected evidence**: A `.zip` file is produced. `unzip -t` reports "No errors detected". Archive contains `SKILL.md`.

28
scenarios/SC-032-export-api-zip.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,28 +0,0 @@
# SC-032: Export System Produces API .zip Package Under 8MB
> Covers: FR-019 — Export system MUST continue to support API .zip variant
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A valid skill directory `log-analysis/` exists with all required files
- The export system (`scripts/export_utils.py`) is available
## When
- `export_skill("log-analysis/", variants=["api"])` is called
## Then
- A `.zip` file is generated for the API variant
- The zip file size is less than 8MB
- The zip contains an optimized subset of files suitable for API consumption
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Call `export_skill("log-analysis/", variants=["api"])`
2. Assert the returned dict contains a path to a `.zip` file
3. Check file size: `os.path.getsize(zip_path) < 8 * 1024 * 1024`
4. Run: `unzip -t <output.zip>` to verify integrity
**Expected evidence**: A `.zip` file is produced. File size is less than 8,388,608 bytes (8MB). `unzip -t` reports no errors.

26
scenarios/SC-033-export-platform-flag.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,26 +0,0 @@
# SC-033: Export System Supports --platform Flag for Cursor
> Covers: FR-020 — Export system SHOULD add a --platform flag to generate platform-specific output
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- A valid skill directory `log-analysis/` exists
- The export system supports the `platform` parameter
## When
- `export_skill("log-analysis/", platform="cursor")` is called
## Then
- The export generates a Cursor-compatible output (e.g., an `.mdc` file or Cursor-formatted directory)
- The output contains the SKILL.md content adapted for Cursor's rule format
## Verification Method
**Method**: Automated test
**Steps**:
1. Call `export_skill("log-analysis/", platform="cursor")`
2. Check that the output contains a `.mdc` file or Cursor-specific format
3. Verify the content includes the original skill instructions
**Expected evidence**: An `.mdc` file or Cursor-compatible output is produced. Content preserves the skill's instructions.

37
scenarios/SC-034-phase3-standard-directory-structure.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,37 +0,0 @@
# SC-034: Phase 3 Generates Standard-Compliant Directory Structure
> Covers: FR-022 — Phase 3 (Architecture) MUST generate standard-compliant directory structures (no -cskill suffix)
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill is invoked with: "Create a skill for API rate limiting management"
## When
- Phase 3 (Architecture) completes and proposes the directory structure
## Then
- The proposed directory name is `api-rate-limiter/` (or similar, without `-cskill`)
- The structure includes: `SKILL.md`, `scripts/`, `references/`, `install.sh`, `README.md`
- No `.claude-plugin/` directory is proposed for a simple skill
- The structure matches the Agent Skills Open Standard layout
## Verification Method
**Method**: Manual test
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill and observe Phase 3 output
2. Verify the directory name does not contain `-cskill`
3. Verify the proposed structure includes all standard files: SKILL.md, install.sh, README.md
4. Verify scripts/ and references/ directories are proposed
**Expected evidence**: Phase 3 output shows a directory like:
```
api-rate-limiter/
SKILL.md
scripts/
references/
install.sh
README.md
```
No `-cskill` suffix. No `marketplace.json`.

28
scenarios/SC-035-phase5-skillmd-first.scenario.md
View file

@ -1,28 +0,0 @@
# SC-035: Phase 5 Creates SKILL.md as the First and Primary File
> Covers: FR-023 — Phase 5 (Implementation) MUST create SKILL.md as the first and primary file
> Type: Happy Path
## Given
- The meta-skill has completed Phases 1-4 for a "data pipeline orchestrator" skill
## When
- Phase 5 (Implementation) begins generating files
## Then
- SKILL.md is the first file created in the implementation sequence
- SKILL.md contains spec-compliant frontmatter (`name`, `description` at minimum)
- marketplace.json is NOT created before or instead of SKILL.md
- The SKILL.md is the primary file that defines the skill's behavior
## Verification Method
**Method**: Manual test
**Steps**:
1. Run the meta-skill and observe Phase 5 output
2. Verify the first file mentioned/created is SKILL.md
3. Verify SKILL.md has valid frontmatter
4. Verify marketplace.json is NOT created for this simple skill
**Expected evidence**: Phase 5 log shows "Creating SKILL.md..." as the first file operation. The generated SKILL.md has valid `name` and `description` frontmatter fields.

Some files were not shown because too many files have changed in this diff Show more